(;(&87,9( 6800$5< ɍju$-bɍ -k i uu`ɍɍukɍ§i-ɍ˜mci§Ÿɍubɍ•-˜ŸukŸɍɍèm§iɍ$mŸa mbm§m-Ÿɍɍmkɍ ˜mjmkabɍ•˜u --$mkcŸɍ(;(&87,9( 6800$5< $eoxw wkh (1$%/( suomhfw dqg wkh 0ogho %hqfkeoon 7kh 0ogho %hqfkeoon oq wkh 5ljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq &ulplqdo 3uofhhglqjv zdv gudiwhg e wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo &opplvvloq oi -xulvwv zlwklq wkh (1$%/( suomhfw lpsohphqwhg lq hljkw (8 foxqwulhv dqg foouglqdwhg e wkh 9dolglw )oxqgdwloq 7kh suomhfw vhhnv wo suopowh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh dqg idluhu fulplqdo suofhhglqjv iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqg svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq %xojduld wkh &]hfk 5hsxeolf /lwkxdqld 3ouwxjdo 5opdqld 6ooydnld 6ooyhqld dqg 6sdlq $v oqh oi wkh pdlq gholyhudeohv oi wkh suomhfw wkh 0ogho %hqfkeoon wkouoxjko dqdolvhv wkh uhohydqw lqwhuqdwloqdo dqg uhjloqdo kxpdq uljkwv vwdqgdugv oq suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqg svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv zlwklq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv suoylglqj dovo sudfwlfdo jxlgholqhv iou wkh wkhlu lpsohphqwdwloq 7kh foqwhqw oi wklv %hqfkeoon lv edvhg oq uhvhdufk foqgxfwhg lq wkh (1$%/( suomhfw oq eduulhuv wo lpsohphqwlqj suofhgxudo dqg idlu wuldo uljkwv gxulqj wkh suhwuldo dqg wuldo skdvhv oi suofhhglqjv dqg lw vhuyhg dv d ioxqgdwloq iou qdwloqdo glvdelolw uljkwv ehqfkeoonv ghyhooshg e sduwqhu oujdqlvdwloqv lq wkh phqwloqhg deoyh foxqwulhv $fnqozohgjphqwv 7kh dxwkouv oi wkh %hqfkeoon dqg wkh (1$%/( suomhfw foouglqdwou zlvkhv wo h[suhvv wkhlu ghhshvw judwlwxgh wo wkh lqwhuqdwloqdo dqg oofdo sduwqhuv oujdqlvdwloqv dqg lqvwlwxwloqv iou wkhlu lqydoxdeoh fooodeoudwloq dqg vxssouw lq wkh ghyhoosphqw oi wklv ehqfk eoon :h sduwlfxoduo dfnqozohgjh wkh vljqlilfdqw foqwulexwloqv oi oxu hvwhhphg sduwqhu oujdqlvdwloqv lq wkh (1$%/( suomhfw 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyh 3v3 .(5$ )oxqgdwloq &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv &/5 )2580 iou +xpdq 5ljkwv /hjdo &hqwuh iou wkh 3uowhfwloq oi +xpdq 5ljkwv dqg wkh (qyluoqphqw 3l& )hqdfhufl 3o«qd ,qfoxvlµq dqg wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo &opplvvloq oi -xulvwv ,&-(,:h dovo zoxog olnh wo h[whqg oxu khduihow wkdqnv wo wkh h[shuw sdqho phpehuv $olfh 0f*duwk %oe )lvfkqhu 'u /dxud 'dylgvoq (vpd *xpehulg]h .dwulqd 6flou /dxud $oïldxvndlw« /dxud -dqhv 0duj &dploohul 0d )duud 5o[dqd &ovpd dqg 6dud 5ofkd iou wkhlu lqvljkwixo foqwulexwloqv dqg ghglfdwhg zoun oq wklv gofxphqw 3@huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ou owkhu shuvoqv zlwk vhuloxv phglfdo foqglwloqv vkoxog uhfhlyh dssuosuldwh fduh fopsdudeoh wo wkdw suoylghg e wkh qdwloqdo sxeolf khdowk vvwhp zklfk phhwv wkhlu vshflilf qhhgv ,q sduwlfxodu 0hpehu 6wdwhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw shuvoqv zko duh gldjqovhg zlwk phqwdo khdowk uhodwhg phglfdo foqglwloqv uhfhlyh vshfldolvhg suoihvvloqdo fduh zkhuh qhhghg lq vshfldolvhg lqvwlwxwloqv ou ghglfdwhg vhfwloqv oi wkh ghwhqwloq idflolw xqghu phglfdo vxshuylvloq dqg wkdw foqwlqxlw oi khdowkfduh lv suoylghg iou ghwdlqhhv lq suhsdudwloq oi uhohdvh zkhuh qhfhvvdu௶ %uxvvhov & ilqdo 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ௬ ,17(51$7,21$/ $1’ (8 /(*$/ )5$0(:25. wkh ,&&35 zklfk suoylgh wkh uljkw wo d idlu wuldo lqfoxglqj suhwuldo uljkwv dqg dffhvv wo dq hiihfwlyh uhphg ,psouwdqwo wkh pxvw dv d pdwwhu oi (8 odz dqg ,+5/ pouh jhqhudoo dovo eh uhdg foqvlvwhqwo zlwk wkh &53’ 7kh lpsohphqwdwloq oi wkh ‘luhfwlyhv dqg 5hfopphqgdwloqv wkuoxjk wkhlu lqfousoudwloq zlwklq qdwloqdo ohjlvodwloq dqg soolf pxvw vlploduo fopso zlwk wklv elqglqj lqwhuqdwloqdo ohjdo iudphzoun :kloh wkhuh lv qo vshflilf (8 lqvwuxphqw vshflilfdoo dgguhvvhg wo wkh uljkwv oi ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkhuh lv wkh (8 vwudwhj oq ylfwlpv uljkwv zklfk suoylghv d qxpehu oi lpsouwdqw vdihjxdugv dovo iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv zklfk lv jhqhudoo oyhuodsslqj zlwk wkovh iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7kh vhw oi suofhgxudo (8 ‘luhfwlyhv lqfoxghv euodgo zoughg suoylvloqv wkdw lq sudfwlfh fdq dqg vkoxog eh lqwhusuhwhg e mxvwlfh dfwouv wo suoylgh dssuosuldwh uljkwv suowhfwloqv wo ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv foqvlvwhqw zlwk wkhlu kxpdq uljkwv 1hyhuwkhohvv wkh suofhgxudo gluhfwlyhv idlo wo lqfoxgh glvdelolw vshflilfdoo zlwklq wkhlu vfosh 7kh ‘luhfwlyhv vkoxog e qoz kdyh ehhq foqyhuwhg lqwo qdwloqdo ohjlvodwloq oi (8 0hpehu 6wdwhv +ozhyhu wkh kdyh qow hw ehhq ixoo lpsohphqwhg lq odz dqg lq voph fdvhv hyhq li ohjlvodwloq kdv ehhq sxw lq sodfh sudfwlfh dqg soolf vwloo whqgv wo odj ehklqg odzvͺ 1oqh oi wkh ‘luhfwlyhv duh dssuosuldwho wdloouhg wo 6wdwh oeoljdwloqv wo hqvxuh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlv qou go wkh suoylgh vxiilflhqw jxlgdqfh dqg gluhfwloq wo mxvwlfh dfwouv lq dwwhpswlqj wo go vo -xvwlfh dfwouv pxvw wkhuhiouh uhdg wkh (8 odz lqvwuxphqwv lq oljkw oi 6wdwh oeoljdwloqv lq whupv oi wkh &53’ (8 vwudwhj oq ylfwlpv uljkwv kwwsv hxuoh[hxuosdhxohjdofoqwhqw(17;7”xul &(/(;$’& .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s )ou lqvwdqfh ௵wkh &oxuw oi -xvwlfh oi wkh (xuoshdq 8qloq &-(8 lq lwv mxgjphqw oi lq fdvh & 338 kdv uxohg oq wkh qoqfoqiouplw oi 3ouwxjxhvh qdwloqdo odz uhjduglqj wkh dvvlvwdqfh e dq lqwhusuhwhu lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv dqg wkh wudqvodwloq oi fhuwdlq suofhgxudo gofxphqwv zlwk wkh suoylvloqv )dlu 7uldov $ydlodeoh dw kwwsv zzzidluwuldovoujduwlfohvohjdodqdovlvfmhxmxgjphqwuljkwvoivxvshfwhgdqgdffxvhgshosohlqsouwxjdofdvhqofssx 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ௬ ,17(51$7,21$/ $1’ (8 /(*$/ )5$0(:25. dqg owkhu dssolfdeoh ,+5/ dqg vwdqgdugv wo hqvxuh wkdw wkhlu dssolfdwloq gohv qow uhvxow lq glvfulplqdwloq djdlqvw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ͻ ,q lwv uhfhqw uhsouw wlwohg ௵7ozdugv (txdo 5ljkwv iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv௶ wkh (xuoshdq 3duoldphqw (3 wdnhv dv lwv vwduwlqj solqw wkh elqglqj ohjdo oeoljdwloqv oi 0hpehu 6wdwhv lq whupv oi wkh &53′ dqg wkh ௵dxwkoulwdwlyh jxlgdqfh oq lwv lpsohphqwdwloq௶ suoylghg e wkh &53′ &opplwwhh lq lwv mxulvsuxghqfh lqfoxglqj *hqhudo &opphqwv &oqfoxglqj 2evhuydwloqv dqg ghflvloqv oq lqglylgxdo foppxqlfdwloqvͺͳ 7kh lqwhusuhwdwloq oi (8 odz lq oljkw oi wkh &53’ lv dovo uhiohfwhg lq wkh 5hfopphqgdwloq oq suofhgxudo uljkwv oi vxvshfwv dqg dffxvhg shuvoqv vxemhfw wo suhwuldo ghwhqwloq dqg oq pdwhuldo ghwhqwloq foqglwloqvͺͳ 7khuh lv dq lpsouwdqw uhihuhqfh lq wkh 3uhdpeoh oi wklv 5hfopphqgdwloq olqnlqj lw gluhfwo wo wkh &53’ dqg vshflilfdoo uhihuulqj wo 6wdwh oeoljdwloqv lq uhodwloq wo uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq dqg dffhvvlelolw ,w uhdgv dv ioooozv ௵5hihuhqfhv lq wklv 5hfopphqgdwloq wo dssuosuldwh phdvxuhv wo hqvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog eh xqghuvwoog lq oljkw oi wkh uljkwv dqg oeoljdwloqv xqghu wkh 8qlwhg 1dwloqv &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv wo zklfk wkh (xuoshdq 8qloq dqg doo lwv 0hpehu 6wdwhv duh sduwlhv ,q dgglwloq lw vkoxog eh hqvxuhg wkdw li shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh ghsulyhg oi wkhlu olehuw lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv wkh duh oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv hqwlwohg wo jxdudqwhhv lq dffougdqfh zlwk lqwhuqdwloqdo kxpdq uljkwv odz dqg vkdoo eh wuhdwhg lq fopsoldqfh zlwk wkh oemhfwlyhv dqg sulqflsohv oi wkh 8qlwhg 1dwloqv &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj e $uwlfoh 7)(8 hvwdeolvkhv wkdw ௵ 7kh 8qloq pd foqfoxgh dq djuhhphqw zlwk oqh ou pouh wklug foxqwulhv ou lqwhuqdwloqdo oujdqlvdwloqv zkhuh wkh 7uhdwlhv vo suoylgh ou zkhuh wkh foqfoxvloq oi dq djuhhphqw lv qhfhvvdu lq oughu wo dfklhyh zlwklq wkh iudphzoun oi wkh 8qloqv soolflhv oqh oi wkh oemhfwlyhv uhihuuhg wo lq wkh 7uhdwlhv ou lv suoylghg iou lq d ohjdoo elqglqj 8qloq dfw ou lv olnho wo diihfw foppoq uxohv ou dowhu wkhlu vfosh $juhhphqwv foqfoxghg e wkh 8qloq duh elqglqj xsoq wkh lqvwlwxwloqv oi wkh 8qloq dqg oq lwv 0hpehu 6wdwhv wkh (8 dffhvvhg wo wkh &53’ wkuoxjk wkh &oxqflo ‘hflvloq (& oi 1oyhpehu foqfhuqlqj wkh foqfoxvloq e wkh (xuoshdq &oppxqlw oi wkh 81 &53’ 2- / (xuoshdq 3duoldphqw5(3257 7ozdugv htxdo uljkwv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,1, kwwsv zzzhxuosduohxuosdhxgofhogofxphqw$ b(1kwpo sdud + %uxvvhov & ilqdo 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ௬ ,17(51$7,21$/ $1’ (8 /(*$/ )5$0(:25. suoylglqj uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq iou vshfldo qhhgv dqg e hqvxulqj dffhvvlelolw௶ͺʹ $ffouglqj wo wkh 5hfopphqgdwloq ௵*xlgdqfh vkoxog eh suoylghg oq vdihjxduglqj wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv iou zkop ghsulydwloq oi olehuw foqvwlwxwhv d vlwxdwloq oi sduwlfxodu yxoqhudelolw vxfk dv zophq fkloguhq shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ou vhuloxv khdowk foqglwloqv /*%7,4 dqg iouhljq qdwloqdov dv zhoo dv wkh suhyhqwloq oi udglfdolvdwloq lq sulvoqv௶ ,q dgglwloq ௵0hpehu 6wdwhv vkoxog wdnh lqwo dffoxqw wkh vshfldo qhhgv oi sduwlfxodu juoxsv oi ghwdlqhhv lqfoxglqj zophq fkloguhq hoghuo shuvoqv shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ou vhuloxv khdowk foqglwloqv /*%7,4 shuvoqv zlwk d plqoulw udfldo ou hwkqlf edfnjuoxqg dqg iouhljq qdwloqdov lq doo ghflvloqv uhodwlqj wo wkhlu ghwhqwloq௶ͺͷ 7kh dlp oi wkh 5hfopphqgdwloq oq suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv iou yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv lv wo suowhfw shosoh lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv zko duh sduwlfxoduo ௵yxoqhudeoh௶ 7kh 5hfopphqgdwloq fdoov xsoq 0hpehu 6wdwhv wo vwuhqjwkhq fhuwdlq suofhgxudo uljkwv oi ௵yxoqhudeoh௶ vxvshfwv ou dffxvhg shuvoqv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv ,w vwuhvvhv wkh uljkw wo lqioupdwloq wkh uljkw wo dffhvv wo d odzhu dqg vdihjxdugv uhodwhg wo ghsulydwloq oi olehuw ,q sduwlfxodu wkhuh duh voph uhfopphqgdwloqv wkdw fdq dsso wo ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv )ou h[dpsoh wkh 5hfopphqgdwloq suhvfulehv wkdw 0hpehu 6wdwhv vkoxog jxdudqwhh ,elg 5hflwdo ,elg 3uhdpeoh 5hflwdo ,elg 5hflwdo &opplvvloq 5hfopphqgdwloq oi 1oyhpehu oq suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv iou yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv ௬ vhfwloqv dqg vhh khuh kwwsv fopplvvloqhxuosdhxvwudwhjdqgsoolfsoolflhvmxvwlfhdqgixqgdphqwdouljkwvfulplqdomxvwlfhuljkwvvxvshfwvdqgdffxvhgbhqghvljqlqjfulplqdoodz ,elg 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ௬ ,17(51$7,21$/ $1′ (8 /(*$/ )5$0(:25. dffhvv wo uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv iou yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv ghsulyhg oi wkhlu olehuwͺ ,w dovo uhihuv wo wkh dffhvvlelolw oi lpsouwdqw lqioupdwloq oq suofhgxudo uljkwvͺͺ $w wkh vdph wlph wkh 5hfopphqgdwloq foqwdlqv d qxpehu oi fulwlfdo hohphqwv lq uhjdug wo wkh lghqwlilfdwloq oi wkh eduulhuv dqg vshfldo qhhgv wkdw yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv pljkw qhhg gxulqj mxglfldo suofhhglqjv ,w uhfojql]hv wkh qhhg wo suopswo lghqwli wkh yxoqhudelolwlhv dqg qhhgv oi wkh ghihqgdqwvͺͻ ,w dovo phqwloqv lpsouwdqw foqfhswv wkdw duh wo dq h[whqw lq olqh zlwk wkh &53′ dqg lwv sulqflsohv )ou lqvwdqfh lw uhfopphqgv wudlqlqj mxvwlfh suoihvvloqdov dqg odz hqioufhphqw dxwkoulwlhv dv zhoo dv wkh dffhvvlelolw oi lqioupdwloq lq gliihuhqw ioupdwvͻͳ 7kh iudplqj oi wkh 5hfopphqgdwloq lv qow zkooo lq olqh zlwk 6wdwhv oeoljdwloqv xqghu wkh &53’ 7kh ghilqlwloq oi ௵yxoqhudeoh௶ shuvoqv suoylghg lq wkh 5hfopphqgdwloq lqfoxghv shuvoqv zko ௵duh qow deoh wo xqghuvwdqg dqg wo hiihfwlyho sduwlflsdwh lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv gxh wo djh wkhlu phqwdo ou skvlfdo foqglwloq ou glvdelolwlhv௶ͻͳ :khuhdv wklv iudplqj hpskdvl]hv yxoqhudelolw dqg gluhfwv lwvhoi wozdugv d phglfdol]hg xqghuvwdqglqj oi glvdelolw wkh &53′ uhtxluhv vxssouw wo hqvxuh wkh ixoo sduwlflsdwloq oi doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv dqg dgoswv d vofldo dssuodfk wo glvdelolw ,q dgglwloq wkh vwdqgdug oi ௵uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq௶ lv oozhu wkdq wkh &53’ vwdqgdug oi ௵suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloq௶ zklfk lv qow vxemhfw wo d whvw oi suosouwloqdolw 3ohdvh ilqg ixuwkhu ghwdlov oq wkhvh lqvwuxphqwv wkuoxjkoxw &kdswhuv ,,, dqg ,9 ehooz 7kh (xuoshdq &opplvvloq ghyhooshg dq (8 glvdelolw vwudwhj iou wkh shulog ͻʹ 7kh (8 6wudwhj iou wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv dovo foqvlghuv htxdo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh dqg qoqglvfulplqdwloq dv (8 suloulwlhvͻ͵ 6oph (8 ‘luhfwlyhv ,elg 5hffopphqgdwloq 1o ,elg 5hfopphqgdwloq 1o ,elg sdud ,elg sdud ,elg 5hflwdo (8 &opplvvloq 8qloq oi (txdolw 6wudwhj iou wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv &20 ilqdo ,elg vhfwloq 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ௬ ,17(51$7,21$/ $1′ (8 /(*$/ )5$0(:25. h[solflwo phqwloq glvdelolw exw oqo lq wkh foqwh[w oi euodghu suhvfulswloqv foqfhuqlqj wkh lqwhjudwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg wkh idlu dgplqlvwudwloq oi wkh mxvwlfh vvwhpͻͷ 7kh (xuoshdq 3duoldphqw lq d &opplwwhh uhsouw oq htxdo uljkwv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv kdv dvvhuwhg wkdw wkh odfn oi d foppoq (8 ghilqlwloq oi glvdelolw foqvwlwxwhv d pdmou oevwdfoh wo wkh foglilfdwloq oi glvdelolw dvvhvvphqw dqg wkh pxwxdo uhfojqlwloq oi qdwloqdo ghflvloqv oq glvdelolw lvvxhv sduwlfxoduo lq wkh foqwh[w oi holjlelolw iou dffhvv wo vshflilf idflolwlhv dqg vhuylfhv lq wkh ilhog oi vofldo vhfxulwͻͷ 7kh (3 &opplwwhh oq &lylo /lehuwlhv -xvwlfh dqg +oph $iidluv wkhuhiouh fdoohg oq wkh &opplvvloq dqg wkh 0hpehu 6wdwhv wo zoun wozdugv ghyhooslqj pxwxdo ghilqlwloqv oi nh whupv uhodwhg wo wkh lpsohphqwdwloq oi wkh &53’ vxfk dv ௵dffhvvlelolw௶ ௵sduwlflsdwloq௶ dqg ௵foppxqlwedvhg olylqj௶ͻ dqg xujhg wkh &opplvvloq wo sxw iouzdug d suosovdo iou d kdupoql]hg ghilqlwloq oi glvdelolw dw wkh (8 ohyho ,w dovo kljkoljkwhg wkh lpsouwdqfh oi d koolvwlf ghilqlwloq dqg dssolfdwloq oi dffhvvlelolw dqg lwv ydoxh dv dq lqglvshqvdeoh edvlv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo kdyh htxdo ossouwxqlwlhv dv uhfojql]hg lq wkh &53′ dqg lq olqh zlwk &53’ *hqhudo &opphqw 1o wdnlqj lqwo dffoxqw wkh glyhuvlw oi wkh qhhgv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg suopowlqj xqlyhuvdo ghvljq dv d sulqflsoh oi wkh (8 (8 3duoldphqw 7ozdugv htxdo uljkwv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ‘hfhpehu $ ,elg sdud + sdud + ,elg sdud ,elg sdud ,elg sdud 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ௬ ,17(51$7,21$/ $1’ (8 /(*$/ )5$0(:25. a -ŸŸɍ§uɍ]Ÿ§m -ɍbu˜ɍ•-˜ŸukŸɍèm§iɍ$mŸa mbm§m-Ÿɍ $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 &kdswhu ,,, dgguhvvhv wkh eduulhuv wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv idfh gxulqj wkh mxvwlfh suofhvv zlwk d sduwlfxodu iofxv oq ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7klv fkdswhu jlyhv dq oyhuylhz oi wkh pdlq fkdoohqjhv lq jxdudqwhhlqj wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg dovo suhvhqwv suoplvlqj sudfwlfhv dqg uhfopphqgdwloqv oq koz wo oyhufoph wkhvh eduulhuv 7kh &kdswhu foyhuv wkh fkdoohqjhv lq jxdudqwhhlqj htxdo wuhdwphqw ehiouh wkh odz wkh uljkw wo ohjdo fdsdflw dqg wkh uljkw wo sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkh ossouwxqlwlhv oiihuhg e uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh lq wklv foqwh[w dqg wkh sovvleoh zdv wo lpsuoyh wkh wudlqlqj oi mxvwlfh suoihvvloqdov oq wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg wkh uljkw wo d idlu wuldo dqg dq hiihfwlyh uhphg $w wkh hqg oi hdfk vhfwloq wkhuh duh sudfwlfdo dqg vvwhplf uhfopphqgdwloqv 7kh sudfwlfdo jxlgdqfh dqg uhfopphqgdwloqv duh gluhfwhg dw mxvwlfh dfwouv zounlqj zlwk ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq oughu wo suoylgh jxlgdqfh dqg suoplvlqj sudfwlfh h[dpsohv oq koz wo lqwhjudwh wkh uhohydqw vwdqgdugv lqwo sudfwlfh 7kh vvwhplf uhfopphqgdwloqv dovo wdujhw soolfpdnhuv dqg ohjlvodwouv suoylglqj vxjjhvwloqv oi ohjlvodwlyh fkdqjhv ou poglilfdwloqv wo wkh ixqfwloqlqj oi wkh foxuw vvwhp lq oughu wo hqvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7kh uhfopphqgdwloqv lq &kdswhu ,,, duh exlow xsoq lq &kdswhu ,9 zklfk ghvfulehv suofhgxudo uljkwv oi ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv $uwlfohv dqg oi wkh &53’ dw wkh wlph oi wuhdw௲v dgoswloq foqvwlwxwhg d sdudgljp vkliw lq wkh ohjdo uhfojqlwloq oi wkh dxwoqop oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7kh &oqyhqwloq uhmhfwv fhuwdlq klvwoulfdoo hqwuhqfkhg xqghuvwdqglqjv oi glvdelolw e zklfk shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv kdyh ehhq ghsulyhg oi dq phdqv wo h[huflvh wkhlu zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv dqg lq pdq foxqwulhv kdyh hiihfwlyho uhvxowhg lq wkhlu ehlqj ghqlhg dffhvv wo mxvwlfh dqg suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv 7klv sdudgljp vkliw zklfk kdv ehhq dgoswhg e wkh (&+5 wkh (xuoshdq 3duoldphqw dqg yduloxv owkhu hqwlwlhv qhfhvvlwdwhv d uhylhz dqg uhylvloq oi doo h[lvwlqj odzv soolflhv dqg suofhgxuhv e hdfk dqg hyhu 6wdwh )hz 6wdwhv kdyh 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv s &oxqflo oi (xuosh ‘lvdelolw 6wudwhj +xpdq 5ljkwv d 5hdolw iou $oo sdudv (xuoshdq 3duoldphqw 5(3257 7ozdugv htxdo uljkwv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,1, kwwsv zzzhxuosduohxuosdhxgofhogofxphqw$ b(1kwpo sdud 2 (xuoshdq &opplvvloq 8qloq oi (txdolw 6wudwhj iou wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv .((11b suooi sgi $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 xqghuwdnhq wklv wdvn fopsuhkhqvlyho dowkoxjk wkhuh kdv ehhq voph judgxdo suojuhvv lq voph 1dwloqdo mxvwlfh dfwouv lqfoxglqj mxgjhv kdyh oeoljdwloqv xqghu wkh &53’ wo uhylhz dqg uhylvh suofhvvhv dqg suofhgxuhv wo hqvxuh fopsoldqfh zlwk wkhlu oeoljdwloqv xqghu wkh &53’ ʴ˥˧˜˖˟˘ ʤʥ ʶ˅˃ʷ ϝ ʸˤ˨˔˟ ˅˘˖ˢ˚ˡ˜˧˜ˢˡ ˕˘˙ˢ˥˘ ˧˛˘ ˟˔˪ 6wdwhv 3duwlhv uhdiilup wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv kdyh wkh uljkw wo uhfojqlwloq hyhuzkhuh dv shuvoqv ehiouh wkh odz 6wdwhv 3duwlhv vkdoo uhfojql]h wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv hqmo ohjdo fdsdflw oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv lq doo dvshfwv oi olih 6wdwhv 3duwlhv vkdoo wdnh dssuosuldwh phdvxuhv wo suoylgh dffhvv e shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo wkh vxssouw wkh pd uhtxluh lq h[huflvlqj wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw 6wdwhv 3duwlhv vkdoo hqvxuh wkdw doo phdvxuhv wkdw uhodwh wo wkh h[huflvh oi ohjdo fdsdflw suoylgh iou dssuosuldwh dqg hiihfwlyh vdihjxdugv wo suhyhqw dexvh lq dffougdqfh zlwk lqwhuqdwloqdo kxpdq uljkwv odz 6xfk vdihjxdugv vkdoo hqvxuh wkdw phdvxuhv uhodwlqj wo wkh h[huflvh oi ohjdo fdsdflw uhvshfw wkh uljkwv zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv oi wkh shuvoq duh iuhh oi foqiolfw oi lqwhuhvw dqg xqgxh lqioxhqfh duh suosouwloqdo dqg wdloouhg wo wkh shuvoqv flufxpvwdqfhv dsso iou wkh vkouwhvw wlph sovvleoh dqg duh vxemhfw wo uhjxodu uhylhz e d fopshwhqw lqghshqghqw dqg lpsduwldo dxwkoulw ou mxglfldo eog 7kh vdihjxdugv vkdoo eh suosouwloqdo wo wkh ghjuhh wo zklfk vxfk phdvxuhv diihfw wkh shuvoqv uljkwv dqg lqwhuhvwv 6xemhfw wo wkh suoylvloqv oi wklv duwlfoh 6wdwhv 3duwlhv vkdoo wdnh doo dssuosuldwh dqg hiihfwlyh phdvxuhv wo hqvxuh wkh htxdo uljkw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo ozq ou lqkhulw suoshuw wo foqwuoo wkhlu ozq ilqdqfldo diidluv dqg wo kdyh htxdo dffhvv wo edqn oodqv pouwjdjhv dqg owkhu ioupv oi ilqdqfldo fuhglw dqg vkdoo hqvxuh wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh qow duelwudulo ghsulyhg oi wkhlu suoshuw $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ʴ˥˧˜˖˟˘ ʤʦ ʶ˅˃ʷ ϝ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ʽ˨˦˧˜˖˘ 6wdwhv 3duwlhv vkdoo hqvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv lqfoxglqj wkuoxjk wkh suoylvloq oi suofhgxudo dqg djhdssuosuldwh dffoppogdwloqv lq oughu wo idflolwdwh wkhlu hiihfwlyh uooh dv gluhfw dqg lqgluhfw sduwlflsdqwv lqfoxglqj dv zlwqhvvhv lq doo ohjdo suofhhglqjv lqfoxglqj dw lqyhvwljdwlyh dqg owkhu suholplqdu vwdjhv ,q oughu wo khos wo hqvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 6wdwhv 3duwlhv vkdoo suopowh dssuosuldwh wudlqlqj iou wkovh zounlqj lq wkh ilhog oi dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh lqfoxglqj soolfh dqg sulvoq vwdii -xvwlfh dfwouv pxvw fopso zlwk wkh &53’ dqg vkoxog lpsohphqw wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv wo hqvxuh idlu dqg hiihfwlyh mxvwlfh vvwhpv $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ʴʡ ʸˤ˨˔˟ ˧˥˘˔˧ˠ˘ˡ˧ ˕˘˙ˢ˥˘ ˧˛˘ ˟˔˪ʟ ˟˘˚˔˟ ˖˔ˣ˔˖˜˧ˬ ˔ˡ˗ ˘ˤ˨˔˟ ˣ˔˥˧˜˖˜ˣ˔˧˜ˢˡ ʸˤ˨˔˟ ˧˥˘˔˧ˠ˘ˡ˧ ˕˘˙ˢ˥˘ ˧˛˘ ˟˔˪ $v uhfojql]hg e wkh &53′ &opplwwhh lq lwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wslfdoo go qow hqmo wkhlu uljkwv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv ehfdxvh oi dpoqj owkhu idfwouv ௵ghsulydwloq oi ohjdo fdsdflw ioufhg lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq h[foxvloq iuop jhqhudo hgxfdwloq shuydvlyh qhjdwlyh vwhuhowshv suhmxglfhv dqg odfn oi dffhvv wo hpsoophqw௶ͳͳ͵ 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv duh hvvhqwldo vdihjxdugv wo oyhufoph wkhvh eduulhuv $uwlfoh oi wkh &53′ uhtxluhv wkdw 6wdwhv ௵wdnh doo dssuosuldwh vwhsv wo hqvxuh wkdw uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq lv suoylghg௶ duwlfoh dqg suoylghv wkdw ௵vshflilf phdvxuhv zklfk duh qhfhvvdu wo dffhohudwh ou dfklhyh gh idfwo htxdolw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkdoo qow eh foqvlghuhg glvfulplqdwloq xqghu wkh whupv oi wkh suhvhqw &oqyhqwloq௶ duwlfoh ͳͳͷ 2wkhu lqwhuqdwloqdo kxpdq uljkwv wuhdwlhv suoylgh iou wkh oeoljdwloqv wo hqvxuh wkdw shosoh duh ௵htxdo ehiouh wkh odz௶ zklfk ghvfulehv wkh hqwlwohphqw oi shuvoqv wo htxdo wuhdwphqw e dqg lq wkh dssolfdwloq oi wkh odz ௵,q oughu wkdw wklv uljkw pd eh ixoo uhdol]hg wkh mxglfldu dqg odz hqioufhphqw oiilfhuv pxvw qow lq wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh glvfulplqdwh djdlqvw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ͳͳͷ 7kh &53′ suoylghv iou voph lpsouwdqw vwhsv wo jxdudqwhh htxdolw dqg dyolg glvfulplqdwloq $ffouglqj wo duwlfoh 6wdwhv ௵vkdoo wdnh doo dssuosuldwh vwhsv wo hqvxuh wkdw uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq lv suoylghg௶ͳͳ 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh suoylghv h[dpsohv oi vxfk uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxglqj ௵pdnlqj h[lvwlqj idflolwlhv &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o sdud 9dolglw )oxqgdwloq +xpdqlvlqj -xvwlfh ,qwhuqdwloqdo uhsouw iuop 9olfhv iou -xvwlfh &oppxqlfdwlqj zlwk 9lfwlpv oi &ulph zlwk ‘lvdelolw s &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o sdud &53’ duwlfoh $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 dqg lqioupdwloq dffhvvleoh wo wkh lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw poglilqj htxlsphqw uhoujdql]lqj dfwlylwlhv uhvfkhgxolqj zoun dgmxvwlqj fxuulfxod ohduqlqj pdwhuldov dqg whdfklqj vwudwhjlhv dgmxvwlqj phglfdo suofhgxuhv ou hqdeolqj dffhvv wo vxssouw shuvoqqho zlwkoxw glvsuosouwloqdwh ou xqgxh exughq௶ͳͳ 7kh &opplwwhh dovo h[sodlqv wkdw ௵uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq௶ vkoxog qow eh foqixvhg zlwk ௵vshflilf phdvxuhv௶ vophwlphv dovo fdoohg ௵vshfldo phdvxuhv௶ ou ௵whpsoudu vshfldo phdvxuhv௶ lq ,+5/ dqg lqfoxglqj zkdw duh oiwhq ghvfulehg dv ௵diilupdwlyh dfwloq phdvxuhv௶ lq voph gophvwlf mxulvglfwloqv $ffouglqj wo wkh &opplwwhh ௵:kloh eowk foqfhswv dlp dw dfklhylqj gh idfwo htxdolw uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq lv d qoqglvfulplqdwloq gxw zkhuhdv vshflilf phdvxuhv lpso d suhihuhqwldo wuhdwphqw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oyhu owkhuv wo dgguhvv klvwoulf dqgou vvwhpdwlfvvwhplf h[foxvloq iuop wkh ehqhilwv oi h[huflvlqj uljkwv ([dpsohv oi vshflilf phdvxuhv lqfoxgh whpsoudu phdvxuhv iou foxqwhulqj wkh ooz qxpehuv oi zophq zlwk glvdelolwlhv hpsoohg lq wkh sulydwh vhfwou dqg vxssouw suojudpphv wo lqfuhdvh wkh qxpehu oi vwxghqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq whuwldu hgxfdwloq௶ͳͳͺ )ou lqvwdqfh lq lwv ylhzv lq wkh &oppxqlfdwloq 0hglqd 9hod y 0h[lfo 1o ͳͳͻ wkh &53′ &opplwwhh ioxqg d yloodwloq oi duwlfoh lq foqmxqfwloq zlwk duwlfoh iou glvfulplqdwou wuhdwphqw ,q wklv pdwwhu wkh dssolfdqw d shuvoq zlwk dq lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw kdg qow ehhq jlyhq wkh ossouwxqlw wo whvwli lq d fdvh djdlqvw wkhp ghvljqdwh wkhlu ozq ghihqfh odzhu ou uhfhlyh vxssouw dqg uhdvoqdeoh ou suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv &oqvhtxhqwo wkh &53′ &opplwwhh foqvlghuhg wkdw wkh dssolfdwloq &53′ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o sdud &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o sdud f 9lhzv dgoswhg e wkh &opplwwhh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh 2swloqdo 3uowofoo foqfhuqlqj foppxqlfdwloq 0hglqd 9hod y 0h[lfo 1o 2fwoehu sdud $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 oi wkh vshfldo suofhgxuh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv h[hpswlqj wkhp iuop fulplqdo oldelolw dv suoylghg iou lq qdwloqdo odz lq 0h[lfo ohg wo glvfulplqdwou wuhdwphqw oi wkh dssolfdqw lq yloodwloq oi duwlfoh uhdg lq foqmxqfwloq zlwk duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloqͳͳͳ $uwlfoh oi wkh (8 &kduwhu oi )xqgdphqwdo 5ljkwv uhfojql]hv wkdw ௵hyhuoqh lv htxdo ehiouh wkh odz௶ zkloh duwlfoh suoklelwv glvfulplqdwloq edvhg oq d udqjh oi juoxqgv lqfoxglqj glvdelolw 7kh &53’ ghilqlwloq oi glvfulplqdwloq kdv ehhq gluhfwo dgoswhg dqg lqfousoudwhg lqwo (8 odzͳͳͳ $uwlfoh oi wkh ,&&35 suoylghv ௵$oo shuvoqv duh htxdo ehiouh wkh odz dqg duh hqwlwohg zlwkoxw dq glvfulplqdwloq wo wkh htxdo suowhfwloq oi wkh odz ,q wklv uhvshfw wkh odz vkdoo suoklelw dq glvfulplqdwloq dqg jxdudqwhh wo doo shuvoqv htxdo dqg hiihfwlyh suowhfwloq djdlqvw glvfulplqdwloq oq dq juoxqg vxfk dv udfh foooxu vh[ odqjxdjh uholjloq soolwlfdo ou owkhu oslqloq qdwloqdo ou vofldo ouljlq suoshuw eluwk ou owkhu vwdwxv௶ :kloh glvdelolw lv qow h[suhvvo hqxphudwhg lw lv foyhuhg xqghu ௵owkhu vwdwxv௶ ,qwhuvhfwloqdo glvfulplqdwloq 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vophwlphv dovo idfh owkhu ioupv oi glvfulplqdwloq dqg h[foxvloq zklfk fdq lpshgh wkhlu dffhvv wo mxvwlfh ‘lvfulplqdwloq oq wkh edvlv oi glvdelolw pd eh fopsoxqghg e vlpxowdqhoxv glvfulplqdwloq oq wkh edvlv oi owkhu lghqwlwlhv ou edvhv vxfk dv jhqghu hwkqlflw uholjloq soyhuw vh[xdo oulhqwdwloq jhqghu lghqwlw ou flwl]hqvkls vwdwxvͳͳʹ )ou lqvwdqfh zophq zlwk glvdelolwlhv whqg wo ,elg sdud (xuoshdq &opplvvloq &oppxqlfdwloq iuop wkh &opplvvloq wo wkh (xuoshdq 3duoldphqw wkh &oxqflo wkh (xuoshdq (foqoplf dqg 6ofldo &opplwwhhdqg wkh &opplwwhh oi wkh 5hjloqv (xuoshdq ‘lvdelolw 6wudwhj $ 5hqhzhg &opplwphqw wo d %duulhu)uhh (xuosh &20 ilqdo 81 2+&+5 ௱5hsouw 5ljkw wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv௲ ’hfhpehu $+5& sdud $v fodulilhg e wkh &53’ lq lwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o ௵>g@lvfulplqdwloq fdq eh edvhg $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 idfh pouh gliilfxowlhv lq dffhvvlqj mxvwlfh fopsduhg wo phq zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg zophq zlwkoxw glvdelolwlhvͳͳ͵ 7kh &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3hosoh zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv kljkoljkwv wkdw zophq zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh pouh olnho wo kdyh wkhlu fuhglelolw txhvwloqhg dqg wkhlu dffxvdwloqv glvplvvhg ehfdxvh oi jhqghu dqg glvdelolw vwhuhowshv 7kh duh dovo pouh olnho wo h[shulhqfh ihdu dqg eh glvfoxudjhg iuop vhhnlqj ohjdo uhphglhv ehfdxvh oi wkh glvplvvlyh dwwlwxgh oi odz hqioufhphqw dxwkoulwlhvͳͳͷ ,qwhuvhfwlqj ioupv oi glvfulplqdwloq vkoxog eh xqghuvwoog dqg foqvlghuhg e doo mxvwlfh dfwouv 0dqgdwou wudlqlqj suojudpphv iou wkovh zounlqj lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp pxvw dgguhvv wkhvh lqwhuvhfwlqj ioupv oi glvfulplqdwloqͳͳͷ 7kh 81 ,qwhuvhfwloqdolw 5hvoxufh *xlgh dqg 7ooonlwͳͳ suhvhqwv d iudphzoun iou dfwloq lq wkh foqwh[w oi lqwhuvhfwloqdo glvfulplqdwloq 7kh *xlgh vkozv koz glvfulplqdwloq fdq kdsshq eowk dw lqglylgxdo dqg fooohfwlyhvvwhplf ohyhov dqg lw fdq diihfw eowk wdqjleoh dqg lqwdqjleoh hohphqwv ,w kljkoljkwv wkdw pdq hohphqwv vkoxog eh wdnhq lqwo dffoxqw wo xqghuvwdqg lqwhuvhfwloqdo glvfulplqdwloq (ohphqwv vxfk dv djhqf fopplwphqw nqozohgjh dqg vnloov qhhghg iou htxdolw vkoxog eh wdnhq lqwo foqvlghudwloq dv zhoo dv dffhvv wo dqg foqwuoo oyhu uhvoxufhv dqg ossouwxqlwlhv (txdoo odzv soolflhv suojudpphv uhvoxufh dooofdwloq dqg dffoxqwdelolw phfkdqlvpv duh dovo hvvhqwldo dvshfwv wo eh foqvlghuhg )lqdoo vofldo qoupv oq d vlqjoh fkdudfwhulvwlf vxfk dv glvdelolw ou jhqghu ou oq pxowlsoh dqgou lqwhuvhfwlqj fkdudfwhulvwlfv ௱,qwhuvhfwloqdo glvfulplqdwloq௲ offxuv zkhq d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw ou dvvofldwhg wo glvdelolw vxiihuv glvfulplqdwloq oi dq ioup oq wkh edvlv oi glvdelolw fopelqhg zlwk foooxu vh[ odqjxdjh uholjloq hwkqlf jhqghu ou owkhu vwdwxv ,qwhuvhfwloqdo glvfulplqdwloq fdq dsshdu dv gluhfw ou lqgluhfw glvfulplqdwloq ghqldo oi uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq ou kdudvvphqw௶ &53’ *& 1o sdud 81 &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3hosoh zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh :ophq dqg *luov zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv &53’&*& ,elg sdud 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv s 81 :20(1 ,qwhuvhfwloqdolw 5hvoxufh *xlgh dqg 7ooonlw $q ,qwhuvhfwloqdo $ssuodfk wo /hdyh 1o 2qh %hklqg dydlodeoh dw ,17(56(&7,21$/,7< 5(6285&( *8,'( $1' 722/.,7 xqzophqouj $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ',6$%,/,7,(6 dwwlwxghv dqg h[foxvloqdu sudfwlfhv fdq dovo kdyh dq lpsdfw oq suogxflqj ou fopsoxqglqj lqwhuvhfwloqdo glvfulplqdwloqͳͳ ,ghqwlilfdwloq oi ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,ghqwlilfdwloq oi ghwdlqhhv dqg ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lv fuxfldo wo hqkdqfh dffhvv wo doo qhfhvvdu vxssouw dqg dffoppogdwloqv 7kh (8 5hfopphqgdwloqv vwdwh wkdw ௵>l@w lv hvvhqwldo wkdw wkh yxoqhudelolw oi d shuvoq vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv lv suopswo lghqwlilhg dqg uhfojqlvhg )ou wkdw sxusovh dq lqlwldo dvvhvvphqw vkoxog eh fduulhg oxw e soolfh oiilfhuv odz hqioufhphqw ou mxglfldo dxwkoulwlhv 7kh fopshwhqw dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog dovo eh deoh wo dvn dq lqghshqghqw h[shuw wo h[dplqh wkh ghjuhh oi yxoqhudelolw wkh qhhgv oi wkh yxoqhudeoh shuvoq dqg wkh dssuosuldwhqhvv oi dq phdvxuhv wdnhq ou hqylvdjhg djdlqvw wkh yxoqhudeoh shuvoq௶ͳͳͺ 7klv 5hfopphqgdwloq dgguhvvhv vkouwfoplqjv lq (8 0hpehu 6wdwhv )ou lqvwdqfh lq uhihuhqfh wo sudfwlfhv lq 6sdlq lq wkh (xuoshdq &opplwwhh iou wkh 3uhyhqwloq oi 7ouwxuh dqg ,qkxpdq ou ‘hjudglqj 7uhdwphqw ou 3xqlvkphqw h[suhvvhg foqfhuq deoxw wkh odfn oi glvdelolw ghwhfwloq gxulqj dgplvvloq wo sulvoq dqg gxulqj mxglfldo suofhhglqjv zklfk uhvxowhg lq shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ehlqj h[sovhg wo mxvwlfh suofhvvhv dqg suofhgxuhv zklfk zhuh lqdffhvvleoh &oqgxfwlqj dq lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw lv dq lpsouwdqw zd wo lghqwli lq d wlpho pdqqhu wkh uljkwv dqg qhhgv iou vxssouw dqg dffoppogdwloqv oi dq lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw 6xfk qhhgv pd fkdqjh wkuoxjkoxw wkh suofhvv ou iuop wlph wo wlph ‘lvdelolw pd ,elg s &opplvvloq 5hfopphqgdwloq oi 1oyhpehu oq suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv iou yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv 5hflwdo 5hsouw wo wkh 6sdqlvk joyhuqphqw oq wkh ylvlw wo 6sdlq e wkh (xuoshdq &opplwwhh iou wkh suhyhqwloq oi wouwxuh dqg lqkxpdq ou ghjudglqj wuhdwphqw ou sxqlvkphqw &37 iuop wo 6hswhpehu kwwsv upfohlqwdd ,q 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµqs $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 eh hyooylqj dqg gqdplf dqg dq lqlwldo dvvhvvphqw dqg lghqwlilfdwloq vkoxog eh vxssohphqwhg e foqvlvwhqw poqlwoulqj dqg dgdswhg wdnlqj lqwo dffoxqw dq lqglylgxdov௲ fkdqjlqj qhhgv 6hh pouh ehooz lq vhfwloq ,9 ,qglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw ʼˡ˦˔ˡ˜˧ˬ ˗˘˙˘ˡ˖˘ $oo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv kdyh d uljkw wo suhvxpswlyh ohjdo fdsdflw lh wo pdnh ohjdoo hiihfwlyh ghflvloqv 7kh vkoxog qow eh ghqlhg dffhvv wo mxvwlfh ou sduwlflsdwloq lq dq mxvwlfh suofhvvhv dqg suofhgxuhv oq wkh edvlv oi glvdelolwͳʹͳ 7kh jhqhudo dvvxpswloq pxvw eh lq hdfk dqg hyhu fdvh wkdw doo shosoh duh fdsdeoh oi pdnlqj dqg wkxv ehlqj uhvsoqvleoh iou wkhlu ozq ghflvloqv dqg dfwloqvͳʹͳ 6wdwhv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw wkh ohjdo fdsdflw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lv uhfojql]hg dw doo ohyhov oi wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhp zlwkoxw glvfulplqdwloq 6wdwhv duh uhtxluhg e wkh &53′ wo ௵>h@qvxuh wkdw foqvwuxfwv vxfk dv ௵fojqlwlyh lqfdsdflw௶ dqg ௵phqwdo lqfdsdflw௶ dv ghwhuplqhg iou lqvwdqfh e ixqfwloqdo ou phqwdo vwdwxv dvvhvvphqwv wkdw duh foppoq lq povw ohjdo vvwhpv duh qow xvhg wo uhvwulfw wkh uljkw wo ohjdo fdsdflw௶ͳʹʹ ,qghhg ghsulydwloq oi ohjdo fdsdflw zkhwkhu ioupdoo pdqgdwhg ou dv d uhvxow oi lqioupdo ou foppoq dqg ooqjvwdqglqj ohjdo sudfwlfhv suofhvvhv dqg suofhgxuhv ohdgv wo h[foxvloq iuop mxglfldo dqg owkhu ohjdo suofhvvhv ,w kdv shuydvlyh hiihfwv oq wkh uljkw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo d idlu wuldo xqghu gxh suofhvv oi odz ͳʹ͵ 7kh &53’ &opplwwhh kdv foqghpqhg olplwdwloqv wkdw duh oiwhq lpsovhg oq wkh uljkwv oi 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 3ulqflsoh &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh (txdo uhfojqlwloq ehiouh wkh odz &53’&*& sdud ,elg 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv sdud f 81 2+&+5 ௱5hsouw 5ljkw wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv௲ ’hfhpehu $+5& sdud $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vxfk dv ghsulydwloq oi wkh uljkw wo eh khdug lq shuvoq sxuvxh dgyhuvduldo suofhhglqjv jlyh hylghqfh ou foqwhvw zlwqhvvhvͳʹͷ :khuh ௵lqvwuxphqwv iou suowhfwloq௶ duh dydlodelolw foqfhuqlqj wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkh pxvw qow eh ௵edvhg oq uhpoylqj ohjdo fdsdflw ou owkhuzlvh klqghulqj wkh dffhvv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo mxvwlfh௶ͳʹͷ &oqvlvwhqw zlwk oeoljdwloqv xqghu wkh &53’ wkh h[lvwhqfh oi d glvdelolw edvhg oq d skvlfdo phqwdo vhqvou ou svfkovofldo lpsdluphqw pxvw qow ௵>@ eh juoxqgv iou ghqlqj ohjdo fdsdflw dqg wkh lpsovlwloq oi ௱vxevwlwxwh ghflvloq௩pdnlqj௲ ௬ wkdw lv d ghflvloq pdgh e dqowkhu shuvoq lq wkh sodfh oi wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw qow dssolqwhg e wkh shuvoq goqh djdlqvw klv ou khu zloo dqg qow edvhg oq klv ou khu ozq ௱zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv௲ͳʹ 6wdwhv duh uhtxluhg e wkh &53′ wo suoylgh wkh vxssouw qhfhvvdu wo hqdeoh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo pdnh ghflvloqv wkdw kdyh ohjdo hiihfwͳʹ 6xfk vxssouw phdvxuhv ௵pxvw uhvshfw wkh uljkwv zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg vkoxog qhyhu dpoxqw wo vxevwlwxwh ghflvloqpdnlqj௶ͳʹͺ :kloh wklv jhqhudo sulqflsoh vhhpv fohdu hqoxjk wkh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv solqwhg wkdw 6wdwh sudfwlfh kdv ehhq odjjlqj ehklqg ,q povw 6wdwhv ௵zkhuh d shuvoq lv foqvlghuhg wo kdyh lpsdluhg ghflvloqpdnlqj vnloov oiwhq ehfdxvh oi d fojqlwlyh ou svfkovofldo glvdelolw klv ou khu ohjdo fdsdflw wo pdnh d sduwlfxodu ghflvloq lv foqvhtxhqwo uhpoyhg௶ͳʹͻ ,elg &53′ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o sdud f &53′ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh (txdo uhfojqlwloq ehiouh wkh odz &53’&*& ,elg sdud &53′ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o sdud &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $sulo dydlodeoh dw *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh (txdo uhfojqlwloq ehiouh wkh odz $goswhg $sulo 3odlq (qjolvk yhuvloq _ 2+&+5 sdud $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7klv 6wdwh sudfwlfh foqvwlwxwhv d ௵ixqfwloqdo dssuodfk௶ zklfk ௵dwwhpswv wo dvvhvv phqwdo fdsdflw dqg ghq ohjdo fdsdflw dffouglqjo௶ ,q vxfk dq dssuodfk ghwhuplqdwloqv duh wslfdoo ௵edvhg oq zkhwkhu d shuvoq fdq xqghuvwdqg wkh qdwxuh dqg foqvhtxhqfhv oi d ghflvloq dqgou zkhwkhu kh ou vkh fdq xvh ou zhljk wkh uhohydqw lqioupdwloq௶ 7kh &opplwwhh foqfoxghv wkdw wklv lv d ௵iodzhg௶ dssuodfk lqfoqvlvwhqw zlwk wkh &53′ ehfdxvh ௵ d lw lv glvfulplqdwoulo dssolhg wo shosoh zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg e lw suhvxphv wo eh deoh wo dffxudwho dvvhvv wkh lqqhuzounlqjv oi wkh kxpdq plqg dqg zkhq wkh shuvoq gohv qow sdvv wkh dvvhvvphqw lw wkhq ghqlhv klp ou khu d fouh kxpdq uljkw௶ͳ͵ͳ 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv xqghuolqhg wkdw ghqldo oi ohjdo fdsdflw oq wkh edvlv oi d ixqfwloqdo dssuodfk lv glvfulplqdwou ,qghhg wklv dssuodfk suhvxphv wkdw wkh ghflvloqpdnlqj vnloov oi d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw duh ghilflhqw lq d zd wkdw dssolhv vooho wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg ௵suhvxphv wo eh deoh wo dffxudwho dvvhvv wkh lqqhuzounlqjv oi wkh kxpdq plqg௶ ohdglqj wo wkh ghqldo oi uljkwvͳ͵ͳ 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh diilupv lq uhodwloq wo wkh uljkw wo khdowk wkdw ௵>l@q foqmxqfwloq zlwk wkh uljkw wo ohjdo fdsdflw oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv 6wdwhv sduwlhv kdyh dq oeoljdwloq qow wo shuplw vxevwlwxwh ghflvloqpdnhuv wo suoylgh foqvhqw oq ehkdoi oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ͳ͵ʹ ,q lwv *xlgholqhv oq duwlfoh uljkw wo olehuw wkh &53′ &opplwwhh diilupv wkdw wklv oeoljdwloq h[whqgv wo hphujhqf dqg fulvlv vlwxdwloqv lq wkh foqwh[w oi ghsulydwloq oi olehuwͳ͵͵ ,elg &53′ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh (txdo uhfojqlwloq ehiouh wkh odz &53’&*& sdud &53′ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh (txdo uhfojqlwloq ehiouh wkh odz &53’&*& sdud &53’ &opplwwhh *xlgholqhv oq duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௬ 7kh uljkw wo olehuw dqg vhfxulw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv sdud $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 8qghu wkh &53’ 6wdwhv pxvw dovo pdnh vxuh doo khdowk vwdii duh dzduh oi wkh uljkw wo iuhh dqg lqiouphg foqvhqw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv iou wkhlu wuhdwphqw dqg dftxluh lw sulou wo xqghuwdnlqj dq wuhdwphqwͳ͵ͷ +hdowk vwdii pxvw suoylgh doo qhfhvvdu lqioupdwloq lq d zd wkdw dq lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw fdq ixoo xqghuvwdqgͳ͵ͷ 6xssouwhg ghflvloqpdnlqjͳ͵ dv ossovhg wo vxevwlwxwh ghflvloqv pdnlqj lv d pogho zklfk uhtxluhv wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh suoylghg zlwk d udqjh oi vxssouw oswloqv lqfoxglqj wkh vxssouw oi shosoh wkh pd wuxvw iou h[dpsoh idplo iulhqgv shhuv dgyofdwhv ou odzhuv lq oughu wo vxssouw dqg hqkdqfh wkhlu delolw wo pdnh ghflvloqv iou wkhpvhoyhvͳ͵ 8qghu duwlfoh oi wkh &53’ 6wdwhv duh uhtxluhg wo wdnh dssuosuldwh phdvxuhv wo suoylgh dffhvv e shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo wkh vxssouw zkhq wkh pd uhtxluh lq h[huflvlqj wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflwͳ͵ͺ 7kdw vxssouw pd eh uhlqioufhg e lqwhuphgldulhv zko dwwhpsw wo hqkdqfh foppxqlfdwloq zlwk wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw wkuoxjkoxw wkh suofhhglqjv 3ohdvh vhh ghwdlov ehooz lq vhfwloq ,9 oq 3uofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv )ou lqvwdqfh lq lwv ylhzv lq wkh &oppxqlfdwloq 0hglqd 9hod y 0h[lfo 1o ͳ͵ͻ wkh &53′ &opplwwhh ioxqg d yloodwloq oi duwlfoh oi wkh &53′ zkhuh wkh 6wdwh ghqlhg wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw wkh sovvlelolw wo h[huflvh wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw wo sohdg qow jxlow fkdoohqjh wkh hylghqfh djdlqvw wkhp ghvljqdwh d ghihqfh odzhu dqg fkdoohqjh dq ghflvloqvͳͷͳ 7kh 6wdwh ghflghg wo dsso d vshfldo suofhgxuh iou shuvoqv h[hpsw iuop fulplqdo oldelolw dqg ghfoduhg wkh dssolfdqw ௵xqilw wo whvwli௶ͳͷͳ &53’ &opplwwhh ௵*xlgholqhv oq wkh uljkw wo olehuw dqg vhfxulw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv $uwlfoh /lehuw dqg vhfxulw oi shuvoq௶ &53’3($ 6hswhpehu dffhvvleoh khuh ,elg 6hh dovo wkh joovvdu deoyh iou vxevwlwxwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj dqg vxssouwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj :ouog +hdowk 2ujdql]dwloq ௵6xssouwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj dqg dgydqfh sodqqlqj :+2 4xdolw 5ljkwv 6shfldol]hg wudlqlqj௶ -dqxdu dffhvvleoh khuh 6wdwxv oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv dffhvvleoh khuh 9lhzv dgoswhg e wkh &opplwwhh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh 2swloqdo 3uowofoo foqfhuqlqj foppxqlfdwloq lq 0hglqd 9hod y 0h[lfo qo 2fwoehu ,elg sdud ,elg sdud $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh uhfdoohg lq wklv fdvh wkdw 6wdwhv duh oeoljhg wo uhfojql]h wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv hqmo ohjdo fdsdflw oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv lq doo dvshfwv oi olih dqg wo suoylgh dffhvv e shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo wkh vxssouw wkh pd uhtxluh lq h[huflvlqj wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflwͳͷʹ 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv vwuhvvhg wkdw ௵shuvoqv zlwk fojqlwlyh ou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv kdyh ehhq dqg vwloo duh glvsuosouwloqdwho diihfwhg e vxevwlwxwh ghflvloqpdnlqj uhjlphv dqg ghqldo oi ohjdo fdsdflw௶ suhyhqwlqj wuhdwphqw oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuvͳͷ͵ 6xfk uhjlphv lqfoxgh iou lqvwdqfh jxdugldqvkls ou fxudwouvklsv oyhu wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw wkdw duh fxuuhqwo xvhg lq d qxpehu oi (8 0hpehu 6wdwhvͳͷͷ 7kh fdvh oi 0duooq -dphv 1oeoh y $xvwudold 1o foqfhuqhg wkh wkh ghqldo oi ohjdo fdsdflw oi shuvoqv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelowlhv 7kh dssolfdqw zdv dq lqglylgxdo zlwk dq lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw zko zdv fkdujhg zlwk wzo fulplqdo oiihqfhv exw zdv ghfoduhg xqilw wo vwdqg wuldo dqg sxw lqwo fxvwog 7kh dssolfdqw fopsodlqhg oi d yloodwloq oi yduloxv uljkwv lqfoxglqj klv uljkw wo olehuw dqg wkh uljkw wo dffhvv mxvwlfh 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh lq ilqglqj d yloodwloq oi wkhvh uljkwv vwuhvvhg wkdw 6wdwhv pxvw ௵ hqvxuh wkdw dghtxdwh vxssouw dqg dffoppogdwloq phdvxuhv duh suoylghg wo shuvoqv zlwk phqwdo dqg lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolwlhv wo hqdeoh wkhp wo h[huflvh wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw ehiouh wkh foxuwv zkhqhyhu qhfhvvdu ௶ͳͷͷ 7kh &53’ &opplwwhh dgoswhg d vlplodu kooglqj lq ‘ooodq y $xvwudold 1o ͳͷ 7kh foppxqlfdqw wkhuh zdv d shuvoq zlwk svfkovofldo glvdelolw zko kdg ,elg sdud &53′ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh (txdo uhfojqlwloq ehiouh wkh odz &53’&*& sdud 3l& %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6ooyhqld /mxeomdqd (1$%/( suomhfw s &53’ &opplwwhh 9lhzv dgoswhg e wkh &opplwwhh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh 2swloqdo 3uowofoo foqfhuqlqj foppxqlfdwloq 1o 81 ‘of &53’&’ &53’ &opplwwhh 9lhzv dgoswhg e wkh &opplwwhh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh 2swloqdo 3uowofoo foqfhuqlqj foppxqlfdwloq 1o 81 ‘of &53’&’ sdud $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ehhq fopplwwhg wo fxvwog diwhu ehlqj fkdujhg zlwk foppoq dvvdxowͳͷ +h fopsodlqhg oi wkh yloodwloq oi vhyhudo uljkwv lqfoxglqj klv uljkwv xqghu $uwlfohv dqg &53’ ehfdxvh kh zdv ghfoduhg xqilw wo vwdqg wuldo dqg zdv ghqlhg klv ohjdo fdsdflwͳͷͺ 7kh mxulvsuxghqfh oi wkh (xuoshdq &oxuw oi +xpdq 5ljkwv oq ohjdo fdsdflw kdv vo idu ehhq xqghughyhooshg dqg lqfoqvlvwhqw zlwk wkh &53’ 7klv lv hpeohpdwlf oi wkh gliilfxowlhv wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv h[shulhqfh lq dffhvvlqj mxvwlfh lq jhqhudo ௬ hvshfldoo wkovh zko duh ioupdoo eduuhg iuop olwljdwloq dv d uhvxow oi wkh ghsulydwloq oi wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflwͳͷͻ 1oqhwkhohvv wkhuh kdyh ehhq vhyhudo foqvhtxhqwldo fdvhv wkdw kdyh ehhq foqvlvwhqw zlwk wkh &53’ ,q 6wdqhy y %xojduldͳͷͳ wkh &oxuw ioxqg d yloodwloq oi $uwlfoh uljkw wo d idlu wuldo oi wkh (&+5 dv d uhvxow oi wkh dssolfdqw ehlqj ghqlhg dffhvv wo d foxuw wo vhhn wkh uhvwoudwloq oi klv ohjdo fdsdflw ,w dovo ioxqg yloodwloqv oi $uwlfohv suoklelwloq oi wouwxuh dqg lqkxpdq ou ghjudglqj wuhdwphqw uljkw wo olehuw dqg vhfxulw dqg uljkw wo dq hiihfwlyh uhphg 7kh dssolfdqw kdg ehhq sodfhg xqghu sduwldo jxdugldqvkls dqg lq d vofldo fduh lqvwlwxwloq 7kh foqglwloqv oi olih lq wkh vofldo fduh lqvwlwxwloq zhuh h[wuhpho soou exw 0u 6wdqhy zdv qow shuplwwhg wo fkdoohqjh klv lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq zlwkoxw klv jxdugldq௲v foqvhqw wo lqlwldwh ohjdo suofhhglqjv ,q lwv ghflvloq wkh &oxuw uhihuuhg wo duwlfohv dqg &53’ kooglqj wkdw dq lqglylgxdo௲v uljkw wo dvn d foxuw wo uhylhz klv ghfodudwloq oi lqfdsdflw zdv fulwlfdo iou wkh shuvoq foqfhuqhg 7kh &oxuw dovo oevhuyhg wkdw klv ohjdo fdsdflw zoxog eh ghflvlyh iou wkh ,elg sdud ,elg sdud 7kh &oxuw௲v iouphu 3uhvlghqw 6lu 1lfoodv %udw]d kdv vdlg wkdw kh kdg koshg wkh uxolqj lq :lqwhuzhus y wkh 1hwkhuodqgv $ssolfdwloq 1o mxgjphqw 2fwoehu ௱zoxog ohdg wo d ioozhulqj oi wkh &oxuw௲v fdvhodz oq wkh &oqyhqwloq uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk phqwdo glvdelolwlhv wkh foqwudu suoyhg wo eh wkh fdvh wkh mxulvsuxghqfh oi wkh &oxuw lq wkh vxffhhglqj wzhqw hduv lv qowdeoh iou wkh dopovw fopsohwh ghduwk oi mxglfldo ghflvloqv lq wklv ylwdoo lpsouwdqw duhd௲ 6hh /xf 6hulhv ௱/hjdo fdsdflw dqg sduwlflsdwloq lq olwljdwloq 5hfhqw ghyhoosphqwv lq wkh (xuoshdq &oxuw oi +xpdq 5ljkwv௲ lq (xuoshdq @ oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv௲ wkuoxjk ௱wkh suoylvloq oi suofhgxudo >@ (&w+5 =+ y +xqjdu $ssolfdwloq 1o -xgjphqw oi )heuxdu (&w+5 6wdqhy y %xojduld $ssolfdwloq 1o -xgjphqw -dqxdu (&w+51lnoodq y $uphqld $ssolfdwloq 1o -xgjphqw oi 2fwoehu (&w+5 =+ y +xqjdu $ssolfdwloq 1o -xgjphqw oi )heuxdu (&w+5 1lnoodq y $uphqld $ssolfdwloq 1o -xgjphqw oi 2fwoehu $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 dffoppogdwloqv suopowlqj dssuosuldwh wudlqlqj iou wkovh zounlqj lq wkh ilhog oi wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh௶ͳͳ 7kh uhsouw qowhv wkdw ௵wkh h[lvwhqfh oi d glvdelolw gohv qow lq lwvhoi mxvwli wkh ghqldo oi wkh ohjdo fdsdflw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ dqg wkdw ௵dq phdvxuh uhvwulfwlqj wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw pxvw eh dgdswhg wo wkhlu flufxpvwdqfhv dqg eh suosouwloqdwh wo wkhlu qhhgv dqg vkoxog eh dssolhg oqo xqghu fhuwdlq foqglwloqv dqg zlwk fhuwdlq jxdudqwhhv௶ͳͳ *xdugldqvkls *xdugldqvkls wslfdoo jlyhv oqh shuvoq ixoo ohjdo fdsdflw oyhu dqowkhu phdqlqj wkdw doo ghflvloqpdnlqj dxwkoulw vwdqglqj dqg fdsdflw lv judqwhg wo vophoqh hovh 7klv ioup oi duudqjhphqw hiihfwlyho vwulsv shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oi wkhlu uljkwv wo pdnh ghflvloqv iou lqvwdqfh deoxw zkhuh wo olyh zkhuh wo zoun dqg koz wo vshqg wkhlu poqh 2qfh jxdugldqvkls lv hvwdeolvkhg lw lv wslfdoo dopovw lpsovvleoh wo uhpoyh dv wkh lqglylgxdo zko kdv ehhq ghsulyhg oi dxwoqop zloo kdyh wo suoyh wkh kdyh wkh fdsdflw wo dfw oq wkhlu ozq ehkdoiͳʹ *xdugldqvkls duudqjhphqwv duh qoqfopsoldqw zlwk ,+5/ dqg vwdqgdugv xqghu zklfk shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv pxvw kdyh wkhlu ixoo ohjdo fdsdflw uhfojql]hg dw doo vwdjhv oi doo ohjdo suofhhglqjv dqg suofhvvhv zkhwkhu flylo ou fulplqdo 3ulqflsoh oi wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv suhvfulehv wkdw 6wdwhv ௵>u@hshdo ou dphqg doo odzv uhjxodwloqv soolflhv jxlgholqhv dqg sudfwlfhv wkdw lpsovh vxevwlwxwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj lq ohjdo suofhhglqjv lqfoxglqj wkovh wkdw doooz iou wkh dssolqwphqw oi ghflvloq pdnhuv djdlqvw wkh zloo oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv hj jxdugldqv dg olwhp qh[w iulhqgv dqg vlplodu duudqjhphqwv ou ghflvloqv pdgh (xuoshdq 3duoldphqw 5(3257 7ozdugv htxdo uljkwv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,1, kwwsv zzzhxuosduohxuosdhxgofhogofxphqw$ b(1kwpo sdud 1 ,elg sdud 2 81 (1$%/( ௵+dqgeoon iou 3duoldphqwduldqv oq wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv dqg lwv 2swloqdo 3uowofoo௶ +538% dffhvvleoh khuh +dqgeoon iou 3duoldphqwduldqv oq wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv _ 8qlwhg 1dwloqv (qdeoh $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 oq wkh edvlv oi wkh ௱ehvw lqwhuhvwv௲ oi wkh shuvoqv foqfhuqhg dv ossovhg wo ehlqj edvhg oq wkhlu ozq zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv௶ͳ͵ ,q lwv foqfoxglqj oevhuydwloqv oq &uodwldͳͷ wkh &53′ &opplwwhh lqglfdwhg wkdw wkh 6wdwh vkoxog wdnh ohjlvodwlyh phdvxuhv wo deoolvk vxevwlwxwh ghflvloqpdnlqj uhjlphv ,w dovo uhfopphqghg wkdw &uodwld lqwuogxfh ohjlvodwloq wo suoylgh d zlgh udqjh oi phdvxuhv wkdw uhvshfw wkh dxwoqop zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj wkhlu uljkwv wo jlyh dqg zlwkgudz wkhlu lqglylgxdo lqiouphg foqvhqw iou phglfdo wuhdwphqw wo dffhvv mxvwlfh wo yowh wo pduu wo ixoo sduhqwdo uljkwv dqg wo zoun ,w ixuwkhu uhfopphqghg wkdw &uodwld wdnh wdqjleoh vwhsv wo lqwuogxfh vvwhpv oi vxssouwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj dqg wo wklv hqg wudlq vofldo zounhuv ohjdo suoihvvloqdov dqg sxeolf dxwkoulwlhv oq &53’ uljkwv &kdoohqjhv 7khuh duh qxphuoxv fkdoohqjhv wo wkh uljkw wo ohjdo fdsdflw oi ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq (8 0hpehu 6wdwhv 6oph oi wkhvh duh uhiohfwhg lq wkh (8 ‘luhfwlyhv &opplvvloq 5hfopphqgdwloqv dqg soolf gofxphqwv vxppdul]hg deoyh 2wkhuv dv lqglfdwhg deoyh lqfoxgh vkouwfoplqjv lq wkh mxulvsuxghqfh oi wkh (&w+5 7kh foqwlqxlqj lpsohphqwdwloq oi jxdugldqvkls duudqjhphqwv sovhv d vljqlilfdqw oevwdfoh wo dffhvv wo ohjdo fdsdflw $ ihz foxqwuvshflilf vlwxdwloqv h[hpsoli wkhvh fkdoohqjhv ,q /lwkxdqld iou sxusovhv oi flylo odz ohjdo lqfdsdflw lv xvxdoo ghwhuplqhg h[foxvlyho lq fdvhv oi phqwdo khdowk foqglwloqv dqg fdq eh ghfoduhg shupdqhqwoͳͷ 7khuhiouh d 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 3ulqflsoh sdud m s &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௵&oqfoxglqj 2evhuydwloqv oq wkh ,qlwldo 5hsouw oi &uodwld௶ 0d &53’&+59&2 dffhvvleoh khuh &lylo &ogh oi wkh 5hsxeolf oi /lwkxdqld oi -xo /dz 1o 9,,, dv dphqghg oq $sulo 1o ;, $uwlfoh ௵ 1dwxudo shuvoq zko dv d uhvxow oi phqwdo looqhvv ou lpehflolw lv qow deoh wo xqghuvwdqg wkh phdqlqj oi klv dfwloqv ou foqwuoo wkhp pd eh ghfoduhg lqfdsdeoh 7kh lqfdsdeoh shuvoq vkdoo eh sodfhg xqghu jxdugldqvkls௶ $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ghflvloq wo ghfoduh d shuvoq lqfdsdflwdwhg pd vlwxdwh wkhp iou olih $ ghflvloq pdgh e wkh foxuw lv luuhyhuvleoh xqohvv d jxdugldq ou owkhu lqwhuhvwhg shuvoq vxffhvvixoo fkdoohqjhv wkh ghflvloq zklfk lv vwloo txlwh uduh ,q wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhp dsduw iuop wkh olplwdwloqv oxwolqhg lq wkh &ulplqdo 3uofhgxuh &ogh wkh foxuw pxvw uhtxluh wkh shuvoq௲v oxwsdwlhqw svfkldwulf h[dplqdwloq zkhq foqvlghulqj zkhwkhu wo uhfojql]h wkhlu uhvwulfwhg fopshwhqfh lq sduwlfxodu duhdv dqg zkhq xvlqj phglfdo phdvxuhv $ shuvoq pd oqo eh vxemhfw wo dq lqsdwlhqw iouhqvlf svfkldwulf hydoxdwloq zkhq wkh foxuw lv foqvlghulqj zkhwkhu wo ghfoduh wkhp lqfdsdeohͳ 6lploduo lq 3ouwxjdo wkh odz jxdudqwhhv wkdw doo shuvoqv kdyh ohjdo fdsdflw wkuoxjk wkh vfkhph oi dq ௵dffopsdqlhg dgxow௶ͳ 7kh ghflvloq oi wkh dffopsdqlphqw olhv zlwk wkh foxuw dqg lw pdnhv lw sovvleoh wo uhtxhvw wkh qhfhvvdu dffopsdqlqj phdvxuhvͳͺ 7khvh phdvxuhv fdq eh uhtxluhg e d foxuw zkhq lw ghhpv wkdw wkh shuvoq lv lqfdsdeoh oi h[huflvlqj wkhlu uljkwv 7kh phdvxuhv fdq eh uhtxhvwhg e wkh 3xeolf 3uovhfxwou௲v 2iilfh e wkh shuvoqv wkhpvhoyhv ou e wkh vsoxvh gh idfwo sduwqhu ou owkhu uhodwlyh zlwk wkh foqvhqw oi wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw lq txhvwloqͳͻ 1xphuoxv fkdoohqjhv kdyh ehhq lghqwlilhg dfuovv (8 0hpehu 6wdwhv olqnhg wo wkh uljkw wo sduwlflsdwloq lq mxvwlfh suofhhglqjv dqg wkh xvh oi wkh jxdugldqvkls pogho 2qh h[dpsoh lv lq 6ooyhqld zkhuh wkh odfn oi ixoo sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv lv lq voph fdvhv gxh wo sodflqj wkhp xqghu jxdugldqvkls 7klv shuwdlqv sduwlfxoduo wo wkovh zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqg svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv ,qvwhdg 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq /lwkxdqld 9loqlxv (1$%/( suomhfw s )(1$&(5&, %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 3ouwxjdo /lveod s $ffouglqj wo duwlfohv dqg oi wkh &lylo &ogh wkh dffopsdqlqj phdvxuhv duh phdvxuhv dlphg dw hqvxulqj wkh zhooehlqj dqg uhfoyhu oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dv zhoo dv wkh ixoo h[huflvh oi doo wkhlu uljkwv dqg wkh ixoiloophqw oi wkhlu gxwlhv wkuoxjk wkh dvvlvwdqfh ou uhsuhvhqwdwloq oi d shuvoq dssolqwhg iou wklv sxusovh dv dq dffopsdqlqj shuvoq $ffouglqj wo $uwlfoh oi wkh &lylo &ogh lq h[fhswloqdo fdvhv wkh h[huflvh oi shuvoqdo uljkwv dqg wkh fdsdflw wo hqwhu lqwo ouglqdu exvlqhvv wudqvdfwloqv fdq eh olplwhg )(1$&(5&, %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 3ouwxjdo /lveod (1$%/( suomhfw s $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 oi vxssouwlqj shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq ohjdo suofhhglqjv dqg hpsozhulqj wkhp wo sduwlflsdwh jxdugldqv xvxdoo zoun dv ௵vxevwlwxwhv௶ͳͺͳ ˅˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˘ˤ˨˔˟ ˣ˔˥˧˜˖˜ˣ˔˧˜ˢˡ (qvxulqj wkh ioupdo suowhfwloq oi ohjdo fdsdflw iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lv qow e lwvhoi hqoxjk wo jxdudqwhh wo hyhuoqh wkh htxdo sovvlelolw wo sduwlflsdwh lq wkh suofhvv (yhuoqh lqfoxglqj wkovh dffxvhg oi fulplqdo oiihqfhv dqg ylfwlpv oi fulph kdv d uljkw wo htxdo dffhvv wo suofhhglqjv lq wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh zlwkoxw glvfulplqdwloqͳͺͳ 7kh oeoljdwloq wo uhvshfw wklv uljkw uhtxluhv 6wdwhv wo hvwdeolvk dqg uhvoxufh foxuwv dqg wo hqvxuh wkdw wkh duh deoh wo foqgxfw idlu wuldov lqfoxglqj lq suhwuldo foqwh[w 6xfk foxuwv pxvw eh oofdwhg lq sodfhv zklfk duh dffhvvleoh wo shosoh wkuoxjkoxw wkh foxqwu dqg wkh lqiudvwuxfwxuh iou foxuw exloglqjv pxvw eh skvlfdoo dffhvvleoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7kh dydlodelolw oi hiihfwlyh ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh ghwhuplqhv zkhwkhu d shuvoq fdq suowhfw wkhlu uljkwv sduwlflsdwh lq suofhhglqjv lq d phdqlqjixo zd ou dffhvv mxvwlfh wkuoxjk wkh foxuwvͳͺʹ )ou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo h[huflvh wkhlu uljkw wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh duwlfoh wkh pxvw hqmo wkh uljkw wo sduwlflsdwh oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp dv d zkooh 7klv sduwlflsdwloq wdnhv pdq ioupv dqg lqfoxghv shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dvvxplqj wkh uoohv oi iou h[dpsoh fodlpdqwv ylfwlpv ou vxuylyouv ghihqgdqwv mxgjhv mxuouv dqg odzhuv dv sduw oi wkh ghpofudwlf vvwhp wkdw foqwulexwhv wo joog joyhuqdqfhͳͺ͵ 3l& %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6ooyhqld /mxeomdqd (1$%/( suomhfw s $uwlfoh oi wkh 8qlyhuvdo ‘hfodudwloq $uwlfohv dqg oi wkh ,&&35 $uwlfohv dqg oi &(‘$: $uwlfohv oi wkh &oqyhqwloq djdlqvw 5dflvp $uwlfohv dqg oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv +5& *hqhudo &opphqw ii *oog y 5hsxeolf oi %owvzdqd +5& *hqhudo &opphqw i 6hh *ooghu y 8qlwhg .lqjgop (&w+5 &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௱*hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj fkloguhq zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkuoxjk wkhlu uhsuhvhqwdwlyh oujdql]dwloqv lq wkh lpsohphqwdwloq dqg poqlwoulqj oi wkh &oqyhqwloq௲ &53’&*& 1oyhpehu sdud $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7kh uljkw wo sduwlflsdwh dssolhv wo doo shuvoqv lqfoxglqj shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv hyhq zkhuh vxfk dq lqglylgxdo lv ioxqg qow fulplqdoo uhvsoqvleoh gxh wo wkhlu glvdelolw lq whupv oi wkh suoylvloq oi d gophvwlf odz 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog dw doo wlphv dqg lq doo flufxpvwdqfhv eh hiihfwlyho lqfoxghg dqg khdug lq wkh suofhhglqjv ௷,qvdqlw௶ ghihqfh ௷xqilwqhvv௶ wo vwdqg wuldo 7kh &53’ &opplwwhh kdv pdgh fohdu wkdw wkh dssolfdwloq oi foqfhswv dqg vwdqgdugv vxfk dv ௵xqilwqhvv wo vwdqg wuldo௶ dqg ௵lqvdqlw ghihqfhv௶ duh glvfulplqdwou dqg lq yloodwloq oi wkh &oqyhqwloq 7kh &opplwwhh kdv wkhuhiouh fdoohg iou wkh uhpoydo oi doo 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 3ulqflsoh ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ˃˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘˦ ˔ˡ˗ ʺ˨˜˗˘˟˜ˡ˘˦ ˢˡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ʽ˨˦˧˜˖˘ ˙ˢ˥ ˃˘˥˦ˢˡ˦ ˪˜˧˛ ʷ˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ ˃˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘ ʪ ௵3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv kdyh wkh uljkw wo sduwlflsdwh lq wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv௶ͳͺͷ 8qghu 3ulqflsoh *oyhuqphqwv ohjlvodwxuhv dqg owkhu dxwkoulwlhv pxvw hdfk zlwklq wkhlu uhvshfwlyh uoohv wdnh wkh ioooozlqj dfwloqv 5hpoyh eduulhuv wkdw suhyhqw ou glvfoxudjh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv iuop hqwhulqj mxvwlfh vvwhpuhodwhg suoihvvloqv 5hpoyh doo glvdelolwuhodwhg eduulhuv lqfoxglqj odzv wkdw suhyhqw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv iuop ehlqj mxgjhv ou mxuouv ou vhuylqj lq dq owkhu mxvwlfh uhodwhg sovlwloqv (qvxuh wkh htxdo sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh mxu vvwhp e suoylglqj doo qhfhvvdu vxssouw uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv dqg suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv &oqvxow foovho zlwk dqg dfwlyho lqyooyh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg wkhlu uhsuhvhqwdwlyh oujdql]dwloqv lq doo glvfxvvloqv dqg ghflvloqpdnlqj deoxw mxvwlfhuhodwhg lvvxhv $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 vxfk vwdqgdugv iuop fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv lq 6wdwh 3duwlhv wo wkh &53’ͳͺͷ ‘hfodudwloqv oi ௵xqilwqhvv wo vwdqg wuldo ou qoquhvsoqvlelolw ou lqfdsdflw lq fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv duh qow oqo glvfulplqdwou exw pd ohdg wo wkh duelwudu ghwhqwloq oi shuvoqv edvhg oq wkhlu glvdelolwlhv foqwudu wo duwlfoh oi wkh &53’ͳͺ 7kh &-(8 kdv diiluphg wkdw mxglfldo suofhhglqjv zklfk doooz iou wkh dssolfdwloq oi dq ௵lqvdqlw ghihqfh௶ zklfk uhvxowhg lq d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw ehlqj sodfhg lq d svfkldwulf kovslwdo sxusouwhgo iou wkhudshxwlf dqg vhfxulw uhdvoqv zdv qoqfopsoldqw zlwk wkh (8 &kduwhu ͳͺ7kh &oxuw ioxqg wkdw wklv zdv lpshuplvvleoh devhqw d ilqglqj iuop d foxuw yhulilqj wkdw fhuwdlq suofhgxudo uljkwv oi d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw kdg ehhq uhvshfwhgͳͺͺ 7kh fdvh foqfhuqhg d %xojduldq pdq zlwk sdudqolg vfkl]oskuhqld zko zdv dffxvhg oi nloolqj klv powkhu 7kh 3xeolf 3uovhfxwou௲v 2iilfh foovhg wkh fulplqdo suofhhglqj djdlqvw klp dqg oughuhg klv sodfhphqw lq d svfkldwulf kovslwdo dvvxplqj wkdw kh kdg fopplwwhg wkh fulph lq d vwdwh oi phqwdo glvoughu dqg kh foxog qow eh khog fulplqdoo uhvsoqvleoh 7kh ghflvloq dw wkh qdwloqdo ohyho zdv wdnhq zlwkoxw txhvwloqlqj wkh shuvoq dqg zlwkoxw judqwlqj klp edvlf suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv vxfk dv dffhvv wo d odzhu ou wkh sovvlelolw oi mxglfldo uhylhzͳͺͻ 81 2+&+5 ௱5hsouw 5ljkw wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv௲ ’hfhpehu $+5& sdud &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௱*xlgholqhv oq duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௬ 7kh uljkw wo olehuw dqg vhfxulw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ 6hswhpehu sdud 5xolqj gdwhg oi wkh &-(8 fdvh έ dydlodeoh khuh kwwsv fxuldhxuosdhxmxulvgofxphqwgofxphqwmvi”goflg pogh uht sdjh,qgh[ glu off iluvw sduw wh[w gofodqj (1 flg ,qwhusuhwdwloq e wkh &-(8 oq $uw oi wkh &kduwhu oi )xqgdphqwdo 5ljkwv oi wkh (xuoshdq 8qloq dv zhoo dv $uw sdud oi ‘luhfwlyh (8 dqg $uw oi ‘luhfwlyh (8 solqw oi wkh 5xolqj 5xolqj gdwhg oi wkh &-(8 fdvh έ dydlodeoh khuh kwwsv fxuldhxuosdhxmxulvgofxphqwgofxphqwmvi”goflg pogh uht sdjh,qgh[ glu off iluvw sduw wh[w gofodqj (1 flg sdud $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ʸ˟˜ˠ˜ˡ˔˧˜ˡ˚ ˧˛˘ ˜ˡ˦˔ˡ˜˧ˬ ˗˘˙˘ˡ˖˘ ˔ˡ˗ ˡˢˡʠ˜ˠˣ˨˧˔˕˜˟˜˧ˬʤʬʣ 7kh qoqfxosdelolw ghihqfh oiwhq uhihuuhg wo dv wkh ௵lqvdqlw ghihqfh௶ uhtxluhv wkh idfwilqghu wo ghflgh li wkh ghihqgdqw kdg wkh phqwdo fdsdflw wo fopplw wkh fkdujhg oiihqfh :lwkoxw lw wkh shuvoq lv foqvlghuhg wo odfn poudo uhvsoqvlelolw iou wkh dfw 7klv uhtxluhv d ooon edfnzdugv wo wkh wlph oi wkh oiihqfh /lnh wkh fdsdflw wo vwdqg wuldo wkh lqvdqlw ghihqfh lv ghhso hqwuhqfkhg lq wkh phglfdo pogho oi glvdelolw 3vfkldwulvwv suoylgh h[shuw whvwlpoq lq povw fdvhv lq zklfk wkh lqvdqlw ghihqfh lv udlvhg $ ghihqgdqw zko kdv ehhq ghwhuplqhg qow wo kdyh kdg wkh phqwdo fdsdflw wo fopplw wkh fulph xvxdoo idfhv d shulog oi ioufhg lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq 7kh ghihqgdqw lv oiwhq ghwdlqhg lq d iouhqvlf svfkldwulf idflolw ou vophwlphv lq d sulvoq ou mdlo ,q voph mxulvglfwloqv wkh odzv dv zhoo dv wkh fxvwopv ou sudfwlfhv doooz wkh ghwhqwloq oi wkh ghihqgdqw iou dq lqghilqlwh shulog ,q wklv foqwh[w wkh shulog oi ioufhg lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq offxuv zlwkoxw dq suooi oi jxlow oi wkh ghihqgdqw oxwvlgh oi wkh suofhvv dqg zlwkoxw suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv 6zhghq deoolvkhg wkh lqvdqlw ghihqfh lq 6zhglvk odz uhfojql]hv phqv uhd phdqlqj lqwhqw ou ௵jxlow plqg௶ dv dq hohphqw oi d fulph exw suoylghv wkdw d ghihqgdqw௲v phqwdo vwdwxv pd qow eh foqvlghuhg lq wkh ghwhuplqdwloq oi jxlow 5dwkhu d shuvoq௲v phqwdo glvdelolw pd eh foqvlghuhg lq vhqwhqflqj $ jxlow ghihqgdqw zlwk d svfkovofldo glvdelolw pd wkhuhiouh eh fopplwwhg wo d iouhqvlf idflolw iou wuhdwphqw 7kh whup oi wkh lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq lv lqghilqlwh exw wkh lqglylgxdo pxvw eh uhohdvhg zkhq wkh uhtxluhphqwv iou lqyooxqwdu svfkldwulf wuhdwphqw duh qo ooqjhu phw 7khuhiouh dowkoxjk ghihqgdqwv lq 6zhghq kdyh wkh uljkw wo kdyh wkhlu fdvhv dgmxglfdwhg dqg dq ossouwxqlw wo ioufh wkh joyhuqphqw wo suoyh lwv fdvh wkh $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh .qozohgjh +xe ,psohphqwlqj wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv $ eulhilqj sdshu -xo ,elg ,elg $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 oxwfoph ௬ lqghilqlwh lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq ௬ pd eh wkh vdph dv iou ghihqgdqwv zko vxffhvvixoo xvh wkh lqvdqlw ghihqfh lq qdwloqv wkdw doooz lw ,q lwv foqfoxglqj oevhuydwloqv wo %hojlxp wkh &53’ uhfopphqghg fkdqjhv wo odzv wo jxdudqwhh wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ௵zko kdyh fopplwwhg d fulph >@ eh wulhg xqghu wkh ouglqdu fulplqdo suofhgxuh oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv dqg zlwk wkh vdph jxdudqwhhv dowkoxjk zlwk vshflilf dgmxvwphqwv wo hqvxuh wkhlu htxdo sduwlflsdwloq lq wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhp௶ ,q wkh +ljk &opplvvloqhu iou +xpdq 5ljkwv zuowh wkdw uhfojqlwloq oi wkh ohjdo fdsdflw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv uhtxluhv uhsodflqj fulplqdo ghihqfhv edvhg oq ௵phqwdo ou lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw௶ zlwk ௵glvdelolwqhxwudo௶ gofwulqhv &oqvxow foovho zlwk dqg dfwlyho lqyooyh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg wkhlu uhsuhvhqwdwlyh oujdql]dwloqv lq doo glvfxvvloqv dqg ghflvloqpdnlqj deoxw mxvwlfhuhodwhg lvvxhv &kdoohqjhv ,q pdq (8 0hpehu 6wdwhv wkh lqvdqlw ghihqfh lv vwloo xvhg dqg ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh sodfhg lq phglfdo foqilqhphqw )ou lqvwdqfh lq 5opdqldͳͻ ohjlvodwloq suoylghv iou phglfdo foqilqhphqw dv d vdihw phdvxuh iou shuvoqv ghwhuplqhg wo eh zlwkoxw ohjdo fdsdflw zko kdyh fopplwwhg d fulplqdo oiihqfhͳͻ %xojduldq odz suoylghv wkdw shuvoqv zko kdyh dfwhg lq d vwdwh oi ௵lqvdqlw௶ fdqqow eh foqvlghuhg fulplqdoo oldeoh ehfdxvh wkh zhuh qow deoh wo xqghuvwdqg zkdw wkh zhuh 3lhuv *ooglqj 7oyd %hqqhww 7kh $eooxwloq oi wkh ,qvdqlw ‘hihqfh lq 6zhghq dqg wkh 8qlwhg 1dwloq௲v &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv +xpdq 5ljkwv %ulqnpdqvkls ou (ylghqfh lw :oq௲w :oun” 1hz &ulplqdo / 5hy dydlodeoh dw kwwsv oqolqhxfsuhvvhgxqfouduwlfoh7kh$eoolwloqoiwkh,qvdqlw’hihqvhlq6zhghq lq ,psohphqwlqj wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv $ eulhilqj sdshu -xo &53’&%(/&2 sdudjudsk dydlodeoh dw kwwsv welqwhuqhwokfkuoujbodoxwvwuhdweogh[whuqdo’ozqoodgdvs[“vpeooqo &53’i&i%(/i&2i /dqj hq 6hh dovo &53’&7.0&2 sdudjudsk e &53’&'(8&2 d dqg e 81 +xpdq 5ljkwv &oxqflo dqqxdo uhsouw oi wkh 81 +ljk &opplvvloqhu iou +xpdq 5ljkwv dqg uhsouwv oi wkh +ljk &opplvvloqhu dqg wkh 81 6hfuhwdu *hqhudo 81 gof $kuf dw -dqxdu kwwsv zzzokfkuoujhqjolvkeoglhvkufoxqflogofvvhvvloq$+5&sgi &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 5opdqld %xfkduhvw (1$%/( suomhfw s 5opdqldq &ulplqdo 3uofhgxuh &ogh duwlfoh sdud ௵ ,i gxulqj wkh foqgxfwlqj oi d iouhqvlf svfkldwulf h[shuw uhsouw lw lv ioxqg wkdw wkh uhtxluhphqwv vhw e $uw duh phw wkh iouhqvlf svfkldwulf h[dplqdwloq fopplwwhh vkdoo qowli wkh mxglfldo eoglhv lq oughu iou wkhp wo wdnh wkh vdihw phdvxuh oi whpsoudu phglfdo dgplvvloq௶ wh[w dydlodeoh dw &’/5() h fohlqw $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 golqj ou wo foqwuoo wkhlu dfwloqvͳͻͺ ,i wkh shuvoq lv suoyhq wo eh ௵lqvdqh௶ dw wkh pophqw wkdw wkh doohjhg oiihqfh zdv fopplwwhg wkh wuldo hqgv 6lplodu odzv oq wkh lqvdqlw ghihqfh dsso lq wkh &]hfk 5hsxeolf :kloh wkh 6wdwh 3uovhfxwou௲v 2iilfh dvvhuwvͳͻͻ wkdw wkhuh lv wkh sovvlelolw wo dssolqw dq h[shuw gxulqj wkh dvvhvvphqw oi zkhwkhu d ghihqgdqw fdq eh khog fulplqdoo uhvsoqvleoh wklv vooxwloq dsshduv suoeohpdwlf zkhq wkh dvvhvvhg shuvoq kdv qow hw ehhq dffxvhg dv wkh ghihqfh uljkwv duh qow jxdudqwhhg sulou wo oiilfldo fkdujhv dqg dffouglqjo wkh shuvoq lv qow hw hqwlwohg iou h[dpsoh wo oemhfw wo wkh h[shuw zlwqhvvʹͳͳ ,q 6sdlq wkh lqvdqlw ghihqfh fdq dpoxqw wo ௵suofhgxudo lpsxqlw௶ zkhq wkh shuvoqv lqyooyhg duh foqvlghuhg wo qow eh fdsdeoh oi xqghuvwdqglqj eowk wkh dfw wkh kdyh ehhq doohjhg wo kdyh fopplwwhg dqg wkh uhohydqw ohjdo suofhvv 8qghu wkh 6sdqlvk vvwhp wkhvh shuvoqv fdqqow sduwlflsdwh lq wkh suofhhglqjv ,q wkhvh fdvhv wkhuh lv d iuhh glvplvvdo zklfk phdqv wkdw wkh lqglylgxdo lv uhohdvhg zlwkoxw dq vhfxulw phdvxuh dqg wkh fdvh lv wudqvihuuhg wo wkh flylo vskhuh 7kh iuhh glvplvvdo lv wkh foqvhtxhqfh oi d ohjdo oooskooh ,qghhg wkh 6sdqlvk ohjdo iudphzoun suoylghv iou wkh sovvlelolw iou wkh fulplqdo foxuw wo dsso fxvwogldo ou qoqfxvwogldo vhfxulw phdvxuhv zkhq d shuvoq fopplwwhg dq dfw iouhvhhq dv d fulph dqg wkh dfw dqg wkh shuvoqdo flufxpvwdqfhv oi wkh vxemhfw uhyhdo wkh suoedelolw oi fopplwwlqj qhz fulphv ([dpsohv oi fxvwogldo vhfxulw phdvxuhv duh wkh sodfhphqw lq d svfkldwulf lqvwlwxwloq uhkdelolwdwloq fhqwhu ou vshfldo hgxfdwloqdo lqvwlwxwloq +ozhyhu wkh 6sdqlvk &oqvwlwxwloq duwlfoh suoylghv wkdw d vhfxulw phdvxuh lpsolqj ghsulydwloq oi olehuw %xojduldq &ulplqdo &ogh duwlfoh sdud ௵ 3hqdoo uhvsoqvleoh vkdoo qow eh d shuvoq zko kdv dfwhg lq d vwdwh oi lqvdqlw zkhuh gxh wo uhwdughg phqwdolw ou ghudqjhphqw oi klv foqvfloxvqhvv oi suoooqjhg ou vkouw gxudwloq wkh shuvoq kdv qow ehhq deoh wo xqghuvwdqg wkh qdwxuh dqg phdqlqj oi wkh dfw ou wo pdqdjh klv dfwloqv௶ 7h[w dydlodeoh dw %8/*$5,$b&ulplqdo &oghsgi okfkuouj 6wdwhphqw oi wkh 6xsuhph 6wdwh 3uovhfxwouv 2iilfh oi -xqh 1o 6/ )2580 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq &]hfkld 3udkd (1$%/( suomhfw s $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 fdqqow eh lpsovhg e flylo dgplqlvwudwloq dqg zlwkoxw d vhqwhqfh ,q wkhvh deoyh phqwloqhg flufxpvwdqfhv wkhuh fdq eh qo vhqwhqfh ehfdxvh wkh suofhgxuh hqghg ,q wkh deoyhphqwloqhg 6wdwhv wkh ghwhuplqdwloq oi wkh ௵lqvdqlw௶ oi wkh ghihqgdqw wdnhv sodfhʹͳʹ lq yloodwloq oi wkh &53’ zlwkoxw wkh uhtxluhphqw wo suoylgh vxssouw iou dq lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw lq wkh uhohydqw suofhvvhv 3udfwlfdo jxlgdqfh dqg uhfopphqgdwloqv 6wdwh mxvwlfh dfwouv pxvw zlwklq wkh sdudphwhuv oi wkhlu uhvshfwlyh uhvsoqvlelolwlhv hqvxuh wkdw wkh dfffoug shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv htxdo wuhdwphqw zlwk owkhuv lq lqwhudfwloqv zlwk wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv pxvw suoylgh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zlwk suofhgxudo dqg uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv zkhuh qhhghg wo idflolwdwh wkhlu sduwlflsdwloq oq dq htxdo edvlv $ -xvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog lqwhusuhw h[lvwlqj odzv dqg soolflhv foqvlvwhqwo zlwk wkh &53’ % -xvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog dfw wo hqvxuh wkdw suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv dqg owkhu vxssouwv wo idflolwdwh wkhlu hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq duh suoylghg iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zkhuh qhfhvvdu 5hvsoqvleoh mxvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog uhvshfw dqg hqvxuh wkh hiihfwlyh uljkw wo sduwlflsdwh iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk odz hqioufhphqw gxulqj wkh suofhhglqjv dqg lq doo ioooozlqj vwdjhv oi lw $ 7kh uljkw hqfopsdvvhv dffhvv wo foxqvho dqg zkhuh qhfhvvdu ohjdo dlg dqg wkh dffopsdqlphqw oi vxssouw shuvoqv oi wkh ghihqgdqw௲v 3ohqd ,qofxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq 0dgulg (1$%/( suomhfw s &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 5opdqld %xfduhvw (1$%/( 3uomhfw s .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq 0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 fkoovlqj lq doo vwdjhv oi fulplqdo suofhhglqjv vwduwlqj iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk odz hqioufhphqw % 1o shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw vkoxog eh fopsohoohg wo kdyh d shuvoq dvvlvwlqj wkhp zlwkoxw wkhp ehlqj deoh wo yolfh wkhlu suhihuhqfhv ou zlwkoxw wkhlu foqvhqw 5hvsoqvleoh mxvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog hqvxuh vdih idlu dqg hiihfwlyh hqjdjhphqw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh suofhhglqjv dqg wkh ossouwxqlw wo ixoo sduwlflsdwh lq suofhhglqjv 7kh uhvsoqvlelolw lqfoxghv wkh suoylvloq oi dgmxvwphqwv dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouwv lqfoxglqj lqwhuphgldulhv vxssouw vhuylfhv ou vxssouw shuvoqv zkhuhyhu dqg zkhqhyhu qhhghg wo hqdeoh fohdu foppxqlfdwloq dpoqj dqg ehwzhhq shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg foxuwv 5hvsoqvleoh mxvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog lpsohphqw d vxssouwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj dssuodfk zkhuhe d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw foqwlqxhv wo koog doo ghflvloqpdnlqj dxwkoulw dqg dxwoqop -xgjhv vkoxog dozdv hqvxuh gluhfw foqwdfw zlwk wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk d glvdelolw hyhq zkhuh owkhuv duh lqfoxghg lq vxfk foqwdfw wo suoylgh wkdw shuvoq zlwk vxssouw $ ,i d shwlwloq iou jxdugldqvkls lv pdgh lw vkoxog eh ghqlhg oq wkh juoxqgv oi yloodwlqj wkh shuvoq௲v lqglylgxdo dxwoqop % 7kh uooh oi dq lqwhuphgldu ou d odzhu pxvw qow uhsodfh wkh gluhfw foqwdfw oi wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk wkh mxgjh /dzhuv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw ghflvloqv wkdw gluhfwo ou lqgluhfwo lqyooyh sduwlflsdwloq lq wkh suofhhglqjv oi wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk d glvdelolw duh zlwk wkh ghihqgdqw $ 7kh vxssouwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj pogho iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv phdqv wkdw wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk d glvdelolw lv wkh shuvoq pdnlqj wkh ghflvloq ,i wkh fkoovh wo lqfoxgh d vxssouw shuvoq wkh zoun oi wkh $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 vxssouw shuvoq lv wo hqvxuh wkh ghflvloq lv pdgh dw wkh ghihqgdqw௲v zloo dqg suhihuhqfh -xvwlfh dfwouv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw foqvwuxfwv vxfk dv ௵fojqlwlyh lqfdsdflw௶ dqg ௵phqwdo lqfdsdflw௶ dv ghwhuplqhg iou lqvwdqfh e ixqfwloqdo ou phqwdo vwdwxv dvvhvvphqwv duh qow xvhg wo uhvwulfw d shuvoq௲v uljkw wo ohjdo fdsdflw ,i d ghihqgdqw zlwk d glvdelolw lv ghwhuplqhg diwhu wkh suoylvloq oi doo qhfhvvdu vxssouw wo sduwlflsdwh lq d fopsohwh ohjdo suofhvv wo odfn wkh qhfhvvdu lqwhqw phqv uhd zlwklq wkh xvxdo phdqlqj oi wkh whup wkh vkoxog eh wuhdwhg wkh vdph zd dv dq owkhu ghihqgdqw zko odfnv lqwhqw -xvwlfh dfwouv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw dq dvvhvvphqwv foqgxfwhg lq uhvshfw oi ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ehiouh dqg gxulqj foxuw suofhhglqjv duh dlphg oqo dw ghwhuplqlqj wkh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloq dqg vxssouw uhtxluhg wo hqvxuh wkhlu ixoo dqg hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq lq wkh suofhhglqjv 6xfk dvvhvvphqwv pxvw kdyh wkh zloo dqg suhihuhqfh oi wkh lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw dv wkhlu fhqwudo iofxv 6vwhplf 5hfopphqgdwloqv 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv pxvw kdyh htxdo dffhvv wo wkh suofhhglqjv dqg wo wkh ghihqfh $ $ vvwhp oi vxssouw vhuylfhv dqg suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wo hqvxuh hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq suofhhglqjv dqg wuldov pxvw eh ghyhooshg dqg lpsohphqwhg lq sudfwlfh vhh ehooz wkh ghwdlov oq suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iuop wkh iluvw vwdjhv oi wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh suofhvv dqg wkuoxjkoxw wkh suofhhglqjv $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh .qozohgjh +xe ,psohphqwlqj wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv $ eulhilqj sdshu -xo s $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh .qozohgjh +xe ,psohphqwlqj wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv $ eulhilqj sdshu -xo s $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 % )uop wkh hduolhvw vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv lghqwlilfdwloq oi wkh qhhgv iou suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouwv pxvw wdnh sodfh vhh vhfwloq ,9 3uofhvv iou lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw iou dgoswloq oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv ehooz 3uofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv vkoxog eh suhvhqw ehiouh gxulqj dqg diwhu wkh whuplqdwloq oi suofhhglqjv wo suhyhqw glvfulplqdwloq dqg wkuoxjkoxw doo suofhvvhv & $ poqlwoulqj phfkdqlvp vkoxog eh sxw lq sodfh lq oughu wo poqlwou zkhwkhu suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv duh ehlqj xvhg dqg fopsolhg zlwk 5hfojql]h dqg dvvxph wkh ixoo ohjdo fdsdflw dqg uljkw oi ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo sduwlflsdwh lq doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv dqg lq doo foxuwv $ (qvxuh wkdw ghihqgdqwv zko kdyh ehhq suhyloxvo ghfoduhg wo eh zlwkoxw ohjdo fdsdflw wo sduwlflsdwh lq foxuw suofhhglqjv kdyh wkh uljkw wo dsshdo ou owkhuzlvh vhhn uhvwoudwloq oi wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw dqg kdyh dffhvv wo dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouwv dv zhoo dv ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh wo sduwlflsdwh lq foxuw suofhhglqjv % -xgjhv dqg owkhu uhohydqw mxvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog eulqj wo wkh dwwhqwloq oi wkh odzpdnhuv dq ohjlvodwloq wkdw lv lq yloodwloq oi wkh &53’ ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ ,q 6sdlq /dz uhfojql]hg ohjdo fdsdflw iou doo shosoh zlwk glvdelolwlhv jxdugldqvkls zdv holplqdwhg dqg mxglfldo phdvxuhv oi vxssouw iou shosoh zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh dgoswhg d dv odvw uhvouw ,q wklv zd wkh 6sdqlvk ohjlvodwloq poyhg iuop d vvwhp oi vxevwlwxwloq oi ghflvloqpdnlqj wo d vvwhp oi vxssouw lq ghflvloqpdnlqj /dz /d gh gh mxqlo sou od txh vh uhioupd od ohjlvodflµq flylo suofhvdo sdud ho dsoo d odv shuvoqdv foq glvfdsdflgdg hq ho hmhuflflo gh vx fdsdflgdg mxu¯glfd m%2(} 1o -xqh $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 & :khuh sovvleoh xqghu wkh qdwloqdo ohjdo vvwhp wkh mxgjhv pd lqlwldwh suofhhglqjv iou uhylhz oi wkh ydolglw oi wkh ohjlvodwloq lqfopsdwleoh zlwk wkh &53’ ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ )ou lqvwdqfh mxgjhv lq 6ooydnld pd vwduw suofhhglqjv ehiouh wkh &oqvwlwxwloqdo &oxuw wo vwulnh gozq wkh ohjlvodwloq $ uhylhz oi soolfhv jxlgholqhv dqg sudfwlfhv vkoxog eh xqghuwdnhq e 6wdwh dxwkoulwlhv $ 6wdwhv vkdoo uhylhz dqg zkhuh qhfhvvdu holplqdwh ou uhylvh soolflhv jxlgholqhv dqg sudfwlfhv wkdw vhuyh gluhfwo ou lqgluhfwo uhvwulfw wkh ohjdo fdsdflw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj wkovh wkdw foqwdlq dqg dsso gofwulqhv oi ௵xqilwqhvv wo vwdqg wuldo௶ dqg ௵lqfdsdflw wo sohdg௶ zklfk suhyhqw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv iuop sduwlflsdwlqj lq ohjdo suofhvvhv edvhg oq txhvwloqv deoxw ou ghwhuplqdwloqv oi wkhlu fdsdflw % 6wdwhv vkdoo uhylhz dqg zkhuh qhfhvvdu holplqdwh ou uhylvh soolflhv jxlgholqhv dqg sudfwlfhv wkdw dxwkoul]h phglfdo suoihvvloqdov wo eh wkh vooh ou suhihuuhg ௵h[shuwv௶ lq ghwhuplqlqj koz dqg wo zkdw h[whqw dqg zlwk zkdw vxssouw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv fdq sduwlflsdwh lq ohjdo suofhhglqjv & 6wdwhv vkdoo uhylhz dqg zkhuh qhfhvvdu holplqdwh ou uhylvh soolflhv jxlgholqhv dqg sudfwlfhv lqfoxglqj foxuw oughuv wkdw vxemhfw ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo ghwhqwloq zkhwkhu lq d sulvoq d phqwdo khdowk idflolw ou dq owkhu lqvwlwxwloq iou d ghilqlwh ou lqghilqlwh whup edvhg oq shufhlyhg ௵gdqjhuoxvqhvv௶ ou qhhg iou fduh wkdw dulvhv iuop wkh foqglwloq oi glvdelolw 6wdwhv vkoxog ghyhoos foppxqlwedvhg vxssouw dqg vhuylfhv wo uhsodfh lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq vhfxulw phdvxuhv ou ioufhg phglfdo dqg svfkldwulf wuhdwphqw lq lqvwlwxwloqv 6wdwhv vkoxog wdnh phdvxuhv wo lpsuoyh wkh fxuuhqw suofhvv iou h[fkdqjlqj phglfdo uhfougv lq oughu wo hvwdeolvk d fohdu vvwhp iou sdvvlqj oq lqioupdwloq $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 dv lqglylgxdov poyh wkuoxjk wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhp zklfk lv hvvhqwldo wo plqlpl]h huuouv dqg jxdudqwhh dssuosuldwh fduh dqg phglfdwloq dffhvv 6wdwhv vkoxog fooohfw glvdjjuhjdwhg gdwd oq wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp dqg xvlqj wkdw gdwd ghyhoos dqg lpsohphqw vwudwhjlhv wo uhioup soolflhv sudfwlfhv dqg odzv wo hqvxuh htxdo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq /lwkxdqld9loqlxv (1$%/( 3uomhfw s $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ʵʡ ˅˘˦˧ˢ˥˔˧˜˩˘ ˝˨˦˧˜˖˘ ˣ˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘˦ 5hvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh lv dq lpsouwdqw dqg lqfuhdvlqjo uhfojql]hg dssuodfkhv wo oyhudoo txhvwloqv oi mxvwlfh 7khuh lv qo vlqjoh dffhswhg ghilqlwloq oi uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh $ iluvw vwhs wozdugv uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh zdv wdnhq wkuoxjk wkh (&262& 5hvooxwloq zklfk iofxvhg oq uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh suojudpphv lq fulplqdo pdwwhuv ,q sduwlfxodu wklv 5hvooxwloq uhfopphqgv iou wkh foqvlghudwloq oi wkh 6wdwhv wkh 81 %dvlf 3ulqflsohv oq wkh xvh oi uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh suojudpv lq fulplqdo pdwwhuv 7khvh sulqflsohv ghilqh wkh uhvwoudwlyh suofhvv vxssouwlqj uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh dv ௵>@ dq suofhvv lq zklfk wkh ylfwlp dqg wkh oiihqghu dqg zkhuh dssuosuldwh dq owkhu lqglylgxdov ou foppxqlw phpehuv diihfwhg e d fulph sduwlflsdwh wojhwkhu dfwlyho lq wkh uhvooxwloq oi pdwwhuv dulvlqj iuop wkh fulph jhqhudoo zlwk wkh khos oi dq lqwhuphgldu 5hvwoudwlyh suofhvvhv pd lqfoxgh phgldwloq foqfloldwloq foqihuhqflqj dqg vhqwhqflqj flufohv௶ $ uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh suofhvv fdq eh dssolhg dw dq vwdjh oi ohjdo suofhhglqjv lqfoxglqj dw wkh sovwvhqwhqflqj vwdjh 7kh oxwfoph oi d uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh suofhvv pd eh wo suoylgh dowhuqdwlyhv wo lpsulvoqphqw dv sduw oi ou lq dgglwloq wo d qoqfxvwogldo vhqwhqfh exw dovo gxulqj lpsulvoqphqw ou diwhu uhohdvh iuop sulvoq 7kh &53’ &opplwwhh kdv vwdwhg lq uhodwloq wo wkh uljkw wo olehuw wkdw ௵ghsulydwloq oi olehuw lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv vkoxog oqo dsso dv d pdwwhu oi odvw uhvouw dqg zkhq owkhu glyhuvloq suojudpphv lqfoxglqj uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh duh lqvxiilflhqw wo ghwhu (foqoplf dqg 6ofldo &oxqflo (&262& 5hvooxwloq %dvlf sulqflsohv oq wkh xvh oi uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh suojudpphv lq fulplqdo pdwwhuv dydlodeoh dw kwwsv zzzxqoujhqhfovofgofvuhvooxwloqsgi 8qlwhg 1dwloqv (foqoplf dqg 6ofldo &oxqflo (&262& 5hvooxwloq %dvlf sulqflsohv oq wkh xvh oi uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh suojudpphv lq fulplqdo pdwwhuv sdud 81 2iilfh oq ‘uxjv &ulph kdqgeoon oq uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh suojudpphv dydlodeoh dw kwwsv zzzxqogfoujsgifulplqdobmxvwlfh b(eoonsgi s $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ixwxuh fulph௶ $ uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh dssuodfk lv wkhuhiouh suhihuuhg e wkh &opplwwhh 0ouh uhfhqwo lq lwv *xlgholqhv oq ‘hlqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq lqfoxglqj hphujhqflhv wkh &53’ &opplwwhh vwdwhg wkdw 6wdwh sduwlhv ௵ vkoxog suoylgh lqglylgxdol]hg dffhvvleoh hiihfwlyh suopsw dqg sduwlflsdwou sdwkzdv wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zko zlvk wo vhhn uhguhvv uhsdudwloqv dqg uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh dqg owkhu ioupv oi dffoxqwdelolw ௶ 7kh &oxqflo oi (xuosh 5hfopphqgdwloq &05hf foqfhuqlqj uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh lq fulplqdo pdwwhuv ghilqhv ௵uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh௶ dv ௵dq suofhvv zklfk hqdeohv wkovh kduphg e fulph dqg wkovh uhvsoqvleoh iou wkdw kdup li wkh iuhho foqvhqw wo sduwlflsdwh dfwlyho lq wkh uhvooxwloq oi pdwwhuv dulvlqj iuop wkh oiihqfh wkuoxjk wkh khos oi d wudlqhg dqg lpsduwldo wklug sduw 5hvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh oiwhq wdnhv wkh ioup oi d gldoojxh zkhwkhu gluhfw ou lqgluhfw ehwzhhq wkh ylfwlp dqg wkh oiihqghu dqg fdq dovo lqyooyh zkhuh dssuosuldwh owkhu shuvoqv gluhfwo ou lqgluhfwo diihfwhg e d fulph 7klv pd lqfoxgh vxssouwhuv oi ylfwlpv dqg oiihqghuv ௶ 7kh 5hfopphqgdwloq lv dgguhvvhg wo sxeolf dqg sulydwh djhqwv ou hqwlwlhv zklfk oshudwh lq wkh gopdlq oi fulplqdo mxvwlfh dqg zklfk gholyhu ou uhihu fdvhv iou uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh ou zklfk pd owkhuzlvh eh deoh wo xwlol]h uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh ou wo dsso lwv sulqflsohv wo wkhlu zoun -xglfldo dxwkoulwlhv dqg fulplqdo djhqflhv vkoxog fuhdwh wkh foqglwloqv suofhgxuhv dqg lqiudvwuxfwxuhv wo uhihu wkh fdvhv wo uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh djhqflhv zkhq sovvleoh 7kh 5hfopphqgdwloq dovo lghqwlilhv wkh qhhg iou ௵ulvn dvvhvvphqw௶ lq wkh foqwh[w oi suhsdudwloq iou wkh xvh oi uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௱*xlgholqhv oq duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௬ 7kh uljkw wo olehuw dqg vhfxulw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ 6hswhpehu sdud &53’ &opplwwhh *xlgholqhv oq ‘hlqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq lqfoxglqj hphujhqflhv 81 ‘of &53’& 5hfopphqgdwloq &05hf sdudv $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 phdvxuhv 7klv ulvn dvvhvvphqw lv wkhq uhodwhg wo wkh uhtxluhphqw oi hqvxulqj lpsduwldolw gljqlw oi wkh sduwlhv dqg wkhlu hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ˃˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘˦ ˔ˡ˗ ʺ˨˜˗˘˟˜ˡ˘˦ ˢˡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ʽ˨˦˧˜˖˘ ˙ˢ˥ ˃˘˥˦ˢˡ˦ ˪˜˧˛ ʷ˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ʥʤʨ *xlgholqh n oi 3ulqflsoh oq /hjdo &dsdflw hqmolqv 6wdwhv wo ௵hvwdeolvk ou vxssouw dowhuqdwlyh mxvwlfh phfkdqlvpv vxfk dv uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh dowhuqdwlyh glvsxwh uhvooxwloq phfkdqlvpv dqg fxowxudo dqg vofldo ioupv dqg iouxpv oi mxvwlfh wkdw duh dydlodeoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv zlwkoxw uhjdug iou dq foqvwuxfw oi fdsdflw wo sduwlflsdwh௶ *xlgholqh g oi 3ulqflsoh ghdov zlwk wkh uljkwv wo uhsouw fopsodlqwv dqg wo lqlwldwh ohjdo suofhhglqjv ,w lqglfdwhv wkdw 6wdwhv vkdoo ௵>s@uoylgh yooxqwdu dowhuqdwlyh glvsxwh uhvooxwloq phfkdqlvpv vxfk dv foqfloldwloq phgldwloq duelwudwloq dqg uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh௶ 5hvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh gholyhuhg dssuosuldwho dqg idluo lv dq lpsouwdqw dowhuqdwlyh wo ou dgmxqfw zlwklq wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhp iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv &huwdlqo li uhvwoudwlyh suojudpv duh oiihuhg wo oiihqghuv dqg ylfwlpv jhqhudoo wkh vkoxog eh htxdoo dydlodeoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk doo owkhuv 5xoh dqg 5hfopphqgdwloq &05hf 6hh hvshfldoo 5xohv dqg 5hfopphqgdwloq &05hf ௷5hvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh vkoxog eh shuiouphg lq dq lpsduwldo pdqqhu edvhg oq wkh idfwv oi wkh fdvh dqg oq wkh qhhgv dqg lqwhuhvwv oi wkh sduwlhv 7kh lqwhuphgldu vkoxog dozdv uhvshfw wkh gljqlw oi wkh sduwlhv dqg hqvxuh wkdw wkh dfw zlwk uhvshfw wozdugv hdfk owkhu ‘oplqdwloq oi wkh suofhvv e oqh sduw ou e wkh lqwhuphgldu vkoxog eh dyolghg wkh suofhvv vkoxog eh gholyhuhg zlwk htxdo foqfhuq iou doo sduwlhv 5hvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh vhuylfhv duh uhvsoqvleoh iou suoylglqj d vdih dqg fopiouwdeoh hqyluoqphqw iou wkh uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh suofhvv 7kh lqwhuphgldu vkoxog wdnh vxiilflhqw wlph wo suhsduh wkh sduwlhv iou wkhlu sduwlflsdwloq eh vhqvlwlyh wo dq oi wkh sduwlhv௲ yxoqhudelolwlhv dqg li qhfhvvdu wo hqvxuh wkh vdihw oi oqh ou pouh sduwlhv glvfoqwlqxh uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh௶ 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ˆˬ˦˧˘ˠ˜˖ ˅˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ $owhuqdwlyhv wo wudglwloqdo fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv vxfk dv wkuoxjk uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh suofhvvhv dqg sulqflsohv vkoxog eh lpsohphqwhg dfuovv wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv dqg eh htxdoo dffhvvleoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv $ $owhuqdwlyh vvwhpv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh suoylghg zkdwhyhu dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouwv duh qhhghg wo sduwlflsdwh htxdoo % 5hvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh vkoxog eh lqfoxghg lq ohjdo vwxglhv fxuulfxod dv zhoo dv lq wudlqlqjv iou mxvwlfh dfwouv 6hh dovo ixuwkhu ehooz lq wudlqlqj .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ʶʡ ˇ˥˔˜ˡ˜ˡ˚ ˢ˙ ˣ˥ˢ˙˘˦˦˜ˢˡ˔˟˦ 7kh wudlqlqj oi mxvwlfh dfwouv lv ylwdo wo hiihfwlyho suoylgh iou dffhvv wo mxvwlfh dqg wkh suowhfwloq oi wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq mxvwlfh suofhvvhv dqg suofhgxuhv :lwkoxw vxfk wudlqlqj hylghqfh dqg sudfwlfdo h[shulhqfh vxjjhvw wkdw lq pdq foxqwulhv mxvwlfh dfwouv pd eh xqdzduh oi wkh ohjdo uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv xqlqiouphg deoxw glvdelolw pouh jhqhudoo dqg lqfdsdeoh oi suoylglqj wkh dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouw uhtxluhg iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo hqmo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh oq dq htxdo edvlv 7kh (qdeoh suomhfw qdwloqdo vwxglhv kdyh foqiluphg wkdw wudlqlqj iou mxvwlfh dfwouv lv juhdwo qhhghg lq doo wkh wdujhw foxqwulhv 7kh ghyhoosphqw dqg lqyhvwphqw lq vxfk wudlqlqj lv dq lpsouwdqw zd wo suopowh pouh dffhvvleoh mxvwlfh vvwhpv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7kh 81 2+&+5 kdv vwuhvvhg wkdw ௵6wdwhv pxvw dovo vhhn wo oyhufoph eduulhuv lq dffhvv wo mxvwlfh e suoylglqj wudlqlqj wo mxglfldo oiilfhuv odzhuv dqg owkhuv lqfoxglqj iouhqvlf h[shuwv sulvoq vwdii dqg wkh soolfh oq wkh kxpdq uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ ,w lv wkhuhiouh fohdu wkdw fopsuhkhqvlyh wudlqlqj oi wkh zlghvw udqjh oi mxvwlfh dfwouv sovvleoh lv ghvludeoh $v 3ulqflsoh oi wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv diilupv ௵>doo@ wkovh zounlqj lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp pxvw eh suoylghg zlwk dzduhqhvvudlvlqj dqg wudlqlqj suojudpphv dgguhvvlqj wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq sduwlfxodu lq wkh foqwh[w oi dffhvv wo mxvwlfh௶ $ffouglqj wo wkh (8 5hfopphqgdwloq oq suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv iou ௵yxoqhudeoh௶ shuvoqv vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv soolfh oiilfhuv odz hqioufhphqw dqg mxglfldo dxwkoulwlhv fopshwhqw lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv foqgxfwhg djdlqvw ௵yxoqhudeoh௶ shuvoqv vkoxog uhfhlyh vshflilf wudlqlqj lq wklv uhjdug 7klv 3o«qd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq 0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s )2580 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq &]hfkld 3udkd (1$%/( 3uomhfw s .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld 9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 81 2+&+5 ௱5hsouw 5ljkw wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv௲ ’hfhpehu $+5& sdud 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv &opplvvloq 5hfopphqgdwloq & oq suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv iou yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv sdud $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 5hfopphqgdwloq vkoxog eh xqghuvwoog dqg lqwhusuhwhg lq wkh foqwh[w oi ,+5/ dqg vwdqgdugv shuwdlqlqj wo wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv % hgxfdwlqj wkhpvhoyhv oq koz gliihuhqw glvdelolwlhv suhvhqw wkhpvhoyhv dqg wkh vwuxjjohv wkdw foph zlwk wkhp mxvwlfh dfwouv lqfoxglqj mxgjhv pd eh htxlsshg wo $ %hwwhu hpsdwkl]h zlwk wkh shuvoq lq txhvwloq % %hwwhu uhfojql]h li dq glvfulplqdwloq kdsshqv lqvlgh ou oxwvlgh oi wkh foxuwuoop & %hwwhu jxlgh wkh suofhvvhv e zklfk glvdelolwlhv duh lghqwlilhg dqg vxssouwv dqg dffoppogdwloqv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh suoylghg ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ ,q 6sdlq wkh 0lqlvwu oi -xvwlfh௲v &hqwhu iou /hjdo 6wxglhv oiihuv d vl[poqwk oqolqh wudlqlqj foxuvh oq ௵’lvdelolw $wwhqwloq lq wkh $gplqlvwudwloq oi -xvwlfh௶ 7kh foxuvh lv oshq wo doo wkh suoihvvloqdov wudlqhg dw wkh &hqwhu iou /hjdo 6wxglhv dqg lw kdv dq xqolplwhg qxpehu oi vsowv ,q 5opdqld wkh &/5 &hqwhu iou /hjdo 5ljkwv lq sduwqhuvkls zlwk wkh 3xeolf 3uovhfxwou௲v 2iilfh oi wkh +ljk &oxuw oi &dvvdwloq dqg -xvwlfh dqg zlwk wkh vxssouw oi wkh 0lqlvwu oi -xvwlfh oujdql]hv pxowlglvflsolqdu wudlqlqj foxuvhv iou ohjdo dqg svfkovofldo vshfldolvwv lqfoxglqj pdjlvwudwhv odzhuv svfkooojlvwv vofldo zounhuv dqg svfkldwulvwv $gdsw-xvw foxuvhv ,q 3ouwxjdo uhjxodu wudlqlqj dfwlylwlhv duh oujdql]hg dw wkh oofdo ohyho e d zounlqj juoxs fopsovhg oi soolfh oiilfhuv oofdo glvdelolw oujdql]dwloqv uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv iuop wkh pxqlflsdolw dqg wkh oofdo khdowk vvwhp 7kh zounlqj juoxs foqvwlwxwhv dq lqwhuhvwlqj qhwzoun iou gliihuhqw dfwouv iou wkh h[fkdqjh oi lqioupdwloq dqg wkh ghyhoosphqw oi dssuosuldwh dqg ioh[leoh vooxwloqv wo oofdo suoeohpv 3o«qd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq 0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 5opdqld %xfduhvw (1$%/( 3uomhfw s )(1$&(5&, %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 3ouwxjdo/lveoq (1$%/( 3uomhfw s $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ˆˬ˦˧˘ˠ˜˖ ˅˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 6wdwhv vkoxog suoylgh shuloglf dqg kljk txdolw wudlqlqj oq d pdqgdwou edvlv wo mxvwlfh dfwouv $ ‘hyhoos d foqvlvwhqw dqg foouglqdwhg wudlqlqj sodq uhjduglqj glvdelolw lvvxhv wdujhwlqj wkh gliihuhqw mxvwlfh vvwhp suoihvvloqdov % &uhdwh d vvwhp oi oqjolqj pdqgdwou wudlqlqj iou mxvwlfh dfwouv zko lqwhudfw zlwk shuvoqv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv l )ou mxgjhv ohjdo sudfwlwloqhuv dqg soolfh shuvoqqho wkhuh vkoxog eh d iofxv oq wkh kxpdq uljkwvedvhg pogho oi glvdelolw oq dffhvv wo mxvwlfh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv lghqwlilfdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg oq foppxqlfdwloq zlwk doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj shuvoqv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv ll )ou doo mxvwlfh dfwouv wkhuh vkoxog eh iofxv oq koz wo foppxqlfdwh zlwk d shuvoq zlwk glvdelolw oq wkh lpsdfw oi ghwhqwloq dqg phglfdo wuhdwphqw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg koz lq sduwlfxodu phglfdwloq diihfwv wkhp lq foxuw ou d khdulqj 7khvh lqfoxgh iou h[dpsoh vooz uhvsoqvhv ou wkh idfw wkdw khdulqjv vkoxog qow eh vfkhgxohg vkouwo diwhu wkh shuvoq uhfhlyhg phglfdo wuhdwphqw 6wdwhv vkoxog jxdudqwhh hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wudlqlqj $ 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog eh lqyooyhg lq wkh ghyhoosphqw dqg wudlqlqj oi mxvwlfh dfwouv lqfoxglqj iou wkh sxusovh oi idflolwdwlqj d ehwwhu &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 5opdqld %xfduhvw (1$%/( 3uomhfw s $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 xqghuvwdqglqj e mxvwlfh dfwouv oi wkh h[shulhqfhv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq ohjdo suofhvvhv $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ʷʡ ˅˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˟˜˕˘˥˧ˬʟ ˙˔˜˥ ˧˥˜˔˟ ˔ˡ˗ ˣ˥˘ʠ˧˥˜˔˟ ˥˜˚˛˧˦ /dfn oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv lq suhwuldo dqg wuldo suofhgxuhv yloodwhv wkh uljkw wo d idlu wuldo dqg pd ohdg wo hiihfwlyh h[foxvloq iuop suofhhglqjv dqgou ehlqj vxemhfwhg wo xqidlu vhqwhqfhv $ shuvoq zloo foph lqwo foqwdfw zlwk wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp iuop wkh pophqw oi duuhvw dqg ghsulydwloq oi olehuw $uwlfoh oi wkh ,&&35 uhtxluhv wkdw ௵$qoqh duuhvwhg ou ghwdlqhg oq d fulplqdo fkdujh vkdoo eh euoxjkw suopswo ehiouh d mxgjh ou owkhu oiilfhu dxwkoul]hg e odz wo h[huflvh mxglfldo sozhu dqg vkdoo eh hqwlwohg wo wuldo zlwklq d uhdvoqdeoh wlph ou wo uhohdvh ,w vkdoo qow eh wkh jhqhudo uxoh wkdw shuvoqv dzdlwlqj wuldo vkdoo eh ghwdlqhg lq fxvwog exw uhohdvh pd eh vxemhfw wo jxdudqwhhv wo dsshdu iou wuldo dw dq owkhu vwdjh oi wkh mxglfldo suofhhglqjv dqg vkoxog offdvloq dulvh iou h[hfxwloq oi wkh mxgjhphqw௶ 0ouhoyhu duwlfoh suoylghv wkdw ௵$qoqh zko lv ghsulyhg oi klv olehuw e duuhvw ou ghwhqwloq vkdoo eh hqwlwohg wo wdnh suofhhglqjv ehiouh d foxuw lq oughu wkdw wkdw foxuw pd ghflgh zlwkoxw ghod oq wkh odzixoqhvv oi klv ghwhqwloq dqg oughu klv uhohdvh li wkh ghwhqwloq lv qow odzixo௶ ‘hwdlohg fodulilfdwloqv oi wkhvh suoylvloqv duh foqwdlqhg lq wkh +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh௲v *hqhudo &opphqw 7kh (&+5 dovo lqwuogxfhv suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv lq fdvh oi ghwhqwloq )luvw duwlfoh lqwuogxfhv wkh uljkw oi wkh ghihqgdqwv wo eh lqiouphg lq d odqjxdjh wkdw wkh nqoz deoxw wkh uhdvoqv oi wkh duuhvw dqg wkh fkdujhv 0ouhoyhu duwlfoh vwdwhv wkdw 81 2+&+5 ௱5hsouw 5ljkw wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv௲ ’hfhpehu $+5& sdud 81 +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh /lehuw dqg vhfxulw oi shuvoq &&35&*& $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ௵(yhuoqh duuhvwhg ou ghwdlqhg lq dffougdqfh zlwk wkh suoylvloqv oi sdudjudsk f oi wklv duwlfoh vkdoo eh euoxjkw suopswo ehiouh d mxgjh ou owkhu oiilfhu dxwkoulvhg e odz wo h[huflvh mxglfldo sozhu dqg vkdoo eh hqwlwohg wo wuldo zlwklq d uhdvoqdeoh wlph ou wo uhohdvh shqglqj wuldo 5hohdvh pd eh foqglwloqhg e jxdudqwhhv wo dsshdu iou wuldo௶ $uwlfoh (&+5 dggv wkdw ௵(yhuoqh zko lv ghsulyhg oi klv olehuw e duuhvw ou ghwhqwloq vkdoo eh hqwlwohg wo wdnh suofhhglqjv e zklfk wkh odzixoqhvv oi klv ghwhqwloq vkdoo eh ghflghg vshhglo e d foxuw dqg klv uhohdvh oughuhg li wkh ghwhqwloq lv qow odzixo௶ $uwlfoh oi wkh ,&&35 suoylghv wkdw hyhuoqh lv hqwlwohg wo d idlu dqg sxeolf khdulqj e d fopshwhqw lqghshqghqw dqg lpsduwldo wulexqdo hvwdeolvkhg e odzʹʹ ,w ixuwkhu suoylghv wkdw hyhuoqh vkdoo eh hqwlwohg wo eh lqiouphg suopswo dqg lq ghwdlo lq d odqjxdjh zklfk oqh xqghuvwdqgv dqg wo kdyh dghtxdwh wlph dqg idflolwlhv iou wkh suhsdudwloq oi wkhlu ghihqfh dqg wo foppxqlfdwh zlwk foxqvho oi wkhlu ozq fkoovlqj 7uldov pxvw dovo eh foqgxfwhg zlwkoxw xqgxh ghod dqg iuhh dvvlvwdqfh oi dq lqwhusuhwhu pxvw eh suoylghg li oqh fdqqow xqghuvwdqg ou vshdn wkh odqjxdjh xvhg lq foxuw 1o shuvoq vkoxog eh fopshoohg wo whvwli djdlqvw wkhpvhoyhv ou wo foqihvv jxlow 6shflilf vdihjxdugv dssolhv dovo dw suhwuldo skdvhv $v kljkoljkwhg e wkh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o shuvoqv lq suhwuldo ghwhqwloq kdyh wkh uljkw wo vhh wkhlu fdxvh euoxjkw wo wuldo zlwk xqgxh ghod dssolhv 0ouhoyhu suhwuldo ghwhqwloq vkoxog eh hpsoohg oqo diwhu dq lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw dqg lw vkoxog qhyhu eh dq dxwopdwlf ,qwhuqdwloqdo &oyhqdqw oq &lylo dqg 3oolwlfdo 5ljkwv dffhvvleoh khuh ,qwhuqdwloqdo &oyhqdqw oq &lylo dqg 3oolwlfdo 5ljkwv dffhvvleoh khuh 81 +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh /lehuw dqg vhfxulw oi shuvoq &&35&*& sdud ,elg sdud $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 dqg pdqgdwou vooxwloq ‘hwdlohg fodulilfdwloqv oi wkhvh uljkwv duh foqwdlqhg lq wkh +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh௲v *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh oi wkh (xuoshdq &oqyhqwloq oi +xpdq 5ljkwv vlploduo suoylghv wkdw hyhuoqh lv hqwlwohg wo d idlu dqg sxeolf khdulqj e d wulexqdo hvwdeolvkhg e odzʹ͵ʹ 0ouhoyhu duwlfoh (&+5 lqwuogxfhv wkh suhvxpswloq oi lqqofhqfh xqwlo suoyhg jxlow dqg duwlfoh (&+5 suoylghv iou d vhulhv oi ixuwkhu suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv 6lploduo wo duwlfoh ,&&35 duwlfoh suoylghv iou wkh ghihqgdqwv wo hqmo wkh uljkw wo eh lqiouphg deoxw wkh uhdvoqv oi ghwhqwloq dqg wkh fkdujhv lq d odqjxdjh nqozq e wkhp wkh uljkw wo ghihqfh wkh uljkw wo ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh wkh uljkw wo kdyh dq lqwhusuhwhu dqg wkh uljkw wo h[dplqh dqg kdyh h[dplqhg zlwqhvvhv djdlqvw wkhp dqg oq wkhlu ehkdoi 0ouh vshflilfdoo duwlfoh &53′ suoylghv wkdw ௵6wdwhv 3duwlhv vkdoo hqvxuh wkdw li shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh ghsulyhg oi wkhlu olehuw wkuoxjk dq suofhvv wkh duh oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv hqwlwohg wo jxdudqwhhv lq dffougdqfh zlwk lqwhuqdwloqdo kxpdq uljkwv odz dqg vkdoo eh wuhdwhg lq fopsoldqfh zlwk wkh oemhfwlyhv dqg sulqflsohv oi wklv &oqyhqwloq lqfoxglqj e suoylvloq oi uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq௶ 7kh &53’ &opplwwhh kdv ixuwkhu uhfopphqghg lq lwv *xlgholqhv oq duwlfoh wkdw ௵doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zko kdyh ehhq dffxvhg oi fulphv dqg >@ ghwdlqhg lq mdlov dqg lqvwlwxwloqv zlwkoxw wuldo eh dooozhg wo ghihqg wkhpvhoyhv djdlqvw fulplqdo fkdujhv dqg eh suoylghg zlwk wkh vxssouw dqg dffoppogdwloq uhtxluhg wo idflolwdwh 81 +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh 5ljkw wo htxdolw ehiouh foxuwv dqg wulexqdov dqg wo d idlu wuldo &&35&*& (xuoshdq &oqyhqwloq oq +xpdq 5ljkwv dffhvvleoh khuh $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 wkhlu hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq௶ dv zhoo dv suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wo hqvxuh idlu wuldo dqg gxh suofhvv௶ 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv hvwdeolvkhg wkdw ghfodudwloqv oi xqilwqhvv wo vwdqg wuldo ou qoquhvsoqvlelolw lq fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv dqg wkh ghwhqwloq oi shuvoqv edvhg oq wkovh ghfodudwloqv duh foqwudu wo duwlfoh oi wkh &53’ vlqfh vxfk ghfodudwloqv ௵ghsulyh wkh shuvoq oi wkhlu uljkw wo gxh suofhvv dqg vdihjxdugv wkdw duh dssolfdeoh wo hyhu ghihqgdqw௵ 7kh &opplwwhh kdv dovo fdoohg iou 6wdwhv sduwlhv wo uhpoyh dq vxfk ghfodudwloqv iuop wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhp 7kh &opplwwhh kdv uhfopphqghg wkdw ௵doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zko kdyh ehhq dffxvhg oi fulphv dqg >@ ghwdlqhg lq mdlov dqg lqvwlwxwloqv zlwkoxw wuldo duh dooozhg wo ghihqg wkhpvhoyhv djdlqvw fulplqdo fkdujhv dqg duh suoylghg zlwk uhtxluhg vxssouw dqg dffoppogdwloq wo idflolwdwh wkhlu hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq௶ &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௵*xlgholqhv oq wkh uljkw wo olehuw dqg vhfxulw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv $uwlfoh /lehuw dqg vhfxulw oi shuvoq௶ &53’3($ 6hswhpehu dffhvvleoh khuh ,elg ,elg $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ʸʡ ˅˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˔ˡ ˘˙˙˘˖˧˜˩˘ ˥˘ˠ˘˗ˬ ˔ˡ˗ ˥˘ˣ˔˥˔˧˜ˢˡʥʦʩ 7kh uljkw wo dq hiihfwlyh uhphg iou yloodwloq oi uljkwv lv d jhqhudo sulqflsoh oi odz dqg suoylghg iou lq hyhu sulqflsdo kxpdq uljkwv wuhdw 7kh sulqflsoh dv h[suhvvhg lq wkh 81 %dvlf 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv dgoswhg e foqvhqvxv oi wkh 81 *hqhudo $vvhpeo lv wkdw ௵7kh oeoljdwloq wo uhvshfw hqvxuh uhvshfw iou dqg lpsohphqw lqwhuqdwloqdo kxpdq uljkwv odz >@ lqfoxghv >@ wkh gxw wo >@ f 3uoylgh wkovh zko fodlp wo eh ylfwlpv oi d kxpdq uljkwv yloodwloq zlwk htxdo dqg hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfhluuhvshfwlyh oi zko pd xowlpdwho eh wkh ehduhu oi uhvsoqvlelolw iou wkh yloodwloq g 3uoylgh hiihfwlyh uhphglhv wo ylfwlpv lqfoxglqj uhsdudwloq >@௶ $uwlfoh oi wkh ,&&35 suoylghv wkdw 6wdwhv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw dq shuvoq zkovh uljkwv ou iuhhgopv duh yloodwhg kdyh dffhvv wo dq hiihfwlyh dqg hqioufhdeoh uhphg $v diiluphg e wkh +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh wklv lqfoxghv suoylvloq oi uhsdudwloq wkdw fdq lqyooyh uhvwlwxwloq uhkdelolwdwloq dqg phdvxuhv oi vdwlvidfwloq hj sxeolf dsooojlhv sxeolf phpouldov jxdudqwhhv oi qoquhshwlwloq dqg fkdqjhv lq uhohydqw odzv dqg sudfwlfhv $uwlfoh (&+5 jxdudqwhhv wkh uljkw wo dq hiihfwlyh uhphg dv ioooozv ௵(yhuoqh zkovh uljkwv dqg iuhhgopv dv vhw iouwk lq wkh &oqyhqwloq duh yloodwhg vkdoo kdyh dq hiihfwlyh uhphg ehiouh d qdwloqdo dxwkoulw qowzlwkvwdqglqj wkdw wkh yloodwloq kdv ehhq fopplwwhg e shuvoqv dfwlqj lq dq oiilfldo fdsdflw௶ )ou d ixoohu wuhdwphqw oi wklv uljkw xqghu lqwhuqdwloqdo kxpdq uljkwv odz vhh ,&- uhylvhg 3udfwlwloqhuv *xlgh qxpehu dffhvvleoh khuh kwwsv zzzlfmoujuhvoxufhwkhuljkwwoduhphgdqguhsdudwloqioujuovvkxpdquljkwvyloodwloqvxsgdwhwosudfwlwloqhuvjxlghqo 81 *hqhudo $vvhpeo 5hvooxwloq dgoswhg e wkh *hqhudo $vvhpeo oq ‘hfhpehu %dvlf 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq wkh 5ljkw wo d 5hphg dqg 5hsdudwloq iou 9lfwlpv oi *uovv 9loodwloqv oi ,qwhuqdwloqdo +xpdq 5ljkwv /dz dqg 6huloxv 9loodwloqv oi ,qwhuqdwloqdo +xpdqlwduldq /dz $5(6 sdud ,qwhuqdwloqdo &oyhqdqw oq &lylo dqg 3oolwlfdo 5ljkwv dffhvvleoh khuh 81 +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o 7kh 1dwxuh oi wkh *hqhudo /hjdo 2eoljdwloq ,psovhg oq 6wdwhv 3duwlhv wo wkh &oyhqdqw &&35&5hy$gg sdud $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $uwlfoh oi wkh (8 &kduwhu oi )xqgdphqwdo 5ljkwv jxdudqwhhv wkh uljkw wo dq hiihfwlyh uhphg iou lqglylgxdo uljkwv yloodwloqv ௵(yhuoqh zkovh uljkwv dqg iuhhgopv jxdudqwhhg e wkh odz oi wkh 8qloq duh yloodwhg kdv wkh uljkw wo dq hiihfwlyh uhphg ehiouh d wulexqdo lq fopsoldqfh zlwk wkh foqglwloqv odlg gozq lq wklv $uwlfoh >@ /hjdo dlg vkdoo eh pdgh dydlodeoh wo wkovh zko odfn vxiilflhqw uhvoxufhv lq vo idu dv vxfk dlg lv qhfhvvdu wo hqvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh௶ &oqvlvwhqwo zlwk wkhvh jhqhudo sulqflsohv wkh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv diiluphg wkdw wkh &53′ uhtxluhv dffhvv wo hiihfwlyh uhphglhv dqg uhsdudwloq lqfoxglqj uhvwlwxwloq fopshqvdwloq uhkdelolwdwloq vdwlvidfwloq dqg jxdudqwhhv oi qoquhshwlwloq 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv vwdwhg wkdw uhguhvv lv dlphg dw ௵uhvwoulqj wkh gljqlw oi wkh ylfwlp௶ dqg wkdw uhvwlwxwloq dlpv wo ௵uhvwouh wkh ylfwlp wo wkh ouljlqdo vlwxdwloq ehiouh wkh yloodwloq offxuuhg௶ 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh ixuwkhu vwdwhg wkdw wkhuh lv d euodghu dlp iou uhphglhv iou yloodwloqv oi wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv qdpho wkdw uhphglhv ௵vkoxog dlp dw fkdqjlqj dwwlwxghv dqg hqvxuh wkh sovvlelolw oi vhhnlqj lqmxqfwloqv௶ 0ouhoyhu wkh &53’ &opplwwhh kdv lqglfdwhg wkdw ௵ wkh uhfojqlwloq oi mxglfldo uhphglhv oi d fooohfwlyh qdwxuh ou fodvv dfwloqv fdq vljqlilfdqwo foqwulexwh wo hiihfwlyho jxdudqwhhlqj dffhvv wo mxvwlfh lq vlwxdwloqv wkdw diihfw juoxsv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ 81 2+&+5 ௱5hsouw 5ljkw wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv௲ ’hfhpehu $+5& sdudv ,elg &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq htxdolw dqg qoqglvfulplqdwloq &53’&*& $sulo sdud k $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ˃˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘˦ ˔ˡ˗ ʺ˨˜˗˘˟˜ˡ˘˦ ˢˡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ʽ˨˦˧˜˖˘ ˙ˢ˥ ˃˘˥˦ˢˡ˦ ˪˜˧˛ ʷ˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ʥʧʦ 3ulqflsoh 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv kdyh wkh uljkw wo uhsouw fopsodlqwv dqg lqlwldwh ohjdo suofhhglqjv foqfhuqlqj kxpdq uljkwv yloodwloqv dqg fulphv kdyh wkhlu fopsodlqwv lqyhvwljdwhg dqg eh diioughg hiihfwlyh uhphglhv௶ 6wdwhv pxvw kdyh dffhvvleoh hdvwoxvh wudqvsduhqw dqg hiihfwlyh phfkdqlvpv iou lqglylgxdov wo uhsouw fopsodlqwv deoxw kxpdq uljkwv yloodwloqv dqg fulphv &opsodlqw dgmxglfdwouv dqg wulexqdov pxvw suoylgh uhphglhv wkdw duh lqglylgxdoo wdloouhg dqg pd lqfoxgh uhguhvv dqg uhsdudwloq $ffouglqjo 6wdwhv vkdoo &opsodlqw phfkdqlvpv d (vwdeolvk fopsodlqw phfkdqlvpv ௬ iou lqvwdqfh qdwloqdo kxpdq uljkwv lqvwlwxwloqv wulexqdov dqg dgplqlvwudwlyh eoglhv ௬ zlwk wkh sozhu wo khdu fopsodlqwv lqfoxglqj fopsodlqwv deoxw glvdelolwedvhg glvfulplqdwloq iuop shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg owkhuv dqg wo oughu uhphglhv e (qvxuh wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv pd iloh fulplqdo fopsodlqwv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv f (qvxuh wkdw flylo dqg fulplqdo fopsodlqw phfkdqlvpv duh dffhvvleoh xvlqj iou h[dpsoh kowolqhv dqg hvhuylfh fopsodlqw phwkogv g 3uoylgh yooxqwdu dowhuqdwlyh glvsxwh uhvooxwloq phfkdqlvpv vxfk dv foqfloldwloq phgldwloq duelwudwloq dqg uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh h (qvxuh wkdw fopsodlqw phfkdqlvpv dqg lqyhvwljdwloqv duh jhqghu vhqvlwlyh wo jxdudqwhh wkdw ylfwlpv oi jhqghuedvhg yloohqfh duh deoh dqg zloolqj wo foph iouzdug vdiho i (qvxuh wkdw vshfldo suowhfwloq xqlwv hj wkovh ghdolqj zlwk jhqghuedvhg yloohqfh kdwh fulph fkloguhq dqg wudiilfnlqj lq shuvoqv duh dffhvvleoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg uhvsoqvlyh wo wkhlu qhhgv 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 j (qvxuh wkdw phfkdqlvpv zkhq dssuosuldwh dqg ghvluhg suoylgh iou dqoqplw dqg foqilghqwldolw 5hphglhv d (qvxuh lq wkh fulplqdo foqwh[w wkdw wkovh zko dexvh ou owkhuzlvh plvwuhdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh suovhfxwhg dqg zkhq dssuosuldwh foqylfwhg ou vxemhfw wo owkhu hiihfwlyh vdqfwloqv e (qvxuh wkdw hiihfwlyh uhphglhv duh lq sodfh iou kxpdq uljkwv yloodwloqv lqfoxglqj wkh uljkw wo eh iuhh iuop glvdelolwedvhg glvfulplqdwloq dqg wkh uljkwv wo uhvwlwxwloq fopshqvdwloq uhkdelolwdwloq vdwlvidfwloq dqg jxdudqwhhv oi qoquhshwlwloq 6xfk uhphglhv vkoxog dpoqj owkhu wklqjv l %h hqioufhdeoh lqglylgxdol]hg dqg wdloouhg wo phhw wkh qhhgv oi fodlpdqwv ll (qvxuh wkdw ylfwlpv duh suowhfwhg iuop uhshdw yloodwloqv oi wkhlu kxpdq uljkwv lll %h suosouwloqdo wo wkh judylw oi wkh yloodwloqv dqg wkh flufxpvwdqfhv oi hdfk fdvh ly %h suoylghg oq wkh edvlv wkdw dq lqglylgxdo௲v iuhh dqg lqiouphg foqvhqw lv uhtxluhg iou dq uhkdelolwdwlyh phdvxuhv y $gguhvv wkh vvwhplf qdwxuh oi kxpdq uljkwv yloodwloqv $gglwloqdoo dffouglqj wo wkh 2+&+5 ௵>u@hguhvv dqg uhsdudwloq lq doo wkhlu fopsoqhqwv vkoxog eh suoylghg wdnlqj lqwo foqvlghudwloq wkh vshflilf flufxpvwdqfhv oi wkh shuvoq zlwk glvdelolw dgguhvvlqj vvwhplf fkdqjh lqfoxglqj wkh h[sovxuh oi wuxwk dv d fopsoqhqw oi vdwlvidfwloq $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 dqg suoylglqj jxlgdqfh iou ohjdo dqg soolf uhioup dqg fdsdflw exloglqj dv jxdudqwhhv oi qoquhshwlwloq௶ 7klv lv lq olqh zlwk wkh mxulvsuxghqfh oi wkh &53’ &opplwwhh lq lwv foppxqlfdwloqv zklfk wslfdoo lqfoxgh uhfopphqgdwloqv ghglfdwhg vshflilfdoo wo hqvxulqj jxdudqwhhv oi qoquhshwlwloq lqfoxglqj foppoqo uhfopphqgdwloqv iou ohjdo soolf dqg suofhvv uhioupv dqg wudlqlqj oi gxw ehduhuv dqg vwdwh dfwouv lqfoxglqj mxvwlfh dfwouv )ou lqvwdqfh lq lwv ylhzv lq wkh foppxqlfdwloq 0hglqd 9hod y 0h[lfo 1o wkh &opplwwhh oevhuyhv wkdw ௵wkh 6wdwh sduw lv xqghu dq oeoljdwloq wo wdnh phdvxuhv wo suhyhqw vlplodu yloodwloqv lq wkh ixwxuh௶ 3ohdvh vhh ghwdlohg 3udfwlfdo jxlgdqfh dqg 5hfopphqgdwloqv lq vhfwloq ,9 ehooz 81 2+&+5 ௱5hsouw 5ljkw wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv௲ ’hfhpehu $+5& sdud ,q sduwlfxodu wkh &opplwwhh hfopphqghg wo ௵ l pdnh doo qhfhvvdu dphqgphqwv wo wkh fulplqdo odz ll5hylhz wkh dssolfdwloq oi vhfxulw phdvxuhv lqyooylqj fopplwwdo iou wkh sxusovhv oi phglfdo dqg svfkldwulf wuhdwphqw dqg wdnh wkh qhfhvvdu vwhsv wo suopowh dowhuqdwlyhv lll(qvxuh wkdw shuvoqv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqg svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv duh suoylghg zlwk dssuosuldwh vxssouw dqg uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv wo hqdeoh wkhp wo h[huflvh wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw ehiouh wkh foxuwv ௶9lhzv dgoswhg e wkh &opplwwhh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh 2swloqdo 3uowofoo foqfhuqlqj foppxqlfdwloq qo 2fwoehu sdud e $&&(66 72 -867,&( )25 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 •˜u -$˜abɍ˜mci§Ÿɍubɍ•-˜ŸukŸɍèm§iɍ$mŸa mbm§m-Ÿɍa§ɍabbɍŸ§ac-Ÿɍubɍ§i-ɍa$jmkmŸ§˜a§mukɍubɍ]Ÿ§m -ɍ 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 7klv &kdswhu hodeoudwhv oq wkh vshflilf hohphqwv uhtxluhg wo jxdudqwhh wkh suofhgxudo uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhvʹͷ ,w iofxvhv oq wkh uljkw wo suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wkh uljkw wo lqwhusuhwdwloq dqg wudqvodwloq wkh uljkw oi dffhvv wo d odzhu wkh uljkw wo ohjdo dlg dffhvvlelolw oi foxuw idflolwlhv lqioupdwloq dqg vhuylfhv dqg voph oi wkh uljkwv dqg sulqflsohv wkdw dsso vshflilfdoo lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv vxfk dv wkh uljkw wo eh suhvhqw dw wuldo wkh suhvxpswloq oi lqqofhqfh dqg uljkwv uhjduglqj ghwhqwloq ʴʡ ˅˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˣ˥ˢ˖˘˗˨˥˔˟ ˔˖˖ˢˠˠˢ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 3uofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv duh ylwdo lq suoylglqj iou dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg uhdolvlqj vxfk uljkwv dv wkh uljkwv wo ohjdo fdsdflw sduwlflsdwloq lqioupdwloq lqwhusuhwdwloq hiihfwlyh dvvlvwdqfh oi ohjdo foxqvho dqg ohjdo dlg ,w lv qow sovvleoh wo oxwolqh doo sovvleoh dffoppogdwloqv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dv wkhvh duh fdvh vshflilf dqg ghshqg oq lqglylgxdo vlwxdwloqv 8qghu duwlfoh 81 &53′ qdwloqdo dxwkoulwlhv pxvw ௵fuhdwh dq dfwloqdeoh dqg hqioufhdeoh uljkw wo uhfhlyh wkh lqglylgxdoo ghwhuplqhg suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxglqj vxssouw qhfhvvdu wo hqdeoh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo sduwlflsdwh hiihfwlyho lq doo suofhhglqjv lq dq foxuw wulexqdo ou iouxp௶ 7kh &53’ &opplwwhh kdv ௵foqvlvwhqwo lqglfdwhg wkdw suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv vkoxog eh suoylghg oq wkh edvlv oi wkh ௱iuhh fkolfh dqg suhihuhqfh௲ oi wkh shuvoq foqfhuqhg௶ʹͷͺ :lwk vshflilf uhihuhqfh wo mxgjhv dffouglqj wo wkh 81 2+&+5 ௵ wkh mxgjh ou wkh uhvsoqvleoh hqwlw vkoxog jlyh sulpdu foqvlghudwloq wo wkh uhtxhvw oi wkh 5hfopphqgdwloqv lq vhfwloqv ,9,9 duh dssolfdeoh wo doo suofhhglqjv qow oqo fulplqdo suofhhglqjv 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 3ulqflsoh s 81 2+&+5 ௱5hsouw 5ljkw wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv௲ ’hfhpehu $+5& sdud 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( lqglylgxdo zlwk glvdelolw dv wkh nqoz ehvw zkdw wkhlu ozq dffoppogdwloq qhhgv duh௶ʹͷͻ ,q lwv ylhzv lq wkh foppxqlfdwloq 0hglqd 9hod y 0h[lfo 1o ʹͷͳ wkh &opplwwhh ioxqg d yloodwloq oi duwlfoh oi wkh &53′ hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv gxh wo 0h[lfo௲v idloxuh wo pdnh suoylvloq iou suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv 7kh 6wdwh lq wklv fdvh kdg ghqlhg wkh dssolfdqw wkh sovvlelolw oi h[huflvlqj wkhlu uljkw wo dffhvv mxvwlfh e idlolqj wo hqvxuh wkhlu ossouwxqlw wo sduwlflsdwh lq wkh mxglfldo suofhhglqjv 7kh dssolfdqw zdv qow shuplwwhg wo whvwli whvw hylghqfh ou dwwhqg khdulqjv shuwdlqlqj wo klv ozq fdvh 1ou zdv wkh dssolfdqw qowlilhg oi wkh ghflvloqv wdnhq lq klv pdwwhu 7kh dssolfdwloq iou wkh vshfldo suofhgxuh lq wklv fdvh glg qow jxdudqwhh wkdw suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv zoxog eh pdgh wo hqdeoh wkh dssolfdqw wo dffhvv mxvwlfh oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv dovo dgguhvvhg wkh lpsouwdqfh oi judqwlqj suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv lq lwv ylhzv lq wkh foppxqlfdwloq *hppd %hdvoh y $xvwudold 1o ʹͷͳ 7kh dssolfdqw lq wkdw fdvh zdv ghdi dqg zdv vxppoqhg wo eh d mxuou lq fulplqdo mxulvglfwloq +ozhyhu vkh zdv ghqlhg wkh dvvlvwdqfh oi d vljqodqjxdjh lqwhusuhwhu ou owkhu suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloq wkdw zoxog doooz khu wo h[huflvh khu uoohʹͷʹ ,q lwv uhfopphqgdwloqv wkh &opplwwhh uhfdoohg wkh 6wdwh௲v gxw wo hqvxuh uhdvoqdeoh dqg suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wo hqdeoh khu ixoo sduwlflsdwloqʹͷ͵ ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ˃˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘˦ ˔ˡ˗ ʺ˨˜˗˘˟˜ˡ˘˦ ˢˡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ʽ˨˦˧˜˖˘ ˙ˢ˥ ˃˘˥˦ˢˡ˦ ˪˜˧˛ ʷ˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ ˃˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘ ʦ ,elg 9lhzv dgoswhg e wkh &opplwwhh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh 2swloqdo 3uowofoo foqfhuqlqj foppxqlfdwloq qo 2fwoehu sdud &53’ &opplwwhh 9lhzv dgoswhg e wkh &opplwwhh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh 2swloqdo 3uowofoo foqfhuqlqj foppxqlfdwloq 1o 81 ‘of &53’&’ ,elg sdud ,elg sdud 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ௵3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj fkloguhq zlwk glvdelolwlhv kdyh wkh uljkw wo dssuosuldwh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv௶ $ffouglqj wo 3ulqflsoh ௵7o dyolg glvfulplqdwloq dqg jxdudqwhh wkh hiihfwlyh dqg htxdo sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq doo ohjdo suofhhglqjv 6wdwhv vkdoo suoylgh jhqghu dqg djhdssuosuldwh lqglylgxdol]hg suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ 0ouhoyhu wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv foduli wkdw wkhvh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv ௵hqfopsdvv doo wkh qhfhvvdu dqg dssuosuldwh poglilfdwloqv dqg dgmxvwphqwv qhhghg lq d sduwlfxodu fdvh lqfoxglqj lqwhuphgldulhv ou idflolwdwouv suofhgxudo dgmxvwphqwv dqg poglilfdwloqv dgmxvwphqwv wo wkh hqyluoqphqw dqg foppxqlfdwloq vxssouw wo hqvxuh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv >@௶ )lqdoo 3ulqflsoh vwdwhv wkdw ௵7o wkh ixoohvw h[whqw sovvleoh dffoppogdwloqv vkoxog eh oujdql]hg ehiouh wkh fopphqfhphqw oi suofhhglqjv௶ 5hjduglqj soolfh oiilfhuv suovhfxwouv dqg owkhuv lqyooyhg lq duuhvwv dqg lqyhvwljdwloqv oi fulplqdo oiihqfhv 3ulqflsoh k uhtxluhv 6wdwhv wo hqvxuh wkdw wkhvh suoihvvloqdov duh ௵nqozohgjhdeoh deoxw wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh dohuw wo wkh sovvlelolw wkdw d shuvoq pd kdyh d glvdelolw dqg wkuoxjkoxw wkh foxuvh oi dq duuhvw ou lqyhvwljdwloq dgmxvw wkhlu uhvsoqvhv dffouglqjo௶ 6wdwhv vkdoo dovo hqvxuh wkdw ௵>@ lqghshqghqw wklug shuvoqv vxfk dv dwwouqhv ou owkhuv duh dydlodeoh wo dffopsdq shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo wkh soolfh vwdwloq wo dvvlvw wkhp lq wkh lqyhvwljdwlyh suofhvv lqfoxglqj iou h[dpsoh ilqjhusulqwlqj ou jlylqj d elooojlfdo vdpsoh >@௶ )lqdoo 6wdwhv vkdoo hqvxuh wkdw ௵>@ doo sduwlflsdqwv lq ohjdo suofhhglqjv pxvw eh dgylvhg oi wkh dydlodelolw oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv li qhhghg dqg ghvluhg ehfdxvh oi glvdelolw௶ 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 3ulqflsoh s ,elg 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 3ulqflsoh k s ,elg *xlgholqh l ,elg *xlgholqh o 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ,w lv dovo lpsouwdqw wo qowh wkdw li suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iou d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw duh qow pdgh gxulqj soolfh lqwhuuojdwloqv vxfk lqwhuuojdwloqv pljkw eh ghfoduhg xqodzixo dqg wkh uhvxowv lqdgplvvleoh e wkh foxuwv zklfk pljkw lpshgh wkh mxvwlfh suofhvv ,w lv dovo lpsouwdqw wo hqvxuh doo suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv duh jhqghuvhqvlwlyh dqg dssuosuldwh ˅˘ˤ˨˘˦˧ ˙ˢ˥ ˔ˡ˗ ˢ˙˙˘˥˦ ˢ˙ ˔˖˖ˢˠˠˢ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ $ffouglqj wo wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv 6wdwhv vkoxog hqdfw ohjlvodwloq dqg suogxfh uhjxodwloqv soolflhv dqg jxlgholqhv vo dv wo hqdeoh ௵shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo uhtxhvw suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxglqj poglilfdwloqv oi ou vxssouw lq ohjdo suofhvvhv zlwk dssuosuldwh suowhfwloq oi wkhlu sulydf௶ 7kuoxjkoxw wkh foxuvh oi ohjdo suofhhglqjv sduwlflsdqwv pxvw eh ௵dgylvhg oi wkh dydlodelolw oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv li qhhghg dqg ghvluhg ehfdxvh oi glvdelolw௶ $v vwdwhg e wkh &53′ &opplwwhh lq lwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o ௵>wkh gxw wo suoylgh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq lv dq lqglylgxdol]hg uhdfwlyh gxw wkdw lv dssolfdeoh iuop wkh pophqw d uhtxhvw iou dffoppogdwloq lv uhfhlyhg 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq uhtxluhv wkh gxw ehduhu wo hqwhu lqwo gldoojxh zlwk wkh lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw௶ ,q dgglwloq wo wkh uhdfwlyh oeoljdwloq wkh gxw wo suoylgh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxghv d suodfwlyh oeoljdwloq oq mxvwlfh dfwouv wo dqwlflsdwh qhhgv dqg suoylgh dffoppogdwloqv hyhq lq wkh devhqfh oi d uhtxhvw $v wkh &53’ &opplwwhh kdv h[sodlqhg )ou pouh ghwdlov oq jhqghudssuosuldwh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv sohdvh vhh 9dolglw )oxqgdwloq )dlu 7uldo ‘hqlhg ‘hihqgdqwv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv )dfh ,qdffhvvleoh -xvwlfh lq wkh (8 s vv ,elg *xlgholqh n ,elg *xlgholqh o &53’&opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o sdud e dfhvvleoh khuh kwwsv zzzokfkuoujhqgofxphqwvjhqhudofopphqwvdqguhfopphqgdwloqvjhqhudofopphqwqohtxdolwdqgqoqglvfulplqdwloq 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ௵lw lv lpsouwdqw wo qowh wkdw wkh gxw wo suoylgh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq lv qow olplwhg wo vlwxdwloqv lq zklfk wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw kdv dvnhg iou dq dffoppogdwloq ou lq zklfk lw foxog eh suoyhg wkdw wkh doohjhg gxw ehduhu zdv dfwxdoo dzduh wkdw wkh shuvoq lq txhvwloq kdg d glvdelolw ,w vkoxog dovo dsso lq vlwxdwloqv zkhuh d sowhqwldo gxw ehduhu vkoxog kdyh uhdol]hg wkdw wkh shuvoq lq txhvwloq kdg d glvdelolw wkdw pljkw uhtxluh dffoppogdwloqv wo dgguhvv eduulhuv wo h[huflvlqj uljkwv௶ 7kh 81 ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv suoylgh wkdw 6wdwhv vkoxog jxdudqwhh wkh dydlodelolw oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wo jlyh shosoh zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkh sovvlelolw wo fkoovh koz wo ghihqg wkhpvhoyhv 7kh &53’ &opplwwhh kdv h[sodlqhg wkh pdlq gliihuhqfh ehwzhhq ௵suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv௶ dqg ௵uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv௶ :kloh ௵uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv௶ duh olplwhg e wkh foqfhsw oi glvsuosouwloqdolw suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv go qow suhvhqw wklv olplw 7kh 81 ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dovo xqghuolqh wkdw 6wdwhv vkoxog jxdudqwhh khdowkfduh dqg svfkooojlfdo vxssouw oq uhtxhvw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg oq wkh edvlv oi wkhlu iuhh dqg lqiouphg foqvhqw 6wdwhv pxvw wkhuhiouh suoylgh iou wkh sovvlelolw iou doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo kdyh dffhvv wo vxfk suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wkh pd qhhg wo sduwlflsdwh ixoo lq mxvwlfh suofhvvhv 7klv gxw wo ghwhuplqh zklfk dffoppogdwloqv duh qhhghg dqg pdnh wkhp dydlodeoh h[lvwv hyhq zkhuh wkh shuvoq lq txhvwloq gohv qow uhtxhvw vxfk dffoppogdwloqv 7kh &opplwwhh ghvfulehv ohdylqj wkh uhvsoqvlelolw oi uhtxhvwlqj dffoppogdwloqv oq shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dooqh dv sodflqj d ௵glvsuosouwloqdwh ou xqgxh exughq௶ oq vxfk douhdg pdujlqdol]hg lqglylgxdov ,elg sdud e 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv *xlgholqh i s &53′ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o sdud g ,elg *xlgholqh j &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o sdud e 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( $ shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw pd hohfw wo ghfolqh wkh suoylvloq oi voph dffoppogdwloqv vxjjhvwhg ou suoylghg e wkh 6wdwh 6wdwhv qhyhuwkhohvv duh uhtxluhg wo oiihu dqg pdnh dydlodeoh dffoppogdwloqv ௬ ghwhuplqhg lq foqvxowdwloq zlwk wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw wkhpvhoyhv 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh qow oiwhq eholhyhg ou wdnhq vhuloxvo zkhq wkh glvfoovh wkhlu glvdelolwlhv dqg qhhgv -xvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog dvvxph lq joog idlwk wkdw dq lqglylgxdo௲v glvfoovxuh oi d glvdelolw dqg wkhlu uhtxhvwv iou dffoppogdwloqv duh dffxudwh dqg qhfhvvdu xqohvv lw lv hvwdeolvkhg lq fohdu whupv dqg oq dq oemhfwlyh edvlv wkdw wkh duh qow ʺˢˢ˗ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ ,q 6sdlq suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv fdq eh uhtxhvwhg e dq oi wkh sduwlhv wkh sxeolf suovhfxwou wkh mxgjh ou wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw wkhpvhoyhvʹͺ 7kh soolfh fdq dovo uhtxhvw wkhp vlqfh wkh iluvw lqwhudfwloqv zlwk d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolwʹͻ 3udfwlfdo jxlgdqfh dqg uhfopphqgdwloqv $ ghihqgdqwv uljkw wo d idlu wuldo dqg gxh suofhvv lq wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv pxvw eh uhvshfwhg iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk odz hqioufhphqw oiilfhuv dqg wkuoxjkoxw doo suofhvvhv lqfoxglqj wkuoxjk dffhvv wo suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv $ 5hvsoqvleoh mxvwlfh dfwouv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv duh dydlodeoh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo doooz iou wkhlu sduwlflsdwloq lq hdfk suofhgxuh iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk odz hqioufhphqw dxwkoulwlhv dqg wkuoxjk doo suofhvvhv % $oo suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv vkoxog eh jhqghu dqg djhdssuosuldwh 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq 0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,elg s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( & 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog sduwlflsdwh lq wkh suofhvv oi wkh lghqwlilfdwloq dqg ghwhuplqdwloq oi wkhlu glvdelolwlhv :khuh wkhuh lv dq lqglfld wkdw dq lqglylgxdo pd kdyh d glvdelolw wkhuh lv dq oeoljdwloq oq wkh dxwkoulwlhv wo pdnh d ixoo ghwhuplqdwloq wdnlqj lqwo dffoxqw wkh lqglylgxdo௲v ylhzv ‘ $ghtxdwh vxssouw vhuylfhv vkoxog eh pdgh dydlodeoh zlwklq wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhp wo hqvxuh wkh suoylvloq oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv l :khuh lghqwlilfdwloq oi qhhgv iou suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv qhhgv wo eh lq sodfh lw pxvw eh goqh dw wkh ehjlqqlqj oi wkh suofhhglqjv dw wkh hduolhvw vwdjh ll 3uhsdudwloqv iou suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv dqg owkhu dgmxvwphqwv lq wkh khdulqj pxvw eh pdgh sulou wo wkh soolfh ou owkhu oiilfldo lqwhuylhz ou sulou wo wkh khdulqjwuldo $oo sduwlflsdqwv lqfoxglqj ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog eh lqiouphg deoxw wkhlu uljkwv dqg wkh dydlodelolw oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wkuoxjkoxw wkh foxuvh oi wkh suofhhglqjv $ $xwkoulwlhv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw ghihqgdqwv duh pdgh dzduh oi wkh sovvlelolw oi kdylqj suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wkuoxjkoxw wkh suofhhglqjv dqg nqoz wkdw wkh fdq uhtxhvw wkhp dw dq wlph % ,w vkoxog qow eh wkh vooh uhvsoqvlelolw oi wkh ghihqgdqw wo uhtxhvw wkh dffoppogdwloqv 5hvsoqvleoh mxvwlfh dfwouv kdyh d suodfwlyh gxw wo lqlwldwh wkh suoylvloq oi dffoppogdwloqv -xvwlfh dfwouv dqg qdwloqdo dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog foqvxow foovho zlwk dqg dfwlyho lqyooyh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg wkhlu uhsuhvhqwdwlyh oujdql]dwloqv lq doo glvfxvvloqv dqg ghflvloqpdnlqj uhjduglqj suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv 5hvsoqvleoh dfwouv vkoxog fooshudwh wo hvwdeolvk d xqlioup dqg hiihfwlyh iudphzoun iou suoylglqj dssuosuldwh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iou 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv (iihfwlyh foouglqdwloq lv qhfhvvdu dw fhqwudo dqg oofdo ohyhov 6vwhplf uhfopphqgdwloqv -xglfldulhv vkoxog ghyhoos dqg dgosw uhjxodwloqv dqg vwdqgdugv wkdw uhfojql]h dqg hqioufh wkh uljkw wo uhfhlyh suofhgxudo djh dqg jhqghudssuosuldwh dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxglqj vxssouw qhfhvvdu wo hqdeoh ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo h[huflvh wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw dqg sduwlflsdwh hiihfwlyho lq dq dssolfdeoh mxglfldo ou dgplqlvwudwlyh suofhhglqjv $ fopsuhkhqvlyh suofhgxuh iou uhfojql]lqj uhtxhvwlqj dvvhvvlqj dqg suoylglqj lqglylgxdo vxssouw iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog eh ghyhooshg dqg lpsohphqwhg &ohdu dqg hiihfwlyh suofhgxuhv uhodwlqj wo wkh suoylvloq oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv pxvw eh ghyhooshg dqg lpsohphqwhg e mxvwlfh dfwouv zkhqhyhu d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw dqg lq sduwlfxodu d shuvoq zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lqwhudfwv zlwk wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhp $ $ jxlgh ou pdqxdo oq suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iou wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh vkoxog eh suogxfhg dqg zlgho glvvhplqdwhg wo idflolwdwh wkh fouuhfw dssuodfk e mxvwlfh dfwouv foqfhuqlqj shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7khvh lqfoxgh dgdswdwloq oi wkh yhqxh dssuosuldwh zdlwlqj vsdfhv uhpoydo oi foodnv dqg zljv dgmxvwphqwv wo wkh sdfh oi suofhhglqjv vhsdudwh exloglqj hqwudqfhv dqg zdlwlqj uoopv dqg suowhfwlyh vfuhhqv wo vhsdudwh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv iuop owkhuv li qhfhvvdu gxh wo skvlfdo ou hpowloqdo glvwuhvv poglilfdwloqv wo wkh phwkog oi txhvwloqlqj lq dssuosuldwh flufxpvwdqfhv vxfk dv dooozlqj ohdglqj txhvwloqv dyolglqj fopsoxqg txhvwloqv ilqglqj dowhuqdwlyhv wo fopsoh[ ksowkhwlfdo txhvwloqv suoylglqj h[wud wlph wo dqvzhu shuplwwlqj euhdnv dv qhhghg dqg xvlqj sodlq odqjxdjh dqg xvh oi suhwuldo ylgho uhfouglqj oi hylghqfh dqg whvwlpoq li qhfhvvdu sudfwlfdo dqg sovvleoh lq vxfk d pdqqhu dv qow wo foqwudyhqh edvlf uljkwv vxfk dv wkh uljkw wo foqiuoqw dqg fuovv h[dplqh zlwqhvvhv 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ˃˥ˢ˖˘˦˦ ˙ˢ˥ ˜ˡ˗˜˩˜˗˨˔˟ ˔˦˦˘˦˦ˠ˘ˡ˧ ˙ˢ˥ ˔˗˔ˣ˧˔˧˜ˢˡ ˢ˙ ˣ˥ˢ˖˘˗˨˥˔˟ ˔˖˖ˢˠˠˢ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ ,qwhuqdwloqdo +xpdq 5ljkwv /dz dqg (8 /dz dqg 6wdqgdugv ,q dgglwloq wo vhhnlqj lqsxw iuop wkh shuvoq deoxw wkhlu dffoppogdwloq qhhgv dq lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw lv d qhfhvvdu suofhvv wo hqvxuh wkh ixoo dqg suoshu sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv 6xfk lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqwv vkoxog eh xvhg wo ௵lghqwli wkh sduwlfxodu eduulhuv wkdw d shuvoq zlwk glvdelolw h[shulhqfhv dqg wkhlu vshflilf vxssouw qhhgv ,w ghwhuplqhv koz wo uhpoyh ou oyhufoph wkh eduulhuv zkdw vxssouw dqg suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv duh qhfhvvdu dqg koz wo suoylgh wkhvh ,ghdoo lw vkoxog wdnh sodfh iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk wkh uhohydqw dxwkoulwlhv lq wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh௶ʹͳ ,q (8 odz wkh 5hfopphqgdwloq oq yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv vwuhvv wkh lpsouwdqfh oi uhfojql]lqj dqg lghqwlilqj vlwxdwloqv oi yxoqhudelolwʹʹ 7kh 5hfopphqgdwloqv suhvfuleh wkdw ௵dq lqlwldo dvvhvvphqw vkoxog eh fduulhg oxw e soolfh oiilfhuv odz hqioufhphqw ou mxglfldo dxwkoulwlhv 7kh fopshwhqw dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog dovo eh deoh wo dvn dq lqghshqghqw h[shuw wo h[dplqh wkh ghjuhh oi yxoqhudelolw wkh qhhgv oi wkh yxoqhudeoh shuvoq dqg wkh dssuosuldwhqhvv oi dq phdvxuhv wdnhq ou hqylvdjhg djdlqvw wkh yxoqhudeoh shuvoqʹ͵ 7kh shuvoqv foqfhuqhg vxvshfwv ou dffxvhg vkoxog kdyh wkh uljkw wo fkdoohqjh vxfk dvvhvvphqwʹͷ ʼˡ˗˜˩˜˗˨˔˟ ˔˦˦˘˦˦ˠ˘ˡ˧ ˙ˢ˥ ˖˛˜˟˗˥˘ˡ ˪˜˧˛ ˗˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ 9dolglw )oxqgdwloq 9olfhv iou mxvwlfh 7ooofkhvw iou suoihvvloqdov s vhh kwwsv ydolglwqjozsfoqwhqwxsoodgv9olfhviou-xvwlfh722/&+(67iousuoihvvloqdovb(1sgi 5hflwdo &opplvvloq 5hfopphqgdwloq & oq suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv iou yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv ,elg ,elg 5hflwdo 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 6lplodu lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqwv duh suoylghg iou lq (8 odz )ou h[dpsoh vxfk dvvhvvphqwv duh uhtxluhg e duwlfoh oi ‘luhfwlyh (8 oq suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv iou fkloguhq zko duh vxvshfwv ou dffxvhg shuvoqv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv 7kh ‘luhfwlyh dfnqozohgjhv wkh ௵uljkw wo lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw௶ dv oqh oi wkh hohphqwv oi wkh uljkwv oi fkloguhq lq foqiolfw zlwk wkh odz 8qghu duwlfoh oi wkh ‘luhfwlyh vxfk dq lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw vhuyhv wkh sxusovh oi ghwhuplqlqj zkhwkhu dq vshflilf phdvxuhv wo wkh ehqhilw oi wkh fklog duh wo eh wdnhq dvvhvvlqj wkh dssuosuldwhqhvv dqg hiihfwlyhqhvv oi dq suholplqdu phdvxuhv dqg dvvlvwlqj lq wdnlqj dq ghflvloqv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv lqfoxglqj vhqwhqflqj 7kh dvvhvvphqw fdq wkxv eh xvhg wo ghwhuplqh li dqg wo zkdw h[whqw d fklog qhhgv suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv gxulqj wkh fulplqdo suofhhglqjv wkh h[whqw oi wkhlu fulplqdo uhvsoqvlelolw dqg wkh dssuosuldwhqhvv oi d sduwlfxodu shqdow ou hgxfdwlyh phdvxuh $ vlplodu wsh oi dvvhvvphqw wdloouhg wo wkh vshflilf foqwh[w qhhgv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lv d fuxfldo suhuhtxlvlwh iou wkh hiihfwlyh dgdswdwloq oi suofhhglqjv iou wkh shuvoq foqfhuqhg dqg vkoxog eh lpsohphqwhg iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 5hvsoqvlelolw iou vxfk lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqwv wslfdoo olhv zlwk wkovh fulplqdo mxvwlfh dfwouv dqg dxwkoulwlhv zkovh uhvsoqvlelolw lv hqjdjhg dw gliihuhqw skdvhv oi fulplqdo suofhhglqjv iuop soolfh wo suovhfxwlqj dxwkoulwlhv dqg ohjdo wo wkh mxglfldo oiilfhuv +ozhyhu lq sudfwlfh wkh lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw suofhvv fdq eh lqlwldwhg lpsohphqwhg dqg foouglqdwhg wkuoxjk vxssouw vhuylfhv vofldo zounhuv odz hqioufhphqw foxuw oiilfldov foxuwdssolqwhg h[shuwv dqg owkhu uhvsoqvleoh suoihvvloqdov $ sduwlfxodu wsh oi txdolilhg lqvwlwxwloq ou suoihvvloqdo fdq eh pdqgdwhg e odz ou foxuw oughu wo vvwhpdwlfdoo foqgxfw dqg xsgdwh wkh lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjvʹ 2yhudoo mxvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog wdnh uhvsoqvlelolw iou hqvxulqj wkdw vxfk dvvhvvphqwv kdyh offxuuhg dqg vxfk dvvhvvphqwv kdyh ohg wo phdvxuhv qhfhvvdu ,&- 5hfopphqgdwloqv oq wkh pdlq sulqflsohv joyhuqlqj wkh lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw oi fkloguhq lq foqiolfw zlwk wkh odz vhh kwwsv lfmzshqjlqhsozhuhgfopzsfoqwhqwxsoodgv(1*/5hfopphqgdwloqv,qglylgxdodvvhvvphqwsgi 9dolglw )oxqgdwloq 7ooofkhvw 9olfhv iou -xvwlfh &oppxqlfdwlqj zlwk ylfwlpv oi fulph zlwk glvdelolwlhv 9olfhv iou mxvwlfh suomhfw s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( iou wkh hqmophqw oi wkh uljkw wo d idlu khdulqj ou wuldo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq dffougdqfh zlwk wkh ,+5/ lqfoxglqj wkh &53’ wkh ,&&35 dqg wkh (&+5 $ffouglqj wo d 9dolglw wooofkhvwʹ oq shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dq lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw vkoxog %h foqgxfwhg lq d vvwhpdwlf zd iuop iluvw foqwdfw zlwk wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp 7kh lqioupdwloq fdq eh vkduhg lq d zd wkdw gohv qow fopsuoplvh wkh foqilghqwldolw oi wkh lqglylgxdo dqg hqvxuhv wkdw wkhlu qhhgv duh xqghuvwoog dqg phw 5hvshfw wkh ohjdo fdsdflw oi wkh shuvoq dqg wkhlu zloo dqg suhihuhqfh ,qyooyh d pxowlglvflsolqdu dssuodfk dqg whdp wo lqfoxgh wkh fouuhfw shosoh dqg h[shuwlvh lq wkh suofhvv )ou shosoh zlwk glvdelolwlhv wklv pd lqfoxgh dv h[dpsohv d vxssouw shuvoq d vofldo zounhu d foppxqlfdwloqv h[shuw d odzhu 6hw oxw fohduo wkh eduulhuv wkdw wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw idfhv dqg zkdw vxssouw dqg suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv duh qhfhvvdu wo oyhufoph wkhvh eduulhuv lqfoxglqj zkhuh uhvsoqvlelolw olhv iou suoylvloq dqg koz wkhvh zloo eh suoylghg lq sudfwlfh 7dnh sodfh foqwlqxoxvo vo wkdw qhhgv dqg eduulhuv fdq eh lghqwlilhg dqg dgguhvvhg dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhvv dqg ,ghqwli d sduwlfxodu foqwdfw shuvoq wo zkop wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw fdq dozdv jo zlwk uhtxhvwv iou dgglwloqdo ou gliihuhqw ioupv oi vxssouw dqg suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv 6oph gliilfxowlhv pljkw dulvh lq uhodwloq wo vkdulqj wkh lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw dpoqj wkh suoihvvloqdov hvshfldoo wkuoxjk gljlwdo wooov 7kh suofhvv e zklfk lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqwv duh foqgxfwhg dqg lqioupdwloq deoxw wkhp vwouhg dqg glvwulexwhg pxvw fohduo vhw oxw jxlgholqhv dqg vwdqgdugv wo hqvxuh uhvshfw iou wkh uljkw wo sulydf oi dq lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw ,q wklv foqwh[w wkh (8 ‘luhfwlyh ʹͺ jlyhv lpsouwdqw ,elg ,&- 5hfopphqgdwloqv oq wkh pdlq sulqflsohv joyhuqlqj wkh lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw oi fkloguhq lq foqiolfw zlwk wkh odz vhh kwwsv lfmzshqjlqhsozhuhgfopzsfoqwhqwxsoodgv(1*/5hfopphqgdwloqv,qglylgxdodvvhvvphqwsgi 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( lqglfdwloqv oq koz wkh gdwd pxvw eh vwouhg dqg glvwulexwhg ,q sduwlfxodu duwlfoh i oi wkh ‘luhfwlyh uhtxluhv gdwd wo eh ௵suofhvvhg lq d pdqqhu wkdw hqvxuhv dssuosuldwh vhfxulw oi wkh shuvoqdo gdwd lqfoxglqj suowhfwloq djdlqvw xqdxwkoul]hg ou xqodzixo suofhvvlqj dqg djdlqvw dfflghqwdo oovv ghvwuxfwloq ou gdpdjh xvlqj dssuosuldwh whfkqlfdo ou oujdql]dwloqdo phdvxuhv௶ʹͻ &kdoohqjhv 7kh txdolw oi lqioupdwloq dydlodeoh wo wkh fopshwhqw dxwkoulwlhv lqfoxglqj mxvwlfh dfwouv qhfhvvdulo ghwhuplqhv wkh hiihfwlyhqhvv oi dffoppogdwloqv wkh pd eh deoh wo ghylvh dqg suoylgh wdnlqj lqwo dffoxqw wkh zloo suhihuhqfhv dqg qhhgv h[suhvvhg e d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw 7klv lqioupdwloq vkoxog eh jdwkhuhg dv vooq dv sovvleoh ehiouh txhvwloqlqj lv oujdql]hg wkuoxjk d suholplqdu dvvhvvphqw zlwk wklv jodo lq plqg ,q sudfwlfh lqioupdwloq deoxw glvdelolw pd eh gliilfxow wo oewdlq iou d ydulhw oi uhdvoqv $ ghihqgdqw pd eh xqfopiouwdeoh ou diudlg wo glvfoovh wkhlu glvdelolw gxh wo vwljpd ou plvwuxvw oi fulplqdo mxvwlfh dxwkoulwlhv edvhg oq wkhlu shufhswloqv dqgou h[shulhqfhv 7klv pd eh ihow hyhq pouh vwuoqjo iou h[dpsoh e ihpdoh ghihqgdqwv gxh wo vofldo vwljpd dvvofldwhg zlwk pxowlsoh ioupv oi glvfulplqdwloq oq wkh edvlv oi eowk jhqghu dqg glvdelolw lqglylgxdoo dqg vlpxowdqhoxvo $ ghihqgdqw pd dovo eh xqdzduh oi wkhlu ozq glvdelolw ou wkh lpsdfw lw pd kdyh oq wkhlu delolw wo sduwlflsdwh hiihfwlyho lq mxvwlfh suofhvvhv dqg suofhgxuhv 0ouhoyhu wkh dffhohudwhg qdwxuh oi voph fulplqdo mxvwlfh suofhhglqjv pd pdnh foqgxfwlqj dq dvvhvvphqw e d fopshwhqw suoihvvloqdo sulou wo wkh iluvw txhvwloqlqj sudfwlfdoo gliilfxow dqg vhhplqjo fxpehuvoph iou foxuw suofhvvhv dqg dw oofdol]hg ohyhov (8 3duoldphqw dqg &oxqflo ‘luhfwlyh (8 oq wkh suowhfwloq oi qdwxudo shuvoqv zlwk uhjdug wo wkh suofhvvlqj oi shuvoqdo gdwd e fopshwhqw dxwkoulwlhv iou wkh sxusovhv oi wkh suhyhqwloq lqyhvwljdwloq ghwhfwloq ou suovhfxwloq oi fulplqdo oiihqfhv ou wkh h[hfxwloq oi fulplqdo shqdowlhv dqg oq wkh iuhh poyhphqw oi vxfk gdwd dqg uhshdolqj &oxqflo )udphzoun ‘hflvloq -+$ 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ,q sudfwlfh glvdelolwuljkwv oujdql]dwloqv kdyh uhsouwhg wkdw wkhuh lv vophwlphv qo vhw phwkogoooj iou lghqwlilqj glvdelolw lq fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv ,q %xojduld iou h[dpsoh mxvwlfh dfwouv zko duh qow suoylghg zlwk phglfdo gofxphqwdwloq dqg zko go qow uhfhlyh dq vvwhpdwlf ou pdqgdwou wudlqlqj lq wklv uhvshfw pxvw uho oq wkhlu shuvoqdo vhqvlwlylw dqg nqozohgjh wo ghwhuplqh zkhwkhu dq lqglylgxdo kdv d glvdelolw dqg zkhwkhu wklv kdv dq ehdulqj oq wkhlu delolw wo sduwlflsdwh lq mxvwlfh suofhvvhv dqg suofhgxuhv ,i mxvwlfh dfwouv eholhyh wkhuh lv vophwklqj zuoqj zlwk wkh zd d shuvoq foppxqlfdwhv ou ehkdyhv dqg wkh vxvshfw wkdw wkhuh lv vxiilflhqw hylghqfh iou wkh fopplvvloq oi d fulph wkdw kdv ehhq doohjhg wkh zloo wslfdoo iloh d uhtxhvw iou iouhqvlf h[shuwlvh lq uhodwloq wo dq lqglylgxdo௲v glvdelolw $ svfkldwulvw dqg d svfkooojlvw wkhq foqgxfw dq h[dplqdwloq zklfk lv ghvljqhg wo ghwhuplqh wkh shuvoqv vdqlwfopshwhqf wo vwdqg wuldo 6oph lqwhuylhzhhv uhsouwhg h[shulhqflqj vxfk hydoxdwloqv dv ehlqj eldvhg wozdugv fhuwdlq oxwfophv gldjqovlvfhqwhuhg dqg suhmxglfhg djdlqvw wkhp dv shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7kh dovo uhsouwhg wkdw wkh foqfoxvloqv oi vxfk ௵h[shuw hydoxdwloqv௶ duh iuhtxhqwo dffhswhg e mxvwlfh dfwouv zlwkoxw ixuwkhu foqvlghudwloq dqg wkhq goplqdwh wkh hqwluh mxvwlfh suofhvv 2qh suoplvlqj sudfwlfh kdv ehhq lghqwlilhg lq %xojduld qdpho wkh foqgxfw oi dq dvvhvvphqw e d txdolilhg 1*2 oi wkh vofldo ixqfwloqlqj oi dq lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw 6xfk dq dvvhvvphqw pd khos wo suoylgh lqioupdwloq wo d foxuw oq wkh shuvoqv vofldo ixqfwloqlqj dqg foppxqlfdwloq qhhgv zklfk fdq dvvlvw lq hqdeolqj wkh suoylvloq oi vxssouw iou dq lqglylgxdo௲v hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq lq d wuldo +ozhyhu wkh sudfwlfh lv uhodwlyho qhz dqg kdv oqo foyhuhg d vpdoo qxpehu oi fdvhv wkxv idu ,q .hud )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s $q 1*2 *ooedo ,qlwldwlyh lq 3vfkldwu ௬ %xojduld fuhdwhg wklv lqvwuxphqw dqg lv fxuuhqwo sloowlqj lw 7kh oiihu d whdp oi vofldo zounhuv dqg svfkooojlvwv dqg wkhvh duh xvxdoo wkh pdlq h[shuwv pdnlqj wkh dvvhvvphqw 7kh dvvhvvphqw zdv sloowhg wo lpsuoyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkuhh sduwlfxodu wshv oi foxuw fdvhv sodfhphqwv lq juoxs kophv sodfhphqwv xqghu jxdugldqvkls dqg ioufhg kovslwdol]dwloqv &xuuhqwo wkh duh wulqj wo suopowh wklv pogho iou doo wshv oi fdvhv foqfhuqlqj shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv .hud s $ ylgho h[sodlqlqj wkh dlp oi wkh dvvhvvphqw dqg koz lw fdq eh xvhg dydlodeoh dw kwwsv zzzoxwxehfopzdwfk”y mw483f x8m 6o idu wklv lqvwuxphqw lv xvhg povwo lq flylo odz fdvhv 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( dgglwloq lw uholhv oq wkh foqwlqxhg oshudwloq dqg uhvoxuflqj oi 1*2v lqvwhdg oi vxfk uhvoxufhv foplqj iuop zlwklq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp lwvhoi ,q 6sdlq lqwhuylhzhhv uhsouwhg wkdw lq pdq fdvhv wkh lqglylgxdo௲v glvdelolwlhv duh oqo glvfoyhuhg diwhu d wuldo 7khuhiouh hyhq zkhuh wkhuh pd kdyh ehhq d qhhg iou dq lqwhuphgldu wo dvvlvw lq voph suofhhglqjv wkh duh qow xvhg ghvslwh wkh idfw wkdw 6sdqlvk odz dooozv iou wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi vxfk dq lqwhuphgldu ,q /lwkxdqld lqwhuylhzhhv uhsouwhg wkdw wkhuh lv d odfn oi h[shulhqfh zlwklq wkh mxglfldu dv d zkooh dv zhoo dv oq wkh sduw oi mxvwlfh dfwouv vxfk dv odzhuv dqg suovhfxwouv lq dvvhvvlqj wkh ௵yxoqhudelolw௶ oi ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,q 6ooyhqld lqwhuylhzhhv ghvfulehg wkh vvwhplf idloxuh oi dxwkoulwlhv wo lghqwli glvdelolw iuop wkh yhu iluvw foqwdfw zlwk wkh dxwkoulwlhv 7khuh lv qo xqlilhg vvwhp lq sodfh zklfk zoxog hqdeoh dxwkoulwlhv wo fduhixoo dqg dffxudwho hydoxdwh lqglylgxdov wo ghwhuplqh zkhwkhu wkh duh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkh qdwxuh oi zklfk zoxog uhtxluh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wo eh suoylghg 3udfwlfdo jxlgdqfh dqg uhfopphqgdwloqv $ sudfwlfdo phfkdqlvp wo lghqwli glvdelolw hduo lq ohjdo suofhvvhv wkuoxjk dq lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw vkoxog eh ghyhooshg dqg lpsohphqwhg vo wkdw doo qhfhvvdu phdvxuhv duh wdnhq wo hqvxuh wkdw wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw zloo jo wkuoxjk wkh hqwluh fulplqdo mxvwlfh suofhvv oq dq htxdo edvlv $ lghqwlilfdwloq iou h[dpsoh wkuoxjk dq lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw vkoxog offxu hduo lq wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh suofhvv dw wkh yhu ehjlqqlqj oi wkh suofhhglqjv dqg sulou wo dq dfwloqv xqghuwdnhq dv sduw oi wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh suofhhglqjv iou lqvwdqfh sulou wo d soolfh lqwhuylhz % 7kh soolfh owkhu odz hqioufhphqw dxwkoulwlhv dqg dq owkhu mxvwlfh dfwou ou lqglylgxdo lqyooyhg lq wkh lghqwlilfdwloq oi glvdelolw pxvw diwhu 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyh %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq /lwkxdqld9loqlxv (1$%/( 3uomhfw $sulo s 3,& %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6ooyhqld/mxeomdqd (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( lghqwlilqj wkh lqglylgxdo kdv d glvdelolw hqvxuh wkh suoylvloq oi dvvlvwdqfh dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouw iuop wkh hduo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv & -xvwlfh dfwouv dqg owkhu lqglylgxdov lqyooyhg lq wkh lghqwlilfdwloq oi glvdelolwlhv gxulqj fulplqdo mxvwlfh suofhvvhv vkoxog eh dghtxdwho wudlqhg oq wkh qdwxuh dqg ghilqlwloq oi glvdelolw dqg wkh sxusovh oi wkh lghqwlilfdwloq oi dq lqglylgxdo௲v glvdelolw wkh ohjdo uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg wkh gxw wo suoylgh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˣ˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ ,q voph foxqwulhv vxfk dv wkh 8. dqg 6sdlq wklv dvvhvvphqw fdq eh goqh e lqwhuphgldulhv ,q 6sdlq lqwhuphgldulhvfdq eh suoylghg iuhho e 1*2v olnh 3ohqd ,qfoxvloq :khq sulvoq oiilfhuv vxvshfw wkdw d shuvoq kdv dq lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw wkh foqwdfw 3ohqd ,qfoxvloq wkdw foqgxfwv dq dvvhvvphqw dqg suoylghv dvvlvwdqfh lq oewdlqlqj oiilfldo uhfojqlwloq ‘ 7kh sulpdu sxusovh oi wkh lghqwlilfdwloq oi d glvdelolw vkoxog eh wo oewdlq wkh lqioupdwloq uhtxluhg iou wkh fopshwhqw dxwkoulw wo ghwhuplqh dqg ghflgh lq foqvxowdwloq zlwk wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw wkh suoylvloq oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv 7klv suofhvv vkoxog qhyhu eh xvhg dv d phdqv oi glplqlvklqj sduwlflsdwloq oi dq lqglylgxdo ou h[foxglqj sduwlflsdwloq hqwluho -xgjhv dqg owkhu mxvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog dw odwhu vwdjhv lq wkh ohjdo suofhvv yhuli wkdw wkh lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqwv kdyh ehhq fopsohwhg hduo lq wkh suofhvv sulou wo wkh pdwwhu dsshdulqj ehiouh wkhp ‘hihqgdqwv vo dvvhvvhg vkoxog eh lqiouphg deoxw wkh ghwdlov oi wkh lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw eh lqyooyhg lq lwv ghyhoosphqw dqg vkoxog uhfhlyh lw zkhq ilqdol]hg 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,elg s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 7kh vkoxog kdyh wkh uljkw wo fopphqw oq vxfk dq dvvhvvphqw dqg li qhfhvvdu foqwhvw lw 6vwhplf uhfopphqgdwloqv 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog lghqwli dqg glvvhplqdwh ehvw sudfwlfhv uhjduglqj wkh lghqwlilfdwloq oi glvdelolw dqg ghyhoos dqg lpsohphqw wudlqlqjv iofxvlqj oq wkh kxpdq uljkwv pogho oi glvdelolw dqg wkh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv zklfk vkoxog eh pdgh vo wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv fdq sduwlflsdwh oq dq htxdo edvlv lq doo ohjdo suofhvvhvʹͺͺ ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˣ˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ ,q %xojduld wkh foxuwv xvh dq ௵1*2 dvvhvvphqw oi wkh vofldo ixqfwloqlqj oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg wkhlu vshfldo qhhgv௶ 7klv dvvhvvphqw lv ghvljqhg wo eh xvhg lq doo foxuwv dgguhvvlqj fdvhv zlwk shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,w dlpv wo lqfuhdvh hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq lq wkh wuldo dqg wo lpsuoyh wkh suowhfwloq oi wkh shuvoq௲v uljkwv dqg lqwhuhvwv ,qioupdwloq vkdulqj uxohv dqg vdihjxdugv vkoxog eh lq sodfh zkhq dq lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw lv ehlqj foqgxfwhg e mxvwlfh dfwouv ʼˡ˗˘ˣ˘ˡ˗˘ˡ˧ ˜ˡ˧˘˥ˠ˘˗˜˔˥˜˘˦ ,qwhuqdwloqdo +xpdq 5ljkwv /dz ,qwhuphgldulhv dovo vophwlphv uhihuuhg wo dv ௵idflolwdwouv௶ duh shuvoqv zko zoun dv uhtxluhg zlwk mxvwlfh vvwhp shuvoqqho dqg shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo hqvxuh hiihfwlyh foppxqlfdwloq e dqg zlwk d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw gxulqj ohjdo suofhhglqjv 6oph shuvoqv shuiouplqj vlplodu uoohv duh uhihuuhg wo dv &oppxqlfdwloq $vvlvwdqwv $xvwudold ou &oppxqlfdwloq 6xssouw 6shfldolvwv 86ʹͻͳ )(1$&(5&, %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 3ouwxjdo /lveoq (1$%/( 3uomhfw s .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld 9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,elgs -,6. ௬ 0ogxoh ghilqlqlqj wkh mxwlfh lqwhuphgldu s 6hh kwwsv mxvwlfhlqwhuphglduoujpogxohv 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ,qwhuphgldulhv duh wslfdoo dssolqwhg dqg hpsoohg e wkh foxuwʹͻʹ dqg wkhlu dlp lv wo idflolwdwh foppxqlfdwloq ehwzhhq dq lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw dqg mxvwlfh dfwouv lq ohjdo suofhvvhv 7kh duh qow vxssouw shuvoqv shu vh exw udwkhu vhuyh dv d foqgxlw wo idflolwdwh hiihfwlyh foppxqlfdwloq wo hqvxuh wkdw d ghihqgdqw ou dffxvhg shuvoq xqghuvwdqgv txhvwloqv dqg fdq eh xqghuvwoog e mxvwlfh dfwouv dqg owkhu sduwlflsdqwv lq ohjdo suofhvvhv 7kh lqwhuphgldu dovo wdnhv wlph wo xqghuvwdqg wkh foppxqlfdwloq qhhgv oi wkh ghihqgdqwdffxvhg dqg vkoxog eh lqyooyhg lq d fdvh dw wkh hduolhvw solqw sovvleoh lghdoo dw wkh solqw dw zklfk wkh dffxvhg lv lqwhuylhzhg e wkh soolfh 7kuoxjk lqwhuphgldulhv shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv fdq eh vxssouwhg lq pdnlqj lqiouphg fkolfhv dqg foppxqlfdwlqj wkhp fohduo 7klv lv goqh lq gliihuhqw zdv ghshqglqj oq wkh lqglylgxdo௲v sduwlfxodu glvdelolw exw dozdv e pdnlqj vxuh wkdw lqioupdwloq lv h[sodlqhg dqg wdonhg deoxw lq zdv wkdw wkh lqglylgxdo xqghuvwdqgv ,qwhuphgldulhv dovo kdyh d nh uooh wo sod lq uhfopphqglqj dssuosuldwh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouwv zklfk pd eh suoylghg wo dvvlvw lq dq lqglylgxdov hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq lq ohjdo suofhvvhvʹͻ͵ 7kh uooh oi dq lqwhuphgldu pd ydu dfuovv yduloxv mxulvglfwloqv ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ˃˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘˦ ˔ˡ˗ ʺ˨˜˗˘˟˜ˡ˘˦ ˢˡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ʽ˨˦˧˜˖˘ ˙ˢ˥ ˃˘˥˦ˢˡ˦ ˪˜˧˛ ʷ˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ 3ulqflsoh *xlgholqh m hqmolqv 6wdwhv wo ௵suoylgh lqwhuphgldulhv ou idflolwdwouv zkhuhyhu dqg zkhqhyhu qhhghg wo hqdeoh fohdu foppxqlfdwloq dpoqj dqg ehwzhhq shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg foxuwv wulexqdov dqg odz hqioufhphqw djhqflhv wo hqvxuh vdih idlu dqg hiihfwlyh hqjdjhphqw dqg wkh ossouwxqlw wo ixoo sduwlflsdwh lq ohjdo suofhvvhv௶ʹͻͷ ,qwhuphgldulhv ou idflolwdwouv pxvw eh dydlodeoh wo idflolwdwh foppxqlfdwloq ehwzhhq shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg odz hqioufhphqw dqg foxuw shuvoqqhoʹͻͷ )ou lqvwdqfh lq wkh 8qlwhg .lqjgop wkh &ulplqdo 3uofhgxuh $phqgphqw 5xohv $uwlfoh fodulilhv wkdw lqwhuphgldulhv duh dssolqwhg e wkh &oxuw ,elg 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv s ,elg 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( $ffouglqj wo wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv ௵>l@qwhuphgldulhv duh qhxwudo dqg wkh go qow vshdn iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ou iou wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp qou go wkh ohdg ou lqioxhqfh ghflvloqv ou oxwfophv௶ʹͻ ,qwhuphgldulhv ou idflolwdwouv suoylgh vxssouw iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq oughu iou wkhp wo hqmo ohjdo fdsdflw oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuvʹͻ ,qghshqghqw lqwhuphgldulhv ou idflolwdwouv wudlqhg wo suoylgh foppxqlfdwloq dvvlvwdqfh wo sduwlhv wo wkh suofhhglqjv dqg wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp vkoxog eh dydlodeoh lq hyhu mxvwlfh vvwhpʹͻͺ ,qwhuphgldulhv vkoxog eh ehvw foqvlghuhg dv oiilfhuv oi wkh foxuw dqg eh uhvsoqvleoh wo wkh foxuw ou mxvwlfh vvwhp pouh euodgo $q dsshoodwh foxuw lq (qjodqg ghvfulehg koz dq lqwhuphgldu dvvlvwhg d ghihqgdqw zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqg foppxqlfdwloq glvdelolw lq d fulplqdo fdvh lq wkh ioooozlqj zd >7kh lqwhuphgldu@ ௵pdlqwdlqhg d ylvxdo uhfoug wo hqdeoh wkh >ghihqgdqw@ wo iooooz wkh hylghqfh vkh zuowh vlpsoh vhqwhqfhv iou klp dqg vkh khog wzlfh gdlo phhwlqjv zlwk >klp@ oxwvlgh foxuw wo vxppdulvh sdvw dqg ixwxuh hyhqwv lq wkh wuldo vkh dvvlvwhg klp zlwk d yofdexodu iooghu wo h[sodlq pouh gliilfxow foqfhswv dqg vkh zdv hyhqwxdoo deoh wo h[sodlq vdwlvidfwoulo wo klp zkdw wkh uooh oi wkh mxu zdv௶ʹͻͻ &kdoohqjhv ,q d qxpehu oi (8 0hpehu 6wdwhv lqwhuphgldulhv iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv duh qow uhjxodwhg e odz dw doo͵ͳͳ $ffhvv wo lqwhuphgldulhv lv dovo oiwhq gliilfxow (yhq lq 6wdwhv zkhuh wkh xvh oi lqwhuphgldulhv lv suoylghg iou lq odz ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv s ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv s ,elg 5 y ‘l[oq >@ (:&$ &ulp l dydlodeoh dw kwwsv zzzedlolloujhzfdvhv(:&$&ulpkwpo lq ,psohphqwlqj wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv $ eulhilqj sdshu -xo 6hh iou lqvwdqfh exojdul s 3,& %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6ooyhqld/mxeomdqd (1$%/( 3uomhfw s )(1$&(5&, %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 3ouwxjdo /lveoq (1$%/( 3uomhfw $sulo s )2580 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6ooydnld 3udkd (1$%/( suomhfw s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( wkhuh pd eh qo fohdu lqglfdwloqv oq owkhu sudfwlfdo hohphqwv wo oujdql]h dqg doooz wkhlu zoun ,q 5opdqld lqwhuphgldulhv duh qow uhjxodwhg e odz exw lq sudfwlfh fulplqdo mxvwlfh dfwouv vophwlphv vhhn wkh dvvlvwdqfh oi ௵lqioupdo lqwhuphgldulhvvxssouw shuvoqv௶ zkhq wkh vhh ilw wkhvh duh vophwlphv uhihuuhg wo dv ௵lqwhuphgldulhv௶ exw duh qow uhjxodwhg dv vxfk͵ͳͳ 7khuh duh lqvwdqfhv zkhq wkh foxuw pd oughu wkh suhvhqfh dw d khdulqj oi d svfkooojlvw͵ͳʹ ou zkhq ghdolqj zlwk d ylfwlp oi d fulph dovo d vshfldolvw lq ylfwlp foxqvhoolqj exw oqo vshflilfdoo iou d ylfwlp oi d fulph͵ͳ͵ ou d plqou͵ͳͷ zkhqhyhu wkh duh d ylfwlp ou d zlwqhvv͵ͳͷ 1o vxfk suoylvloq lv pdgh iou d fulplqdo dffxvhg ou owkhu sduwlflsdqwv lq mxvwlfh suofhvvhv 7kh &53’ kozhyhu uhtxluhv suoylvloq iou vxssouw iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog eh suoylghg wo doo sduwlflsdqwv lq doo mxvwlfh suofhvvhv dqg suofhgxuhv luuhvshfwlyh oi wkh qdwxuh oi wkh sduwlflsdwloq e wkh lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw͵ͳ ,q 6sdlq͵ͳ wkh &lylo 3uofhgxuh $fw dqg wkh 9ooxqwdu -xulvglfwloq $fw h[suhvvo suoylgh iou dffoppogdwloqv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg doooz iou dq ௵h[shuw suoihvvloqdo wo dfw dv dq lqwhuphgldu wo suoylgh wkh qhfhvvdu dgdswdwloqv dqg dffoppogdwloqv wo hqdeoh wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw wo xqghuvwdqg dqg eh xqghuvwoog௶͵ͳͺ :kloh wklv uooh lv uhfojql]hg e odz lw kdv qow ehhq ixuwkhu uhjxodwhg dqg vxssohphqwhg e dgplqlvwudwlyh uhjxodwloqv jxlgholqhv dqg soolflhv 7klv phdqv wkdw lw lv qow vshflilhg e odz zko fdq shuioup wklv ixqfwloq zkdw txdolilfdwloqv h[shuwlvh dqg h[shulhqfh duh &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 5opdqld%xfduhvw (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,q wkh suoylvloqv oi wkh 5opdqldq &ulplqdo &ogh oqo wkh svfkooojlvw dqg wkh vshfldolvw lq ylfwlp foxqvhoolqj duh vshflilhg wo eh suhvhqw dw d khdulqj lq fdvhv zlwk ylfwlpv oi fulphv dgxow ou xqghudjh $qg lq wkh fdvh oi xqghudjh zlwqhvvhv wkh suoylvloqv vshfli oqo wkh suhvhqfh oi d svfkooojlvw lq d khdulqj 3uomhfw sduwqhuv go qow kdyh dq gdwd uhjduglqj lqlwldo wudlqlqj ou foqwlqxoxv wudlqlqj iou svfkooojlvwv lq wkhvh fdvhv $uwlfoh e &ulplqdo fogh &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv &/5 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 5opdqld %xfduhvw (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,elg ,elg ,elg s )(1$&(5&, %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 3ouwxjdo /lveoq (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,elg 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( uhtxluhg wo go vo ou koz vxfk sovlwloqv duh wo eh ilqdqfhg ou e zkop $ffouglqj wo 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµq wkh dxwkou oi wkh qdwloqdo vwxg lq wkh (qdeoh suomhfw dw suhvhqw wkhuh duh shuvoqv zko dfw dv lqwhuphgldulhv lq mxglfldo suofhhglqjv exw wkh ehooqj wo 1*2v wkdw zoun lq wklv ilhog dqg suoylgh wkh vhuylfh͵ͳͻ $ffouglqj wo wkh qdwloqdo vwxg lq povw fdvhv glvdelolwlhv kdg oqo ehhq glvfoyhuhg diwhu wkh wuldo dqg wkhuhiouh wkhuh duh wslfdoo qo lqwhuphgldulhv lqyooyhg lq wkh suofhhglqjv dowkoxjk 6sdqlvk odz shuplwv wkhlu lqyooyhphqw͵ͳͳ ,q /lwkxdqld qo ioupdo suoylvloqv uhjduglqj suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv h[lvw zlwklq wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhp ,q sudfwlfh suofhgxudo phdvxuhv duh ohiw wo wkh glvfuhwloq oi mxgjhv suovhfxwouv dqg owkhu fulplqdo mxvwlfh suoihvvloqdov ,q oqh fdvh dffouglqj wo wkh qdwloqdo vwxg dq lqwhuphgldu zdv suhvhqw dqg lpphgldwho hqvxuhg pouh vhfxuh dqg fdop suofhhglqjv iou wkh ghihqgdqw͵ͳͳ 3udfwlfdo jxlgdqfh dqg uhfopphqgdwloqv :khuh qhhghg dq lqwhuphgldu vkoxog eh fdoohg wo dvvlvw lq foppxqlfdwloq gxulqj soolfh lqwhuylhzv zlwk wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw vxvshfwhg oi wkh fulph $v d ioup oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloq lqwhuphgldulhv vkoxog eh suoylghg wo ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zkhuhyhu dqg zkhqhyhu qhhghg wo hqdeoh fohdu foppxqlfdwloq ehwzhhq wkhp wkh soolfh dqg mxvwlfh dfwouv lqfoxglqj wkh foxuwv wo hqvxuh vdih idlu dqg hiihfwlyh hqjdjhphqw dqg wo suoylgh wkh ossouwxqlw wo ixoo sduwlflsdwh lq doo vwdjhv oi suofhhglqjv 7klv uhtxluhv wkdw $ $ vxiilflhqw qxpehu oi wudlqhg lqwhuphgldulhv eh pdgh dydlodeoh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv iuop wkh vwduw oi wkh suofhhglqjv dqg dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh ,elg s 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyh %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq /lwkxdqld 9loqlxv (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( % 6vwhpdwlf wudlqlqj oq wkh uooh oi lqwhuphgldulhv duh lq sodfh & 7kh xvh oi lqwhuphgldulhv go qow jhqhudwh fovwv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ‘ ,q wkh devhqfh oi vxiilflhqw dqg txdolilhg foxuwdssolqwhg lqwhuphgldulhv foxuwv zoun fooodeoudwlyho zlwk vwdnhkooghuv zko suoylgh vxfk vxssouw wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 6vwhplf uhfopphqgdwloqv ,q wkh ooqjwhup suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv ௬ lqfoxglqj wkh sovvlelolw oi dq lqwhuphgldu௬ vkoxog eh lqfoxghg lq qdwloqdo ohjlvodwloq dqg uxohv dssolfdeoh wo wkh &oxuwv wo hqvxuh wkh ixoo lpsohphqwdwloq oi wkh &53′ lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhpv 1dwloqdo odz vkoxog lqfoxgh wkh uhjxodwloq oq wkh sovlwloq oi lqwhuphgldulhv zklfk vkoxog lqfoxgh zko fdq eh dq lqwhuphgldu zkdw foqglwloqv qhhg wo eh ixoiloohg d fogh oi hwklfv dqg wkh qhhg wo uhpdlq lqghshqghqw sduw lq wkh suofhvv (yhq zkhuh 1*2v suoylgh wkh uhvoxufhv wo hqvxuh lqwhuphgldulhv lq wkh suofhhglqjv wkh 6wdwh kdv wkh oeoljdwloq wo suoylgh qhfhvvdu ilqdqfldo pdwlhudo dqg kxpdq uhvoxufhv iou lqwhuphgldulhv dqg vkoxog jlyh sudfwlfdo hiihfw wo wklv uhvsoqvlelolw ˅˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˕˘ ˔˖˖ˢˠˣ˔ˡ˜˘˗ ˕ˬ ˔ ˦˨ˣˣˢ˥˧ ˣ˘˥˦ˢˡʟ ˪˛˜˖˛ ˠ˔ˬ ˜ˡ˖˟˨˗˘ ˔ ˥˘˟˔˧˜˩˘ ,qwhuqdwloqdo +xpdq 5ljkwv /dz 7kh uljkw wo eh dffopsdqlhg e d vxssouw shuvoq lqfoxglqj d uhodwlyh ou owkhu wuxvwhg shuvoq zkloh qow h[suhvvo suoylghg iou xqghu wkh &53’ lv dq hvvhqwldo fopsoqhqw oi d vhw oi phdvxuhv wo hqvxuh htxdo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,q sduwlfxodu duwlfoh oi wkh &53′ uhtxluhv 6wdwhv wo suoylgh dffhvv e shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo wkh vxssouw wkh pd uhtxluh wo h[huflvh wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw 7kh &53’ 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( &opplwwhh kdv lqwhusuhwhg wkh whup ௵vxssouw௶ lq duwlfoh dv vxiilflhqwo euodg wo lqfoxgh wkh sovvlelolw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ehlqj hqwlwohg wo fkoovh oqh ou pouh wuxvwhg shuvoqv wo dvvlvw wkhp lq h[huflvlqj wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw͵ͳʹ 7kh wklug sulqflsoh oi wkh 81 ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv h[solflwo uhihuv wo wkh oeoljdwloq oi 6wdwhv wo jxdudqwhh wkh uljkw wo eh dffopsdqlhg ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ˃˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘˦ ˔ˡ˗ ʺ˨˜˗˘˟˜ˡ˘˦ ˢˡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ʽ˨˦˧˜˖˘ ˙ˢ˥ ˃˘˥˦ˢˡ˦ ˪˜˧˛ ʷ˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ ௵ g $ooozlqj shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhvv li wkh vo fkoovh wo eh dffopsdqlhg e idplo iulhqgv ou owkhuv wo suoylgh hpowloqdo dqg poudo vxssouw zlwkoxw uhsodflqj kozhyhu wkh uooh oi dq lqwhuphgldu ou idflolwdwou௶ 7khvh vxssouw shuvoqv pd sod d fulwlfdo dqg vshflilf uooh wkdw gliihuv iuop wkdw oi wkh lqwhuphgldulhv $v h[sodlqhg lq wkh suhyloxv vhfwloq vhfwloq ,9 lqwhuphgldulhv pd kdyh gliihuhqw ixqfwloqv exw lq jhqhudo oiihu sudfwlfdo vxssouw wo idflolwdwh foppxqlfdwloq dqg wo suoylgh dghtxdwh dffoppogdwloqv )dplolhv iulhqgv dqg owkhu wuxvwhg shuvoqv fdq oiihu poudo dqg hpowloqdo vxssouw͵ͳ͵ &kdoohqjhv ,q pdq foxqwulhv wkh uljkw wo eh dffopsdqlhg e idplo iulhqgv ou owkhu wuxvwhg shuvoqv lv qow suoylghg iou lq odz ou lpsohphqwhg lq sudfwlfh )ou lqvwdqfh lq 5opdqld wkhuh lv d fopsohwh odfn oi suoylvloq iou lqglylgxdov zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo eh dffopsdqlhg e idplo iulhqgv ou owkhu wuxvwhg shuvoqv zko pd eh deoh wo suoylgh wkhp zlwk hpowloqdo dqg poudo vxssouw gxulqj wkh suofhhglqjv͵ͳͷ &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o sdud 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 3ulqflsoh g s &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv &/5 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 5opdqld %xfduhvw (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 6sdlq௲v flylo suofhgxuh ohjlvodwloq suoylghv wkdw ௵shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv kdyh wkh uljkw wo eh dffopsdqlhg e d shuvoq oi wkhlu fkolfh iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk dxwkoulwlhv௶ ,q sudfwlfh kozhyhu ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh xvxdoo dooozhg wo fdoo d shuvoq oi wuxvw dv zhoo dv wkhlu idplo exw povwo oqo wkuoxjk whohskoqlf foqwdfw zkloh qo idfhwoidfh foqwdfw lv shuplwwhg ‘xulqj wkh wuldo lq voph fdvhv idplo kdv qow ehhq shuplwwhg wo dwwhqg suofhhglqjv ,q /lwkxdqld d suovhfxwouv ghflvloq ou d foxuw oughu lv uhtxluhg wo doooz d shuvoq wo sduwlflsdwh lq wkh suofhvv zlwk wkh uljkw wo d uhsuhvhqwdwlyh 7klv pd lqfoxgh d idplo phpehu ou d foovh uhodwlyh zko kdv vxeplwwhg d zulwwhq ou yhuedo uhtxhvw wo sduwlflsdwh lq wklv pdqqhu 6xfk shuvoq pd dfw dv d uhsuhvhqwdwlyh iou d shuvoq zko lv qow qhfhvvdulo uhfojql]hg dv lqfdsdflwdwhg e wkh foxuw exw zko gxh wo wkhlu oog djh glvdelolw looqhvv ou owkhu lpsouwdqw uhdvoqv lv foqvlghuhg wo qow eh fdsdeoh oi suoshuo h[huflvlqj wkhlu uljkwv͵ͳ 7klv vhhpv wo eh gh idfwo vxevwlwxwhg ghflvloq pdnlqj zlwkoxw d uhtxluhphqw iou lqiouphg foqvhqw ,q 6ooydnld wkh foqgxfwlqj oi lqyhvwljdwlyh suofhgxuhv dqg khdulqjv lq wkh suhvhqfh oi d ௵foqilgdqw௶ lv dooozhg lq doo suofhgxuhv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv iou wkh djjulhyhg sduwlhv $fw oi -xqh uhiouplqj flylo dqg suofhgxudo ohjlvodwloq iou vxssouwlqj shosoh zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh h[huflvh oi wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw %2( qo -xqh 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq /lwkxdqld9loqlxv (1$%/( 3uomhfw $sulo s /lwkxdqldq &ogh oi &ulplqdo 3uofhgxuh duwlfoh ௵ $ idplo phpehu ou d foovh uhodwlyh oi d shuvoq zko lv qow uhfojqlvhg dv ohjdoo lqfdsdeoh lq dffougdqfh zlwk wkh hvwdeolvkhg suofhgxuh exw zko gxh wo klv oog djh glvdelolw looqhvv ou iou owkhu fopshoolqj uhdvoqv lv xqdeoh wo suoshuo h[huflvh wkh uljkwv judqwhg e odz pd xsoq d zulwwhq ou oudo uhtxhvw eh shuplwwhg wo sduwlflsdwh lq suofhhglqjv lq wkh fdsdflw d ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwlyh e d ghflvloq oi d suovhfxwou ou e d foxuw uxolqj௶ $uwlfoh d oi wkh &ogh oi &ulplqdo 3uofhgxuh 8qghu duwlfoh wkhuhlq djjulhyhg sduw lv dqoqh zko vxiihuhg kdup gxh wo d fulph h j wo wkhlu khdowk suoshuw poudoh owkhu kdup ou wo wkhlu owkhu uljkwv dqg iuhhgopv )2580 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq &]hfkld 3udkd (1$%/( suomhfw s 2wkhuzlvh ghihqgdqwv pd kdyh suhvhqfh oi foqilgdqwv oqo lq fdvhv zkhuh khdulqjv duh wdnlqj sodfh zlwk wkh jhqhudo sxeolf h[foxghg hj vhqvlwlyh fdvhv dqg foqilgdqwv iou ghihqgdqwv vhuyh wo oyhuvhh lqwhjulw oi wkh suofhhglqjv udwkhu wkdq foppxqlfdwloq vxssouw 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 3udfwlfdo jxlgdqfh dqg uhfopphqgdwloqv )uop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk wkh dxwkoulwlhv shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog eh lqiouphg oi wkhlu uljkw wo eh dffopsdqlhg e d vxssouw shuvoq oi wkhlu fkolfh wkdw foxog lqfoxgh d idplo phpehu 6wdwhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw $ li dq lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw vo zlvkhv vxfk wuxvwhg vxssouw shuvoqv fdq eh suhvhqw gxulqj doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqj % d suofhgxuh e zklfk wkh uooh oi vxfk d vxssouw shuvoq lv fohduo ghwhuplqhg dqg uhjxodwhg & qo shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw lv fopshoohg wo doooz wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi dq vxfk vxssouw shuvoqv lq wkhlu ohjdo diidluv dw dq vwdjh oi ohjdo suofhhglqjv djdlqvw wkhlu zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv ‘ wkh uooh oi dq lqwhuphgldu lv qow foqiodwhg zlwk ou uhsodfhg e d vxssouw shuvoq 7kh lqwhuphgldu dqg wkh vxssouw shuvoq kdyh gliihuhqw uoohv dqg zkhuh qhhghg suoylvloq iou wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi eowk vkoxog eh pdgh 7khuh vkoxog dozdv eh d idfhwoidfh foqwdfw zlwk wkh wuxvwhg vxssouw shuvoq li wkh lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw ghvluhv vxfk foqwdfw 3uofhgxudo dgmxvwphqwv dqg poglilfdwloqv $uwlfoh oi wkh &53′ uhtxluhv 6wdwhv wo ௵hqvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv lqfoxglqj wkuoxjk wkh suoylvloq oi suofhgxudo dqg djhdssuosuldwh dffoppogdwloqv௶ 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh lq lwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq htxdolw ehiouh wkh odz fodulilhv wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv pd qhhg vxssouw wo dffhvv mxvwlfh dqg wklv vxssouw ௵foxog wdnh yduloxv ioupv lqfoxglqj uhfojqlwloq oi glyhuvh foppxqlfdwloq phwkogv dooozlqj ylgho whvwlpoq lq fhuwdlq vlwxdwloqv suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloq wkh suoylvloq oi suoihvvloqdo vljq odqjxdjh lqwhusuhwdwloq dqg owkhu dvvlvwlyh phwkogv௶͵ͳͻ &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1osdud 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ˃˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘˦ ˔ˡ˗ ʺ˨˜˗˘˟˜ˡ˘˦ ˢˡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ʽ˨˦˧˜˖˘ ˙ˢ˥ ˃˘˥˦ˢˡ˦ ˪˜˧˛ ʷ˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ 3uofhgxuhv pxvw eh dgoswhg iou khdulqjv wkdw hqvxuh wkh idlu wuhdwphqw dqg ixoo sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv )ou lqvwdqfh ͵ʹͳ l $gdswdwloq oi wkh yhqxh ll $ssuosuldwh zdlwlqj vsdfhv lll 5hpoydo oi foodnv dqg zljv ly $gmxvwphqwv wo wkh sdfh oi suofhhglqjv y 6hsdudwh exloglqj hqwudqfhv dqg zdlwlqj uoopv dqg suowhfwlyh vfuhhqv wo vhsdudwh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv iuop owkhuv li qhfhvvdu gxh wo skvlfdo ou hpowloqdo glvwuhvv yl 0oglilfdwloqv wo wkh phwkog oi txhvwloqlqj lq dssuosuldwh flufxpvwdqfhv vxfk dv dooozlqj ohdglqj txhvwloqv dyolglqj fopsoxqg txhvwloqv ilqglqj dowhuqdwlyhv wo fopsoh[ ksowkhwlfdo txhvwloqv suoylglqj h[wud wlph wo dqvzhu shuplwwlqj euhdnv dv qhhghg dqg xvlqj sodlq odqjxdjh yll8vh oi suhwuldo ylgho uhfouglqj oi hylghqfh dqg whvwlpoq li qhfhvvdu sudfwlfdo dqg sovvleoh lq vxfk d pdqqhu dv qow wo foqwudyhqh edvlf uljkwv vxfk dv wkh uljkw wo foqiuoqw dqg fuovvh[dplqh zlwqhvvhv $w doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhvv li wkh fkoovh vo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv pd eh dffopsdqlhg e idplo iulhqgv ou owkhuv wo suoylgh hpowloqdo dqg poudo vxssouw zlwkoxw uhsodflqj kozhyhu wkh uooh oi dq lqwhuphgldu ou idflolwdwou͵ʹͳ 3udfwlfdo jxlgdqfh dqg uhfopphqgdwloqv 7kh uhvsoqvleoh 6wdwh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw yhqxhv lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp zkhuh ohjdo suofhvvhv wdnh sodfh lqfoxglqj zdlwlqj duhdv duh dozdv vxiilflhqwo dgdswhg dqg dffhvvleoh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ௬ dqg dssuosuldwh wo wkh vshflilf qhhgv oi wkh shuvoq ,q dgglwloq wo d skvlfdo hqyluoqphqw uhvsoqvleoh 6wdwh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog foqvlghu dgdswdwloq oi yhqxhv oq d fdvhefdvh edvlv lq foqvxowdwloq zlwk dq 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv *xlgholqh f s ,elg *xlgholqh g 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( lqglylgxdo zlwk glvdelolw wkhlu lqwhuphgldu dqgou vxssouw shuvoq 7kh ioooozlqj foxog eh foqvlghuhg $ /lplwlqj wkh h[sovxuh oi wkh ghihqgdqwv wo wkh sxeolf ou pouh jhqhudoo wkhlu foqwdfw zlwk owkhu shuvoqv ͵ʹʹ % foqvlghulqj wkh vhdwlqj dqg sovlwloqlqj wo eh dgdswhg zkhq qhhghg iou lqvwdqfh odzhuv vlwwlqj zlwk wkhlu edfnv wo wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk glvdelolw lq foxuw pd qhhg dgdswdwloq dqg & wdnlqj phdvxuhv wo hqvxuh wkdw wkh foqwdfw zlwk wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp lv dv idu dv sovvleoh qow lqwlplgdwlqj 2q skvlfdo dffhvvlelolw dqg idflolwlhv vhh ixuwkhu vhfwloq ,9 -xglfldo &ooohjh 8qlwhg .lqjgop ௱(txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon௲ )heuxdu s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ʵʡ ˅˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˜ˡ˙ˢ˥ˠ˔˧˜ˢˡ ˔ˡ˗ ˖ˢˠˠ˨ˡ˜˖˔˧˜ˢˡ ˜ˡ ˔˖˖˘˦˦˜˕˟˘ ˙ˢ˥ˠ˔˧˦ ˅˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˜ˡ˙ˢ˥ˠ˔˧˜ˢˡ ,qwhuqdwloqdo +xpdq 5ljkwv /dz dqg (8 /dz dqg 6wdqgdugv ,&&35 duwlfoh suoylghv wkdw ௵>h@yhuoqh vkdoo kdyh wkh uljkw wo iuhhgop oi h[suhvvloq wklv uljkw vkdoo lqfoxgh iuhhgop wo vhhn uhfhlyh dqg lpsduw lqioupdwloq dqg lghdv oi doo nlqgv uhjdugohvv oi iuoqwlhuv hlwkhu oudoo lq zulwlqj ou lq sulqw lq wkh ioup oi duw ou wkuoxjk dq owkhu phgld oi klv fkolfh௶ ,q wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh foqwh[w wklv pxvw eh uhdg lq foqmxqfwloq zlwk ,&&35 duwlfoh d dqg e zklfk suoylghv wkdw ௵>l@q wkh ghwhuplqdwloq oi dq fulplqdo fkdujh djdlqvw klp hyhuoqh vkdoo eh hqwlwohg wo wkh ioooozlqj plqlpxp jxdudqwhhv lq ixoo htxdolw d 7o eh lqiouphg suopswo dqg lq ghwdlo lq d odqjxdjh zklfk kh xqghuvwdqgv oi wkh qdwxuh dqg fdxvh oi wkh fkdujh djdlqvw klp e 7o kdyh dghtxdwh wlph dqg idflolwlhv iou wkh suhsdudwloq oi klv ghihqfh dqg wo foppxqlfdwh zlwk foxqvho oi klv ozq fkoovlqj >@௶ 7kh +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh lq lwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o kdv pdgh fohdu wkdw ௵>d@ghtxdwh idflolwlhv௶ pxvw lqfoxgh dffhvv wo gofxphqwv dqg owkhu hylghqfh wklv dffhvv pxvw lqfoxgh doo pdwhuldov wkdw wkh suovhfxwloq sodqv wo oiihu lq foxuw djdlqvw wkh dffxvhg ou wkdw duh h[fxosdwou ([fxosdwou pdwhuldo vkoxog eh xqghuvwoog dv lqfoxglqj qow oqo pdwhuldo hvwdeolvklqj lqqofhqfh exw dovo owkhu hylghqfh wkdw foxog dvvlvw wkh ghihqfh hj lqglfdwloqv wkdw d foqihvvloq zdv qow yooxqwdu ,q fdvhv oi d fodlp wkdw hylghqfh zdv oewdlqhg lq yloodwloq oi duwlfoh oi wkh &oyhqdqw lqioupdwloq deoxw wkh flufxpvwdqfhv lq zklfk vxfk hylghqfh zdv oewdlqhg pxvw eh pdgh dydlodeoh wo doooz dq dvvhvvphqw oi vxfk d fodlp >@௶ 81 +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh 5ljkw wo htxdolw ehiouh foxuwv dqg wulexqdov dqg wo d idlu wuldo &&35&*& sdud 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( $uwlfoh (&+5 suoylghv wkdw ௵>h@yhuoqh kdv wkh uljkw wo iuhhgop oi h[suhvvloq 7klv uljkw vkdoo lqfoxgh iuhhgop wo koog oslqloqv dqg wo uhfhlyh dqg lpsduw lqioupdwloq dqg lghdv zlwkoxw lqwhuihuhqfh e sxeolf dxwkoulw dqg uhjdugohvv oi iuoqwlhuv >@௶ $uwlfoh d dovo suoylghv iou d uljkw wo eh lqiouphg suoylglqj wkdw hyhueog zko lv fkdujhg zlwk d fulplqdo oiihqfh kdv wkh uljkw ௵wo eh lqiouphg suopswo lq d odqjxdjh zklfk kh xqghuvwdqgv dqg lq ghwdlo oi wkh qdwxuh dqg fdxvh oi wkh dffxvdwloq djdlqvw klp >@௶ 7kh (8 &kduwhu oi )xqgdphqwdo 5ljkwv gohv qow suhvhqw d vshflilf uhihuhqfh wo wkh uljkw wo eh lqiouphg lq wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vhwwlqj exw lw uhfojql]hv iuhhgop oi h[suhvvloq lq lwv duwlfoh vwdwlqj wkdw ௵>h@yhuoqh kdv wkh uljkw wo iuhhgop oi h[suhvvloq 7klv uljkw vkdoo lqfoxgh iuhhgop wo koog oslqloqv dqg wo uhfhlyh dqg lpsduw lqioupdwloq dqg lghdv zlwkoxw lqwhuihuhqfh e sxeolf dxwkoulw dqg uhjdugohvv oi iuoqwlhuv௶ $ffouglqj wo duwlfoh oi wkh &53’ 6wdwhv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv fdq h[huflvh wkh uljkw wo iuhhgop oi h[suhvvloq dqg oslqloq lqfoxglqj wkh iuhhgop wo vhhn uhfhlyh dqg lpsduw lqioupdwloq dqg lghdv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv dqg wkuoxjk doo ioupv oi foppxqlfdwloq oi wkhlu fkolfh e ௵ d 3uoylglqj lqioupdwloq lqwhqghg iou wkh jhqhudo sxeolf wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq dffhvvleoh ioupdwv dqg whfkqooojlhv dssuosuldwh wo gliihuhqw nlqgv oi glvdelolwlhv lq d wlpho pdqqhu dqg zlwkoxw dgglwloqdo fovw e $ffhswlqj dqg idflolwdwlqj wkh xvh oi vljq odqjxdjhv %udlooh dxjphqwdwlyh dqg dowhuqdwlyh foppxqlfdwloq dqg doo owkhu dffhvvleoh phdqv poghv dqg ioupdwv oi foppxqlfdwloq oi wkhlu fkolfh e shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq oiilfldo lqwhudfwloqv $uwlfoh d e &53’ 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( $uwlfoh i oi wkh &53′ suoylghv wkdw 6wdwhv pxvw suopowh ௵dssuosuldwh ioupv oi dvvlvwdqfh dqg vxssouw wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo hqvxuh wkhlu dffhvv wo lqioupdwloq௶ 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv solqwhg oxw wkdw ௵>s@huvoqv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqg svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv dv zhoo dv ghdieolqg shuvoqv idfh eduulhuv zkhq dwwhpswlqj wo dffhvv lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloq ozlqj wo d odfn oi hdvwouhdg ioupdwv dqg dxjphqwdwlyh dqg dowhuqdwlyh poghv oi foppxqlfdwloq௶ )ou lqvwdqfh lq wkh &oppxqlfdwloq lq 0hglqd 9hod y 0h[lfo 1o wkh &53′ &opplwwhh ioxqg d yloodwloq oi duwlfoh lq foqmxqfwloq zlwk duwlfoh dv wkh 6wdwh idlohg wo hqvxuh wkh dffhvvlelolw oi lqioupdwloq gxulqj wkh fulplqdo suofhhglqjv iou wkh shuvoq zlwk dq lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw vlqfh qo lqioupdwloq zdv dydlodeoh wo wkhp lq dq dffhvvleoh ioupdw 6oph h[dpsohv oi qhfhvvdu dgmxvwphqwv iou dffhvv wo lqioupdwloq fdq eh ioxqg lq wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ˃˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘˦ ˔ˡ˗ ʺ˨˜˗˘˟˜ˡ˘˦ ˢˡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ʽ˨˦˧˜˖˘ ˙ˢ˥ ˃˘˥˦ˢˡ˦ ˪˜˧˛ ʷ˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ 3ulqflsoh 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv kdyh wkh uljkw wo dffhvv ohjdo qowlfhv dqg lqioupdwloq lq d wlpho dqg dffhvvleoh pdqqhu oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv *xlgholqh 7o jxdudqwhh wkh uljkw wo wlpho dqg dffhvvleoh lqioupdwloq 6wdwhv vkdoo (qdfw hqioufhdeoh odzv uhjxodwloqv soolflhv dqg jxlgholqhv wkdw ixoo uhfojql]h wkh uljkw wo wlpho qowlfh dqg lqioupdwloq deoxw doo dvshfwv oi mxglfldo suofhvvhv (qvxuh wkdw lqioupdwloq deoxw mxvwlfh vvwhpv dqg suofhgxuhv fdq eh dffhvvhg e yduloxv phwkogv lqfoxglqj dv dssuosuldwh dqg qhhghg &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh $ffhvvlelolw &53’&*& 0d sdud 9lhzv dgoswhg e wkh &opplwwhh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh 2swloqdo 3uowofoo foqfhulqj foppxqlfdwloq lq 0hglqd 9hod y 0h[lfo qo 2fwoehu sdud 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 3ulqflsoh s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 6ljq odqjxdjh $xglo jxlghv 7hohskoqh olqh dgylfh dqg uhihuudo vhuylfhv $ffhvvleoh zhevlwhv ,qgxfwloq ooos udglo ou lqiuduhg vvwhpv $psolilfdwloq ghylfhv dqg gofxphqw pdjqlilhuv &oovhg fdswloqlqj %udlooh (dv 5hdg dqg sodlq odqjxdjh )dflolwdwhg foppxqlfdwloq (qvxuh wkdw doo qowlfhv wkdw uhtxluh d uhvsoqvh ou dq dfwloq wo eh wdnhq hj vxppoqvhv vxesohqdv zulwv oughuv dqg vhqwhqfhv duh dydlodeoh e dffhvvleoh phdqv dqg lq dffhvvleoh ioupdwv vxfk dv wkovh olvwhg deoyh lq jxlgholqh e (qvxuh wkdw qowlfhv dqg lqioupdwloq lqfoxgh fohdu xqghuvwdqgdeoh lqioupdwloq deoxw koz d suofhgxuh zounv zkdw wo h[shfw gxulqj d suofhvv zkdw lv h[shfwhg oi d shuvoq zkhuh wo jhw khos zlwk xqghuvwdqglqj wkh suofhvv dqg wkh shuvoq௲v uljkwv lq wkh suofhvv lq odqjxdjh wkdw lv qow phuho d uhshwlwloq oi wkh vwdwxwh uhjxodwloq soolf ou jxlgholqh ௬ iou h[dpsoh sodlq odqjxdjh (qvxuh wkdw vxssouw lv dydlodeoh lq uhdo wlph iou lqglylgxdov zko qhhg dvvlvwdqfh wo xqghuvwdqg qowlfhv dqg lqioupdwloq e suoylglqj iou lqvwdqfh lqwhusuhwhuv jxlghv uhdghuv lqwhuphgldulhv dqg idflolwdwouv dqg owkhu ioupv oi vxssouw $ffouglqj wo ‘luhfwlyh (8 oq wkh uljkw wo lqioupdwloq lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv 0hpehu 6wdwhv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw vxvshfwv ou dffxvhg shuvoqv duh lqiouphg oi wkhlu suofhgxudo uljkwv lqfoxglqj wkh uljkw oi dffhvv wo d odzhu wkh uljkw dqg foqglwloqv iou uhfhlylqj iuhh ohjdo dgylfh wkh uljkw wo eh lqiouphg oi wkh dffxvdwloq 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( wkh uljkw wo lqwhusuhwdwloq dqg wudqvodwloq dqg wkh uljkw wo uhpdlq vlohqw $uwlfoh oi ‘luhfwlyh (8 lpsovhv dq oeoljdwloq oq 6wdwhv wo hqvxuh wkdw vxvshfwv dqg dffxvhg shuvoqv duh lqiouphg oi wkhlu uljkwv ௵oudoo ou lq zulwlqj lq vlpsoh dqg dffhvvleoh odqjxdjh wdnlqj lqwo dffoxqw dq sduwlfxodu qhhgv oi yxoqhudeoh vxvshfwv ou yxoqhudeoh dffxvhg shuvoqv௶ ,q dgglwloq wkh (8 3uofhgxudo ‘luhfwlyhv uhtxluh wkdw ௵ shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog uhfhlyh xsoq uhtxhvw lqioupdwloq foqfhuqlqj wkhlu suofhgxudo uljkwv lq d ioup dffhvvleoh wo wkhp௶͵ʹͺ 7kh &oxuw oi -xvwlfh oi wkh (8 &-(8 kdv dgguhvvhg wkh txhvwloq oi dffhvv wo lqioupdwloq oi ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fdvh &͵ʹͻ kooglqj wkdw ௵’luhfwlyh pxvw eh lqwhusuhwhg dv phdqlqj wkdw shuvoqv vxvshfwhg oi kdylqj fopplwwhg d fulplqdo oiihqfh pxvw eh lqiouphg dv vooq dv sovvleoh oi wkhlu uljkwv iuop wkh pophqw zkhq wkh duh vxemhfw wo vxvslfloqv zklfk mxvwli lq flufxpvwdqfhv owkhu wkdq dq hphujhqf wkh uhvwulfwloq oi wkhlu olehuw e wkh fopshwhqw dxwkoulwlhv e phdqv oi fohuflyh phdvxuhv dqg dw wkh odwhvw ehiouh wkh duh iluvw oiilfldoo txhvwloqhg e wkh soolfh௶ $ffouglqj wo wkh (8 5hfopphqgdwloq oq suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv iou yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv ௵ shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog uhfhlyh xsoq uhtxhvw lqioupdwloq foqfhuqlqj wkhlu suofhgxudo uljkwv lq d ioupdw dffhvvleoh wo wkhp௶͵͵ͳ7klv suoylvloq lv foqwudu wo wkh &53’ dv lqioupdwloq lq dffhvvleoh ioupdw vkoxog qow oqo eh suoylghg wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ௵xsoq uhtxhvw௶ exw lq olqh zlwk wkh vwdwh௲v oeoljdwloq wo suoylgh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv &opplvvloq 5hfopphqgdwloq & oq suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv iou yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv vhfwloq ௬ 5ljkwv oi yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv 5ljkw wo lqioupdwloq &-(8 έ 5doqqd suonxudwxud /op y (3 sdud &opplvvloq 5hfopphqgdwloq oi 1oyhpehu oq suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv iou yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv $uwlfoh 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( &kdoohqjhv $ffouglqj wo wkh uhvhdufk xqghuwdnhq e sduwqhuv lq wkh (qdeoh suomhfw wkhuh lv oiwhq fopsohwh idloxuh zlwk yhu ihz h[fhswloqv oi 6wdwh dxwkoulwlhv suoylglqj doo qhfhvvdu lqioupdwloq wo ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv͵͵ͳ ,q wkh devhqfh oi ixoo lqioupdwloq lw lv kljko xqolnho wkdw dq shuvoq ௬ lqfoxglqj d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw ௬ fdq sduwlflsdwh htxdoo dqg phdqlqjixoo lq mxvwlfh suofhvvhv ,q voph lqvwdqfhv wkh idloxuh wo suoylgh dffhvvleoh lqioupdwloq zloo qow oqo uhvxow lq glvfulplqdwloq exw zloo dovo suhyhqw vxfk lqglylgxdov iuop hqmolqj d idlu wuldo dqg ghsulyh wkhp oi wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw lq yloodwloq oi wkh &53’ 7slfdoo oqo jhqhudo suoylvloqv wo lqioup ghihqgdqwv deoxw wkhlu uljkwv duh suoylghg iou lq ohjlvodwloq dqg dgplqlvwudwlyh uhjxodwloqv oi povw (8 0hpehu 6wdwhv͵͵ʹ zlwkoxw dq vshfldo foqvlghudwloq oi wkh sduwlfxodu qhhgv dqg uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,q 6ooydnld wkh odz oqo foqwdlqv d jhqhudo uhtxluhphqw iou ௵dghtxdwh h[sodqdwloq zkhuh qhfhvvdu௶ oi wkh suofhvv dqg suofhgxudo uljkwv exw qow vshflilfdoo iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv͵͵͵ ,q 3ouwxjdo wkh uljkw wo lqioupdwloq iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv lv htxdoo fopsuoplvhg dv wkh &ogh oi &ulplqdo 3uofhgxuh lv qow fohdu͵͵ͷ deoxw wkh 3o«qd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq 0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq /lwkxdqld 9loqlxv (1$%/( suomhfw s )2580 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6ooydnld 3udkd (1$%/( suomhfw s ,elg s $ffouglqj wo $uwlfoh f dqg k oi wkh 3ouwxjxhvh 3hqdo &ogh doo ghihqgdqwv kdyh wkh uljkw wo eh lqiouphg oi wkhlu uljkwv dqg oi wkh idfwv zlwk zklfk wkh duh fkdujhg +ozhyhu 3ouwxjxhvh odz kdv qo h[suhvv uxoh oq jxdudqwhhlqj wkh dffhvvlelolw oi odqjxdjh 7kh ghihqgdqw kdv wkh uljkw wo eh dffopsdqlhg e klv ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwlyh zko pd eh wkh dffopsdqlqj shuvoq li kh kdv ehhq judqwhg sozhuv oi uhsuhvhqwdwloq lh dffopsdqlqj phdvxuhv vxemhfw wo uhsuhvhqwdwloq uxohv 0ouhoyhu dffouglqj wo $uwlfoh l odvw sduw oi wkh 3ouwxjxhvh &ulplqdo &ogh zkhq vshfldo flufxpvwdqfhv edvhg oq klv lqwhuhvwv ou wkh qhhgv oi wkh fdvh vo uhtxluh dqg oqo iou dv ooqj dv wkhvh flufxpvwdqfhv shuvlvw௶ wkh shuvoq kdv wkh uljkw wo eh dffopsdqlhg ௵e dqowkhu vxlwdeoh shuvoq lqglfdwhg e klp dqg dffhswhg e wkh fopshwhqw mxglfldo dxwkoulw 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( uljkw wo uhfhlyh wklv lqioupdwloq lq vlpsoh dqg dffhvvleoh odqjxdjh dv uhfopphqghg e ‘luhfwlyh (8͵͵ͷ ,q 6ooyhqld wkhuh lv d odfn oi dowhuqdwlyh suoylvloq oi lqioupdwloq lq dq hdvwouhdg ioupdw iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv iuop wkh iluvw lqwhudfwloq zlwk oiilfldo dxwkoulwlhvxvxdoo wkh soolfh oqzdug͵͵ 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh iuhtxhqwo qow ixoo lqiouphg oi ou owkhuzlvh xqdzduh oi wkh dydlodelolw oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv 7kh &ulplqdo &ogh oi %xojduld idlov wo suoylgh dq vshflilf suoylvloqv wo hqvxuh wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh vxssouwhg lq oyhufoplqj wkh eduulhuv idfhg lq dffhvvlqj lqioupdwloq 1ou lv suoylvloq pdgh iou wkh uooh oi lqwhuphgldulhv wo dvvlvw gxulqj lqwhuuojdwloqv qou dq owkhu ioupv oi foppxqlfdwloq vxssouw͵͵ 2qo zkhq d shuvoq kdv d ௵vshhfk ou khdulqj lpsdluphqw௶ lv suoylvloq pdgh iou dffoppogdwloq lq wkh ioup oi d vljq odqjxdjh lqwhusuhwhu͵͵ͺ 7klv fuhdwhv d vlwxdwloq lq sudfwlfh zkhuh povw ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv go qow xqghuvwdqg dqwklqj deoxw wkh suofhhglqjv dqg uhsouw ihholqj fopsohwho lvoodwhg͵͵ͻ lqvwhdg oi ehlqj suoylghg lqioupdwloq deoxw wkhlu uljkwv dqg wkh suofhhglqjv ʶˢˠˠ˨ˡ˜˖˔˧˜ˢˡ ˆ˨ˣˣˢ˥˧ ,qwhuqdwloqdo +xpdq 5ljkwv /dz (yhuoqh lv hqwlwohg wo xqghuvwdqg dqg eh xqghuvwoog lq doo mxvwlfh suofhvvhv dqg suofhgxuhv vo wkdw dffhvv wo mxvwlfh lv jxdudqwhhg iou doo $uwlfoh oi wkh &53’ ghilqhv ௵foppxqlfdwloq௶ wo lqfoxgh odqjxdjhv glvsod oi wh[w %udlooh wdfwloh foppxqlfdwloq odujh sulqw dffhvvleoh pxowlphgld dv zhoo dv zulwwhq 3ouwxjxhvh &ogh oi &ulplqdo 3uofhgxuh $uwlfoh ௵ 8qohvv owkhuzlvh suoylghg iou e odz d ghihqgdqw kdv dw doo vwdjhv oi suofhhglqjv wkh uljkw wo k %h lqiouphg oq klv uljkwv e wkh mxglfldo dxwkoulw ou fulplqdo soolfh eog ehiouh zklfk kh pxvw dsshdu௶ )(1$&(5&, %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 3ouwxjdo /lveoq (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 3,& %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6ooyhqld/mxeomdqd (1$%/( 3uomhfw s phqw s $uwlfoh sdud oi wkh %xojduldq &ulplqdo &ogh $uw η oi wkh 0lqlvwu oi ,qwhuqdo $iidluv $fw .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( dxglo sodlqodqjxdjh kxpdquhdghu dqg dxjphqwdwlyh dqg dowhuqdwlyh poghv phdqv dqg ioupdwv oi foppxqlfdwloq lqfoxglqj dffhvvleoh lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloq whfkqoooj͵ͷͳ ,w dovo ghilqhv ௵odqjxdjh௶ wo lqfoxgh vsonhq dqg vljqhg odqjxdjhv dqg owkhu ioupv oi qoqvsonhq odqjxdjhv͵ͷͳ 8qghu duwlfoh oi wkh &53’ 6wdwhv duh oeoljdwhg wo xqghuwdnh ou suopowh uhvhdufk dqg ghyhoosphqw shuwdlqlqj wo wkh dydlodelolw dqg xvh oi qhz whfkqooojlhv lqfoxglqj lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloq whfkqooojlhv poelolw dlgv ghylfhv dqg dvvlvwlyh whfkqooojlhv 6xfk whfkqooojlhv pxvw eh vxlwdeoh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv jlylqj suloulw wo whfkqooojlhv dw dq diiougdeoh fovw͵ͷʹ ,q dgglwloq 6wdwhv pxvw suoylgh iou dffhvvleoh lqioupdwloq wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv deoxw poelolw dlgv ghylfhv dqg dvvlvwlyh whfkqooojlhv lqfoxglqj qhz whfkqooojlhv dv zhoo dv owkhu ioupv oi dvvlvwdqfh vxssouw vhuylfhv dqg idflolwlhv͵ͷ͵ 8qghu duwlfoh oi wkh &53’ 6wdwhv pxvw wdnh dssuosuldwh phdvxuhv wo hqvxuh wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv hqmo dffhvv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv wo wkh euodghvw sovvleoh udqjh oi vhwwlqjv $uwlfoh oi wkh &53’ ixuwkhu vshflilhv wkdw ௵7khvh phdvxuhv zklfk vkdoo lqfoxgh wkh lghqwlilfdwloq dqg holplqdwloq oi oevwdfohv dqg eduulhuv wo dffhvvlelolw vkdoo dsso wo lqwhu dold d %xloglqjv uodgv wudqvsouwdwloq dqg owkhu lqgoou dqg oxwgoou idflolwlhv lqfoxglqj vfkooov koxvlqj phglfdo idflolwlhv dqg zounsodfhv e ,qioupdwloq foppxqlfdwloqv dqg owkhu vhuylfhv lqfoxglqj hohfwuoqlf vhuylfhv dqg hphujhqf vhuylfhv௶ )ou lqvwdqfh 6wdwhv vkdoo lghqwli dqg holplqdwh wkh oevwdfohv dqg eduulhuv wo dffhvvlelolw wo foxuwv soolfh vwdwloqv ou sulvoqv 6wdwxv oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv dffhvvleoh khuh ,elg ,elg ,elg 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh lq lwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o kdv vshflilhg wkdw lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloqv whfkqoooj lqfoxghv wkh lqwhuqhw poeloh skoqhv udglo whohylvloq fopsxwhuv dqg fopsxwhu htxlsphqw͵ͷͷ 6wdwhv kdyh d gxw wo pdnh wkh lqwhuqhw dqg owkhu lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloqv whfkqoooj dffhvvleoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv͵ͷͷ 7kh &opplwwhh ixuwkhu fodulilhv wkdw duwlfoh oi wkh &53′ uhtxluhv wkdw dq sxeolf exloglqjv dqg sodfhv vkoxog suoylgh vxssouw iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj fohdu vljqv lq %udlooh dqg hdv wo xqghuvwdqg ioupdwv dqg foppxqlfdwloq dqg vxssouw vhuylfhv lqfoxglqj shosoh zko fdq jxlgh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duoxqg wkh exloglqj ou foppxqlfdwh lq vljq odqjxdjh͵ͷ $oo suofhvvhv lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp pxvw suoylgh wkh whfkqlfdo dqg owkhu vxssouw qhfhvvdu iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo xvh dq ioup oi foppxqlfdwloq qhfhvvdu͵ͷ iou wkhlu ixoo sduwlflsdwloq lqfoxglqj l dvvlvwlyh olvwhqlqj vvwhpv dqg ghylfhv xvhixo lq fdvh oi khdulqj glvdelolwlhv ͵ͷͺ ll oshq foovhg dqg uhdowlph fdswloqlqj dqg foovhg fdswloq ghfoghuv dqg ghylfhv xvhixo lq fdvh oi khdulqj glvdelolwlhv ͵ͷͻ dqg lll yolfh wh[w dqg ylghoedvhg whohfoppxqlfdwloqv suogxfwv xvhixo lq fdvh oi khdulqj glvdelolwlhv ly ylghowh[w glvsodv xvhixo lq fdvh oi khdulqj glvdelolwlhv ͵ͷͳ y vfuhhq uhdghu voiwzduh pdjqlilfdwloq voiwzduh dqg oswlfdo uhdghuv xvhixo lq fdvh oi ylvxdo glvdelolwlhv ͵ͷͳ dqg &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq $uwlfoh $ffhvvlelolw &53’&*& ,elg ,elg 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv *xlgholqhv h s )ou lqvwdqfh vhh kwwsv zzzqlgfgqlkjoykhdowkdvvlvwlyhghylfhvshosohkhdulqjyolfhvshhfkouodqjxdjhglvoughuv )ou lqvwdqfh vhh kwwsv zzzzdvklqjwoqhgxgolwzkdwgliihuhqfhehwzhhqoshqdqgfoovhgfdswloqlqj kwwsv qdwloqdoglvdelolwqdyljdwououjqgqufpdwhuldovglvdelolwjxlghfopsxwhudlghguhdowlphwudqvfulswloqfduw kwwsv zzzdieoujeolqgqhvvdqgoozylvloqxvlqjwhfkqooojxvlqjfopsxwhusduwllh[shulhqfhgfopsxwhuxvhuqhz 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( yl ylgho ghvfulswloq dqg vhfoqgdu dxglwou suojudpplqj ghylfhv wkdw slfnxs dxglo ihhgv iou whohylvloq suojudpphv xvhixo lq fdvh oi khdulqj glvdelolwlhv 6xlwdelolw oi whohskoqh dqg ylghofoqihuhqflqj vkoxog eh ghwhuplqhg oq d fdvhefdvh edvlv͵ͷʹ ,q voph lqvwdqfhv wkh zloo eh wowdoo xqvxlwdeoh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,q owkhuv wkh zloo uhtxluh poglilfdwloq oi vhwwlqjv dqg poghv dqg lq voph wkhlu xvh pd vljqlilfdqwo hqkdqfh wkh delolw oi lqglylgxdov zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo sduwlflsdwh lq ohjdo suofhvvhv ,q dgglwloq wo lqwhuphgldulhv dqg wuxvwhg shuvoqv glvfxvvhg deoyh owkhu vxssouw shuvoqv pd dvvlvw lqglylgxdov zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq d ydulhw oi zdv 6xfk shuvoqv pljkw lqfoxgh l 1owhwdnhuv zklfk pd eh xvhixo lq fdvhv oi khdulqj glvdelolwhv svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv dqg fojqlwlyh ou ohduqlqj uhodwhg glvdelolwlhv ll txdolilhg vljq odqjxdjh dqg oudo lqwhusuhwhuv xvhixo lq fdvh oi khdulqj dqg vshhfk uhodwhg glvdelolwlhv ͵ͷ͵ dqg uhod vhuylfhv xvhixo lq fdvhv oi khdulqj dqg vshhfk uhodwhg glvdelolwlhv ͵ͷͷ dqg lll wdfwloh lqwhusuhwhuv xvhixo lq fdvh oi khdulqj ou ylvxdo glvdelolwlhv͵ͷͷ 2qh oi wkh eduulhuv wo sduwlflsdwloq fdq eh wkh wsh oi odqjxdjh xvhg e wkh ohjdo vvwhp ௬ e mxgjhv ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv dqg foxuw dgplqlvwudwloq͵ͷ )ou lqvwdqfh wkh ohjdo odqjxdjh pljkw foqvwlwxwh d eduulhu iou shosoh zlwk dftxluhg eudlq lqmxu shosoh zlwk dxwlvwlf vshfwuxp glvoughu ou shosoh zlwk dq lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw (yhq li wkh ghihqgdqw kdv ehhq lghqwlilhg dv idoolqj vophzkhuh zlwklq wkhvh fdwhjoulhv wkhuh lv ,qwhuqdwloqdo &opplvvloq oi -xulvwv ௵7kh &oxuwv dqg &29,’ ௶ 0d s kwwsv qdwloqdoglvdelolwqdyljdwououjqgqufpdwhuldovglvdelolwjxlghvljqodqjxdjhlqwhusuhwhuv kwwsv qdwloqdoglvdelolwqdyljdwououjqgqufpdwhuldovglvdelolwjxlghwhohfoppxqlfdwloqvuhodvhuylfh kwwsv zigehxlqwhusuhwdwloq -xglfldo &ooohjh 8qlwhg .lqjgop ௱(txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon௲ )heuxdu s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( vwloo d qhhg wo dyolg dvvxpswloqv deoxw wkh ghihqgdqw௲v xqghuvwdqglqj dqg wo dvvhvv wkh sovvleoh gliilfxowlhv fdvh e fdvh͵ͷ &kdoohqjhv ,q 6ooydnld wkhuh lv qo ohjlvodwloq hvwdeolvklqj wkh qhhg wo pdnh suoylvloq iou hdvuhdg vljq odqjxdjh lqwhusuhwhuv %udlooh ou dq owkhu dffhvvleoh ioupv oi foppxqlfdwloq dqg wkhuh lv qo hylghqfh oi dq zlghvsuhdg sudfwlfh lq wklv uhjdug͵ͷͺ 6lploduo lq wkh &]hfk 5hsxeolf ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv jhqhudoo go qow uhfhlyh dq foppxqlfdwloq vxssouw 7kh oqo h[fhswloqv lghqwlilhg lq wkh qdwloqdo vwxg duh wkh uljkw wo dq lqwhusuhwhu lq doo fdvhv lq zklfk wkh ghihqgdqw gohv qow xqghuvwdqg &]hfk dqg wkh xvh oi ghdi dqg ghdieolqg shuvoqv foppxqlfdwloq vvwhpv lq foxuwv͵ͷͻ 7kh qdwloqdo vwxg lq 6sdlq iofxvhg oq wkh gliilfxowlhv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqg svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkhlu foqwdfw zlwk mxgjhv dqg suovhfxwouv ‘hihqgdqwv zko zhuh qow suoylghg zlwk foppxqlfdwloq vxssouw foppoqo lqglfdwhg wkdw wkh glg qow xqghuvwdqg dqwklqj zkhq txhvwloqhg e d mxgjh ou suovhfxwou͵ͳ 6xfk ghihqgdqwv kdyh fopsodlqhg wkdw mxgjhv dqg suovhfxwouv vsonh woo txlfno dqg xvhg fopsolfdwhg odqjxdjh zklfk wkh foxog qow xqghuvwdqg 2qo wzo oxw oi vhyhq oi wkh lqwhuylhzhg ghihqgdqwv ehqhilwhg iuop dq lqwhuphgldu zko wulhg wo dvvlvw wkh odzhuv lqyooyhg lq wkh fdvh wo pdnh wkh foppxqlfdwloq pouh xqghuvwdqgdeoh͵ͳ ,q 6sdlq dowkoxjk wkhuh duh hdvwouhdg wooov dydlodeoh iou zkhq soolfh ou sulvoqv duh foqiuoqwhg zlwk d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw wkhuh duh dssduhqwo qo owkhu dydlodeoh $xvwudoldq ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon dydlodeoh dw ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon mxglfldofooohjhylfhgxdx )2580 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6ooydnld 3udkd (1$%/( suomhfw s )2580 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq &]hfkld 3udkd (1$%/( suomhfw s 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,elg s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( phwkogv oi vxssouw lqyooylqj iou h[dpsoh dxjphqwdwlyh dqg dowhuqdwlyh vvwhpv oi foppxqlfdwloq ,q 5opdqld ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv idfh vlplodu foppxqlfdwloq suoeohpv 7kh 5opdqldq &lylo 3uofhgxuh &ogh gohv qow uhtxluh wkh dgdswdwloq oi odqjxdjh dqg lqioupdwloq wo dffoppogdwh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv͵͵ 0ouhoyhu lq wkh 5opdqldq &ulplqdo &ogh wkhuh lv d jhqhudo oeoljdwloq wo suoylgh lqioupdwloq wo ghihqgdqwv sulou wo wkhlu iluvw khdulqj exw wkh &ogh gohv qow vshflilfdoo uhihu wo wkh oeoljdwloq wo dgdsw wkh odqjxdjh dqg wo foppxqlfdwh wkh lqioupdwloq lq dq dffhvvleoh zd zkhq ghdolqj zlwk shuvoqv zlwk d glvdelolw 7klv lqioupdwloq ghilflw lv fopsoxqghg e wkh odfn oi lqwhuqdo uhjxodwloqv dqg suofhgxuhv wo hqvxuh wkdw wkh dffxvhg ixoo xqghuvwdqgv wkh lqioupdwloq wkh uhfhlyh͵ͷ ,q sudfwlfh ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv iuhtxhqwo go qow kdyh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo dffhvvleoh lqioupdwloq ˅˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˜ˡ˧˘˥ˣ˥˘˧˔˧˜ˢˡ ˔ˡ˗ ˧˥˔ˡ˦˟˔˧˜ˢˡ ,qwhuqdwloqdo +xpdq 5ljkwv /dz dqg (8 /dz dqg 6wdqgdugv ,&&35 $uwlfoh k suoylghv dv d plqlpxp jxdudqwhh wkdw hyhuoqh vkdoo eh hqwlwohg ௵lq ixoo htxdolw௶ ௵woo kdyh wkh iuhh dvvlvwdqfh oi dq lqwhusuhwhu li >wkh@ fdqqow xqghuvwdqg ou vshdn wkh odqjxdjh xvhg lq foxuw௶ (&+5 $uwlfoh h suoylghv iou vlplodu jxdudqwhhv 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv kdyh d uljkw wo dffhvv lqwhusuhwdwloq dqg wudqvodwloq vhuylfhv lq oughu wo hqvxuh wkhlu hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq lq wkh mxvwlfh suofhvv 6xfk lqwhusuhwdwloq dqg wudqvodwloq vhuylfhv pd eh hvshfldoo lpsouwdqw iou shuvoqv zlwk ylvxdo ou khdulqj glvdelolwlhv ,elg &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 5opdqld %xfduhvw (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,elg s 6hh duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 7kh 8qlwhg 1dwloqv 2iilfh oi wkh +ljk &opplvvloqhu iou +xpdq 5ljkwv jlyhv h[dpsohv oi zdv wkh &53’ &opplwwhh kdv vkozq wkdw suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv fdq eh pdgh wkuoxjk ௵>s@uoylvloq oi vljq odqjxdjh lqwhusuhwdwloq ohjdo dqg mxglfldo lqioupdwloq lq dffhvvleoh ioupdwv iou pxowlsoh phdqv oi foppxqlfdwloq hdv uhdg yhuvloqv oi gofxphqwv %udlooh dqg ylgho olqn whvwlpoq dpoqj owkhuv௶ $ffouglqj wo ‘luhfwlyh (8 oq wkh uljkw wo lqwhusuhwdwloq dqg wudqvodwloq lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv 6wdwhv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw vxvshfwv ou dffxvhg shuvoqv zko go qow vshdn ou xqghuvwdqg wkh odqjxdjh oi wkh fulplqdo suofhhglqjv duh suoylghg zlwk lqwhusuhwdwloq 7klv lqfoxghv wkh suoylvloq oi dvvlvwdqfh iou shuvoqv zlwk ௵khdulqj ou vshhfk lpshglphqwv௶ dv zhoo dv zulwwhq wudqvodwloq oi doo hvvhqwldo gofxphqwv wo hqvxuh wkdw wkh shuvoqv duh deoh wo h[huflvh wkhlu uljkw oi ghihqfh dqg wo vdihjxdug wkh idluqhvv oi wkh suofhhglqjv 7kh ‘luhfwlyh dssolhv wo shosoh zko uhtxluh dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouwv ehfdxvh oi dq ௵skvlfdo lpsdluphqw௶ zklfk diihfwv wkhlu delolw wo foppxqlfdwh hiihfwlyho $uwlfoh suoylghv wkdw shuvoqv vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg zko go qow vshdn ou xqghuvwdqg wkh odqjxdjh oi wkh fulplqdo suofhhglqjv pxvw eh suoylghg zlwk lqwhusuhwdwloq zlwkoxw ghod 6xfk lqwhusuhwdwloq vhuylfhv pxvw eh suoylghg iou suofhhglqjv ehiouh lqyhvwljdwlyh dqg mxglfldo dxwkoulwlhv ,w fohduo lv vxiilflhqwo euodg sduwlfxoduo li lqwhusuhwhg foqvlvwhqwo zlwk wkh &53’ wo lqfoxgh lqwhusuhwdwloq vhuylfhv uhtxluhg e shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj vljq odqjxdjh lqwhusuhwdwloq $uwlfoh suoylghv wkdw wkh uljkw wo lqwhusuhwdwloq lqfoxghv wkh suoylvloq oi dssuosuldwh dvvlvwdqfh iou shuvoqv zlwk khdulqj ou vshhfk lpshglphqwv 81 2+&+5 ௱5hsouw 5ljkw wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv௲ ’hfhpehu $+5& sdud ‘luhfwlyh (8 oi wkh (xuoshdq 3duoldphqw dqg oi wkh &oxqflo ௬ duwlfohv dqg ,elg 3uhdpeoh sdud 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 5hflwdo uhihuv wo shosoh zko duh lq ௵d sowhqwldoo zhdn sovlwloq௶ lq sduwlfxodu ehfdxvh oi dq skvlfdo lpsdluphqw zklfk diihfwv wkhlu delolw wo foppxqlfdwh hiihfwlyho͵ͻ :kloh wklv odqjxdjh lv lqdssuosuldwh dqg glvfulplqdwou lqwhusuhwhg foqvlvwhqwo zlwk wkh &53’ wkh 5hflwdo vkoxog eh xqghuvwoog wo uhtxluh wkh suoylvloqv oi lqwhusuhwdwloq vhuylfhv dv ioupv oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv qhfhvvdu wo hqvxuh htxdo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7kh ‘luhfwlyh ixuwkhu vwdwhv wkdw foppxqlfdwloq whfkqoooj vxfk dv ylghofoqihuhqflqj whohskoqlf ghylfhv ou wkh lqwhuqhw pd eh xvhg lq oughu wo jxdudqwhh wkh idluqhvv oi wkh suofhhglqj͵ͳdqg wkdw d uhjlvwhu oi dssuosuldwho txdolilhg lqwhusuhwhuv vkoxog eh hvwdeolvkhg͵ͳ $uwlfoh oi wkh ‘luhfwlyh dovo suoylghv wkdw mxglfldo vwdii pxvw eh wudlqhg lq foppxqlfdwlqj zlwk shuvoqv zko go qow vshdn ou xqghuvwdqg wkh odqjxdjh zlwk wkh dvvlvwdqfh oi dq lqwhusuhwhu $sduw iuop lqwhusuhwdwloq iou shuvoqv zlwk ௵khdulqj ou vshhfk lpshglphqwv௶ wkh ‘luhfwlyh gohv qow foqwdlq dq vshflilf vxssouw iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zlwk owkhu qhhgv 7klv devhqfh foqvwlwxwhv d oooskooh lq (8 ohjlvodwloq zklfk oxjkw wo eh gluhfwo dgguhvvhg ,uuhvshfwlyh oi wklv ghilflhqf mxvwlfh dfwouv qoqhwkhohvv pxvw dfw lq fopsoldqfh zlwk 6wdwh oeoljdwloqv xqghu wkh &53’ 7khvh vkoxog eh foqvwuxhg dqg lqwhusuhwhg lq olqh zlwk wkh &53’ &opplwwhh௲v mxulvsuxghqfh dqg wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv wo hqvxuh idlu qoqglvfulplqdwou dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv &kdoohqjhv 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv kdyh wkh uljkw wo dffhvv lqioupdwloq dqg wo foppxqlfdwh dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqj 6wdwhv pxvw wdnh doo dssuosuldwh phdvxuhv wo hqvxuh wkdw 5hflwdo ‘luhfwlyh (8 ‘luhfwlyh (8 duwlfoh ,elg duwlfoh 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv nqoz wkhlu uljkwv dqg wkh suofhgxuh dqg fdq hiihfwlyho dqg ixoo dffhvv mxvwlfh 6wdwhv go qow oqo kdyh wo jxdudqwhh wkhp dffhvv wo lqioupdwloq iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk odz hqioufhphqw dxwkoulwlhv exw wkh dovo kdyh wo dffoppogdwh doo wkhlu foppxqlfdwloq vxssouw dqg odqjxdjh qhhgv 7khuhiouh 6wdwhv pxvw jxdudqwhh foppxqlfdwloq wooov whfkqlfdo vxssouw dowhuqdwlyh ioupdwv iou gofxphqwv dqg lqioupdwloq hdvwouhdg gofxphqwv lqwhusuhwdwloq dqg wudqvodwloq vhuylfhv dqg lqwhuphgldulhv li qhhghg $ffhvv wo vshflilf suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv dqg lqwhusuhwdwloq dqg wudqvodwloq vhuylfhv lv wslfdoo yhu olplwhg lq (8 0hpehu 6wdwhv lq foqwudyhqwloq oi ohjdo oeoljdwloqv )ou lqvwdqfh lq %xojduld wkh &ulplqdo &ogh suoylghv iou d vljq odqjxdjh lqwhusuhwhu iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk ௵vshhfk ou khdulqj lpsdluphqwv௶͵ʹ $q owkhu lqwhusuhwdwloq qhhgv duh hqwluho xs wo wkh glvfuhwloq oi wkh lqyhvwljdwlqj dqg mxglfldo dxwkoulwlhv zlwk qo jxdudqwhhv iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkdw ghflvloqv lq wklv uhvshfw zloo eh pdgh lq gxh foxuvh͵͵ ,q 5opdqld wkh &ulplqdo &ogh dooozv iou fhuwdlq suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iou voph fdwhjoulhv oi shuvoqv zklfk pd lqfoxgh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv hyhq wkoxjk shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh qow h[solflwo phqwloqhg͵ͷ ,q /lwkxdqld dffouglqj wo wkh qdwloqdo vwxg͵ͷ lq vlwxdwloqv zkhuh vljq odqjxdjh lqwhusuhwdwloq zdv qhfhvvdu lw lv suoylghg $uwlfoh lwhp ௵ξ௶ oi &3& .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv &/5 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 5opdqld %xfduhvw (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq /lwkxdqld9loqlxv (1$%/( 3uomhfw $sulo s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 3udfwlfdo jxlgdqfh dqg uhfopphqgdwloqv (yhu shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw kdv wkh uljkw wo pdnh fkolfhv iou wkhpvhoyhv dqg vkoxog kdyh dffhvv wo doo wkh uhohydqw lqioupdwloq dqg vxssouw uhtxluhg wo go vo iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk odz hqioufhphqw dxwkoulwlhv 3xuvxdqw wo wklv oeoljdwloq $ ,qioupdwloq vkoxog eh vkduhg zlwk ghihqgdqwv dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv lqfoxglqj exw qow olplwhg wo wkh suhwuldo skdvh gxulqj wkh wuldo dqg sovwwuldo lqioupdwloq % ,qioupdwloq oq h[lvwlqj vxssouw uhvoxufhv dqg dffoppogdwloqv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dv zhoo dv oq koz wo dffhvv dqg xvh wkhp vkoxog eh dydlodeoh dqg fohduo foppxqlfdwhg wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv & $q dssolqwphqw oi dq lqwhuphgldu dqgou owkhu vxssouw shuvoq v vkoxog eh foqvlghuhg dqg zkhuh qhfhvvdu hiihfwxdwhg lq oughu wo vljqlilfdqwo khos lq foppxqlfdwloq dqg hqvxuh wkdw doo uhohydqw lqioupdwloq lv wudqvplwwhg wo dqg foppxqlfdwhg e wkh ghihqgdqw 7kh soolfh dxwkoulwlhv dqg owkhu mxvwlfh suoihvvloqdov pxvw hqvxuh wkdw lqglylgxdov zlwk glvdelolwlhv xqghuvwdqg wkhlu uljkwv dqg doo uhohydqw ohjdo suofhgxuhv dqg suofhvvhv -xvwlfh suoihvvloqdov pxvw hqvxuh wkdw dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh suoylghg zlwk dffhvvleoh dqg xqghuvwdqgdeoh lqioupdwloq deoxw wkhlu uljkwv lqfoxglqj $ wkh uljkw qow wo lqfulplqdwh oqhvhoi % zkdw lv olnho wo kdsshq lq wkh dssolfdeoh ohjdo suofhgxuh & wkh uxohv oi sodfhv oi ghwhqwloq dqg 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ‘ wkdw wkh fdq uho oq wkh vxssouw oi wkh sxeolf lqvwlwxwloqv vwduwlqj zlwk wkhlu iluvw foqwdfw zlwk wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp :khq vkdulqj lqioupdwloq wkh uhvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw lw lv ehlqj foppxqlfdwhg lq d zd wkdw lv dffhvvleoh wo wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk uhjdug wo wkhlu vshflilf foppxqlfdwloq qhhgv /dqjxdjh qhhgv wo eh dgdswhg wo wkh lqglylgxdo foppxqlfdwloq qhhgv $ -xvwlfh suoihvvloqdov vkoxog kdyh dffhvv wo d olvw oi foqfuhwh wooov lqfoxglqj wkh wooov iuop wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg fohdu jxlgdqfh dqg h[dpsohv oq koz wo xvh wkhp wo idflolwdwh hiihfwlyh foppxqlfdwloq zlwk lqglylgxdov zlwk glvdelolwlhv % :khuh qhfhvvdu lqioupdwloq vkoxog eh suhvhqwhg lq d vlpsolilhg fopsuhkhqvleoh hdvwoxqghuvwdqg ioupdw ou pdqqhu & 6shflilfdoo mxvwlfh dfwouv vkdoo dgdsw wkh ioooozlqj hohphqwv wkh vshhg dqg woqh oi gholyhu ohyho oi yofdexodu ohyho oi judppdu dqg wkh fopsoh[lw oi txhvwloqv :kloh dgdswlqj wkhlu odqjxdjh mxvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog dovo foqvlghu wkh ghihqgdqwv௲ delolw wo qduudwh lqghshqghqwo dqg wo xqghuvwdqg txhvwloqv uhodwhg wo wlph wkhlu oulhqwdwloq dqg glvwdqfh dqg wkhlu ohyho oi olwhudf ‘ (qvxuh wkh sdfh oi wkh suofhhglqjv lv zhoo dgmxvwhg ௬ hqvxuh iou lqvwdqfh udwkhu vkouw vhvvloqv iuhtxhqw euhdnv :ulwwhq lqioupdwloq vkoxog eh dydlodeoh lq dowhuqdwlyh ioupdwv mxvwlfh dfwouv pxvw hqvxuh wkh hodeoudwloq oi dqg suoylvloq oi dffhvv wo hdvwouhdg gofxphqwv $ffhvv $elolw $xvwudold $$$ 7kh &dslwdo 6ofldo 6wou dydlodeoh dw $ylvlwwo7kh&dslwdo6ofldo6wou9sgi dffhvvdelolwdxvwudoldfop s -xvwlfh ,qwhuphgldu 6wduwhu .lw 0ogxoh $ffoppogdwloqv s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw lqioupdwloq deoxw foxuw suofhgxuhv lqfoxglqj qowlfhv wkdw uhtxluh d uhvsoqvh ou dq dfwloq wo eh wdnhq lqfoxglqj vxppoqvhv vxesohqdv zulwv oughuv dqg vhqwhqfhv lv suoylghg lq dffhvvleoh ioupdwv 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv hqvxuh wkdw doo foxuw suofhvvhv suoylgh wkh whfkqlfdo dqg owkhu vxssouw qhfhvvdu iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo xvh dq ioup oi foppxqlfdwloq qhfhvvdu iou wkhlu ixoo sduwlflsdwloq 7khvh ioupv oi foppxqlfdwloq pd dpoqj owkhuv uhtxluh wkh xvh oi $ dvvlvwlyh olvwhqlqj vvwhpv dqg ghylfhv % oshq foovhg dqg uhdowlph fdswloqlqj dqg foovhg fdswloq ghfoghuv dqg ghylfhv & yolfh wh[w dqg ylghoedvhg whohfoppxqlfdwloqv suogxfwv ‘ ylghowh[w glvsodv ( fopsxwhudvvlvwhg uhdowlph wudqvfulswloq ) vfuhhq uhdghu voiwzduh pdjqlilfdwloq voiwzduh dqg oswlfdo uhdghuv dqg * ylgho ghvfulswloq dqg vhfoqgdu dxglwou suojudpplqj ghylfhv wkdw slfn xs dxglo ihhgv iou whohylvloq suojudpv 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog suoylgh foppxqlfdwloq vxssouw lqfoxglqj wkuoxjk wklugsduwlhv iou h[dpsoh $ffhvvleoh ioupdwv lqfoxgh 6ljq odqjxdjh 9lgho dqg dxglo jxlghv 7hohskoqh olqh dgylfh dqg uhihuudo vhuylfhv $ffhvvleoh zhevlwhv ,qgxfwloq ooos udglo ou lqiuduhg vvwhpv &oovhg fdswloqlqj %udlooh (dv 5hdg dqg sodlq odqjxdjh )dflolwdwhg foppxqlfdwloq dqg dpsolilfdwloq ghylfhv dqg gofxphqw pdjqlilhuv 7khvh lqfoxgh $vvlvwlyh olvwhqlqj vvwhpv dqg ghylfhv 2shq foovhg dqg uhdowlph fdswloqlqj dqg foovhg fdswloq ghfoghuv dqg ghylfhv 9olfh wh[w dqg ylghoedvhg whohfoppxqlfdwloqv suogxfwv 9lghowh[w glvsodv &opsxwhudvvlvwhg uhdowlph wudqvfulswloq 6fuhhq uhdghu voiwzduh pdjqlilfdwloq voiwzduh dqg oswlfdo uhdghuv 9lgho ghvfulswloq dqg vhfoqgdu dxglwou suojudpplqj ghylfhv wkdw slfn xs dxglo ihhgv iou whohylvloq suojudpphv 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( $ qowhwdnhuv % txdolilhg vljq odqjxdjh dqg oudo lqwhusuhwhuv & uhod vhuylfhv dqg ‘ wdfwloh lqwhusuhwhuv zkhuh dqg zkhq qhfhvvdu 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog suoylgh mxvwlfh suoihvvloqdov zlwk foppxqlfdwloq wooov wo xvh lq foppxqlfdwloq zlwk shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv )ou lqvwdqfh $ wkh $$& slfwojudpv euozvhu dqg dq h[dpsoh oi xvh % dq h[dpsoh oi d ௵foppxqlfdwloq eodug௶ & hdvwouhdg jxlgholqhv dqgg ‘ koz wo zulwh d vofldo vwou dqg dq h[dpsoh oi xvh 7kh uljkw wo lqwhusuhwdwloq dqg wudqvodwloq vkoxog eh ixoiloohg dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv 7udqvodwouv lqwhusuhwhuv dqg lqwhuphgldulhv sod gliihuhqw uoohv exw vophwlphv dq lqwhuphgldu fdq eh khosixo lq ixoiloolqj wkh uljkw wo lqwhusuhwdwloq dqg wudqvodwloq $udjoqhvh &hqwhu oi $xjphqwdwlyh dqg $owhuqdwlyh &oppxqlfdwloq $5$6$$& zhevlwh dydlodeoh dw $$& 6peoov dqg vkduhg uhvoxufhv $5$6$$& wkh $xjphqwdwlyh dqg $owhuqdwlyh 6vwhpv oi &oppxqlfdwloq $$& duh zdv oi h[suhvvloq gliihuhqw iuop vsonhq odqjxdjh wkdw dlp dw lqfuhdvlqj dqgou fopshqvdwlqj iou wkh gliilfxowlhv oi foppxqlfdwloq dqg odqjxdjh oi pdq shosoh zlwk glvdelolwlhv )ou lqvwdqfh wkh fdq eh xvhg wo ehwwhu foppxqlfdwh zlwk shuvoqv suhvhqwlqj fhuheudo sdov &3 lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw dxwlvp vshfwuxp glvoughuv $6’ qhxuooojlfdo glvhdvhv vxfk dv dpowuosklf odwhudo vfohuovlv $/6 pxowlsoh vfohuovlv 06 ou 3dunlqvoq௲v glvhdvh pxvfxodu gvwuosklhv wudxpdwlf eudlq lqmxulhv dskdvldv 2+&+5 0dnlqj vxuh shosoh zlwk glvdelolwlhv jhw mxvwlfh (dv5hdg yhuvloq oi ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dydlodeoh dw ,6/ (5 81 $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh okfkuouj $ffhvv $elolw $xvwudold $$$ &oppxqlfdwloq %odug :ounvkosv dqg 0hhwlqjv &oppxqlfdwloq eodugv xvh vpeoov wo vkduh lghdv zdqwv qhhgv dqg wkoxjkwv dvvlvwlqj lqglylgxdov zlwk foppxqlfdwloq fkdoohqjhv 7kh duh wslfdoo xvhg zlwk shuvoqv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolwlhv dxwlvp vshfwuxp ohduqlqj glvdelolwlhv wudxpdwlf eudlq lqmxulhv ghphqwld ou ghdiqhvv 0hqfds $p , pdonlqj pvhoi fohdu” 0hqfds௲v jxlgholqhv iou dffhvvleoh zulwlqj dydlodeoh dw jxlgholqhvbioubdffhvvleohbzulwlqjsgi ixqglqjvsouwfoxn )ou lqvwdqfh wkh fdq eh hpsoohg wo foppxqlfdwh zlwk shosoh zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolwlhv ohduqlqj glvdelolwlhv ou dxwlvp vshfwuxp $xwlvp 6huylfhv (gxfdwloq 5hvoxufhv dqg 7udlqlqj $6(57 zhevlwh dydlodeoh dw +oz wo &uhdwh d 6ofldo 6wou ௭ 3$$xwlvpouj dq $6(57 $xwlvp 5hvoxufh *xlgh 6ofldo vwoulhv khos shosoh wo uhdfw wo vofldo vlwxdwloqv wkdw dp eh fkdoohqjlqj olnh dsshdulqj lq foxuw ehlqj ghwdlqhg ou ehlqj duuhvwhg 7kh duh wslfdoo xvhg wo foppxqlfdwh zlwk shosoh zlwk dxwlvp vshfwuxp $ffhvv $elolw $xvwudold $$$ 7kh &dslwdo 6ofldo 6wou 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 6vwhplf uhfopphqgdwloqv 7kh uhvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog dfw wo hqvxuh wkdw doo foppxqlfdwloq vxssouw shuvoqv duh deoh wo lqwhusuhw hiihfwlyho dffxudwho dqg lpsduwldoo eowk uhfhswlyho xqghuvwdqglqj zkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh vdlqj dqg h[suhvvlyho kdylqj wkh vnloo qhfhvvdu wo foqyh lqioupdwloq edfn wo wkovh shuvoqv zkloh xvlqj dq qhfhvvdu vshfldol]hg yofdexodu vxfk dv ohjdo ou phglfdo odqjxdjh dqg uhvshfwlqj suoihvvloqdo dqg hwklfdo vwdqgdugv 7kh uhvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog dfw wo suoylgh iou dghtxdwh wudlqlqj oq foppxqlfdwloq wooov dqg phwkogv iou doo mxvwlfh suoihvvloqdov lqfoxglqj e hqvxulqj wkh odqjxdjh eduulhu lv oyhufoph wkuoxjk wudlqlqj oi mxvwlfh dfwouv dv zhoo dv wudlqlqj oq wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oi wkh doo owkhu uhohydqw suoihvvloqdov olnh lqwhusuhwhuv dqg lqwhuphgldulhv ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˣ˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ $ffouglqj wo wkh $xvwudoldq ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon dq hdv zd wo dyolg wklv odqjxdjh eduulhu lv wo dyolg xvlqj ohjdo whuplqoooj dqg wo xvh lqvwhdg foqfuhwh dqg sodlq odqjxdjh )ou lqvwdqfh wkh mxgjhv dqg ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv vkoxog xvh wkh yhue ௵wo iooooz௶ lqvwhdg oi wkh yhue ௵wo fopso௶ -xgjhv dqg ohjdo sudfwlwloqhuv vkoxog dovo h[sodlq sduwlfxodu whupv dqg fkhfn gxulqj wkh khdulqj zkhwkhu wkh ghihqgdqw xqghuvwdqgv wkh phdqlqj oi vshflilf zougv ͵ͺ $xvwudoldq ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon dydlodeoh dw ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon mxglfldofooohjhylfhgxdx 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ʶʡ ˅˜˚˛˧ ˢ˙ ˔˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ˔ ˟˔˪ˬ˘˥ ˔ˡ˗ ˧ˢ ˟˘˚˔˟ ˔˜˗ ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ʻ˨ˠ˔ˡ ˅˜˚˛˧˦ ʿ˔˪ ˔ˡ˗ ʸˈ ʿ˔˪ ˔ˡ˗ ˆ˧˔ˡ˗˔˥˗˦ ,qwhuqdwloqdo +xpdq 5ljkwv /dz 7kh ,&&35 lq duwlfoh g suoylghv iou wkh uljkw wo ghihqg oqh௲v vhoi ௵lq shuvoq ou wkuoxjk ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh oi >oqh௲v@ ozq fkoovlqj wo eh lqiouphg li >oqh@ gohv qow kdyh ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh oi wklv uljkw dqg wo kdyh ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh dvvljqhg wo >wkhp@ lq dq fdvh zkhuh wkh lqwhuhvwv oi mxvwlfh vo uhtxluh dqg zlwkoxw sdphqw e >wkhp@ lq dq vxfk fdvh li >wkh@ gohv qow kdyh vxiilflhqw phdqv wo sd iou lw௶ 7klv lqfoxghv dw suhwuldo skdvhv 7kh (&+5 uhfojql]hv wkh uljkw oi dffhvv wo d odzhu dqg wo ohjdo dlg lq lwv duwlfoh $uwlfoh f suoylghv iou hyhuoqh fkdujh zlwk d fulplqdo oiihqfh wkh uljkw ௵wo ghihqg klpvhoi lq shuvoq ou wkuoxjk ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh oi klv ozq fkoovlqj ou li kh kdv qow vxiilflhqw phdqv wo sd iou ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh wo eh jlyhq lw iuhh zkhq wkh lqwhuhvwv oi mxvwlfh vo uhtxluh >@௶ 8qghu wkh &53′ doo shuvoqv kdyh d uljkw wo htxdolw dqg htxdo wuhdwphqw ehiouh wkh foxuwv dqg wulexqdov dqg pouh jhqhudoo lq doo mxvwlfh suofhvvhv dqg suofhgxuhv 6wdwhv kdyh ohjdo oeoljdwloqv wo hqvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv (yhu shuvoq zko lv duuhvwhg ou ghwdlqhg zkhwkhu ou qow wkh duh ghwdlqhg oq d fulplqdo fkdujh dqg hyhu lqglylgxdo idflqj d fulplqdo fkdujh zkhwkhu ou qow wkh duh ghwdlqhg kdv wkh uljkw wo wkh dvvlvwdqfh oi ohjdo foxqvho 7kh dvvlvwdqfh oi foxqvho lv oqh oi wkh sulpdu phdqv oi suowhfwlqj wkh kxpdq uljkwv oi lqglylgxdov dffxvhg oi fulplqdo oiihqfhv dqg lq sduwlfxodu wkhlu uljkw wo d idlu wuldo :khwkhu ou qow lqglylgxdov duh dvvlvwhg e d odzhu oiwhq ghwhuplqhv zkhwkhu ou qow wkh fdq sduwlflsdwh lq ohjdo suofhhglqjv lq d phdqlqjixo zd &53’ duwlfohu $uwlfoh ,&&35 $uwlfoh &53’ +5& *hqhudo &opphqw sdud +5& *hqhudo &opphqw i 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ˃˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘˦ ˔ˡ˗ ʺ˨˜˗˘˟˜ˡ˘˦ ˢˡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ʽ˨˦˧˜˖˘ ˙ˢ˥ ˃˘˥˦ˢˡ˦ ˪˜˧˛ ʷ˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ 3ulqflsoh ௵3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv kdyh wkh uljkw wo iuhh ou diiougdeoh ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh௶ *xlgholqhv 7o jxdudqwhh wkh uljkw wo d idlu wuldo 6wdwhv vkdoo suoylgh iuhh ou diiougdeoh ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq doo ohjdo suofhgxuhv dqg suofhhglqjv wkdw uhodwh wo yloodwloqv oi kxpdq uljkwv ou ixqgdphqwdo iuhhgopv ou wkovh wkdw foxog qhjdwlyho diihfw vxfk uljkwv ou iuhhgopv lq sduwlfxodu wkh uljkwv wo olih olehuw shuvoqdo lqwhjulw suoshuw dghtxdwh koxvlqj ghflvloqpdnlqj dxwoqop dqg idplo lqwhjulw /hjdo dvvlvwdqfh pxvw eh fopshwhqw dqg dydlodeoh lq d wlpho pdqqhu iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo sduwlflsdwh htxdoo lq dq ohjdo suofhhglqjv 7o wkdw hqg 6wdwhv vkdoo d (qdfw dqg lpsohphqw odzv uhjxodwloqv soolflhv jxlgholqhv dqg sudfwlfhv diiouglqj wkh uljkw wo ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh lq doo mxglfldo dqg txdvlmxglfldo suofhhglqjv uhjdugohvv oi wkh uooh oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh suofhvv ou wkh sovvleoh foqvhtxhqfhv ou oxwfophv g (qvxuh lq dgglwloq wo ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh dffhvv wo ohjdo dgylfh wkuoxjk iou h[dpsoh whohskoqh ou gljlwdo jdwhzd vhuylfhv sdudohjdo vhuylfhv dqg oqolqh ohjdo khos vhuylfhv xvlqj dvvlvwlyh whfkqoooj dv qhfhvvdu h 5hshdo ou dphqg dq odzv uhjxodwloqv soolflhv jxlgholqhv ou sudfwlfhv wkdw uhvwulfw wkh ohjdo fdsdflw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo uhwdlq dqg lqvwuxfw d odzhu i (qvxuh hdv dffhvv wo ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh uhpoylqj doo dgplqlvwudwlyh foppxqlfdwloq dqg skvlfdo eduulhuv wo vxfk dffhvv k 0dnh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv vxfk dv lqwhusuhwhuv dvvlvwlyh whfkqoooj dqg lqwhuphgldulhv dqg idflolwdwouv ou wkh uhvoxufhv qhfhvvdu wo oewdlq vxfk dffoppogdwloqv dydlodeoh wo odzhuv wo vxssouw hiihfwlyh foppxqlfdwloq zlwk folhqwv zlwqhvvhv dqg owkhu shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh glvfkdujh oi wkhlu suoihvvloqdo gxwlhv 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( /hjdo dlg pxvw eh dydlodeoh iou doo wkovh zko fdqqow diioug wo sd iou ohjdo vhuylfhv ͵ͻͳ 6wdwhv vkoxog lpsohphqw odzv dqg soolflhv wkdw hqvxuh wkdw wkh lqioupdwloq qhhghg e shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo ghihqg wkhlu uljkwv lv dffhvvleoh dqg wkdw iuhh dqg diiougdeoh ohjdo dlg lv suoylghg wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq doo ohjdo pdwwhuv͵ͻͳ $v wkh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv fodulilhg ௵/hjdo dlg lv dq hvvhqwldo hohphqw oi d idlu kxpdqh dqg hiilflhqw vvwhp oi dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh wkdw lv edvhg oq wkh uxoh oi odz ,w lv d ioxqgdwloq iou wkh hqmophqw oi owkhu uljkwv lqfoxglqj wkh uljkw wo d idlu wuldo dqg wkh uljkw wo dq hiihfwlyh uhphg d suhfoqglwloq wo h[huflvlqj vxfk uljkwv dqg dq lpsouwdqw vdihjxdug wkdw hqvxuhv ixqgdphqwdo idluqhvv dqg sxeolf wuxvw lq wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh௶͵ͻʹ 7kh ,&&35 suoylghv iou wkh uljkw oi dffxvhg shuvoqv wo fkoovh wkhlu odzhu dqg uhfojql]hv wkhlu uljkw wo eh lqiouphg oi wkhlu uljkw wo ohjdo dlg 0ouhoyhu lqglylgxdov zko go qow kdyh dffhvv wo ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh kdyh wkh uljkw wo iuhh ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh ௵lq dq fdvh zkhuh wkh lqwhuhvwv oi mxvwlfh vo uhtxluh௶ dqg zkhuh vxfk lqglylgxdov fdqqow diioug wo sd iou d odzhu͵ͻ͵ $uwlfoh f (&+5 dovo uhfojql]hv wkh uljkw oi wkh dffxvhg shuvoqv wo fkoovh wkhlu odzhu dqg wkhlu uljkw wo iuhh ohjdo dlg lq fdvh wkh go qow kdyh vxiilflhqw phdqv wo sd iou ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh 7kh duwlfoh oi wkh (8 &kduwhu oi )xqgdphqwdo 5ljkwv suoylghv wkdw ௵>@ /hjdo dlg vkdoo eh pdgh dydlodeoh wo wkovh zko odfn vxiilflhqw uhvoxufhv lq vo idu dv vxfk dlg lv qhfhvvdu wo hqvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh௶ ,q lwv *hqhudo &opphqw wkh &53’ &opplwwhh kdg diiluphg wkdw hiihfwlyh hqmophqw oi wkh uljkwv wo htxdolw dqg qoqglvfulplqdwloq fdoov iou wkh dgoswloq oi hqioufhphqw 81 +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh 5ljkw wo htxdolw ehiouh foxuwv dqg wulexqdov dqg wo d idlu wuldo &&35&*& sdud 81 2+&+5 ௱5hsouw 5ljkw wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv௲ ’hfhpehu $+5& sdud 5hsouw oi wkh 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh lqghshqghqfh oi mxgjhv dqg odzhuv /hjdo dlg 81 ‘of $+5& $sulo ,&&35 duwlfoh g 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( phdvxuhv vxfk dv ௵>v@xiilflhqw dqg dffhvvleoh suoylvloq oi ohjdo dlg wo hqvxuh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou wkh fodlpdqw lq glvfulplqdwloq olwljdwloq௶͵ͻͷ $iiougdeoh txdolw ohjdo dlg pxvw dovo eh dydlodeoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq uhodwloq wo hiihfwlyh uhguhvv phfkdqlvpv dqg wo hqvxuh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh͵ͻͷ 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv wkhuhiouh suhvfulehg wkdw ௵dssuosuldwh dqg >@ diiougdeoh txdolw ohjdo dlg௶ eh oiihuhg wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq d phdqv dqg phulwvwhvwhg edvlv͵ͻ (ovhzkhuh wkh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv dovo suoylghg ixuwkhu jxlgdqfh oq wklv uljkw hpskdvl]lqj wkh lpsouwdqfh oi wudlqlqj oi mxvwlfh dfwouv lq uhvshfwlyh oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv ௵2q wkh txhvwloq oi wkh uljkw oi dffhvv wo ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwloq suoshu foqvlghudwloq vkoxog eh jlyhq wo duwlfohv l dqg oi wkh &53’ lq oughu wo wudlq sxeolf dqg sulydwh ghihqghuv mxgjhv suovhfxwouv dqg sulvoq vwdii wo suoshuo dsso wkh uhohydqw suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wo jlyh dffhvv wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv wo wkh jhqhudo suofhgxuhv suoylghg lq qdwloqdo ohjlvodwloq $ovo wkhuh qhhgv wo eh dq dzduhqhvv oi wkh lqvwdqfhv lq zklfk fhuwdlq sudfwlfhv oi wkh fulplqdo vvwhp djdlqvw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog eh foqvlghuhg dv d ioup oi wouwxuh dqg loowuhdwphqw௶ ͵ͻ $ffouglqj wo 3ulqflsoh oi wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv 6wdwhv vkoxog ௵ fuhdwh ixqg dqg lpsohphqw ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh suojudpphv wo suoylgh iuhh ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwloq wo shuvoqv zko fdqqow diioug wo uhwdlq ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh lqfoxglqj shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv >@௶͵ͻͺ 7kh vdph 3ulqflsoh lqglfdwhv wkdw ohjdo dlg lv dffhvvleoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dw foqglwloqv dv idyoxudeoh dv wkh oqhv iou shuvoqv zlwkoxw glvdelolwlhv &53’ *hqhudo &opphqw 1o sdud j ,elg sdud k &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௵*hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq htxdolw dqg qoqglvfulplqdwloq௶ &53’&*& $sulo sdud k 2evhuydwloqv oq wkh 6wdqgdug 0lqlpxp 5xohv iou wkh 7uhdwphqw oi 3ulvoqhuv suhsduhg e wkh &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv sdud 81 ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 3ulqflsoh e 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 8qghu wkh 3ulqflsoh 6wdwhv vkoxog sd vshfldo dwwhqwloq wo jxdudqwhh ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zko duh ylfwlpv oi yloohqfh͵ͻͻ ,q wkh fdvh oi 1hqoy y %xojduld zklfk foqfhuqhg dq dssolfdqw gldjqovhg zlwk vfkl]oskuhqld wkh (&w+5 khog wkdw idloxuh wo suoylgh ohjdo dlg wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zoxog yloodwh wkhlu uljkw wo d idlu wuldo zkhuh vxfk dq lqglylgxdo kdv gliilfxow xqghuvwdqglqj wkh mxglfldo suofhhglqjv wkxv suhyhqwlqj wkhp iuop dghtxdwho hqvxulqj wkh suowhfwloq oi wkhlu lqwhuhvwvͷͳͳ ,q olqh zlwk wkh &53’ wklv suhfhghqw vkoxog eh dssolhg pouh euodgo wo doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq sduwlfxodu (8 /dz dqg 6wdqgdugv 7klv 3ulqflsoh lv dovo jxdudqwhhg e duwlfoh oi wkh (8 &kduwhu wkuoxjk wkh suoylvloq oi ohjdo dlg e d vxlwdeo txdolilhg dqg h[shulhqfhg odzhu 6xfk uhsuhvhqwdwloq fdq vhuyh dv wkh eulgjh oi foppxqlfdwloq dqg lqioupdwloq iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg fdq li wkh odzhu lq txhvwloq kdv dssuosuldwh nqozohgjh dqg h[shulhqfh lq foppxqlfdwlqj zlwk dqg uhsuhvhqwlqj shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv eh wkh vlqjoh povw lpsouwdqw idfwou wo hqvxuh wkhlu hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloqͷͳͳ 7klv vkoxog eh foqvlghuhg lq dgglwloq wo wkh uljkw wo owkhu dssuosuldwh vxssouw shuvoqv vxfk dv lqwhuphgldulhv dv glvfxvvhg deoyh $ ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwlyh uhjdugohvv oi xqghuvwdqglqj dqg h[shulhqfh fdqqow e lwvhoi uhsodfh wkh uooh oi doo owkhu vxssouw shuvoqv ‘luhfwlyh (8 oq wkh uljkw oi dffhvv wo d odzhu lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv vhwv oxw wkh plqlpxp vwdqgdugv foqfhuqlqj wkh uljkwv oi vxvshfwv dqg dffxvhg shuvoqv $ffxvhg dqg vxvshfwhg shuvoqv pxvw hqmo wkh uljkw wo dffhvv wo d odzhu kdyh d wklug sduw lqiouphg oi wkh ghsulydwloq oi olehuw dqg kdyh wkh phdqv wo foppxqlfdwh zlwkoxw xqgxh ghod zlwk wklug shuvoqv dqg zlwk foqvxodu dxwkoulwlhv zkloh ghsulyhg oi ,elg 3ulqflsoh f dqg n 1hqoy y %xojduld (&w+5 $ssolfdwloq qo sdud 9dolglw )oxqgdwloq +xpdqlvlqj -xvwlfh ,qwhuqdwloqdo uhsouw iuop 9olfhv iou -xvwlfh &oppxqlfdwlqj zlwk 9lfwlpv oi &ulph zlwk ‘lvdelolw s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( olehuw $v solqwhg oxw e wkh (xuoshdq &opplvvloq ௵li d yxoqhudeoh shuvoq lv xqdeoh wo xqghuvwdqg dqg iooooz wkh suofhhglqjv wkh uljkw wo dffhvv wo d odzhu lq dffougdqfh zlwk ‘luhfwlyh (8 vkoxog qow eh zdlyhg௶ 7klv xqgoxewhgo dssolhv wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv $ffouglqj wo (8 ‘luhfwlyh 0hpehu 6wdwhv ௵vkdoo hqvxuh wkdw vxvshfwv dqg dffxvhg shuvoqv zko odfn vxiilflhqw uhvoxufhv wo sd iou wkh dvvlvwdqfh oi d odzhu kdyh wkh uljkw wo ohjdo dlg zkhq wkh lqwhuhvwv oi mxvwlfh vo uhtxluh௶ͷͳ͵ )xuwkhupouh lq whupv oi 5hflwdo ௵>@ 0hpehu 6wdwhv vkoxog uhvshfw dqg jxdudqwhh wkh uljkwv vhw oxw lq wklv ‘luhfwlyh zlwkoxw dq glvfulplqdwloq edvhg oq dq juoxqg vxfk dv >@ glvdelolw௶ͷͳͷ &kdoohqjhv *lyhq wkh oevwdfohv ghvfulehg deoyh odzhuv duh vophwlphv eh wkh oqo shuvoqv lq wkh mxglfldo vvwhp zko zloo eh lq d sovlwloq wo suoylgh dghtxdwh dvvlvwdqfh wo wkh ghihqgdqw gxulqj wkh fulplqdo suofhhglqj 7kh wkhuhiouh kdyh dq lpsouwdqw vxssouwlyh uooh wo sod wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7kh qhhg wo dsso iou ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh fdq eh d vhuloxv dgplqlvwudwlyh exughq iou dq lqglylgxdo dqg hvshfldoo iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv uhqghulqj ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh lqdffhvvleohͷͳͷ /dzhuv pd dovo eh ehvw sovlwloqhg wo lqioup dq dffxvhgghihqgdqw zlwk d glvdelolw dqgou mxvwlfh dfwouv oi wkhlu folhqw௲v qhhg iou dqg uljkw wo suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wo hqvxuh wkhlu hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh :khuh owkhu vxssouw shuvoqv duh qow &opplvvloq 5hfopphqgdwloq & oq suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv iou yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv vhfwloq ௬ 5ljkwv oi yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv 5ljkw oi dffhvv wo d odzhu sdud $uwlfoh ,elg 5hflwdo 7klv ‘luhfwlyh vkoxog dsso wo vxvshfwv dffxvhg shuvoqv dqg uhtxhvwhg shuvoqv uhjdugohvv oi wkhlu ohjdo vwdwxv flwl]hqvkls ou qdwloqdolw 0hpehu 6wdwhv vkoxog uhvshfw dqg jxdudqwhh wkh uljkwv vhw oxw lq wklv ‘luhfwlyh zlwkoxw dq glvfulplqdwloq edvhg oq dq juoxqg vxfk dv udfh foooxu vh[ vh[xdo oulhqwdwloq odqjxdjh uholjloq soolwlfdo ou owkhu oslqloq qdwloqdolw hwkqlf ou vofldo ouljlq suoshuw glvdelolw ou eluwk 7klv ‘luhfwlyh xskoogv wkh ixqgdphqwdo uljkwv dqg sulqflsohv uhfojqlvhg e wkh &kduwhu dqg e wkh (&+5 lqfoxglqj wkh suoklelwloq oi wouwxuh dqg lqkxpdq ou ghjudglqj wuhdwphqw wkh uljkw wo olehuw dqg vhfxulw uhvshfw iou sulydwh dqg idplo olih wkh uljkw wo wkh lqwhjulw oi wkh shuvoq wkh uljkwv oi wkh fklog wkh lqwhjudwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkh uljkw wo dq hiihfwlyh uhphg dqg wkh uljkw wo d idlu wuldo wkh suhvxpswloq oi lqqofhqfh dqg wkh uljkwv oi wkh ghihqfh 7klv ‘luhfwlyh vkoxog eh lpsohphqwhg lq dffougdqfh zlwk wkovh uljkwv dqg sulqflsohv ,elg s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( dydlodeoh foqwudu wo wkh uhtxluhphqwv oi wkh &53’ odzhuv pd eh ehvw sovlwloqhg wo dgylvh dffxvhgghihqgdqwv oi wkhlu uljkw wo fkdoohqjh wkh idluqhvv oi wkh ohjdo suofhvv dqg sowhqwldoo vhhn wo kdyh lw ghfoduhg xqodzixo 7kh odfn oi vshfldol]hg nqozohgjh dpoqj odzhuv fdq vxevwdqwldoo diihfw wkh idwh oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq jhqhudo dqg wkdw oi lqglylgxdov zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq sduwlfxodu 7kh odzhu kdv d sulpdu uhvsoqvlelolw wo hqvxuh wkdw wkh kxpdq uljkwv dqg ixqgdphqwdo iuhhgopv oi wkhlu folhqw duh uhvshfwhg dqg vxevwdqwldo wudlqlqj lv qhhghg wo hqvxuh wkhlu delolw wo go vo 7kh (8 /dz dqg 6wdqgdugv suoylghv iou wkh uljkw wo d odzhu exw hvwdeolvkhv olwwoh wo qo jxlgdqfh wo odzhuv dqg mxvwlfh dfwouv zkhq wkh ghihqgdqw lv d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw )ou lqvwdqfh lq %xojduld wkhuh lv qo vhw oi uxohv uhjxodwloqv ou jxlgholqhv wkdw joyhuq d odzhuv uhvsoqvlelolwlhv zkhq wkhlu folhqw kdv d glvdelolw dqg wkhuh duh qo vshfldo nqozohgjh ou h[shulhqfh uhtxluhphqwv iou odzhuv zko zoun zlwk shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhvͷͳ (yhq zkhuh ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh suoylghg zlwk d odzhu wkh duh foppoqo lqwhuylhzhg e wkh soolfh dqg vophwlphv hyhq duuhvwhg ou kovslwdol]hg lq svfkldwulf lqvwlwxwloqv ehiouh wkh dffhvv dq ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwloqͷͳ 7khvh duh suofhvvhv lq zklfk wkh vhuylfhv oi d odzhu duh oiwhq fulwlfdo lq vhfxulqj wkh suowhfwloq oi wkhlu uljkwv dqg wkh h[suhvvloq oi wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw ,q 5opdqld ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh iou vxvshfwv ou ghihqgdqwv lv fopsxovou zkhuh wkh duh sodfhg lq phglfdo foqilqhphqw ehfdxvh d mxglfldo eog foqvlghuv vxfk shuvoqv zoxog qow eh deoh wo ghihqg wkhpvhoyhv dqg lq fdvhv zkhuh wkh odz suoylghv olih lpsulvoqphqw ou lpsulvoqphqw iou pouh wkdq ilyh hduv iou wkh oiihqfh fopplwwhgͷͳͺ ,q .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,elg s $uwlfoh sdud 0dqgdwou ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh suoylghg wo d vxvshfw ou ghihqgdqw &ulplqdo fogh 5opdqld &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 5opdqld %xfduhvw (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( sudfwlfh kozhyhu qow doo vxfk ghihqgdqwv kdyh suopsw gluhfw dqg foqilghqwldo dffhvv wo d odzhu ehiouh wkhlu lqwhuuojdwloqͷͳͻ ,q jhqhudo ohjdo dlg lv qow dozdv dydlodeoh hvshfldoo iou shosoh zko kdyh ehhq lpsulvoqhg 6oph shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv kdyh uhsouwhg dq lqdelolw wo dffhvv d odzhu ehfdxvh wkh ihhv dqg fovwv oi ohjdo vhuylfhv duh xqdiiougdeohͷͳͳ 6ophwlphv suoeohpv duh dovo hqfoxqwhuhg zkhq wkh odzhuv duh fkdqjhg gxulqj dq oqjolqj suofhhglqj 6oph ghihqgdqwv hyhq kdg d gliihuhqw odzhu dw hdfk mxglfldo whup dqg wkh glg qow kdyh wkh ossouwxqlw wo phhw wkhlu odzhu ehiouh wkh khdulqjͷͳͳ ,q 6ooyhqld ohjdo dlg ghshqgv oq ilqdqfldo flufxpvwdqfhv oi d ghihqgdqw ou wkhlu idplo $owkoxjk h[fhswloqdo ohjdo dlg fdq eh judqwhg wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq voph flufxpvwdqfhv wkh fulwhuld dqg ilqdqfldo wkuhvkoog duh vhw woo kljk hiihfwlyho ghsulylqj pdq shuvoqv lq qhhg oi vxfk vxssouw oi dffhvv wo ohjdo dlgͷͳʹ /hjdo dlg lv dovo dssduhqwo lqvxiilflhqw lq /lwkxdqldͷͳ͵ 2q oqh kdqg ghihqgdqwv kdyh qowhg d sudfwlfdo glvwlqfwloq ehwzhhq sulydwh dqg h[ oiilflo ௵joyhuqphqw௶ odzhuv dqg uhsouw h[shulhqfhv wkdw joyhuqphqw odzhuv oiwhq go qow jlyh ixoo dwwhqwloq wo wkhlu folhqwv go qow suoylgh wkhp zlwk vxiilflhqw lqioupdwloq dqg duh qow shufhlyhg wo eh ௵oq wkhlu vlgh௶ 2q wkh owkhu kdqg dffouglqj wo wkh &ulplqdo 3uofhgxudo &ogh wkhuh duh vlwxdwloqv lq zklfk ohjdo dlg lv judqwhg wo wkh vxvshfwv dqg ghihqgdqwv uhjdugohvv oi wkhlu ilqdqfldo vwdwxv )ou lqvwdqfh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh uhtxluhg wo kdyh ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwloq zkhq lw lv lq wkh lqwhuhvwv oi mxvwlfh iou vxfk suoylvloq wo eh pdgh ,q wkh foqwh[w oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wklv phdqv wkdw vxfk dffhvv lv oqo fopsxovou zkhuh wkh ,elg s &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv &/5 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 5opdqld %xfduhvw (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,elg s 3,& %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6ooyhqld/mxeomdqd (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq /lwkxdqld9loqlxv (1$%/( 3uomhfw $sulo s ,elg s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( glvdelolw kdv ehhq ioupdoo ௵gldjqovhg௶ dqg lv oq wkh uhfoug 7kh ௵fopsxovou௶ ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv e vshflilf odzhuv djdlqvw wkh zloo dqg suhihuhqfh oi dq lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw lv qow dozdv dqg dssuosuldwh sudfwlfh uhtxluhg lq doo flufxpvwdqfhvͷͳͷ ,q 3ouwxjdo wkh odz ioupdoo jxdudqwhhv ohjdo dlg iou vxvshfwv dqg dffxvhg shuvoqv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjvͷͳ+ozhyhu wkhuh duh owkhu fkdoohqjhv wkdw fdq klqghu wkh hiihfwlyh h[huflvh oi wklv uljkw oi dffhvv wo d odzhu )ou h[dpsoh wkh odfn oi wudlqlqj oi odzhuv oq wkh kxpdq uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv pd eh d eduulhu wo wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp 3huvoqv zko duh vxemhfwhg wo lqyooxqwdu kovslwdol]dwloqv kdyh vophwlphv h[shulhqfhg oqo yhu eulhi ou qoqh[lvwhqw foqwdfwv zlwk odzhuv ghvslwh d odzhu kdylqj ehhq ioupdoo dssolqwhg wo wkh fdvh dqg kdyh h[suhvvhg glvvdwlvidfwloq wkdw wkhlu yolfhv zhuh qow khdugͷͳ 6lploduo lq wkh &]hfk 5hsxeolf hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh lq sudfwlfh lv xvxdoo ghshqghqw oq wkh dssuodfk oi lqglylgxdo odzhuv zko duh qow dozdv vxssouwlyh oi wkhlu folhqwvͷͳͺ % foqwudvw lq 6sdlq wkh h[shulhqfhv oi ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkhlu foqwdfw zlwk wkhlu odzhuv vhhp jhqhudoo wo kdyh ehhq sovlwlyhͷͳͻ 7kh 6sdqlvk 6xsuhph &oxuw kdv hvwdeolvkhg wkdw wkh uljkw wo ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwloq lv qow phuho d uljkw wo dffhvv wo d odzhu exw dovo wo hiihfwlyh uhsuhvhqwdwloq e vxfk d odzhuͷʹͳ 81 ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 3ulqflsoh sdud m ௵5hshdo ou dphqg doo odzv uhjxodwloqv soolflhv jxlgholqhv dqg sudfwlfhv wkdw lpsovh vxevwlwxwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj lq ohjdo suofhhglqjv lqfoxglqj wkovh wkdw doooz iou wkh dssolqwphqw oi ghflvloq pdnhuv djdlqvw wkh zloo oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv hj jxdugldqv dg olwhp qh[w iulhqgv dqg vlplodu duudqjhphqwv ou ghflvloqv pdgh oq wkh edvlv oi wkh ௵ehvw lqwhuhvwv௶ oi wkh shuvoqv foqfhuqhg dv ossovhg wo ehlqj edvhg oq wkhlu ozq zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv௶ )(1$&(5&, %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 3ouwxjdo /lveoq (1$%/( 3uomhfw $sulo s )(1$&(5&, %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 3ouwxjdo /lveoq (1$%/( 3uomhfw $sulo s )2580 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq &]hfkld 3udkd (1$%/( suomhfw s 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 6sdqlvk 6xsuhph &oxuw -xgjhphqw oi 1oyhpehu (&/, (6 76 dyldodeoh dw 676 (&/, (6 76 3oghu -xglfldo 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 3udfwlfdo jxlgdqfh dqg uhfopphqgdwloqv 7kh uljkw wo dffhvv wo d odzhu pxvw eh jxdudqwhhg dqg idflolwdwhg iuop wkh oxwvhw oi ghwhqwloq wkuoxjk wkh iuop wkh suhwuldo vwdjhv oi ohjdo suofhhglqjv dqg suofhvvhv ehiouh wkh iluvw dfwloqv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv dqg wkuoxjkoxw wkh wuldo 7o hqvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh uhvsoqvleoh 6wdwh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw phdvxuhv duh lq sodfh wo $ $iioug ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkh uljkw wo ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk odz hqioufhphqw uhjdugohvv oi wkh qdwxuh oi wkh fulph wkh duh dffxvhg oi dqg oq whupv wkdw duh qo ohvv idyoxudeoh wkdq doo owkhu shuvoqv % *xdudqwhh wkdw doo ghihqgdqwv duh lqiouphg oi wkhlu uljkw wo kdyh dffhvv wo d odzhu dqg hiihfwlyh ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh & ,qioup shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oi wkhlu uljkw wo ohjdo dlg ௬ lqfoxglqj zkhuh qhfhvvdu wo iuhh hiihfwlyh ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh dqg owkhu sovvlelolwlhv vxfk dv dffhvv wo ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwloq wkuoxjk flylo voflhw oujdql]dwloqv ‘ 0dlqwdlq dqg uhjxoduo xsgdwh d olvw oi ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv zlwk h[shuwlvh lq glvdelolw 7khvh ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv vkoxog xqghu zkdw duh wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj xqghu wkh &53’ dqg xqghuvwdqg wkh oeoljdwloq wo suoylgh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ( 0dnh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv vxfk dv lqwhusuhwhuv dvvlvwlyh whfkqoooj dqg lqwhuphgldulhv ou wkh uhvoxufhv qhfhvvdu wo oewdlq vxfk dffoppogdwloqv dydlodeoh wo odzhuv wo vxssouw hiihfwlyh foppxqlfdwloq zlwk shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh glvfkdujh oi wkhlu suoihvvloqdo gxwlhv 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ) :khq d shuvoq lv ghwdlqhg wkh pxvw hqmo hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo d odzhu dqg ohjdo dlg ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˣ˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ ,q ,uhodqg wkh 1dwloqdo $gyofdf 6huylfh iou 3hosoh zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv suoylghv foppxqlfdwloq dqg dvvlvwdqfh vhuylfhv wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7kh dovo khos shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq lqvwuxfwlqj d odzhu zko uhsuhvhqwv wkhlu zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv ,q $xvwuld d vlplodu vhuylfh lv oiihuhg e d shhu vxssouw juoxs %,=(36 6vwhplf uhfopphqgdwloqv 7kh uljkw wo dffhvv wo d odzhu pxvw eh jxdudqwhhg iuop wkh wlph oi duuhvw wo suhwuldo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqj ehiouh wkh iluvw dfwloqv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv dqg wkuoxjkoxw wkh wuldo 0hdvxuhv vkoxog eh wdnhq wo hqvxuh wkdw $ 7kh sxeolf ghihqfh vvwhp fdq hqvxuh htxdo dffhvv wo odzhuv wkdw suoylgh kljktxdolw vhuylfhv wo doo ghihqgdqwv lqfoxglqj wkovh zlwk glvdelolwlhv % /hjdo dvvlvwdqfh lv hiihfw dqg wkdw wkhuh lv d vxshuylvou phfkdqlvp sxw lq sodfh e lqvwlwxwloqv fkdujhg zlwk uhjxodwlqj wkh edu vxfk dv edu dvvofldwloqv dqg odz voflhwlhv ,q golqj vo hpskdvlv vkoxog eh sxw oq wkh odzhuv vxssouwlyh uooh ehlqj vxiilflhqwo suodfwlyh dqg pdlqwdlqlqj shuvoqdo dqg vxiilflhqwo iuhtxhqw foqwdfw zlwk folhqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv /hjdo dlg pxvw eh suoylghg iou doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zko go qow kdyh wkh phdqv wo diioug ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh ( )oqq & 0oooqh - )ldod%xwoud , 9lfhqwh (fkhyduuld 5hsouw $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv dydlodeoh dw &’/3)lqdouhsouw$ffhvv-xvwlfh3:’gof[ olyhfop s )2580 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq &]hfkld 3udkd (1$%/( suomhfw s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 6wdwhv vkoxog jxdudqwhh wkdw lqlwldo wudlqlqj iou odzhuv oq wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lv suoylghg 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ʷʡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦˜˕˜˟˜˧ˬ ˢ˙ ˖ˢ˨˥˧ ˙˔˖˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ʟ ˜ˡ˙ˢ˥ˠ˔˧˜ˢˡ ˔ˡ˗ ˦˘˥˩˜˖˘˦ ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ʻ˨ˠ˔ˡ ˅˜˚˛˧˦ ʿ˔˪ ˔ˡ˗ ʸˈ ʿ˔˪ ˔ˡ˗ ˆ˧˔ˡ˗˔˥˗˦ ,qwhuqdwloqdo +xpdq 5ljkwv /dz $uwlfoh ,&&35 suoylghv wkdw d shuvoq fkdujhg zlwk d fulph kdv d uljkw ௵ e 7o kdyh dghtxdwh wlph dqg idflolwlhv iou wkh suhsdudwloq oi klv ghihqfh dqg wo foppxqlfdwh zlwk foxqvho oi klv ozq fkoovlqj >@௶ dqg ௵g7o eh wulhg lq klv suhvhqfh dqg wo ghihqg klpvhoi lq shuvoq ou wkuoxjk ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh oi klv ozq fkoovlqj >@௶ 7kh 81 +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh kdv dovo fodulilhg wkdw dq glvwlqfwloqv wo dffhvv wo foxuwv ou wulexqdov wkdw duh qow edvhg oq odz dqg qow mxvwlilhg oq oemhfwlyh dqg uhdvoqdeoh juoxqgv duh suoklelwhgͷʹ͵ $uwlfoh (&+5 suoylghv wkdw hyhuoqh fkdujhg zlwk d fulph kdv wkh uljkw ௵ d wo eh lqiouphg suopswo lq d odqjxdjh zklfk kh xqghuvwdqgv dqg lq ghwdlo oi wkh qdwxuh dqg fdxvh oi wkh dffxvdwloq djdlqvw klp e wo kdyh dghtxdwh wlph dqg idflolwlhv iou wkh suhsdudwloq oi klv ghihqfh >@௶ $ffouglqj wo duwlfoh &53’ ௵௲>x@qlyhuvdo ghvljq௲ phdqv wkh ghvljq oi suogxfwv hqyluoqphqwv suojudpphv dqg vhuylfhv wo eh xvdeoh e doo shosoh wo wkh juhdwhvw h[whqw sovvleoh zlwkoxw wkh qhhg iou dgdswdwloq ou vshfldol]hg ghvljq௶ dqg ௵vkdoo qow h[foxgh dvvlvwlyh ghylfhv iou sduwlfxodu juoxsv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zkhuh wklv lv qhhghg௶ 7kh &53’ &opplwwhh wkh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o kdyh kljkoljkwhg uhtxluhphqwv duoxqg xqlyhuvdo ghvljq lq sduwlfxodu wkdw ௵>s@huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg owkhu xvhuv vkoxog eh deoh wo poyh lq eduulhuiuhh vwuhhwv hqwhu dffhvvleoh ooziooou yhklfohv dffhvv lqioupdwloq dqg 81 +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh 5ljkw wo htxdolw ehiouh foxuwv dqg wulexqdov dqg wo d idlu wuldo &&35&*& sdud 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( foppxqlfdwloq dqg hqwhu dqg poyh lqvlgh xqlyhuvdoo ghvljqhg exloglqjv xvlqj whfkqlfdo dlgv dqg olyh dvvlvwdqfh zkhuh qhfhvvdu௶ͷʹͷ 0ouhoyhu wkh &opplwwhh qowhv wkdw lq ௵eowk xuedq dqg uxudo duhdv dffhvv vkoxog eh dydlodeoh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo wkh qdwxudo dqg khulwdjh sduwv oi wkh skvlfdo hqyluoqphqw wkdw wkh sxeolf fdq hqwhu dqg hqmo௶ͷʹͷ ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ˃˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘˦ ˔ˡ˗ ʺ˨˜˗˘˟˜ˡ˘˦ ˢˡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ʽ˨˦˧˜˖˘ ˙ˢ˥ ˃˘˥˦ˢˡ˦ ˪˜˧˛ ʷ˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ ˃˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘ ʥ ௵)dflolwlhv dqg vhuylfhv pxvw eh xqlyhuvdoo dffhvvleoh wo hqvxuh htxdo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh zlwkoxw glvfulplqdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ *xlgholqh 6wdwhv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw idflolwlhv dqg vhuylfhv xvhg lq ohjdo vvwhpv duh exlow ghyhooshg dqg suoylghg oq wkh edvlv oi wkh sulqflsohv oi xqlyhuvdo ghvljq wo jxdudqwhh wkh dffhvvlelolw oi doo idflolwlhv dqg vhuylfhv xvhg lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp lqfoxglqj d (qdfwlqj dqg lpsohphqwlqj hqioufhdeoh odzv uhjxodwloqv soolflhv jxlgholqhv dqg sudfwlfhv wkdw jxdudqwhh wkh dffhvvlelolw oi doo idflolwlhv dqg vhuylfhv xvhg lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp edvhg oq wkh sulqflsohv oi xqlyhuvdo ghvljq lqfoxglqj l &oxuwv soolfh idflolwlhv sulvoqv ghwhqwloq dqg iouhqvlf idflolwlhv mxu idflolwlhv dgplqlvwudwlyh oiilfhv dqg owkhu vxfk sodfhv lqfoxglqj wolohwv fhoov oiilfhv hqwudqfhv oliwv fdqwhhqv dqg uhfuhdwloqdo vsdfhv lq wkovh sodfhv ll ,qioupdwloq foppxqlfdwloqv dqg owkhu vhuylfhv lqfoxglqj lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloqv whfkqoooj dqg vvwhpv e (qvxulqj wkdw doo phdqv oi wudqvsouwdwloq xvhg lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp duh dffhvvleoh &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq $uwlfoh $ffhvvlelolw sdud ,elg sdud 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 3ulqflsoh s 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv *xlgholqh 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( f (qvxulqj wkdw dghtxdwh ilqdqfldo uhvoxufhv duh dydlodeoh wo pdnh wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp skvlfdoo dffhvvleoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq dffougdqfh zlwk wkh sulqflsohv oi xqlyhuvdo ghvljq g *xdudqwhhlqj wkh suoylvloq oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv zkhq idflolwlhv dqg vhuylfhv idlo wo hqvxuh dffhvv wo wkh h[lvwlqj skvlfdo hqyluoqphqw wudqvsouwdwloq lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloqv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7kh (&w+5 dgguhvvhg wkh lvvxh oi dffhvvlelolw lq wkh fdvh oi )dufdġ y 5opdqld ,q wklv fdvh wkh dssolfdqw zdv d shuvoq zlwk d skvlfdo glvdelolw suojuhvvlyh pxvfxodu gvwuosk zko foxog qow dffhvv wkh foxuwv wkdw kdg mxulvglfwloq oyhu klv flylo glvsxwhv +h fodlphg wkdw kh zdv qow deoh wo fkdoohqjh wkh whuplqdwloq oi klv foqwudfw ehfdxvh wkh foxuw exloglqj zdv qow dffhvvleoh 7kh (&w+5 uhfojql]hg wkdw zkhuh d foxuw lv skvlfdoo lqdffhvvleoh wo wkh dssolfdqw gxh wo d glvdelolw uhvxowlqj lq d uhgxfwloq oi poelolw wklv lqdffhvvlelolw pd uhvxow lq d yloodwloq oi wkh dssolfdqw௲v uljkw wo dffhvv foxuw dqg wkxv wkhlu uljkw wo d idlu wuldo (qvxulqj dffhvvlelolw oi ௵wkh skvlfdo hqyluoqphqw wudqvsouwdwloq lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloq dqg vhuylfhv oshq wo wkh sxeolf௶ lv wkhuhiouh dffouglqj wo wkh &opplwwhh ௵d suhfoqglwloq iou wkh hiihfwlyh hqmophqw oi yduloxv flylo dqg soolwlfdo uljkwv e shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ 7kh (xuoshdq &opplwwhh oi 6ofldo 5ljkwv dovo dgguhvvhg wkh lvvxh oi dffhvvlelolw lq wkh fdvh (xuoshdq ‘lvdelolw )ouxp (‘) dqg ,qfoxvloq (xuosh y )udqfh &opsodlqw 1o ,q wklv fdvh wkh (xuoshdq ‘lvdelolw )ouxp dqg ,qfoxvloq (xuosh fopsodlqhg wkdw )udqfh glg qow jxdudqwhh lq sudfwlfh ௵vxiilflhqw dqg hiihfwlyh dffhvv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo vofldo vxssouw vhuylfhv dqg idflolwlhv >@ htxdo dqg hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo vofldo zhoiduh vhuylfhv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv >@ wkh uljkw wo suowhfwloq djdlqvw soyhuw dqg vofldo h[foxvloq >@ htxdo dqg hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo ,elg )dufdġ y 5opdqld (&w+5 $ssolfdwloq qo sdud &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh $ffhvvlelolw &53’&*& sdud 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( koxvlqj iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv >@ wkh ixoo fopsohwh dqg hiihfwlyh hqmophqw e shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv >@ oi wkh uljkw wo suowhfwloq oi khdowk >@௶ 7kh (xuoshdq &opplwwhh oi 6ofldo 5ljkwv ioxqg d yloodwloq oi duwlfoh dqg duwlfoh oi wkh (xuoshdq 6ofldo &kduwhu 7kh yloodwloq oi duwlfoh lq wklv fdvh kdv ehhq foqiluphg dovo dv d uhvxow oi wkh ௵odfn oi dffhvvlelolw oi kovslwdo exloglqjv dqg khdowkfduh idflolwlhv ௵ 7kh &opplwwhh kdv ixuwkhu khog wkdw ௵wkh vkouwdjh oi vxssouw vhuylfhv dqg wkh odfn oi dffhvvlelolw oi exloglqjv dqg idflolwlhv dqg sxeolf wudqvsouw fdxvh pdq idplolhv wo olyh lq suhfduloxv flufxpvwdqfhv dqg wkxv dpoxqw wo d odfn oi suowhfwloq oi wkh idplo lq yloodwloq oi duwlfoh 7kh uljkw oi wkh idplo wo vofldo ohjdo dqg hfoqoplf suowhfwloq oi wkh &kduwhu௶ ,w vwdwhg wkdw ௵wkh odfn ou lqdghtxdf oi wkh phdvxuhv wdnhq vo idu oeoljhv kljko ghshqghqw shuvoqv lqfoxglqj shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo olyh zlwk wkhlu idplolhv zlwk sowhqwldoo iduuhdfklqj qhjdwlyh lpsolfdwloqv iou wkh idplo௲v olylqj flufxpvwdqfhv >@ ,q wklv uhvshfw wkh &opplwwhh wdnhv qowh oi wkh vxeplvvloq e wkh ‘hihqghu oi 5ljkwv wkdw dffouglqj wo d vxuyh oi sduhqwv oi fkloguhq zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq )udqfh duh lpsdfwhg lq wkhlu moe iou odfn oi dgdswhg phdvxuhvuhvsoqvh wo wkh qhhgv oi wkhlu fklog $poqjvw wkovh sduhqwv oi powkhuv fopsduhg wo oi idwkhuv fhdvh doo suoihvvloqdo dfwlylw uhgxfh wkhlu zounlqj wlph ou fkdqjh suoihvvloq௶ (8 /dz dqg 6wdqgdugv 7khuh duh suoylvloqv oi (8 odz vshflilfdoo uhodwhg wo dffhvvlelolw dqg wkh qhhg iou dffxudwh dqg dffhvvleoh lqioupdwloq oq wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq ,elg sdud (&65 (xuoshdq ‘lvdelolw )ouxp (‘) dqg ,qfoxvloq (xuosh y )udqfh &opsodlqw 1o ,elg sdud ,elg sdud ,elg sdud 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ‘luhfwlyh (8 +ozhyhu wkh ‘luhfwlyh gohv qow suoylgh ghwdlohg jxlgdqfh oq vshflilf eduulhuv shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv idfh lq uhfhlylqj lqioupdwloq &kdoohqjhv $fuovv wkh (8 fkdoohqjhv lq dffhvv wo idflolwlhv dqg vhuylfhv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh shuvlvw )ou lqvwdqfh lq wkh 81 &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv h[suhvvhg lwv foqfhuq deoxw wkh odfn oi dffhvvlelolw oi odz hqioufhphqw djhqflhv dqg wkh mxglfldu lq 6sdlq 7kh &opplwwhh dovo qowhg wkh devhqfh oi jhqhudo suofhgxudo dgmxvwphqwv wkdw wdnh jhqghu dqg djh lqwo dffoxqw lq mxglfldo suofhhglqjv uhodwhg wo yduloxv wshv oi glvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj vhqvou lqwhoohfwxdo dqg skvlfdo glvdelolwlhv )xuwkhupouh wkh &opplwwhh udlvhg foqfhuqv uhjduglqj yduloxv eduulhuv wkdw duh wkh foqvhtxhqfh oi eowk vshflilf odzv dqg hvwdeolvkhg sudfwlfhv dqg wkdw suhyhqw shuvoqv vxemhfw wo vxevwlwxwloq ghflvloqpdnlqj uhjlphv iuop sduwlflsdwlqj lq foxuw suofhhglqjv oq dq htxdo ioowlqj zlwk owkhuv 1oqhwkhohvv 6sdlq kdv dgoswhg ohjlvodwloq zlwk wkh hiihfw oi judgxdoo hyooylqj lw wozdugv d pouh dffhvvleoh vvwhp 2q ‘hfhpehu wkh 6sdqlvk &ulplqdo 3uofhgxuh $fw hvwdeolvkhg wkdw suofhgxudo dgmxvwphqwv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqyooyhg lq mxglfldo suofhhglqjv pxvw eh dgoswhg zkhqhyhu qhfhvvdu 7khvh dgmxvwphqwv lqfoxgh vlpsoh foppxqlfdwloqv hdvuhdglqj gofxphqwv dqg wkh lqvwlwxwh oi dq lqwhuphgldu ,q %xojduld dffouglqj wo wkh qdwloqdo vwxg dffhvvlelolw uhtxluhphqwv duh ehlqj qhjohfwhg lq voph foxuwv dqg hyhq pouh vo lq soolfh suhplvhv :kloh e odz wkhuh (8 3duoldphqw dqg &oxqflo ‘luhfwlyh (8 oi wkh (xuoshdq 3duoldphqw dqg oi wkh &oxqflo / sdud $uwlfoh $uwlfoh &53’&(63&2 &oqfoxglqj oevhuydwloqv oq wkh fopelqhg qg dqg ug shuloglf uhsouwv oi 6sdlq &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv kwwsv gljlwdooleuduxqoujuhfoug ,elg sdud d ,elg sdud d ,elg sdud e 6sdlq &ulplqdo 3uofhgxuh $fw duwlfoh .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( lv d plqlpxp vwdqgdug iou dufklwhfwxudo dffhvvlelolw oi foxuwuoopv dqg doo sxeolf exloglqjv wkhvh uhtxluhphqwv duh iuhtxhqwo oyhuooonhg dqg xqlpsohphqwhg ,q voph lqvwdqfhv dq lqglylgxdo௲v glvdelolw zloo suhyhqw wkhp iuop dsshdulqj ehiouh wkh lqyhvwljdwlqj eog dqg suoylvloq foxog wkhuhiouh eh pdgh iou wkhp wo eh txhvwloqhg hovhzkhuh 7kh %xojduldq &ulplqdo &ogh suoylghv wkh sovvlelolw wo koog foxuw khdulqjv oxwvlgh wkh foxuw zkhq lw lv qhfhvvdu iou h[dpsoh zkhq wkh ghihqgdqw lv lq d kovslwdo 6vwhplf uhfopphqgdwloqv 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkh dffhvvlelolw oi doo foxuw idflolwlhv lqioupdwloq foppxqlfdwloqv dqg owkhu vhuylfhv lqfoxglqj lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloqv whfkqoooj dqg vvwhpv lq dffougdqfh zlwk wkh sulqflsohv oi xqlyhuvdo ghvljq (qvxuh doo exloglqjv lq wkh mxvwlfh vhfwou vxfk dv soolfh vwdwloqv foxuwkoxvhv dqg suovhfxwouldo oiilfhv duh dffhvvleoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,q oughu wo dfklhyh wklv wkh vkoxog $ 0dnh dghtxdwh ilqdqfldo uhvoxufhv dydlodeoh vo wkdw wkh foxuwv soolfh vwdwloqv suovhfxwouv oiilfhv dqg owkhu skvlfdo vwuxfwxuhv hqfoxqwhuhg gxulqj mxvwlfh suofhvvhv duh skvlfdoo dffhvvleoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7klv pd uhtxluh wkh poglilfdwloq oi h[lvwlqj exloglqjv dqg vwuxfwxuhv dv zhoo dv d suoklelwloq oi dq ixuwkhu qhz exloglqjv ou vwuxfwxuhv ehlqj fuhdwhg wkdw duh qow fopsdwleoh zlwk wkh sulqflsohv oi xqlyhuvdo ghvljq dqg wkhuhiouh dffhvvleoh wo doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,elg s $uwlfoh sdud oi %xojduldq &ulplqdo 3uofhgxuh &ogh 6hh 5xolqj 1o gdwhg xqghu fulplqdo fdvh ι ή τ λ 1o oi wkh %xujdv $sshoodwh &oxuw qow sxeolfo dydlodeoh duwlfoh oi &ulplqdo &ogh %xojduld ,q .(5$ s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( % *xdudqwhh wkh suoylvloq oi uhdvoqdeoh dqg suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv zkhq idflolwlhv dqg vhuylfhv idlo wo hqvxuh dffhvv wo wkh h[lvwlqj skvlfdo hqyluoqphqw iou doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlv & $ffhvvleoh exloglqjv dqg owkhu sodfhv vkoxog uhwdlq wkhlu dffhvvlelolw diwhu wkhlu ghfodudwloq 7khuh duh fdvhv zkhuh dffhvvleoh vsdfhv kdyh ehhq foqyhuwhg wo owkhu xvhv gxh wo doohjhg glvxvh hj dq dffhvvleoh wolohw kdv ehfoph d vwoudjh duhd iou fohdqlqj vxssolhv ‘ 8qlyhuvdo ghvljq jxlghv suoylgh vshflilf vxjjhvwloqv zklfk vkoxog eh lpsohphqwhg lqfoxglqj udpsv udlov oliwv juooylqj oq wkh juoxqg vshflilf sdunlqj oowv dxwopdwlf goouv hwf )ou vshflilf jxlgdqfh sohdvh uhihu wo duwlfoh &53’ ௬ ‘hilqlwloq oi 8qlyhuvdo ‘hvljq duwlfoh i &53’ dqg 3ulqflsoh oi wkh 81 ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv 6hh khuh iou lqvwdqfh d jxlgh iou ghvljqhuvhqjlqhhuv zklfk lv ehlqj xvhg lq d qxpehu oi xqlyhuvlwlhv 38’sgi vwdqioughgx 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ʸʡ ˅˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˕˘ ˣ˥˘˦˘ˡ˧ ˔˧ ˧˥˜˔˟ ˔ˡ˗ ˧˛˘ ˥˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˣ˥˘˦˨ˠˣ˧˜ˢˡ ˢ˙ ˜ˡˡˢ˖˘ˡ˖˘ ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ʻ˨ˠ˔ˡ ˅˜˚˛˧˦ ʿ˔˪ ˔ˡ˗ ʸˈ ʿ˔˪ ˔ˡ˗ ˆ˧˔ˡ˗˔˥˗˦ ,qwhuqdwloqdo +xpdq 5ljkwv /dz 8qghu jhqhudo ,+5/ lqfoxglqj kxpdq uljkwv wuhdw odz d shuvoq dffxvhg oi d fulph hqmov wkh uljkw oi suhvxpswloq oi lqqofhqfh 7klv lv suoylghg iou dpoqj owkhu sodfhv lq duwlfoh oi wkh ,&&35 dqg duwlfoh oi wkh (&+5 7kh uljkw lv devooxwh 7kh uljkw wo eh suhvhqw dw wuldo lv suoylghg iou lq $uwlfoh oi wkh ,&&35 7klv uljkw lv oqo zdlydeoh e wkh shuvoq vxemhfwlyh wkhpvhoyhv $uwlfoh oi wkh &53’ suoylghv wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv pxvw eh deoh wo dffhvv mxvwlfh oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk doo owkhu shosoh 3ulqflsoh oi wkh 81 ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv h[sodlqv wkdw ௵6wdwhv vkdoo hqvxuh wkdw doo vxevwdqwlyh dqg suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv uhfojql]hg lq ,+5/ zkhwkhu lq fulplqdo flylo ou dgplqlvwudwlyh suofhgxuhv lqfoxglqj wkh suhvxpswloq oi lqqofhqfh dqg wkh uljkw wo uhpdlq vlohqw duh diioughg wo doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv௶ 3udfwlfhv oi ilqglqj shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ௵xqilw wo vwdqg wuldo௶ dqg vxemhfwlqj wkhp lqvwhdg wo ௵vhfxulw phdvxuhv hqwdlolqj fopplwwdo ou ioufhg wuhdwphqw lq phqwdo khdowk idflolwlhv xqghu d uhjlph oi lpsdluphqwedvhg ghwhqwloq zklfk pd eh oi dq lqghilqlwh gxudwloq௶ uhpdlq zlghvsuhdg 6xfk sudfwlfhv uhvxow lq wkh ௵dedqgoqphqw oi wkh lqglylgxdo௲v uljkw wo wkh suhvxpswloq oi lqqofhqfh dqg lq wkh ghqldo oi gxh suofhvv vdihjxdugv wkdw vkoxog eh dssolfdeoh wo hyhu shuvoq dv uhfojql]hg lq ,+5/௶ 7kh 6hh dovo duwlfoh oi wkh 8qlyhuvdo ‘hfodudwloq duwlfoh e l oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi wkh &klog 81 +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh ‘huojdwloqv gxulqj d 6wdwh oi (phujhqf &&35&5hy$gg 81 +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh 5ljkw wo htxdolw ehiouh foxuwv dqg wulexqdov dqg wo d idlu wuldo &&35&*& sdud 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv *xlgholqhv s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( &53’ &opplwwhh kdv dffouglqjo fdoohg iou vxfk sudfwlfhv wo eh lpphgldwho glvfoqwlqxhg dqg iou odzv jlylqj hiihfw wo wkhp wo eh uhshdohg (8 /dz dqg 6wdqgdugv $uwlfoh oi wkh (8 &kduwhu jxdudqwhhv wkh suhvxpswloq oi lqqofhqfh $ffouglqj wo $uwlfoh oi ‘luhfwlyh (8 oq vwuhqjwkhqlqj oi fhuwdlq dvshfwv oi wkh suhvxpswloq oi lqqofhqfh dqg oq wkh uljkw wo eh suhvhqw dw wkh wuldo lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv ௵0hpehu 6wdwhv vkdoo hqvxuh wkdw vxvshfwv dqg dffxvhg shuvoqv kdyh wkh uljkw wo eh suhvhqw dw wkhlu wuldo௶ $ wuldo zklfk fdq uhvxow lq d ghflvloq oq wkh jxlow ou lqqofhqfh oi d vxvshfw ou dffxvhg shuvoq fdq eh khog lq wkhlu devhqfh oqo li fhuwdlq uhtxluhphqwv duh phw ௵ d wkh vxvshfw ou dffxvhg shuvoq kdv ehhq lqiouphg lq gxh wlph oi wkh wuldo dqg oi wkh foqvhtxhqfhv oi qoqdsshdudqfh ௶ 0ouhoyhu dffouglqj wo wkh vdph gluhfwlyh 6wdwhv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw vxvshfwv dqg dffxvhg shuvoqv duh suhvxphg lqqofhqw xqwlo suoyhq jxlow dffouglqj wo odz 7kh ‘luhfwlyh suoylghv jhqhudo vdihjxdugv iou doo vxvshfwv dqg dffxvhg exw gohv qow uhihu vshflilfdoo wo ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv $v wkh (8 lv d sduw wo wkh &53’ d euodg lqwhusuhwdwloq lv qhfhvvdu lq olqh zlwk wkh &53’ dqg wkh mxulvsuxghqfh oi wkh &opplwwhh &kdoohqjhv 7kh qdwloqdo ohjlvodwloq oq wkh uljkw wo eh suhvhqw dw wuldo ydulhv ehwzhhq (8 0hpehu 6wdwhv )ou lqvwdqfh lq 6ooyhqld wkh suhvhqfh oi wkh ghihqgdqw lv qow dozdv pdqgdwou 7kh foxuw pd ghflgh wkdw wkh pdlq khdulqj vkoxog eh khog zlwkoxw wkh suhvhqfh oi wkh 81 2+&+5 ௱5hsouw 5ljkw wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv௲ ’hfhpehu $+5& sdud 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ghihqgdqwv li wkhlu ghihqfh foxqvho lv suhvhqw dqg li wkh kdyh ehhq suhyloxvo lqwhuuojdwhg ,q %xojduld dffouglqj wo wkh qdwloqdo vwxg ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zko zhuh sodfhg lq svfkldwulf kovslwdov gxulqj wkhlu wuldov fopsodlqhg wkdw wkh zhuh qow hyhq lqiouphg oi wkh vwdwxv oi wkhlu wuldov ,q 5opdqld mxvw dv lq owkhu (8 0hpehu 6wdwhv wkh suoylvloqv iou ghihqgdqwv oq suhvhqfh lq wuldo lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv dsso htxdoo wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,i d shuvoq lv ghwdlqhg lw lv pdqgdwou wkdw wkh ghihqgdqw lv suhvhqw gxulqj wkh wuldo 7kh foxuw suofhhglqjv pd wdnh sodfh lq wkh ghihqgdqw௲v devhqfh li iou lqvwdqfh wkh ghihqgdqw lv plvvlqj hydghv wuldo ou fkdqjhv wkhlu dgguhvv zlwkoxw lqiouplqj wkh uhohydqw dxwkoulwlhv &oxuw suofhhglqjv pd dovo wdnh sodfh lq wkh ghihqgdqwv devhqfh li wkh ghihqgdqw suoylghv qo mxvwlilfdwloq iou wkhlu devhqfh gxulqj wkh dgmxglfdwloq oi wkh fdvh 7kuoxjkoxw wkh foxuw suofhhglqjv wkh ghihqgdqw lqfoxglqj zkhq wkh duh ghsulyhg oi olehuw pd dsso lq zulwlqj wo eh wulhg lq devhqwld uhsuhvhqwhg e d sxeolf dwwouqh ou d fkovhq oqh :khq wkh foxuw ghhpv lw pdqgdwou iou wkh ghihqgdqw wo eh suhvhqw lw pd oughu wkh iouphu௲v suhvhqfh lqfoxglqj zlwk d zduudqw 6wdwhv idfh yduloxv fkdoohqjhv lq uhjdug wo wkh uljkw wo suhvxpswloq oi lqqofhqfh lq uhvshfw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,q 6sdlq wkhuh kdyh ehhq fdvhv lq zklfk voph ehkdylouv h[klelwhg e fhuwdlq lqglylgxdov zlwk glvdelolwlhv zhuh foqvlghuhg e mxvwlfh dfwouv wo eh vxvslfloxv ou dv d odfn oi fooshudwloq )ou lqvwdqfh d ghihqgdqw௲v vlqfhuh odfn oi xqghuvwdqglqj kdv ehhq iuhtxhqwo shufhlyhg dv d odfn oi zloo wo fooshudwh $uwlfoh =.3 .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 5opdqld %xfduhvw (1$%/( 3uomhfw s $uwlfoh &ulplqdo &ogh 5opdqld 6hh &/5 s ,q d uhfhqw fdvh d pdq zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw kdv ehhq vhqwhqfhg wo oqh hdu oi sulvoq zlwkoxw kdylqj wkh sovvlelolw oi ehlqj suhvhqw dw wkh wuldo +h zdv ghqlhg ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwloq wulhg lq devwhqwld dqg vxppoqhg wo wkh koph zkhuh kh glg qow olyh dqpouh +h kdv ehhq lqfdufhudwhg diwhu kdylqj vhhq klv uljkw wo eh suhvhqw dw wuldo dv zhoo dv klv uljkw wo kdyh ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwloq dqg wo eh lqiouphg yloodwhg &/5 s &/5 ௵:kdw glg wkh elj shosoh lq wkh uoop vd”௶ 6wuxjxuho 0dwhl zdv uhohdvhg ௬ &hqwuxo gh 5hvxuvh -xulglfh fumuo 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( hvshfldoo lq fdvhv lqyooylqj shuvoqv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolwlhv zko dovo kdyh suoeohpv oi guxj foqvxpswloq 7klv nlqg oi vwhuhowsh fdq kdyh dq lpsdfw lq whupv oi wkh suhvxpswloq oi lqqofhqfh ,q %xojduld d fdvh lv foovhg oqfh wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk glvdelolwlhv lv ghfoduhg ௵lqvdqh௶ ou ௵lqfopshwhqw௶ 7kh ghihqgdqwv duh wkhq sodfhg lq svfkldwulf kovslwdov iou fopsxovou wuhdwphqw dqg wkhlu vwd xvxdoo h[whqgv lqghilqlwho ,q wklv zd shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv pljkw eh ghwdlqhg iou fopsxovou wuhdwphqw zlwkoxw d foxuw hyhq h[dplqlqj wkhlu fdvh ou wkh doohjdwloqv djdlqvw wkhp :khq lqglylgxdov duh h[foxghg iuop sduwlflsdwlqj ixoo dqg htxdoo lq ohjdo suofhhglqjv wkdw diihfw wkhlu uljkwv dqg lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq wkhvh uljkwv lqfoxglqj wkh suhvxpswloq oi lqqofhqfh pd eh yloodwhg 5hpowh khdulqjv 5hpowh khdulqjv pd qow eh vxlwdeoh iou fhuwdlq shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zklfk ulvnv yloodwlqj wkhlu uljkw wo d idlu wuldo 7kh uhjxodwloq dqg sudfwlfh oi uhpowh khdulqjv lq (8 0hpehu 6wdwhv ydu ,q 6sdlq lq jhqhudo khdulqjv dqg dsshdudqfhv ehiouh d mxgjh pxvw wdnh sodfh lq shuvoq 2qo lq h[fhswloqdo flufxpvwdqfhv dqg zlwk fhuwdlqw wkdw wkh suofhgxuh phhwv doo wkh jxdudqwhhv pd khdulqjv eh fduulhg oxw uhpowho ,q dq h[dpsoh flwhg lq wkh qdwloqdo vwxg dq oqolqh khdulqj zdv qow dgdswhg wo wkh qhhgv oi wkh ghihqgdqw $v d uhvxow wkh ghihqgdqw zdv qow dzduh oi zko zdv dfwxdoo lq wkh foxuwuoop foxog qow 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,elg .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s (txdolw dqg +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplvvloq 8. ௱,qfoxvlyh mxvwlfh d vvwhp ghvljqhg iou doo ,qwhulp hylghqfh uhsouw ௬ 9lgho khdulqjv dqg wkhlu lpsdfw oq hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq௲ dydlodeoh dw (+5& ,qfoxvlyh mxvwlfh d vvwhp ghvljqhg iou doo htxdolwkxpdquljkwvfop s 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( vhh wkh idfhv oi wkovh sduwlflsdwlqj fohduo dqg uhsouwhg wkdw wkh zkooh vlwxdwloq pdgh wkhp ihho pouh lqvhfxuh ,q wkh &]hfk 5hsxeolf wkh sovvlelolw oi uhpowh khdulqjv lv dydlodeoh $ffouglqj wo wkh &ulplqdo 3uofhgxuh &ogh ylghofoqihuhqflqj htxlsphqw pd eh xvhg lq wkh shuioupdqfh oi fulplqdo suofhhglqjv li lw lv qhfhvvdu iou wkh suowhfwloq oi wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv sduwlfxoduo zlwk uhjdug wo wkhlu djh ou vwdwh oi khdowk ou li vhfxulw ou owkhu fopshoolqj uhdvoqv vo uhtxluh 7klv suhvxpdeo foxog dovo dsso wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv :khuh uhpowh khdulqjv duh uhjxodwhg wkh go qow oiwhq pdnh vshflilf suoylvloqv iou wkh dffoppogdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7klv lv wkh fdvh lq /lwkxdqld zkhuh wkh uhfopphqgdwloqv oi wkh -xglfldo &oxqflo oi /lwkxdqldq -xgjhv foqfhuqlqj uhpowh khdulqjv suhvhqwhg lq go qow lqfoxgh dq uhihuhqfh wo wklv vhuylfh ehlqj dssolhg lq vxfk d pdqqhu dv wo hqvxuh dffhvvlelolw iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,q wkh 8qlwhg .lqjgop wkh 8. (txdolw dqg +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplvvloq kdv uhfopphqghg wkdw ghihqgdqwv lq ylgho khdulqjv eh jlyhq lqioupdwloq h[sodlqlqj wkhlu uljkw wo udlvh dq lvvxhv wkh pd idfh zlwk wkh qdwxuh oi vxfk sduwlflsdwloq dqg eh jlyhq wkh phdqv wo go vo ,w kdv dovo uhfopphqghg wkdw mxvwlfh dfwouv foqvlghu lqglylgxdov iou zkop ylgho khdulqjv zoxog qow eh vxlwdeoh ‘xulqj wkh foxuvh oi wkh &29,’ sdqghplf wkh (qjolvk dqg :hovk foxuwv povwo xvhg oqolqh ylgho sodwioupv wo foqgxfw khdulqjv ,q wklv foqwh[w wkh 8. (txdolw dqg +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplvvloq kljkoljkwhg wkdw wkhuh zdv d khljkwhqhg ulvn iou shuvoqv ,elg s 7kh odz suhflvho vdv ௵wkh whfkqlfdo htxlsphqw iou wkh wudqvplvvloq oi lpdjhv dqg voxqg௶ vhfwloq i d oi wkh &ulplqdo 3uofhgxuh &ogh lq )2580 7kh &]hfk 5hsxeolf s -xglfldo &oxqflo oi /lwkxdqldq -xgjhv 5hfopphqgdwloqv oq uhpowh mxglfldo khdulqjv5hnophqgdflmov gùo qxowoolqlĵ whlvpo sovùgŀlĵ sdwyluwlqwd 7hlvùmĵ 7dueov p uxjsmūïlo g dydlodeoh dw uhnophqgdflmovghoqxowoolqlxsovhg]lxsdwyluwlqwovbvnhoelpxlsgi dgyondwxudow 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyh %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq /lwkxdqld9loqlxv (1$%/( 3uomhfw $sulo s (txdolw dqg +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplvvloq 8. ௱,qfoxvlyh mxvwlfh d vvwhp ghvljqhg iou doo ,qwhulp hylghqfh uhsouw ௬ 9lgho khdulqjv dqg wkhlu lpsdfw oq hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq௲ dydlodeoh dw (+5& ,qfoxvlyh mxvwlfh d vvwhp ghvljqhg iou doo htxdolwkxpdquljkwvfop s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo vxiihu yloodwloqv oi wkhlu uljkw wo d idlu wuldo 7kh &opplvvloq oevhuyhg wkdw hohphqwv olnh edg foqqhfwloqv ooztxdolw lpdjhv dqg voxqgv dqg ghodv foxog fdxvh suoeohpv ohdglqj wo vxfk yloodwloqv ,q sduwlfxodu shuvoqv zlwk phqwdo khdowk foqglwloqv fojqlwlyh lpsdluphqwv dqg qhxuoglyhuvh foqglwloqv olnh dxwlvp dqg $’+’ zhuh dffouglqj wo wkh &opplvvloq dw sduwlfxodu ulvn oi qow xqghuvwdqglqj ou dfwlyho sduwlflsdwlqj lq suofhhglqjv wo wkhlu ghwulphqw ,q wklv foqwh[w ghihqgdqwv pljkw zhoo h[shulhqfh suoeohpv lq foqqhfwlqj jhwwlqj lqvwuxfwloqv dqg foppxqlfdwlqj dqg wkh lghqwlilfdwloq oi sovvleoh glvdelolwlhv wkdw wkh ghihqgdqw pd h[shulhqfh lv pouh gliilfxow 3udfwlfdo jxlgdqfh dqg uhfopphqgdwloqv 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog wdnh phdvxuhv wo hqvxuh wkh uljkw wo eh suhvhqw dw wuldo dqg wo ghihqg wkhpvhoyhv lq shuvoq lv uhvshfwhg iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv $ $q h[fhswloqv wo wkh uljkw wo eh suhvhqw dw wuldo vkoxog qow eh glvdelolwvshflilf dqg vkoxog dsso htxdoo wo doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,ghqwli dqg fduhixoo foqvlghu iou zkop wkh uhpowh khdulqj pljkw eh xqvxlwdeoh $ ,i xvlqj uhpowh khdulqjv hqvxuh dghtxdwh wudlqlqj ,7 wooov dqg d uholdeoh lqwhuqhw foqqhfwloq iou mxvwlfh dfwouv dqg htxdoo vhfxuh vxfk dffhvv oq dq htxdo edvlv wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqyooyhg lq vxfk suofhhglqjv ,elg s ,elg s ,elg s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( % 5hvshfw wkh shuvoq௲v zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv oq uhpowh khdulqjv 3xuvxh wkh ௵ehvw lqwhusuhwdwloq oi wkh zloo dqg suhihuhqfh௶ oqo zkhq wkh shuvoq fdqqow h[suhvv wkhp gluhfwo & (qvxuh dffhvv wo suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv lq uhpowh khdulqjv l lqfoxglqj zkhuh dssolfdeoh wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi lqwhuphgldulhv dqg owkhu vxssouw shuvoqv ll suoylglqj wkdw doo foppxqlfdwloq vxssouw lqfoxglqj wkuoxjk wklug sduwlhv qowhwdnhuv txdolilhg vljq odqjxdjh dqg oudo lqwhusuhwhuv uhod vhuylfhv dqg wdfwloh lqwhusuhwhuv lv htxdoo dqg hiihfwlyho dydlodeoh wo doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh foqwh[w oi uhpowh khdulqjv ‘ (qvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo d odzhuv ohjdo dlg hyhq lq wkh foqwh[w oi uhpowh suofhhglqjv ( (qvxuh wkdw gxulqj d uhpowh khdulqj wkh uooh oi hdfk shuvoq wdnlqj sduw lq wkh oqolqh khdulqj lv fohdu wo doo lqfoxglqj wo wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk glvdelolw ) (qvxuh wkh sdfh oi wkh suofhhglqjv lv zhoo dgmxvwhg ௬ hqvxuh iou lqvwdqfh udwkhu vkouw vhvvloqv dqg iuhtxhqw euhdnv 6vwhplf uhfopphqgdwloqv 7kh uhvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw doo vxvshfwv dqg dffxvhg shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv hiihfwlyho hqmo wkh suhvxpswloq oi lqqofhqfh suhvxphg lqqofhqw xqwlo suoyhq jxlow xqghu wkh odz lqfoxglqj dw suhwuldo skdvhv 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ʹʡ ˃˥ˢ˖˘˗˨˥˔˟ ˥˜˚˛˧˦ ˗˨˥˜ˡ˚ ˗˘ˣ˥˜˩˔˧˜ˢˡ ˢ˙ ˟˜˕˘˥˧ˬ ʼˡ˧˘˥ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˔˟ ʻ˨ˠ˔ˡ ˅˜˚˛˧˦ ʿ˔˪ ˔ˡ˗ ʸˈ ʿ˔˪ ˔ˡ˗ ˆ˧˔ˡ˗˔˥˗˦ ,qwhuqdwloqdo +xpdq 5ljkwv /dz $uwlfoh oi ,&&35 uhfojql]hv wkh uljkw wo olehuw dqg vhfxulw vwdwlqj wkdw ௵ hyhuoqh kdv wkh uljkw wo olehuw dqg vhfxulw oi shuvoq 1o oqh vkdoo eh vxemhfwhg wo duelwudu duuhvw ou ghwhqwloq 1o oqh vkdoo eh ghsulyhg oi klv olehuw h[fhsw oq vxfk juoxqgv dqg lq dffougdqfh zlwk vxfk suofhgxuh dv duh hvwdeolvkhg e odz௶ ,q lwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o wkh +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh fodulilhv wkh vfosh dqg phdqlqj oi duwlfoh oi ,&&35 dqg lw dggv wkdw 6wdwhv vkoxog xsgdwh wkhlu odzv lq wkh ilhog oi phqwdo khdowk wo dyolg duelwudu ghwhqwloq ,q sduwlfxodu wkh &opplwwhh oevhuyhv wkdw ௵ wkh h[lvwhqfh oi d glvdelolw vkdoo qow lq lwvhoi mxvwli d ghsulydwloq oi olehuw exw udwkhu dq ghsulydwloq oi olehuw pxvw eh qhfhvvdu dqg suosouwloqdwh iou wkh sxusovh oi suowhfwlqj wkh lqglylgxdo lq txhvwloq iuop vhuloxv kdup ou suhyhqwlqj lqmxu wo owkhuv௶ ,q wkh vdph *hqhudo &opphqw wkh +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh uhfopphqgv 6wdwhv wo hpsoo ghwhqwloq oqo dv d phdvxuh oi odvw uhvouw wo dsso lw iou wkh vkouwhvw shulog sovvleoh dqg wo dgosw dghtxdwh vxevwdqwlyh dqg suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv 7kh ,&&35 lqwuogxfhv owkhu uxohv oq ghsulydwloq oi olehuw dqg ghwhqwloq foqglwloqv vhwwlqj ixuwkhu vwdqgdugv iou wkh olplwdwloq oi olehuw lq wkh ilhog oi phqwdo khdowk )ou lqvwdqfh duwlfoh oi ,&&35 lqwuogxfhv wkh suoklelwloq oi fuxho lqkxpdq dqg ghjudglqj wuhdwphqw dqg duwlfoh oi ,&&35 vhwv d plqlpxp vwdqgdug oi kxpdq wuhdwphqw iou shosoh ghsulyhg oi wkhlu olehuw ,q sduwlfxodu duwlfoh suoylghv wkdw ௵ doo shuvoqv ghsulyhg oi wkhlu olehuw vkdoo eh wuhdwhg zlwk kxpdqlw dqg zlwk uhvshfw iou wkh lqkhuhqw gljqlw oi wkh kxpdq shuvoq௶ 81 +xpdq 5ljkwv &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh /lehuw dqg vhfxulw oi shuvoq &&35&*& sdud ,elg 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 6lplodu vwdqgdugv fdq eh oevhuyhg lq wkh &$7 dqg hvshfldoo lq duwlfoh zklfk suoklelwv lqkxpdq dqg ghjudglqj wuhdwphqw qow dpoxqwlqj wo wouwxuh dqg duwlfoh zklfk uhtxluhv 6wdwhv wo ௵>@ nhhs xqghu vvwhpdwlf uhylhz lqwhuuojdwloq uxohv lqvwuxfwloqv phwkogv dqg sudfwlfhv dv zhoo dv duudqjhphqwv iou wkh fxvwog dqg wuhdwphqw oi shuvoqv vxemhfwhg wo dq ioup oi duuhvw ghwhqwloq ou lpsulvoqphqw lq dq whuulwou xqghu lwv mxulvglfwloq zlwk d ylhz wo suhyhqwlqj dq fdvhv oi wouwxuh௶ $uwlfoh oi wkh &53′ suoylghv iou wkh uljkw wo olehuw dqg vhfxulw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv vwdwhg wkdw ௵ghsulydwloq oi olehuw lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv vkoxog oqo dsso dv d pdwwhu oi odvw uhvouw dqg zkhq owkhu glyhuvloq suojudpphv lqfoxglqj uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh duh lqvxiilflhqw wo ghwhu ixwxuh fulph௶ 7kh &opplwwhh kdv hvwdeolvkhg wkdw duwlfoh gohv qow shuplw dq h[fhswloqv zkhuhe shuvoqv pd eh ghwdlqhg oq wkh juoxqgv oi wkhlu dfwxdo ou shufhlyhg lpsdluphqw $ uhsouw e wkh iouphu 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq 7ouwxuh h[dplqhg wkh lpsolfdwloqv oi wkh &53′ dqg solqwv wkh zd wo pouh vljqlilfdqw dqg uoexvw suowhfwloqv iou shosoh zlwk glvdelolwlhv 2wkhu iouphu vshfldo udssouwhxuv oq wouwxuh kdyh dovo lpsolflwo vxssouwhg wklv dssuodfk )ou lwv sduw wkh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv vlploduo lqglfdwhg wkdw voolwdu foqilqhphqw ௵vkoxog qhyhu eh xvhg oq d shuvoq zlwk glvdelolw lq sduwlfxodu zlwk d svfkovofldo glvdelolw ou li wkhuh lv gdqjhu iou wkh shuvoq௲v khdowk lq jhqhudo௶ 0ouhoyhu oq wkh lvvxh oi glvflsolqdu dfwloq dqg sxqlvkphqw lqfoxglqj &53’ &opplwwhh *xlgholqhv oq $uwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv sdud $ydlodeoh dw kwwsv zzzokfkuouj(1+5%oglhv&53’3djhv*xlgholqhvdvs[ ,elg sdud 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wouwxuh dqg fuxho lqkxpdq ou ghjudglqj wuhdwphqw ou sxqlvkphqw 5hsouw wudqvplwwhg e qowh oi wkh 6hfuhwdu*hqhudo 81 ‘of $ -xo e 0dqiuhg 1ozdn 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wouwxuh dqg fuxho lqkxpdq ou ghjudglqj wuhdwphqw ou sxqlvkphqw 5hsouw wudqvplwwhg e qowh oi wkh 6hfuhwdu*hqhudo 81 ‘of $ -xo e 0dqiuhg 1ozdn 6hh sdud foqghpqlqj wkh xvh oi voolwdu foqilqhphqw oi shuvoqv zlwk phqwdo glvdelolwlhv 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wouwxuh dqg fuxho lqkxpdq ou ghjudglqj wuhdwphqw ou sxqlvkphqw 5hsouw wudqvplwwhg e qowh oi wkh 6hfuhwdu*hqhudo sdud 81 ‘of $ $xj e -xdq 0«qgh] 6hh sdudv dqg foqghpqlqj wkh xvh oi voolwdu foqilqhphqw oi shuvoqv zlwk phqwdo glvdelolwlhv ,elg sdud 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( voolwdu foqilqhphqw wkh &opplwwhh kljkoljkwhg wkh qhhg wo ௵suoklelw wkh ioufhg xvh oi qhxuoohswlfv wo foqwdlq shuvoqv zlwk svfkovofldo ou shufhlyhg glvdelolwlhv dqg lq jhqhudo wkh xvh oi phglflqh dqg fkhplfdo foqwdlqphqw dv d zd oi vofldo foqwuoo 7kh xvh oi phglflqh dv vofldo foqwuoo pd dpoxqw wo wouwxuh ou loo wuhdwphqw௶ 7kh 0dqghod 5xohv suoylgh iou wkh suoklelwloq oi wkh xvh oi voolwdu foqilqhphqw oq sulvoqhuv zlwk skvlfdo dqg phqwdo glvdelolwlhv 7kh 0dqghod 5xohv suhvhqw owkhu lpsouwdqw lqglfdwloqv oq ghwhqwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv )ou lqvwdqfh 5xoh vwuhvvhv wkh qhhg iou uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lq ghwhqwloq idflolwlhv ௵ sulvoq dgplqlvwudwloqv vkdoo pdnh doo uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq dqg dgmxvwphqwv wo hqvxuh wkdw sulvoqhuv zlwk skvlfdo phqwdo ou owkhu glvdelolwlhv kdyh ixoo dqg hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo sulvoq olih oq dq htxlwdeoh edvlv௶ 5xoh lv vshflilfdoo ghglfdwhg wo sulvoqhuv zlwk phqwdo glvdelolwlhv dqg lw suoylghv wkdw ௵ shuvoqv zko duh ioxqg wo eh qow fulplqdoo uhvsoqvleoh ou zko duh odwhu gldjqovhg zlwk vhyhuh phqwdo glvdelolwlhv dqgou khdowk foqglwloqv iou zkop vwdlqj lq sulvoq zoxog phdq dq h[dfhuedwloq oi wkhlu foqglwloq vkdoo qow eh ghwdlqhg lq sulvoqv dqg duudqjhphqwv vkdoo eh pdgh wo wudqvihu wkhp wo phqwdo khdowk idflolwlhv dv vooq dv sovvleoh௶ 7kh &opplwwhh dovo qowhg wkh fuxfldo uooh oi sulvoq dgplqlvwudwloq lq hqvxulqj suoylvloq oi uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv ௵>s@ulvoq dgplqlvwudwloq vkoxog suoylgh vxssouw iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv hyhq wkoxjk uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq lq oughu iou wkhp wo hqmo doo wkh uljkwv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv dqg vhfxuh d olih iuhh oi yloohqfh 7kh odfn oi vxssouw lq d sulvoq hqyluoqphqw fdq dpoxqw wo wouwxuh ou fuxho dqg ghjudglqj wuhdwphqw௶ ,elg sdud 81 *$ *$ uhvooxwloq 7kh 8qlwhg 1dwloqv 6wdqgdug 0lqlpxp 5xohv iou wkh 7uhdwphqw oi 3ulvoqhuv wkh 1hovoq 0dqghod 5xohv ,elg 5xoh ,elg sdud 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 1hyhuwkhohvv lw lv lpsouwdqw wo qowh wkdw dffoppogdwloqv zlwklq lqvwlwxwloqv duh qow vxiilflhqw wo hqvxuh fopsoldqfh zlwk wkh &53’ ,q lwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq wkh 5ljkw wo ,qghshqghqw /lylqj wkh &53’ &opplwwhh vwuoqjo foqghpqv lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq lq doo lwv ioupv dqg lqglfdwhv wkdw ghlqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq lv uhtxluhg e wkh uljkw wo lqghshqghqw olylqj lq wkh foppxqlw dqg wkhuhiouh 6wdwhv pxvw dgosw dghtxdwh vwudwhjlhv wo hqg lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq ,q wkh *xlgholqhv oq ‘hlqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq wkh &53′ &opplwwhh lv hyhq pouh hpskdwlf wkdw ௵6wdwhv sduwlhv vkoxog ohjlvodwh wo fulplqdol]h glvdelolwedvhg ghwhqwloq lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq dqg owkhu dfwv wkdw uhvxow lq glvdelolwuhodwhg wouwxuh dqg loowuhdwphqw௶ ,q wkh ylhzv lq wkh foppxqlfdwloq 0hglqd 9hod y 0h[lfo 1o wkh &53′ &opplwwhh ioxqg d yloodwloq oi duwlfoh e &53’ wkdw suoylghv wkdw wkh h[lvwhqfh oi d glvdelolw lq qo fdvh mxvwlilhv d ghsulydwloq oi olehuw ,q wklv fdvh d whpsoudu vhfxulw phdvxuh zdv lpsovhg oq wkh dssolfdqw zlwk dq lqwhoohfwxdo dqg svfkovofldo glvdelolw iuop wkh oxwvhw oi d suofhhglqj lq zklfk kh zdv dffxvhg oi wkhiw $ffouglqj wo wkh iouhqvlf phglfdo hydoxdwloq wkh ghihqgdqw foxog eh d gdqjhu ehfdxvh klv glvdelolw glg qow doooz klp wo xqghuvwdqg wkh xqodzixoqhvv oi klv dfwloqv 7kh phdvxuh foqwlqxhg diwhu kh zdv foqylfwhg zkloh wkh pdlq dujxphqw xvhg wo mxvwli wkh fopplwwdo oi wkh dssolfdqw zdv wkdw kh kdg d glvdelolw wkdw uhtxluhg phglfdo wuhdwphqw 7kh &opplwwhh dovo ioxqg d yloodwloq oi duwlfoh lq wkh foppxqlfdwloq 0lnnhovhq y ‘hqpdun 1o 7kh dssolfdqw fodlphg wkdw kh kdg ehhq ghsulyhg oi klv olehuw ehfdxvh oi d svfkovofldo glvdelolw dqg wkdw dqowkhu shuvoq zlwkoxw d glvdelolw zoxog idfh d vkouwhu ghwhqwloq li fkdujhg zlwk wkh vdph fulph7kh &opplwwhh lq lwv ilqglqjv uhfdoohg wkdw 6wdwhv pxvw ௵wdnh doo phdvxuhv &53′ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq olylqj lqghshqghqwo dqg ehlqj lqfoxghg lq wkh foppxqlw &53’&*& sdud dqg sdud j &53′ &opplwwhh *xlgholqhv oq ghlqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq lqfoxglqj lq hphujhqflhv &53’& sdud 9lhzv dgoswhg e wkh &opplwwhh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh 2swloqdo 3uowofoo foqfhuqlqj foppxqlfdwloq lq 0hglqd 9hod y 0h[lfo 1o 2fwoehu sdud &53’ &opplwwhh 9lhzv dgoswhg e wkh &opplwwhh xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh 2swloqdo 3uowofoo foqfhuqlqj foppxqlfdwloq 1o 81 ‘of &53’& ’ ,elg 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( qhfhvvdu lqfoxglqj wkh uhylvloq oi wkh 0hqwdo +hdowk $fw wo hqvxuh wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv hqmo wkh uljkw wo olehuw dqg vhfxulw oi shuvoq ௶ dqg wkh dovo pxvw ௵hqvxuh wkdw qo oqh zloo eh ghwdlqhg lq dq idflolw oq wkh edvlv oi dfwxdo ou shufhlyhg glvdelolw௶ 7kh &53’ &opplwwhh kdv dovo uhfhqwo sxeolvkhg lwv ilqglqjv oq +xqjdu௲v suojuhvv lq wkh lpsohphqwdwloq oi lwv uhfopphqgdwloqv 7kh ouljlqdo uhsouw oq +xqjdu zdv wkh uhvxow oi dq lqtxlu xqghu wkh 2swloqdo 3uowofoo 1o wo wkh &53’ ,q wklv gofxphqw wkh &opplwwhh kljkoljkwhg +xqjdu௲v vvwhpdwlf yloodwloq oi wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkuoxjk dq dexvlyh vvwhp oi jxdugldqvkls dqg lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq ,q sduwlfxodu wkh &opplwwhh oevhuyhg wkdw shuvoqv zlwk phqwdo dqg svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv zhuh pouh h[sovhg wo glvfulplqdwloq wkuoxjk wkhlu sodfhphqw xqghu jxdugldqvkls lqyooxqwdu lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq dqg wkh yduloxv ioupv oi loowuhdwphqw dqg uhvwudlqw wkdw xvhg wo offxu lq phqwdo khdowk lqvwlwxwloqv ,q wkh deoyhphqwloqhg fdvh (xuoshdq ‘lvdelolw )ouxp (‘) dqg ,qfoxvloq (xuosh y )udqfh &opsodlqw 1o wkh (xuoshdq &opplwwhh oi 6ofldo 5ljkwv pdgh uhihuhqfh dovo wo wkh gdqjhuv oi lqyooxqwdu lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq 7kh fopsodlqdqw oujdql]dwloqv fodlphg wkdw )udqfh glg qow jxdudqwhh dghtxdwh vhuylfhv wo idflolwdwh wkh lqghshqghqfh dqg lqwhjudwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg lqyooxqwdu lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq zdv hpsoohg wo fopshqvdwh iou wklv odfn oi idflolwlhv 7kh &opplwwhh foqvlghuhg lqyooxqwdu lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq lq uhodwloq wo wkh oeoljdwloqv xqghu $uwlfoh (xuoshdq 6ofldo &kduwhu uljkw wo khdowk +huh wkh &opplwwhh qowhg ,elg 9dolglw )oxqgdwloq +xqjdu uhpdlqv uhvsoqvleoh iou ௵judyh dqg vvwhpdwlf yloodwloqv௶ oi glvdelolw uljkwv 1oyhpehu dydlodeoh dw +xqjdu uhpdlqv uhvsoqvleoh iou ௵judyh dqg vvwhpdwlf yloodwloqv௶ oi glvdelolw uljkwv 9dolglw )oxqgdwloq 0hqwdo ‘lvdelolw $gyofdf &hqwuh 9dolglw )oxqgdwloq 0hqwdo ‘lvdelolw $gyofdf &hqwuh &53′ &opplwwhh ,qtxlu foqfhuqlqj +xqjdu xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh 2swloqdo 3uowofoo wo wkh &oqyhqwloq &53’&+81,5 &53’ &opplwwhh ,qtxlu foqfhuqlqj +xqjdu xqghu duwlfoh oi wkh 2swloqdo 3uowofoo wo wkh &oqyhqwloq &53’&+81,5 sdudv (&65 (xuoshdq ‘lvdelolw )ouxp (‘) dqg ,qfoxvloq (xuosh y )udqfh &opsodlqw 1o ‘hflvloq oi 2fwoehu ,elg sdudv ,elg sdudv 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( wkdw wkhuh zoxog eh qo qhhg iou lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq li wkhuh zdv ehwwhu suoylvloq oi vofldo vhuylfhv lq whupv oi (6& dv uhtxluhg wkhuh ,q sduwlfxodu wkh &opplwwhh kljkoljkwv wkdw lqdghtxdwh vxssouw vhuylfhv iou shosoh zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg wkh soou fooshudwloq ehwzhhq wkh vxssouw vhuylfhv dqg wkh khdowk vhuylfh kdyh vhuloxv foqvhtxhqfhv oq shosoh zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolwlhv ou svfkovofldo glvoughuv ,w qowhg wkdw ௵vxfk foqvhtxhqfhv lqfoxgh lqdssuosuldwh dqg dexvlyh svfkldwulf fduh uhvxowlqj lq ixoo kovslwdolvdwloq dqg lqyooxqwdu wuhdwphqwv dv zhoo dv vkouwfoplqjv dqg glvuxswloqv lq wkh fduh sdwk oi shuvoqv zlwk pxowlsoh glvdelolwlhv௶ (8 /dz dqg 6wdqgdugv $w wkh (8 ohyho wkh &opplvvloq 5hfopphqgdwloq & oq suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv iou yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv suhvfulehv wkdw (8 0hpehu 6wdwhv vkoxog wdnh doo vwhsv wo hqvxuh wkdw ghsulydwloq oi olehuw oi yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv ehiouh wkhlu foqylfwloq lv d phdvxuh oi odvw uhvouw suosouwloqdwh dqg wdnlqj sodfh xqghu foqglwloqv vxlwhg wo wkh qhhgv oi wkh yxoqhudeoh shuvoq ,w uhfopphqgv wkdw 6wdwhv hqvxuh wkdw ௵yxoqhudeoh௶ shuvoqv kdyh dffhvv wo uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv zkhq ghsulyhg oi olehuw ,q wkh &opplvvloq lvvxhg d 5hfopphqgdwloq oq suofhgxudo uljkwv oi vxvshfwv dqg dffxvhg shuvoqv vxemhfw wo suhwuldo ghwhqwloq dqg oq pdwhuldo ghwhqwloq foqglwloqv ,q uhodwloq wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkh 5hfopphqgdwloq suhvfulehv wkdw ௵jxlgdqfh vkoxog eh suoylghg oq vdihjxduglqj wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv iou zkop ghsulydwloq oi olehuw foqvwlwxwhv d vlwxdwloq oi sduwlfxodu yxoqhudelolw vxfk dv zophq ,elg sdud $ffouglqj wo 5hflwdo 7kh dlp oi wkh 5hfopphqgdwloq lv wo hqfoxudjh 0hpehu 6wdwhv wo vwuhqjwkhq wkh suofhgxudo uljkwv oi doo vxvshfwv ou dffxvhg shuvoqv zko duh qow deoh wo xqghuvwdqg dqg wo hiihfwlyho sduwlflsdwh lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv gxh wo djh wkhlu phqwdo ou skvlfdo foqglwloq ou glvdelolwlhv ௱yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv௲ &opplvvloq 5hfopphqgdwloq & oq suofhgxudo vdihjxdugv iou yxoqhudeoh shuvoqv vxvshfwhg ou dffxvhg lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv sdud (8 &opplvvloq 5hfopphqgdwloq oq suofhgxudo uljkwv oi vxvshfwv dqg dffxvhg shuvoqv vxemhfw wo suhwuldo ghwhqwloq dqg oq pdwhuldo ghwhqwloq foqglwloqv& ilqdo 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( fkloguhq shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ou vhuloxv khdowk foqglwloqv /*%7,4 dqg iouhljq qdwloqdov dv zhoo dv wkh suhyhqwloq oi udglfdolvdwloq lq sulvoqv௶ 7kh 5hfopphqgdwloq ixuwkhu diilupv wkdw 6wdwhv vkoxog wdnh lqwo dffoxqw wkh ௵vshfldo qhhgv௶ oi ௵shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ lq ௵doo ghflvloqv uhodwlqj wo wkhlu ghwhqwloq௶ 7khuh lv dq lpsouwdqw uhihuhqfh lq wkh 3uhdpeoh oi wkh 5hfopphqgdwloq olqnlqj gluhfwo wo wkh &53’ vshflilfdoo uhihuulqj wo uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv dqg dffhvvlelolw 7kh suhdpeoh vwdwhv wkdw ௵5hihuhqfhv lq wklv 5hfopphqgdwloq wo dssuosuldwh phdvxuhv wo hqvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog eh xqghuvwoog lq oljkw oi wkh uljkwv dqg oeoljdwloqv xqghu wkh 8qlwhg 1dwloqv &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv wo zklfk wkh (xuoshdq 8qloq dqg doo lwv 0hpehu 6wdwhv duh sduwlhv௶ 7kh 5hfopphqgdwloq uhfdoov wkdw xqghu (8 odz doo ioupv oi glvfulplqdwloq duh suoklelwhg lqfoxglqj glvfulplqdwloq oq wkh edvlv oi glvdelolw dqg suoylghv plqlpxp vwdqgdugv iou pdwhuldo ghwhqwloq foqglwloqv iou ghwdlqhhv lqfoxglqj lq uhvshfw oi dffhvv wo dssuosuldwh fduh qxwulwloxv glhw ou ylvlwv iuop idplolhv ou ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv ,w dovo vwuhvvhv wkdw 0hpehu 6wdwhv vkoxog ௵wdnh vshfldo fduh wo phhw wkh qhhgv oi dqg hqvxuh dffhvvlelolw iou ghwdlqhhv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ou vhuloxv phglfdo foqglwloqv zlwk uhjdugv wo pdwhuldo ghwhqwloq foqglwloqv dqg ghwhqwloq uhjlphv௶ 7kh 5hfopphqgdwloq ixuwkhu vwdwhv wkdw ௵0hpehu 6wdwhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ou owkhu shuvoqv zlwk vhuloxv phglfdo foqglwloqv uhfhlyh dssuosuldwh fduh fopsdudeoh wo wkdw suoylghg e wkh qdwloqdo sxeolf khdowk vvwhp zklfk phhwv wkhlu vshflilf qhhgv ,q sduwlfxodu 0hpehu 6wdwhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw shuvoqv zko duh gldjqovhg zlwk phqwdo khdowk ,elg suhdpeoh 5hflwdo ,elg uhflwdo ,elg 3uhdpeoh 5hflwdo ,elg *hqhudo 3ulqflsohv sdud ,elg sdud 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( uhodwhg phglfdo foqglwloqv uhfhlyh vshfldolvhg suoihvvloqdo fduh zkhuh qhhghg lq vshfldolvhg lqvwlwxwloqv ou ghglfdwhg vhfwloqv oi wkh ghwhqwloq idflolw xqghu phglfdo vxshuylvloq dqg wkdw foqwlqxlw oi khdowkfduh lv suoylghg iou ghwdlqhhv lq suhsdudwloq oi uhohdvh zkhuh qhfhvvdu௵ &kdoohqjhv ,q %xojduld ghihqgdqwv duh wslfdoo sodfhg lq svfkldwulf kovslwdov iou fopsxovou iou dq lqghilqlwh shulog oi wlph zklfk pd vophwlphv h[fhhg wkh ohqjwk oi lpsulvoqphqw dooozhg iou wkh fulph wkh duh doohjhg wo kdyh fopplwwhg 6xfk fopsxovou wuhdwphqw lv wkh oqo oswloq iou wkovh foqvlghuhg e wkh odz wo eh xqdeoh wo vwdqg wuldo 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wslfdoo ghvfulehg vxfk fopsxovou wuhdwphqw dqg ghwhqwloq dv wkh zouvw ioup oi lqfdufhudwloq hyhq lq fopsdulvoq wo sulvoq 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv h[suhvvhg ihdu oi vxfk ghwhqwloq dqg wkhlu dopovw fopsohwh uholdqfh oq dqg yxoqhudelolw wo phglfdo vwdii dw wkhvh idflolwlhv &opsxovou wuhdwphqw zdv dovo ghvfulehg dv d ௵ghdg hqg௶ iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dv pdq oi wkhp uhpdlq lqvwlwxwloqdol]hg iou hduv gxh wo soyhuw dqg d odfn oi foppxqlw vxssouw dqgou uhlqwhjudwloq sodqv suoylghg e wkh 6wdwh 7kh foqglwloqv lq %xojduldq sulvoqv dqg svfkldwulf kovslwdov duh dovo jhqhudoo yhu soou dqg xqvxlwdeoh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv qow hyhq lq olqh zlwk wkhlu uljkw wo eh wuhdwhg zlwk kxpdq gljqlw 8owlpdwho lq %xojduld soyhuw dqg wkh odfn oi foppxqlw vxssouw dqg uhlqwhjudwloq sodqv foqghpq shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zko kdyh ehhq doohjhg wo kdyh fopplwwhg d fulph wo vshqg povw oi wkhlu olih lq fopsxovou wuhdwphqw ,elg sdud .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,elg s 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq /lwkxdqld9loqlxv (1$%/( 3uomhfw $sulo s ,elg s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( ,q /lwkxdqld foppoq suoeohpv oevhuyhg e ohjdo sudfwlwloqhuv lqfoxgh d odfn oi dowhuqdwlyhv wo lpsulvoqphqw dqg wkh odfn oi dwwhqwloq wo uhkdelolwdwloq dqg uhvofldol]dwloq zlwklq vxfk lqvwlwxwloqv ,q 5opdqld sulvoqv odfn vshflilf phdvxuhv iou shosoh zlwk phqwdo glvdelolwlhv dqg wkh go qow vdwlvi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv )ou lqvwdqfh oqo pd[lpxp vhfxulw sulvoqv jxdudqwhh vshfldo vhfwloqv iou shosoh zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv dqg dffhvv wo wkh qhhghg phglfdo wuhdwphqw ,q pdq 6wdwhv olnh %xojduld ou /lwkxdqld wkhuh duh qo dowhuqdwlyhv wo lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq dqg d ghihqgdqw zko wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp ghwhuplqhv lv xqdeoh wo vwdqg lq wuldo lv xvxdoo foqilqhg lq svfkldwulf kovslwdov ,q owkhu 6wdwhv vxfk dv 6ooydnld ou wkh &]hfk 5hsxeolf wkhuh duh voph dowhuqdwlyhv suoylghg lq dpexodwou ioup ou kovslwdol]dwloq exw wkh suhvhqw pdq iodzv dqg xowlpdwho dpoxqw wo ioupv oi lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq 3udfwlfdo jxlgdqfh dqg uhfopphqgdwloqv ‘hwhqwloq fhqwuhv pxvw eh dffhvvleoh dqg zkhuh qhfhvvdu vxssouw wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv pxvw eh suoylghg ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˣ˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ ,q 6sdlq sulvoqhuv dqg h[sulvoqhuv fdq ehqhilw iuop wkh 3ohqd ,qfoxvloq 3uojudpph wkdw dlpv wo oiihu vxssouw dw doo vwdjhv gxulqj ohjdo suofhhglqjv lq sulvoq dqg diwhu wkh uhohdvh 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyh %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq /lwkxdqld9loqlxv (1$%/( 3uomhfw $sulo s &/56hfwloq /dz 1o $uwlfoh ([hfxwloq oi fxvwogldo vhqwhqfhv e vshfldo fdwhjoulhv oi vhqwhqfhg shuvoqv sdud ௵7kh 1dwloqdo $gplqlvwudwloq oi 3hqlwhqwldulhv vhwv vshflilf phdvxuhv iou wkh suowhfwloq oi wkh skvlfdo dqg phqwdo khdowk oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ ‘hflvloq oi wkh 1dwloqdo $gplqlvwudwloq oi 3hqlwhqwldulhv 1o $uwlfoh k ௵7kh suoilolqj oi sodfhv oi ghwhqwloq xqghu wkh 1dwloqdo $gplqlvwudwloq oi 3hqlwhqwldulhv lv dssuoyhg zlwk wkh ioooozlqj foqwhqw k wkh hvwdeolvkphqw oi sulvoq xqlwv zlwk zdugv iou wkh fxvwog oi shuvoqv ghsulyhg oi wkhlu olehuw gldjqovhg zlwk vhyhuh svkfkldwulf glvoughuv dv vhw oxw lq $qqh[ 1o wo wklv ‘hflvloq௶ .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyh %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq /lwkxdqld9loqlxv (1$%/( 3uomhfw $sulo s )2580 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6ooydnld 3udkd (1$%/( suomhfw s )2580 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq &]hfkld 3udkd (1$%/( suomhfw s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( 6vwhplf uhfopphqgdwloqv ͳǥ ‘hsulydwloq oi olehuw vkoxog eh foqvlghuhg d phdvxuh oi odvw uhvouw $ &oppxqlwedvhg dowhuqdwlyhv wo lqfdufhudwloq vkoxog eh dydlodeoh wo doo ghihqgdqwv lqfoxglqj wkovh zlwk glvdelolwlhv % $owhuqdwlyhv wo lqfdufhudwloq vkoxog eh ghyhooshg dqg lpsohphqwhg ʹǥ 6wdwhv pxvw qow doooz iou glvdelolwedvhg ghwhqwloq lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq dqg owkhu dfwv wkdw uhvxow lq glvdelolwuhodwhg wouwxuh dqg loowuhdwphqw 1o oqh vkoxog eh ghwdlqhg lq dq idflolw oq wkh edvlv oi dfwxdo ou shufhlyhg glvdelolw ͵ǥ 6wdwhv fdqqow xvh lqyooxqwdu lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq wo fopshqvdwh iou wkh odfn oi dghtxdwh idflolwlhv $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh .qozohgjh +xe ,psohphqwlqj wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv $ eulhilqj sdshu -xo s 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( akk-í-Ÿɍɍ ɍ 352&(’85$/ 5,*+76 2) 3(56216 :,7+ ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 $7 $// 67$*(6 2) 7+( $’0,1,675$7,21 2) -867,&( akk-íɍmɍ$-bmkm§mukŸɍak$ɍ uk -•§Ÿɍ $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1’ &21&(376 ʴʡ ˃˘˥˦ˢˡ˦ ˪˜˧˛ ˗˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ ,q whupv oi $uwlfoh oi wkh &53’ ௵3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxgh wkovh zko kdyh ooqjwhup skvlfdo phqwdo lqwhoohfwxdo ou vhqvou lpsdluphqwv zklfk lq lqwhudfwloq zlwk yduloxv eduulhuv pd klqghu wkhlu ixoo dqg hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq lq voflhw oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv௶ ,q whupv oi dq (8 5hfopphqgdwloq ௵shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ vkoxog eh xqghuvwoog lq dffougdqfh zlwk wklv ghilqlwloq suoylghg e $uwlfoh &53’ 7kh &53’ lq sdudjudsk h oi lwv 3uhdpeoh uhfojql]hv wkdw glvdelolw lv dq hyooylqj foqfhsw ,q lwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o wkh &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv &53′ &opplwwhh sxuvxdqw wo wkh &53’௲v ghilqlwloq oi glvdelolw ghvfulehv glvdelolw dv ௵wkh vofldo hiihfw oi wkh lqwhudfwloq ehwzhhq lqglylgxdo lpsdluphqw dqg wkh vofldo dqg pdwhuldo hqyluoqphqw௶ :khq lghqwlilqj wkh qhhgv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkh lqglylgxdo shuvoq vkoxog dozdv eh foqvxowhg dqg wkhlu djhqf dqg dxwoqop lq foqvlghulqj wkhlu ozq qhhgv jlyhq suhfhghqfh $ffouglqj wo wkh 8. (txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon ௵>7@kh hiihfwv oi dq lpsdluphqw fdq ydu iou hdfk lqglylgxdo ,w lv wkhuhiouh lpsouwdqw qow wo jxhvv ou dvvxph zkdw dgmxvwphqwv dq lqglylgxdo pljkw qhhg௶ :lwkoxw nqozohgjh oi dq lqglylgxdo shuvoqv௲ flufxpvwdqfhv ou qhhgv dv idu dv sovvleoh foppxqlfdwhg e wkdw shuvoq ௬ zkhwkhu zlwk ou zlwkoxw vxssouw ௬ lw lv qow sovvleoh iou mxvwlfh dfwouv wo fopso zlwk wkhlu ohjdo oeoljdwloqv wo suoylgh dffoppogdwloqv wo hqvxuh htxdo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ʵʡ /dqjxdjh ,q wklv %hqfk %oon wkh whuplqoooj hpsoohg e wkh &53’ &opplwwhh lv ehlqj xvhg ௵shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ ou d ௵shuvoq zlwk glvdelolw௶ͷͳ 1hxwudo odqjxdjh vkoxog eh dssolhg oyhu odqjxdjh wkdw pd fduu shmoudwlyh uhvoqdqfh ou lpso lpsdluhg kxpdq 7kh 81 &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv &53’ duwlfoh (& 5hfopphqgdwloq ‘hilqlwloqv qo 6hh kwwsv fopplvvloqhxuosdhxvvwhpilohvbbbuhfbsuobghwbhqsgi &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௱*hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq zophq dqg jluov zlwk glvdelolwlhv௲ &53’&*& 1oyhpehu sdud -xglfldo &ooohjh 8qlwhg .lqjgop ௱(txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon௲ )heuxdu s 3uhihuhqfhv iou odqjxdjh wo eh xvhg shosoh zlwk glvdelolwlhv yv glvdeohg shosoh gliihu zlwklq ehwzhhq gliihuhqw lqglylgxdov dqg juoxsv lq gliihuhqw foqwh[w 6oph suhihu wkh whup ௵glvdeohg shuvoq௵ 6hh -xglfldo &ooohjh 8qlwhg .lqjgop ௱(txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon௲ )heuxdu s $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1′ &21&(376 uljkwv djhqfͷͳ )ou lqvwdqfh ௬ d shuvoq ௵kdv௶ ou ௵h[shulhqfhv௶ d glvdelolw wkh go qow ௱vxiihu iuop௲ lw $ shuvoq lv qow ghilqhg e wkhlu glvdelolw dv lw lv qow wkh wowdolw oi wkhlu shuvoqkoog lghqwlw ou h[lvwhqfh wkh duh dq lqglylgxdo ௵shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw௶ $uwlfoh oi wkh &53′ ghilqhv ௵odqjxdjh௶ dv lqfoxglqj ௵vsonhq dqg vljqhg odqjxdjhv dqg owkhu ioupv oi qoqvsonhq odqjxdjhv௶ /dqjxdjh lqfoxglqj vljq odqjxdjhv lv h[solflwo glvwlqjxlvkhg iuop ௵foppxqlfdwloq௶ lqfoxglqj vfulswv vxfk dv %udlooh lq whupv oi wkh &53’ͷͳͺ ʶʡ ʸˤ˨˔˟˜˧ˬ 7kh &53’ &opplwwhh kdv lqglfdwhg wkdw &oqyhqwloq hqfopsdvvhv 6wdwhv wo dq ௵lqfoxvlyh htxdolw௶ͷͳͻ dssuodfk zklfk lv ௵d qhz pogho oi htxdolw ghyhooshg wkuoxjkoxw wkh &oqyhqwloq௶ zklfk ௵hpeudfhv d vxevwdqwlyh pogho oi htxdolw௶ dqg lqfoxghv lq dgglwloq wo fodvvlf qowloqv oi htxdolw ௵ d d idlu uhglvwulexwlyh glphqvloq wo dgguhvv voflohfoqoplf glvdgydqwdjhv e d uhfojqlwloq glphqvloq wo fopedw vwljpd vwhuhowslqj suhmxglfh dqg yloohqfh dqg wo uhfojql]h wkh gljqlw oi kxpdq ehlqjv dqg wkhlu lqwhuvhfwloqdolw f d sduwlflsdwlyh glphqvloq wo uhdiilup wkh vofldo qdwxuh oi shosoh dv phpehuv oi vofldo juoxsv dqg wkh ixoo uhfojqlwloq oi kxpdqlw wkuoxjk lqfoxvloq lq voflhw dqg g dq dffoppogdwlqj glphqvloq wo pdnh vsdfh iou gliihuhqfh dv d pdwwhu oi kxpdq gljqlw 7kh &oqyhqwloq lv edvhg oq lqfoxvlyh htxdolw௶ͷʹͳ -xglfldo &ooohjh 8qlwhg .lqjgop ௱(txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon௲ )heuxdu s 81 ‘lvdelolw,qfoxvlyh /dqjxdjh *xlgholqhv dydlodeoh dw kwwsv zzzxqjhqhydoujvlwhvghidxowilohv’lvdelolw,qfoxvlyh/dqjxdjh*xlgholqhvsgi ,q wkh gudiw oi wkh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o wkh &opplwwhh dgoswhg wkh foqfhsw oi htxdolw vxjjhvwhg lq wkh vxeplvvloq pdgh e 6dqgud )uhgpdq dqg owkhu vfkooduv )uhgpdq௲v pogho oi htxdolw sxuvxhv ioxu pdlq oemhfwlyhv ௵uhguhvvlqj wkh vofldo dqg hfoqoplf glvdgydqwdjh dvvofldwhg zlwk glvdelolw dgguhvvlqj vwljpd vwhuhowslqj suhmxglfh dqg yloohqfh hqkdqflqj sduwlflsdwloq dqg dffoppogdwlqj gliihuhqfh e dfklhylqj vwuxfwxudo fkdqjh௶ 6hh 6dqgud )uhgpdq 0hjkdq &dpsehoo 6kuhd $wuh -dvoq %ulfnkloo 1opixqgo 5dpdohndqd 6dqd 6dpwdql $fklhylqj 7udqvioupdwlyh (txdolw iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 6xeplvvloq wo wkh &53’ &opplwwhh iou *hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq $uwlfoh oi wkh 81 &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv dydlodeoh dw &35’6xeplvvloqsgi o[dfxn &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq htxdolw dqg qoqglvfulplqdwloq &53’&*& sdud $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1′ &21&(376 ʷʡ ʷ˜˦˖˥˜ˠ˜ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ $uwlfoh oi wkh &53′ suoylghv wkdw ௵6wdwhv 3duwlhv vkdoo suoklelw doo glvfulplqdwloq oq wkh edvlv oi glvdelolw dqg jxdudqwhh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv htxdo dqg hiihfwlyh ohjdo suowhfwloq djdlqvw glvfulplqdwloq oq doo juoxqgv௶ ,q dgglwloq ௵ lq oughu wo suopowh htxdolw dqg holplqdwh glvfulplqdwloq 6wdwhv 3duwlhv vkdoo wdnh doo dssuosuldwh vwhsv wo hqvxuh wkdw uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq lv suoylghg௶ͷʹͳ 0ouhoyhu $uwlfoh oi wkh &53′ ghilqhv glvfulplqdwloq oq wkh edvlv oi glvdelolw dv ௵ dq glvwlqfwloq h[foxvloq ou uhvwulfwloq oq wkh edvlv oi glvdelolw zklfk kdv wkh sxusovh ou hiihfw oi lpsdlulqj ou qxoolilqj wkh uhfojqlwloq hqmophqw ou h[huflvh oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv oi doo kxpdq uljkwv dqg ixqgdphqwdo iuhhgopv lq wkh soolwlfdo hfoqoplf vofldo fxowxudo flylo ou dq owkhu ilhog ,w lqfoxghv doo ioupv oi glvfulplqdwloq lqfoxglqj ghqldo oi uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq ௶ 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv pd dovo h[shulhqfh lqwhuvhfwloqdo glvfulplqdwloq zklfk offxuv ௵ zkhq d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw ou dvvofldwhg wo glvdelolw vxiihuv glvfulplqdwloq oi dq ioup oq wkh edvlv oi glvdelolw fopelqhg zlwk foooxu vh[ odqjxdjh uholjloq hwkqlf jhqghu ou owkhu vwdwxv௶ͷʹʹ 3uoklelwhg juoxqgv oi glvfulplqdwloq lq lqwhuqdwloqdo kxpdq uljkwv odz dqg fulplqdo odz qoqh[kdxvwlyho lqfoxgh ௵djh vh[ vh[ fkdudfwhulvwlfv jhqghu vh[xdo oulhqwdwloq jhqghu lghqwlw jhqghu h[suhvvloq udfh foooxu qdwloqdo ou vofldo ouljlq qdwloqdolwflwl]hqvkls hwkqlflw glvdelolw lppljudwloq vwdwxv suoshuw eluwk ou ghvfhqw lqfoxglqj oq wkh edvlv oi fdvwh dqg dqdoojoxv vvwhpv oi lqkhulwhg vwdwxv odqjxdjh uholjloq ou eholhi soolwlfdo ou owkhu oslqloq phpehuvkls oi d sduwlfxodu vofldo juoxs pdulwdo ou idplo &53’ duwlfoh &53’ &opplwwhh *hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq (txdolw dqg 1oqglvfulplqdwloq &53’&*& sdud $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1′ &21&(376 vwdwxv suhjqdqf fklogeluwk sduhqwkoog khdowk vwdwxv lqfoxglqj +,9 vwdwxv ou guxj ghshqghqfh hfoqoplf dqg vofldo vwdwxv offxsdwloqdo vwdwxv sodfh oi uhvlghqfh lqgljhqoxv lghqwlw ou vwdwxv plqoulw ou owkhu vwdwxv௶ͷʹ͵ ʸʡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦˜˕˜˟˜˧ˬ 8qltxho dpoqj lqwhuqdwloqdo kxpdq uljkwv wuhdwlhv wkh &35′ foqwdlqv vhoivwdqglqj oeoljdwloqvͷʹͷ iou 6wdwhv wo hqvxuh dffhvvlelolw lqfoxglqj oi sxeolf dqg sulydwh vhuylfhv idflolwlhv lqioupdwloq dqg phdqv oi foppxqlfdwloq wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhvͷʹͷ ,uuhvshfwlyh oi zkhwkhu dq lqglylgxdo qhhgv ou vhhnv suofhgxudo ou uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv 6wdwhv pxvw suodfwlyho wdnh phdvxuhv wo hqvxuh wkdw doo idflolwlhv lqiudvwuxfwxuh foppxqlfdwloq sodwioupv dqg lqioupdwloq suoylghg lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp duh ixoo dffhvvleoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlvͷʹ $ffhvvlelolw duwlfoh wkhuhiouh lqfoxghv d vhsdudwh dqg dgglwloqdo oeoljdwloq oq 6wdwhv lq uhvshfw oi dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxglqj lq wkh foqwh[w oi dffhvv wo mxvwlfh dgglwloqdo wo wkh oeoljdwloq wo suoylgh uhdvoqdeoh duwlfoh dqg suofhgxudo duwlfoh dffoppogdwloqv 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv vshflilhg lq lwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq dffhvvlelolw wkdw 6wdwhv pxvw hqvxuh wkh dffhvvlelolw oi dpoqj owkhuv ௵wkh skvlfdo hqyluoqphqw wudqvsouwdwloq lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloq dqg vhuylfhv௶ 7khvh oeoljdwloqv dsso wo doo ௵joogv suogxfwv dqg vhuylfhv oshq ou suoylghg wo wkh sxeolf௶ uhjdugohvv oi ௵zkhwkhu wkh duh ozqhg dqgou suoylghg e d sxeolf dxwkoulw ou d sulydwh ,elg vhh dovo &opplwwhh oq (foqoplf 6ofldo dqg &xowxudo 5ljkwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o 1oqglvfulplqdwloq lq hfoqoplf vofldo dqg fxowxudo uljkwv duw sdud oi wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo &oyhqdqw oq (foqoplf 6ofldo dqg &xowxudo 5ljkwv (&*& sdud :khwkhu $uwlfoh fuhdwhv d qhz uljkw ou duwlfxodwhv dq h[lvwlqj dvshfw oi doo uljkwv lv d pdwwhu oi voph vfkooduo ghedwh )ou oxu sxusovhv lw lv vxiilflhqw wkdw $uwlfoh dv lqwhusuhwhg e wkh &53’ &opplwwhh fohduo sodfhv ohjdoo elqglqj oeoljdwloqv oq 6wdwhv lq hqvxulqj dffhvvlelolw jhqhudoo dqg lq wkh vshflilf foqwh[w oi mxvwlfh suofhvvhv suofhgxuhv dqg vvwhpv ,elg $uwlfoh &53’ ௵7o hqdeoh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo olyh lqghshqghqwo dqg sduwlflsdwh ixoo lq doo dvshfwv oi olih 6wdwhv 3duwlhv vkdoo wdnh dssuosuldwh phdvxuhv wo hqvxuh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dffhvv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv wo wkh skvlfdo hqyluoqphqw wo wudqvsouwdwloq wo lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloqv lqfoxglqj lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloqv whfkqooojlhv dqg vvwhpv dqg wo owkhu idflolwlhv dqg vhuylfhv oshq ou suoylghg wo wkh sxeolf eowk lq xuedq dqg lq uxudo duhdv >@௶ $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1’ &21&(376 hqwhusulvh௶ ‘hqldo oi dffhvv oq dq htxdo edvlv dpoxqw wo glvfulplqdwloq zkhwkhu shushwudwhg e 6wdwh ou qoq6wdwh dfwouvͷʹ ʹʡ ˃˥ˢ˖˘˗˨˥˔˟ ʴ˖˖ˢˠˠˢ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 3uofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv uhihu wo doo qhfhvvdu dqg dssuosuldwh ௵poglilfdwloqv dqg dgmxvwphqwv lq wkh foqwh[w oi dffhvv wo mxvwlfh zkhuh qhhghg lq d sduwlfxodu fdvh wo hqvxuh wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv௶ 0ovw oi wkh phdvxuhv ghvfulehg lq wklv %hqfk %oon uhtxluhg wo holplqdwh eduulhuv wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh idfhg e shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq mxvwlfh suofhvvhv dqg suofhgxuhv dpoxqw wo ௵suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv௶ $owkoxjk wkh oeoljdwloq wo suoylgh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv $uwlfoh oyhuodsv vljqlilfdqwo zlwk wkh oeoljdwloq wo suoylgh ௵uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv௶ $uwlfoh lw dovo gliihuv lq dq lpsouwdqw uhvshfw 8qolnh wkh oeoljdwloq wo suoylgh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv wkh lpphgldwh oeoljdwloq wo suoylgh dq dqg doo suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv qhhghg e shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo sduwlflsdwh lq mxvwlfh vvwhpv lv qow vxemhfw wo dq olplwdwloq ou uhvwulfwloq edvhg oq wkh suoylvloq e wkh 6wdwh fodlplqj ou suoylglqj dq ௵xqgxh exughq௶ 7klv phdqv iou h[dpsoh wkdw d vkouwdjh oi kxpdq ilqdqfldo ou owkhu uhvoxufhv vkoxog eh lqyonhg e wkh 6wdwh dv d mxvwlilfdwloq iou wkh idloxuh wo suoylgh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wo hqvxuh htxdo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ͷʹͻ $uwlfoh &53’ suoylghv wkdw 6wdwhv pxvw ௵hqvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo mxvwlfh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv lqfoxglqj wkuoxjk wkh suoylvloq &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv kdv vshflilhg lq lwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq dffhvvlelolw &53’& sdud kwwsv zzzokfkuoujvlwhvghidxowilohv’ofxphqwv,vvxhv’lvdelolw65b’lvdelolw*oog3udfwlfhv$ffhvvwo-xvwlfh(1sgi s 3uofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv duh glvwlqjxlvkdeoh iuop uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq lq wkdw suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv duh qow vxemhfwhg wo d suosouwloqdolw whvw dqg wkh kdyh d gxdo fkdudfwhu oqh lv wkdw oi vvwhplf uhdol]dwloq lq whupv oi wudqviouplqj mxglfldo vvwhpv wo eh dffhvvleoh iou dqg lqfoxvlyh oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg dqowkhu wkdw suoylghv iou wkh lpphgldwh suoylvloq oi dffoppogdwloq lq ohjdo suofhhglqjv lq oughu wo dyolg wkdw wkh uljkw wo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh ehfophv yolg lq d sduwlfxodu vlwxdwloq *& $uwlfoh sdud ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv s $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1’ &21&(376 oi suofhgxudo dqg djhdssuosuldwh dffoppogdwloqv௶ 6wdwhv duh uhtxluhg wo ௵idflolwdwh wkhlu hiihfwlyh uooh dv gluhfw dqg lqgluhfw sduwlflsdqwv lqfoxglqj dv zlwqhvvhv lq doo ohjdo suofhhglqjv lqfoxglqj dw lqyhvwljdwlyh dqg owkhu suholplqdu vwdjhv ௵ͷ͵ͳ 7kh 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv௲ ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv ghilqh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv dv lqfoxglqj ௵doo qhfhvvdu dqg dssuosuldwh poglilfdwloqv dqg dgmxvwphqwv lq wkh foqwh[w oi dffhvv wo mxvwlfh zkhuh qhhghg lq d sduwlfxodu fdvh wo hqvxuh wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv௶ ʺʡ ˅˘˔˦ˢˡ˔˕˟˘ ʴ˖˖ˢˠˠˢ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ $uwlfoh oi wkh &53’ ghilqhv ௵uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq௶ dv wkh ௵qhfhvvdu dqg dssuosuldwh poglilfdwloq dqg dgmxvwphqwv qow lpsovlqj d glvsuosouwloqdwh ou xqgxh exughq zkhuh qhhghg lq d sduwlfxodu fdvh wo hqvxuh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkh hqmophqw ou h[huflvh oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv oi doo kxpdq uljkwv dqg ixqgdphqwdo iuhhgopv௶ ௵’hqldo oi uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq௶ foqvwlwxwhv glvfulplqdwloq lq whupv oi wkh &oqyhqwloq ,w lv lpsouwdqw wo qowh wkdw 6wdwhv௲ oeoljdwloqv lq whupv oi dffhvvlelolw vhh deoyh duh vhsdudwh iuop dqg dgglwloqdo wo wkhlu oeoljdwloqv lq uhvshfw wo uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv 7kh &53’ &opplwwhh glvwlqjxlvkhv ehwzhhq dffhvvlelolw dqg uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq oeoljdwloqv lq wkh ioooozlqj pdqqhu ௵ 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq gxwlhv duh gliihuhqw iuop dffhvvlelolw gxwlhv %owk dlp wo jxdudqwhh dffhvvlelolw exw wkh gxw wo suoylgh dffhvvlelolw wkuoxjk xqlyhuvdo ghvljq ou dvvlvwlyh whfkqooojlhv lv dq h[ dqwh gxw zkhuhdv wkh gxw wo suoylgh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq lv dq h[ qxqf gxw &53’ $uwlfoh $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1’ &21&(376 ʴʡ $v dq h[dqwh gxw dffhvvlelolw pxvw eh exlow lqwo vvwhpv dqg suofhvvhv zlwkoxw uhjdug wo wkh qhhg oi d sduwlfxodu shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw iou h[dpsoh wo kdyh dffhvv wo d exloglqj d vhuylfh ou d suogxfw oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv 6wdwhv sduwlhv pxvw vhw dffhvvlelolw vwdqgdugv wkdw duh ghyhooshg dqg dgoswhg lq foqvxowdwloq zlwk oujdql]dwloqv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv foqvlvwhqw zlwk duwlfoh oi wkh &oqyhqwloq 7kh gxw oi dffhvvlelolw lv d suodfwlyh vvwhplf gxw ʵʡ $v dq h[ qxqf gxw uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq pxvw eh suoylghg iuop wkh pophqw wkdw d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw uhtxluhv dffhvv wo qoqdffhvvleoh vlwxdwloqv ou hqyluoqphqwv ou zdqwv wo h[huflvh klv ou khu uljkwv 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq lv oiwhq exw qow qhfhvvdulo uhtxhvwhg e wkh shuvoq zko uhtxluhv dffhvv ou e uhohydqw uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv oi d shuvoq ou d juoxs oi shosoh 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq pxvw eh qhjowldwhg zlwk wkh dssolfdqw v ௶ͷ͵ͳ 7kh gxw oq mxvwlfh dfwouv wo suoylgh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lq vshflilf vlwxdwloqv lv wkhuhiouh dgglwloqdo wo iou h[dpsoh wkh 6wdwhv oeoljdwloqv wo hqvxuh dffhvvlelolw )ou h[dpsoh zkloh d idloxuh wo hqvxuh wkdw d foxuwuoop ou exloglqj lv dffhvvleoh iou d zkhhofkdlu xvhu pljkw foqwudyhqh wkh dffhvvlelolw oeoljdwloq dqg eh ehoqg wkh sozhu oi d vlqjoh suovhfxwou wkdw suovhfxwou zloo kdyh wkh uhvsoqvlelolw lq hdfk vshflilf flufxpvwdqfh wo dffoppogdwh zkhhofkdlu xvhuvͷ͵ʹ 7kh oeoljdwloq wo suoylgh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxghv eowk sovlwlyh oeoljdwloqv wo pdnh poglilfdwloqv dqg dgmxvwphqwv wo hqvxuh htxdolw dqg d gxw wo hqvxuh wkdw vxfk dffoppogdwloqv go qow lpsovh dq xqgxh exughq oq mxvwlfh dfwouvͷ͵͵ &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq htxdolw dqg qoqglvfulplqdwloq௲ 81 ‘of &53’&*& sdud *hqhudo fopphqw 1o $uwlfoh $ffhvvlelolw 81 ‘of &53’&*&sdud &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o $uwlfoh $ffhvvlelolw 81 ‘of &53’&*& sdud &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq htxdolw dqg qoqglvfulplqdwloq௲ 81 ‘of &53’&*& sdud $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1′ &21&(376 $ffouglqj wo wkh &53′ &opplwwhh zkloh zkdw lv ௵uhdvoqdeoh௶ pd ydu lw vkoxog qow eh ghwhuplqhg vooho zlwk uhihuhqfh wo uhvoxufhv dydlodeoh 7kh ghwhuplqdwloq oi uhdvoqdeohqhvv lv wkhuhiouh deoxw wkh ௵uhohydqfh dssuosuldwhqhvv dqg hiihfwlyhqhvv௶ oi d suosovhg dffoppogdwloq iou d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw dqg zkhwkhu lw dfklhyhv lwv sxusovhͷ͵ͷ 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh kdv hpskdvl]hg wkdw ௵gldoojxh zlwk wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw foqfhuqhg௶ vkoxog ௵jxlgh wkh lpsohphqwdwloq௶ oi wkh gxw wo suoylgh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqvͷ͵ͷ ,q dgglwloq vlqfh wkh oemhfwlyh lv wo vxssouw d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw lq hqmolqj htxdo uljkwv wkh ௵exughq oi suooi uhvwv zlwk wkh gxw ehduhu zko fodlpv wkdw wkhlu exughq zoxog eh glvsuosouwloqdwh ou xqgxh௶ dqg lw lv lpsouwdqw wo hqvxuh wkdw ௵shuvoqv zlwk d glvdelolw >@ go qow ehdu wkh fovwv௶ oi dffoppogdwloqv௶ͷ͵ ,q ghwhuplqlqj zkhwkhu d exughq lv xqgxh wkh ilqdqfldo uhvoxufhv dydlodeoh vkoxog eh foqvlghuhg exw vo vkoxog wkh ehqhilwv wo wkh lqglylgxdo ehlqj dffoppogdwhg dqg wo owkhu vlploduo sodfhg lqglylgxdov lq wkh ixwxuhͷ͵ ʻʡ ˆˣ˘˖˜˔˟ ˠ˘˔˦˨˥˘˦ ௵5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq௶ vkoxog qow eh foqixvhg zlwk ௵vshflilf phdvxuhv௶ vophwlphv dovo fdoohg ௵vshfldo phdvxuhv௶ ou ௵whpsoudu vshfldo phdvxuhv௶ lq ,+5/ dqg lqfoxglqj zkdw duh oiwhq ghvfulehg dv ௵diilupdwlyh dfwloq phdvxuhv௶ lq voph gophvwlf mxulvglfwloqvͷ͵ͺ $v wkh &53’ &opplwwhh vwdwhg ௵:kloh eowk foqfhswv dlp dw dfklhylqj gh idfwo htxdolw uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloq lv d qoqglvfulplqdwloq gxw zkhuhdv vshflilf phdvxuhv lpso d suhihuhqwldo wuhdwphqw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oyhu owkhuv wo dgguhvv klvwoulf dqgou vvwhpdwlfvvwhplf h[foxvloq iuop wkh ehqhilwv oi h[huflvlqj uljkwv ,elg sdud d ,elg sdud d ,elg sdud i j ,elg sdud g h ,elg sdud f $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1′ &21&(376 ([dpsohv oi vshflilf phdvxuhv lqfoxgh whpsoudu phdvxuhv iou foxqwhulqj wkh ooz qxpehuv oi zophq zlwk glvdelolwlhv hpsoohg lq wkh sulydwh vhfwou dqg vxssouw suojudpphv wo lqfuhdvh wkh qxpehu oi vwxghqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq whuwldu hgxfdwloq௶ͷ͵ͻ ʼʡ ˇ˛˘ ˦ˢ˖˜˔˟ʟ ˛˨ˠ˔ˡ ˥˜˚˛˧˦ ˔ˡ˗ ˠ˘˗˜˖˔˟ ˠˢ˗˘˟˦ ˢ˙ ˗˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧ˬ ,q whupv oi wkh phglfdo pogho oi glvdelolw iofxv lv sodfhg oq wkh shuvoq௲v foqglwloq zklfk lv xqghuvwoog wo gluhfwo fdxvh wkhlu glvdelolwͷͷͳ 7kh &53’ &opplwwhh kdv h[sodlqhg wkdw ௵>x@qghu wkh phglfdo pogho oi glvdelolw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh qow uhfojql]hg dv uljkwv kooghuv exw duh lqvwhdg ௱uhgxfhg௲ wo wkhlu lpsdluphqwv௶ͷͷͳ (duolhu lqwhuqdwloqdo vwdqgdugv uhodwlqj wo glvdelolw zhuh edvhg oq vxfk d phglfdo pogho oi glvdelolw lqfoxglqj wkh ‘hfodudwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 0hqwdoo 5hwdughg 3huvoqv dqg wkh ‘hfodudwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi ‘lvdeohg 3huvoqv ͷͷʹ 7kh &53’ &opplwwhh uhsuhvhqwv d ghflvlyh ghsduwxuh iuop wklv dssuodfk wo dqg xqghuvwdqglqj oi glvdelolw 7kh vofldo pogho oi glvdelolw oq wkh owkhu kdqg sodfhv iofxv oq wkh eduulhuv fuhdwhg e voflhw dqg wkh lqwhudfwloq oi vxfk eduulhuv zlwk hdfk lqglylgxdo shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw ,w dfnqozohgjhv wkdw vofldo dwwlwxglqdo ohjdo dqg owkhu eduulhuv iuhtxhqwo suhyhqw lqglylgxdov zlwk glvdelolwlhv iuop hqmolqj kxpdq uljkwv oq dq htxdo edvlvͷͷ͵ 7kh 2iilfh oi wkh +ljk &opplvvloqhu iou +xpdq 5ljkwv 2+&+5 kdv h[sodlqhg wkh vofldo pogho oi glvdelolw lq wkh ioooozlqj whupv ௵glvdelolw lv qow d ௵plvwdnh௶ oi voflhw exw dq hohphqw oi lwv glyhuvlw ‘lvdelolw lv d vofldo foqvwuxfw௭wkh uhvxow oi wkh lqwhudfwloq lq voflhw ehwzhhq shuvoqdo idfwouv dqg hqyluoqphqwdo idfwouv ‘lvdelolw lv qow dq lqglylgxdo suoeohp exw wkh oxwfoph &53’ *hqhudo &opphqw 1o sdud f (xuoshdq 3duoldphqwdu 5hvhdufk 6huylfh ௱8qghuvwdqglqj (8 soolflhv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௲ 1oyhpehu s &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௱*hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq htxdolw dqg qoqglvfulplqdwloq௲ &53’&*& $sulo sdud ,elg (xuoshdq 3duoldphqwdu 5hvhdufk 6huylfh ௱8qghuvwdqglqj (8 soolflhv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௲ 1oyhpehu s $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1′ &21&(376 oi d zuoqj oujdql]dwloq oi voflhw $v d foqvhtxhqfh voflhw vkoxog uhvwuxfwxuh soolflhv sudfwlfhv dwwlwxghv hqyluoqphqwdo dffhvvlelolw ohjdo suoylvloqv dqg soolwlfdo oujdql]dwloqv dqg wkhuhiouh glvpdqwoh wkh vofldo dqg hfoqoplf eduulhuv wkdw suhyhqw ixoo sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv௶ͷͷͷ 7kh &53′ uhiohfwv d vofldo pogho oi glvdelolwͷͷͷ dpoxqwlqj wo zkdw wkh &53’ &opplwwhh ghvfulehv dv d kxpdq uljkwv pogho oi glvdelolw ͷͷ dqg h[sodlqv lq lwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o dv ioooozv ௵7kh kxpdq uljkwv pogho oi glvdelolw uhfojql]hv wkdw glvdelolw lv d vofldo foqvwuxfw dqg lpsdluphqwv pxvw qow eh wdnhq dv d ohjlwlpdwh juoxqg iou wkh ghqldo ou uhvwulfwloq oi kxpdq uljkwv ,w dfnqozohgjhv wkdw glvdelolw lv oqh oi vhyhudo odhuv oi lghqwlw +hqfh glvdelolw odzv dqg soolflhv pxvw wdnh wkh glyhuvlw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqwo dffoxqw ,w dovo uhfojql]hv wkdw kxpdq uljkwv duh lqwhughshqghqw lqwhuuhodwhg dqg lqglylvleoh௶ͷͷ 7kh kxpdq uljkwv pogho oi glvdelolw lv iofxvhg oq ௵wkh lqkhuhqw gljqlw oi wkh kxpdq ehlqj dqg vxevhtxhqwo exw oqo li qhfhvvdu oq wkh shuvoq௲v phglfdo fkdudfwhulvwlfv௶ 7khuhiouh lpsouwdqwo lw sodfhv wkh lqglylgxdo shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw ௵dw fhqwuh vwdjh lq doo ghflvloqv diihfwlqj wkhp dqg povw lpsouwdqwo oofdwhv wkh pdlq suoeohp௲ oxwvlgh wkh shuvoq dqg lq voflhw௶ͷͷͺ 7klv pogho wkhuhiouh uhfojql]hv wkdw suowhfwloq oi kxpdq uljkwv iou dq lqglylgxdo shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw ௵gohv qow uhtxluh wkh devhqfh oi lpsdluphqw௶ͷͷͻ ʽʡ ʿ˘˚˔˟ ˖˔ˣ˔˖˜˧ˬ 81 2+&+5 ௱7kh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௬ 7udlqlqj *xlgh 1o ௲ s ,elg s &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௱*hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj fkloguhq zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkuoxjk wkhlu uhsuhvhqwdwlyh oujdql]dwloqv lq wkh lpsohphqwdwloq dqg poqlwoulqj oi wkh &oqyhqwloq௲ &53’&*& 1oyhpehu sdud &opplwwhh oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv ௱*hqhudo &opphqw 1o oq htxdolw dqg qoqglvfulplqdwloq௲ &53’&*& $sulo sdud *hudug 4xlqq dqg 7khuhvld ‘hjhqhu +xpdq 5ljkwv dqg ‘lvdelolw s flwhg lq 7khuhvld ‘hjhqhu ௱$ +xpdq 5ljkwv 0ogho oi ‘lvdelolw௲ lq 5oxwohgjh +dqgeoon oi ‘lvdelolw /dz dqg +xpdq 5ljkwv -xo 7khuhvld ‘hjhqhu ௱$ +xpdq 5ljkwv 0ogho oi ‘lvdelolw௲ lq 5oxwohgjh +dqgeoon oi ‘lvdelolw /dz dqg +xpdq 5ljkwv -xo $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1′ &21&(376 $uwlfoh &53′ suoylghv wkdw ௵shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv hqmo ohjdo fdsdflw oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv lq doo dvshfwv oi olih௶ 6wdwhv pxvw ௵wdnh dssuosuldwh phdvxuhv wo suoylgh dffhvv e shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo wkh vxssouw wkh pd uhtxluh lq h[huflvlqj wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw௶ ,q lwv *hqhudo &opphqw 1o wkh &53′ &opplwwhh diilupv wkdw ௵/hjdo fdsdflw lqfoxghv wkh fdsdflw wo eh eowk d kooghu oi uljkwv dqg dq dfwou xqghu wkh odz /hjdo fdsdflw wo eh d kooghu oi uljkwv hqwlwohv d shuvoq wo ixoo suowhfwloq oi klv ou khu uljkwv e wkh ohjdo vvwhp /hjdo fdsdflw wo dfw xqghu wkh odz uhfojql]hv wkdw shuvoq dv dq djhqw zlwk wkh sozhu wo hqjdjh lq wudqvdfwloqv dqg fuhdwh pogli ou hqg ohjdo uhodwloqvklsv௶ 7kh ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv ghilqh ohjdo fdsdflw dv ௵wkh fdsdflw wo eh eowk d kooghu oi uljkwv dqg dq dfwou xqghu wkh odz /hjdo fdsdflw wo eh d kooghu oi uljkwv hqwlwohv shuvoqv wo ixoo suowhfwloq oi wkhlu uljkwv e wkh ohjdo vvwhp /hjdo fdsdflw wo dfw xqghu wkh odz uhfojql]hv wkdw shuvoq dv dq djhqw zlwk wkh sozhu wo hqjdjh lq wudqvdfwloqv dqg fuhdwh pogli ou hqg ohjdo uhodwloqvklsv௶ 1owh sohdvh vhh pouh ghwdlov lq wkh vhfwloq oq ohjdo fdsdflw ʾʡ ʶˢˠˠ˨ˡ˜˖˔˧˜ˢˡ $uwlfoh oi wkh &53′ ghilqhv foppxqlfdwloq dv lqfoxglqj ௵odqjxdjhv glvsod oi wh[w %udlooh wdfwloh foppxqlfdwloq odujh sulqw dffhvvleoh pxowlphgld dv zhoo dv zulwwhq dxglo sodlqodqjxdjh kxpdquhdghu dqg dxjphqwdwlyh dqg dowhuqdwlyh poghv phdqv dqg ioupdwv oi foppxqlfdwloq lqfoxglqj dffhvvleoh lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloq whfkqoooj௶ ʿʡ ʷ˘˜ˡ˦˧˜˧˨˧˜ˢˡ˔˟˜˭˔˧˜ˢˡ ,qvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq lv d vhw oi glvfulplqdwou sudfwlfhv zklfk wkh &53’ &opplwwhh kdv lqglfdwhg shu vh yloodwh d udqjh oi uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhvͷͷͳ &53’ *xlgholqhv oq ghlqvwlwxoqdol]dwloq lqfoxglqj lq hphujhqflhv 2fwoehu sdud $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1′ &21&(376 7kh &53′ &opplwwhh௲v *xlgholqhv oq ghlqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq go qow ghilqh ghlqvwlwxoqdol]dwloq exw h[sodlq zkdw lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq lv dqg suoylgh h[dpsohv vxfk dv gh idfwo ghqldo oi wkh ohjdo fdsdflw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq euhdfk oi duwlfoh ghwhqwloq dqg ghsulydwloq oi olehuw edvhg oq lpsdluphqw foqwudu wo duwlfoh h[sovxuh oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo ioufhg phglfdo lqwhuyhqwloq zlwk svfkowuoslf phglfdwloqv vxfk dv vhgdwlyhv poog vwdelol]huv hohfwuofoqyxovlyh wuhdwphqw dqg foqyhuvloq wkhuds lqiulqjlqj duwlfohv dqg h[sovxuh oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi guxjv dqg owkhu lqwhuyhqwloqv zlwkoxw wkhlu iuhh sulou dqg lqiouphg foqvhqw lq yloodwloq oi duwlfohv dqg ͷͷͳ ˀʡ ˆ˨ˣˣˢ˥˧˘˗ ʷ˘˖˜˦˜ˢˡʠˀ˔˞˜ˡ˚ 6xevwlwxwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj lv d pogho hqwuhqfkhg lq pdq ohjdo vvwhpv dqg odzv zklfk vhuyhv wo ghsulyh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oi wkh uljkw wo pdnh ghflvloqv iou wkhpvhoyhv dqg lqvwhdg ghohjdwhv wkh uljkw wo owkhuv wo pdnh ghflvloqv oq ehkdoi oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhvͷͷʹ 7kovh wdvnhg zlwk vxevwlwxwlqj wkh ghflvloqpdnlqj oi d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw pdeh dssolqwhg wkuoxjk d ioupdo ohjdo suofhvv vxfk dv zkhq vophoqh lv dssolqwhg wo eh d ௵jxdugldq௶ e odz ou wkuoxjk lqioupdo phdqv vxfk dv zkhq idplo phpehuv ou sudfwlwloqhuv dxwopdwlfdoo dqg vvwhpdwlfdoo wdnh oyhu doo ghflvloqpdnlqjͷͷ͵ 6xevwlwxwhg ghflvloq pdnlqj ghvslwh lwv oqjolqj suhydohqfh lq sudfwlfh dfuovv wkh zouog lv lq gluhfw foqwudyhqwloq oi wkh &53’ dqg lq yloodwloq oi wkh dxwoqop dqg ohjdo fdsdflw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,elg sdud :ouog +hdowk 2ujdql]dwloq ௵6xssouwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj dqg dgydqfh sodqqlqj :+2 4xdolw5ljkwv 6shfldol]hg wudlqlqj௶ -dqxdu dffhvvleoh khuh ,elg $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1′ &21&(376 6xssouwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj lv d pogho wkdw wkh &53’ uhtxluhv 6wdwhv wo dgoswhg e zklfk shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh suoylghg zlwk d udqjh oi vxssouw oswloqv lqfoxglqj wkh vxssouw oi shosoh wkh wuxvw idplo iulhqgv shhuv dgyofdwhv odzhuv lqwhusuhwhuv lqwhuphgldulhv lq oughu wo vxssouw dqg hqkdqfh wkhlu delolw wo pdnh ghflvloqv iou wkhpvhoyhvͷͷͷ 8qghu $uwlfoh oi wkh &53’ 6wdwhv pxvw wdnh dssuosuldwh phdvxuhv wo suoylgh dffhvv e shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo wkh vxssouw wkh pd uhtxluh lq h[huflvlqj wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflwͷͷͷ 6xssouwhg ghflvloq pdnlqj gohv qow lpso wkh sudfwlfh oi wkovh suoylglqj vxssouw zloo vhhn wo hvwdeolvk d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw௲v ௵ehvw lqwhuhvwv௶ iou wkhp ,qvwhdg wkh fhqwudo dlp oi vxssouwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj lv hqvxulqj vxssouw wo hqdeoh dxwoqopoxv ghflvloqpdnlqj dqg wkh h[suhvvloq oi wkh zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv oi dq lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw ˁʡ ʼˡ˧˘˥ˠ˘˗˜˔˥˜˘˦ ,qwhuphgldulhv dovo nqozq dv idflolwdwouv duh ghilqhg e wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo sulqflsohvͷͷ dv ௵ shuvoqv zko zoun dv uhtxluhg zlwk mxvwlfh vvwhp shuvoqqho dqg shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo hqvxuh hiihfwlyh foppxqlfdwloq gxulqj ohjdo suofhhglqjv௶ͷͷ 6xfk lqwhuhphgldulhv pd ௵vxssouw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo xqghuvwdqg dqg pdnh lqiouphg fkolfhv pdnlqj vxuh wkdw wklqjv duh h[sodlqhg dqg wdonhg deoxw lq zdv wkdw wkh fdq xqghuvwdqg dqg wkdw dssuosuldwh dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouw duh suoylghg௶ͷͷͺ 6hh pouh ghwdlov lq vhfwloq ,9 ehooz ,elg 6wdwxv oi wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv dffhvvleoh khuh 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsh dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolwlhv 81 6shfldo 5dssouwhxu oq wkh 5ljkwv oi 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv oq $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh iou 3huvoqv zlwk ‘lvdelolw *oovvdu ,elg $11(; ‘(),1,7,216 $1’ &21&(376 akk-íɍmmɍ-íaj•b-Ÿɍubɍ$mŸa mbm§m-Ÿɍ§ia§ɍjmci§ɍ˜-—m˜-ɍ•˜u -$˜abɍa$]Ÿ§-j-k§ $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 7kh &53′ lwvhoi ghvfulehv glvdelolw dv dq ௵hyooylqj foqfhsw௶ dqg lqglfdwhv wkdw dpoqj owkhuv shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxgh ௵wkovh zko kdyh ooqjwhup skvlfdo phqwdo lqwhoohfwxdo ou vhqvou lpsdluphqwv zklfk lq lqwhudfwloq zlwk yduloxv eduulhuv pd klqghu wkhlu ixoo dqg hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq lq voflhw oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv௶ͷͷͻ 7kh fxuuhqw dqqh[ suoylghv d olvw oi lpsdluphqwv wkdw pd foqvwlwxwh d glvdelolw lq d vshflilf fdvh dqg vshflilf foqwh[w ,w vkoxog qow eh uhdg dv h[foxvlyh qou suhvfulswlyh olvw oi glvdelolwlhv ,w lv udwkhu lqwhqghg wo suoylgh jhqhudo lqioupdwloq deoxw voph glvdelolwlhv dqg lw fdq foqvwlwxwh d xvhixo wooo iou mxvwlfh dfwouv wo hqvxuh wkh hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq oi lqglylgxdov zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq suofhhglqjv $ foqwh[wxdo dqdovlv dqg hydoxdwloq qhhgv wo eh goqh lq hdfk dqg hyhu lqglylgxdo fdvh lq oughu wo foqvlghu zkhwkhu vshflilf dgmxvwphqwv suofhgxudo ou owkhu dffoppogdwloqv duh qhhghg lq hdfk vshflilf fdvh ʴ˖ˤ˨˜˥˘˗ ʵ˥˔˜ˡ ʼˡ˝˨˥ˬ 7kh whup $ftxluhg %udlq ,qmxu $%, uhihuv wo dq gdpdjh wo wkh eudlq wkdw offxuv diwhu eluwk $%, pd eh fdxvhg e yduloxv flufxpvwdqfhv hj dfflghqw vwuonh wxpoxuv ou glvoughuv vxfk dv 3dunlqvoq௲v glvhdvh $ftxluhg %udlq ,qmxu pd ohdg wo fkdqjhv lq skvlfdo dqg vhqvou delolwlhv ou wo fkdqjhv lq wkh delolw wo wklqn dqg ohduq hj phpou oovv odfn oi foqfhqwudwloq gliilfxow zlwk devwudfw wklqnlqj ,w pd dovo fdxvh fkdqjhv lq ehkdyloxu dqg shuvoqdolw hj odfn oi powlydwloq poog vzlqjv ihholqj iodw ou ghsuhvvhg lpsxovlyh ou xqlqklelwhg ehkdyloxu )lqdoo $%, pd fuhdwh foppxqlfdwloq gliilfxowlhv hj vooz ou voxuuhg vshhfk gliilfxow ioooozlqj foqyhuvdwloqv dqg phglfdo gliilfxowlhv hj hslohsv vhl]xuhͷͳ &53’ 3uhdpeoh h ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon -xglfldo &ooohjh 9lfwould $xvwudold 6hfwloq 6hh kwwsv uhvoxufhvmxglfldofooohjhylfhgxdxduwlfoh vhfwloq $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 6oph uhdvoqdeoh dgmxvwphqwv vkoxog eh pdgh wo dvvlvw shuvoqv zlwk $%, zko kdyh gliilfxowlhv lq foppxqlfdwloq ([dpsohv oi wkhvh dgmxvwphqwv duh wkh xvh oi whfkqooojlhv wkh xvh oi fohdu dqg foqflvh odqjxdjh wkh uhshwlwloq oi voph lqglfdwloqv dqg foqfhswv dqg wkh dooozdqfh oi h[wud wlph wo dqvzhuͷͳ ‘xulqj wkh khdulqj owkhu xvhixo dgmxvwphqwv duh uhjxodu euhdnv odwh vwduw wlphv vkouwhqhg gdv dqg d txlhw hqyluoqphqwͷʹ ʴ˚ˢ˥˔ˣ˛ˢ˕˜˔ $joudskoeld lv d skoeld wkdw xvxdoo foqvlvwv oi wkh ihdu oi wudyholqj dzd iuop d shuvoq௲v vdih vsdfh hj koph ou oi ehlqj wudsshg vophzkhuh 7klv skoeld fdq pdqlihvw lq yduloxv zdv dqg zlwk ydulqj vhyhulw $ shuvoq zlwk djoudskoeld pljkw ihdu ehlqj glvwdqw iuop koph exw dovo ehlqj lq xqidploldu uoxwhv dqg sodfhv lq zlgh oshq vsdfhv lq fuozghg sodfhv lq foqilqhg vsdfhv hj wudlqv ou oliwv 6ophwlphv shosoh pljkw dovo ihdu vwdqglqj lq ooqj olqhv ou ehlqj ohiw dooqh :khq shuvoqv zlwk djoudskoeld duh lq wkh ihduhg sodfhv wkh pljkw h[shulhqfh d sdqlf dwwdfn 7khvh shuvoqv pljkw dovo ehfoph dq[loxv hyhq wklqnlqj deoxw jolqj wo wkhvh sodfhv dqg whqg wo dyolg wkhpͷ͵ 3ovvleoh dgmxvwphqwv iou wkh khdulqj lqfoxgh fkoovlqj d oofdwloq iou wkh yhqxh lq d sodfh foovh wo wkh shuvoq௲v koxvh dqg oq wkh juoxqg iooou wdnlqj hylghqfh lq zulwwhq ioup ou wkuoxjk hohfwuoqlf phdqv olplwlqj wkh qxpehu oi shuvoqv lq wkh foxuwuoop dqg dooozlqj wkh ghihqgdqw wo vlw qh[w wo wkh goou kdylqj d fopsdqloq dqg wdnlqj euhdnv zkhq qhhghgͷͷ ʴ˟˕˜ˡ˜˦ˠ ,elg 6hfwloq (txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon 8. -xo 6hh kwwsv zzzmxglflduxndeoxwwkhmxglflduglyhuvlwhtxdowuhdwphqwehqfkeoon ,elg ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 $oelqlvp lv d uduh lqkhulwhg foqglwloq wkdw foqvlvwv oi d uhgxfhg dpoxqw oi phodqlq ou d odfn oi phodqlq 3hosoh zlwk doelqlvp xvxdoo suhvhqw yhu sdoh vnlq kdlu dqg hhv exw wklv pljkw ydu dffouglqj wo wkh wsh oi doelqlvp wkh dpoxqw oi phodqlq suogxfhg e wkh shuvoq௲v eog dqg wkh xvxdo sljphqwdwloq oi wkh hwkqlf juoxs wo zklfk wkh shuvoq ehooqjv 2fxodu doelqlvp diihfwv oqo wkh hhv dqg ofxoofxwdqhoxv doelqlvp diihfwv oqo vnlq dqg kdlu $oelqlvp fdq fdxvh hh suoeohpv wkdw fdqqow eh fouuhfwhg zlwk jodvvhv vhqvlwlylw wo oljkw skowoskoeld dqg qvwdjpxv 1vwdjpxv foqvlvwv oi d shuvoq௲v hhv poylqj lqyooxqwdulo iuop vlgh wo vlgh ou xs dqg gozq ou duoxqgͷͷ 5hdvoqdeoh dgmxvwphqwv iou shosoh zlwk doelqlvp pljkw eh dgmxvwphqwv zlwk oljkwlqj dqg dyolgdqfh oi ylgho khdulqjv li wkh fopsxwhu vfuhhq fuhdwhv gliilfxowlhv 0ouhoyhu wkhvh shuvoqv vkoxog eh dooozhg wo zhdu gdun jodvvhv ou fdsv dqg wkhuh vkoxog eh qo dvvxpswloqv ehfdxvh oi odfn oi hh foqwdfw ou wkh poyhphqw oi wkh hhv )uhtxhqw euhdnv dqg foqvxowlqj wkh lqwhuhvwhg shuvoq deoxw wkh uoop od pljkw dovo eh xvhixo sudfwlfhvͷ ʴ˥ˠʟ ˛˔ˡ˗ʟ ˢ˥ ˦˛ˢ˨˟˗˘˥ ˜ˠˣ˔˜˥ˠ˘ˡ˧ $up kdqg dqg vkoxoghu lpsdluphqwv duh yhu foppoq dqg wkh fdq eh fdxvhg e $uwkulwlv iuo]hq vkoxoghu lqmxu dqg uhshwlwlyh vwudlq lqmxu 56, 56, lv d jhqhudo whup wkdw uhihuv wo d udqjh oi sdlqixo foqglwloqv diihfwlqj wkh pxvfxoovnhohwdo vvwhp 3huvoqv zlwk dup kdqg dqg vkoxoghu lpsdluphqw pljkw h[shulhqfh sdlq oovv oi juls oovv oi poyhphqw pxvfoh zhdnqhvv vsdvpv qxpeqhvv vhqvdwloq oi foog exuqlqj vhqvdwloq slqv dqg qhhgohvͷ 3ovvleoh uhdvoqdeoh dgmxvwphqwv lqfoxgh vxlwdeoh fkdluv uhjxodu euhdnv vkouwhu gdv dvvlvwdqfh zlwk vzhdulqj wkh odwk oshqlqj goouv soxulqj zdwhu pdqohxyulqj khdulqj ,elg ,elg ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 exqgohv dqg wxuqlqj sdjhv 7kh shuvoq vkoxog dovo eh dooozhg wo vlw lq d fopiouwdeoh sovlwloq zlwkoxw wzlvwlqjͷͺ ʴ˥˧˛˥˜˧˜˦ $uwkulwlv lv d foqglwloq wkdw diihfwv shosoh oi doo djhv dqg suhvhqwv yduloxv ioupv hj ovwhoduwkulwlv ukhxpdwolg duwkulwlv oxsxv joxw dqnoovlqj vsoqgolwlv 3huvoqv zlwk duwkulwlv pljkw idfh gliilfxowlhv lq vwdqglqj zdonlqj vlwwlqj dqg lq pdq gdlo wdvnv wkdw uhtxluh poyhphqwvͷͻ ‘xulqj wkh wuldo wkhvh shuvoqv pljkw qhhg dvvlvwdqfh zlwk pdqohxyulqj wuldo exqgohv ou soxulqj zdwhu ,q fdvh wkh kdyh gliilfxowlhv zlwk poyhphqwv wkh vkoxog qow eh uhtxluhg wo vwdqg zkhq wkh mxgjh hqwhuv wkh uoop ,q fdvh oi vzhdulqj wkh zlwqhvv wkh shuvoq vkoxog qow eh dvnhg wo wdnh koog oi wkh odwk fdug ou uholjloxv eoonvͷͳ ʴ˧˧˘ˡ˧˜ˢˡ ʷ˘˙˜˖˜˘ˡ˖ˬ ʻˬˣ˘˥˔˖˧˜˩˜˧ˬ ʷ˜˦ˢ˥˗˘˥ ʛʴʷʻʷʜ $wwhqwloq ‘hilflhqf +shudfwlylw ‘lvoughu $’+’ lv d glvoughu fkdudfwhul]hg e lqdwwhqwlyhqhvv lpsxovlyhqhvv dqg kshudfwlylw wkdw vkoz xs iuop wkh djh oi vhyhq hduv dqg lw pljkw foqwlqxh lq dgxowkoog 7klv glvoughu pljkw diihfw d wuldo ehfdxvh wkh shuvoq pljkw vwuxjjoh wo iofxv dqg olvwhq wo wkh mxgjhͷͳ )ou wklv uhdvoq uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv fdq foqvlvw oi jlylqj pdqdjhphqw lqvwuxfwloqv ou oughuv oqh dw d wlph qow dvnlqj iou oyhufopsoh[ sduwlfxoduv ou vfkhgxohv dqg zulwlqj gozq zkdw dfwloqv qhhg wo eh wdnhq 0ouhoyhu euhdnv vxpplqj xs wkh fxuuhqw vwdjh oi wkh suofhvv ou xvlqj vkouw vhqwhqfhv fdq eh xvhixo )lqdoo wkhvh shuvoqv vkoxog eh dooozhg wo suoylgh zulwwhq dqvzhuv wo zulwwhq ,elg ,elg ,elg ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 txhvwloqv dqg wo kdyh wkh khdulqj lq d uoop zlwk plqlpdo oxwvlgh qolvhv dqg uhgxfhg glvwudfwloqvͷʹ ʴ˨˧˜˦ˠ ˦ˣ˘˖˧˥˨ˠ ˗˜˦ˢ˥˗˘˥ $xwlvp vshfwuxp glvoughu $6’ lv d olihooqj ghyhoosphqwdo glvdelolw dqg lw diihfwv wkh uhodwloqvklsv dqg lqwhudfwloqv oi wkh shuvoq zlwk wkh hqyluoqphqw dqg owkhu shosoh $6′ lv d vshfwuxp foqglwloq vo shosoh fdq h[shulhqfh lw lq yhu gliihuhqw zdv )ou lqvwdqfh qow doo shuvoqv zlwk $6′ kdyh voph ghjuhh oi lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw 3hosoh zlwk $6′ pd h[shulhqfh ghodhg ou lpsdluhg odqjxdjh fopsuhkhqvloq dqg h[suhvvloq 7kh pd dovo kdyh gliilfxowlhv xvlqj dqg xqghuvwdqglqj wkh vofldo foqwh[w oi odqjxdjh dqg lpsdluhg vofldo vnloov )ou h[dpsoh wkh pd lqwhusuhw zougv olwhudoo dyolg hh foqwdfw ou kdyh gliilfxowlhv xqghuvwdqglqj wkhlu ozq ou owkhu shosoh௲v hpowloqv 6oph shuvoqv zlwk $6′ pd dovo kdyh uhshwlwlyh ulwxdolvwlf ou xqxvxdo ehkdyloxuv dqg wkh pd eh vhqvlwlyh wo voxqgv woxfk oljkw ou owkhu vhqvou shufhswloqvͷ͵ ,q wkhvh fdvhv uhdvoqdeoh dgmxvwphqwv lqfoxgh wkh xvh oi fohdu foqflvh dqg sodlq odqjxdjh d fdop yolfh woqh h[wud wlph wo dqvzhu dqg dyolgdqfh oi vdufdvp dqg woo pdq jhvwxuhv ou glvwudfwloqv 7kh txhvwloqv vkoxog eh suhflvh dqg gluhfw dqg wkh mxgjh vkoxog vwduw wkh txhvwloqv zlwk wkh shuvoq௲v qdph wo dyolg plvxqghuvwdqglqjv 7kh mxgjh vkoxog dovo eh fduhixo wo qow foqvlghu dyolglqj hh foqwdfw ou owkhu ehkdyloxuv dv odfn oi uhvshfwͷͷ 2wkhu sovvleoh dgmxvwphqwv duh fohdu h[sodqdwloqv deoxw wkh suofhgxudo vwdjhv flufxodwloq oi zulwwhq lqglfdwloqv vfkhgxohv dqg fkuoqooojlhv oi ghdgolqhv dooozdqfh oi uhjxodu euhdnv dqg sdwlhqfh 7kh foxuwuoop vkoxog eh txlhw dqg zlwk ooz oljkwv dqg wkh shuvoq vkoxog eh dooozhg wo fkoovh zkhuh wo vhdwͷͷ ,elg ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon $xvwudold 6hfwloq ,elg 6hfwloq (txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon 8. $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 ʵ˔˖˞ ʼˠˣ˔˜˥ˠ˘ˡ˧ %dfn sdlq lv zlghvsuhdg dqg lwv vhyhulw dqg gxudwloq pljkw ydu 7kh khdulqj pljkw uhtxluh voph dgmxvwphqwv ghshqglqj oq wkh vhyhulw oi wkh suoeohp )ou lqvwdqfh wkh ghihqgdqwv pljkw qhhg d vxlwdeoh fkdlu uhjxodu euhdnv ou dvvlvwdqfh zlwk pdqohxyulqj khdulqj exqgohv dqg soxulqj zdwhu 7khvh shuvoqv pljkw dovo eh dooozhg wo vwdqg xs dqg zdon duoxqg ou vlw lq d vshflilf sovlwloq wo dyolg wzlvwlqj zkloh wdonlqj zlwk wkh mxgjh dqg dgyofdwhvͷ ʵ˟˜ˡ˗ˡ˘˦˦ ˔ˡ˗ ˉ˜˦˨˔˟ ʼˠˣ˔˜˥ˠ˘ˡ˧ʢʿˢ˪ ˩˜˦˜ˢˡ %olqgqhvv lv d fopsohwh ou dopovw fopsohwh oovv oi ylvloq dqg lw diihfwv wkh shuvoq௲v delolw wo vhh :kloh voph shosoh pd shufhlyh oljkw vkdgozv dqgou vkdshv owkhu shuvoqv vhh qowklqj dw doo &oooxu %olqgqhvv lv dq lqdelolw wo glvwlqjxlvk ehwzhhq foooxuv 6oph shuvoqv go qow glvwlqjxlvk ehwzhhq uhg dqg juhhq owkhuv vhh hyhuwklqj lq eodfn zklwh dqg juh 9lvxdo ,psdluphqw/oz 9lvloq lv d sduwldo oovv oi ylvloq wkdw fdqqow eh fouuhfwhg wkuoxjk jodvvhv 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxgh hqvxulqj gofxphqwv duh lq dffhvvleoh ioupdwv hj %udlooh uhtxlulqj jhqhudo vxssouw dqg jxlgdqfh iuop wkh vxssouw vwdii zkhq wklv lv qhhghg pdnlqj qhfhvvdu skvlfdo dgmxvwphqwv lq wkh foxuwuoop dooozlqj vxssouw shuvoqv wo eh suhvhqw dqg jxdudqwhhlqj dffhvv wo wkh dvvlvwdqfh goj 7kh shuvoqv vkoxog dovo eh dooozhg wo idploldulvh wkhpvhoyhv zlwk wkh skvlfdo hqyluoqphqw dqg wkh vkoxog qow eh dvnhg wo uhfdoo lqioupdwloq ou hyhqwv edvhg oq wkhlu ylvloq )lqdoo suoplvlqj sudfwlfhv iou mxgjhv dqg ohjdo suoihvvloqdov duh dqqoxqflqj wkhpvhoyhv ehiouh vshdnlqj dqg dvnlqj wkh ghihqgdqwv deoxw wkhlu vshflilf qhhgv ,elg ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon $xvwudold 6hfwloq ,elg 6hfwloq $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 ʶ˔ˡ˖˘˥ 7khuh duh pdq gliihuhqw nlqgv oi fdqfhuv wkdw kdyh yduloxv hiihfwv dqg qhhg gliihuhqw wuhdwphqwv 7uhdwphqwv hj vxujhu udgldwloq wkhuds ou fkhpowkhuds vwhp fhoo ou eoqh pduuoz wudqvsodqw koupoqh wkhuds kdyh yduloxv vlgh hiihfwv olnh qdxvhd dqdhpld yoplwlqj sdlq lqvopqld dqg poog fkdqjh /oqjwhup phglfdwloqv fdq kdyh eowk skvlfdo dqg svfkooojlfdo fkdoohqjhv 0ouhoyhu shuvoqv pljkw h[shulhqfh ௵fdqfhu idwljxh௶ zklfk lv fkdudfwhul]hg e wluhgqhvv dqg lqdelolw wo ixqfwloq ehfdxvh oi d odfn oi hqhuj &dqfhu idwljxh pljkw ouljlqdwh iuop wkh fdqfhu lwvhoi ou iuop wkh wuhdwphqw dqg lw fdq eh dfxwh ou fkuoqlf 3huvoqv zlwk fdqfhu pljkw dovo kdyh suoeohpv ehfdxvh oi d zhdnhqhg lppxqh vvwhp dqg wkh qhhg wo dwwhqg qxphuoxv phglfdo dssolqwphqwv iou wuhdwphqwv ,q wkh fdvh oi d ghihqgdqw zlwk fdqfhu uhpowh khdulqjv fdq khos wo dyolg wkh qhhg iou wudyho ou xqqhfhvvdu h[sovxuh wo lqihfwloqv 0ouhoyhu wkh shuvoqv vkoxog eh dooozhg wo dwwhqg phglfdo wuhdwphqwv dqg wo kdyh wkh qhfhvvdu wlph wo jhw wkh uhtxluhg phglfdo fhuwlilfdwh lq uhodwloq wo sudfwlfdo lvvxhv $ suoplvlqj sudfwlfh lv dovo wo dvn lq dgydqfh wo wkh ghihqgdqwv li wkh qhhg sduwlfxodu dgmxvwphqwv gxulqj wkh khdulqjv hj zdwhu ou owkhu gulqn vxssohphqwv d sloooz fkdlu zlwk dup vxssolhv sovvlelolw wo fkdqjh sovlwloq iuop wlph wo wlph duudqjhphqwv lq fdvh oi yoplw ou li wkh suhihu uhpowh khdulqjv ʶ˘˥˘˕˥˔˟ ˣ˔˟˦ˬ &huheudo 3dov lv d juoxs oi glvoughuv diihfwlqj d shuvoq௲v delolw wo poyh lqfoxglqj pxvfoh foqwuoo foouglqdwloq woqh sovwxuh dqg edodqfh ,w lv xvxdoo wkh uhvxow oi oqh ou pouh qoqsuojuhvvlyh deqoupdolwlhv lq wkh eudlq kdsshqlqj ehiouh wkh juozwk dqg ghyhoosphqw duh fopsohwh ,w fdq eh fdxvhg e lqvxiilflhqw o[jhq jhwwlqj wo wkh eudlq (txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon 8. ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 dw eluwk wo[lqv ou jhqhwlf idfwouv /dqjxdjh wkhudslvwv ou vophoqh idploldu zlwk wkh vshhfk sdwwhuqv oi wkh lqglylgxdo fdq eh khosixo wo foppxqlfdwh 6oph shuvoqv dovo xvh foppxqlfdwloq dlgv olnh vshhfk vqwkhvl]huv ou zoug eodugvͷͺͳ 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv duh jxdudqwhhlqj skvlfdo dffhvv wo wkh foxuwuoop wkh wolohw dqg doo wkh wulexqdo௲v idflolwlhv dqg dooozlqj wkh xvh oi foppxqlfdwloq dlgv dqg ghylfhv lq fdvh fhuheudo sdov diihfwv foppxqlfdwloq delolwlhv 3uoplvlqj sudfwlfhv dovo lqfoxgh oujdql]lqj iuhtxhqw euhdnv dooozlqj vxssouw shuvoqv wo sduwlflsdwh dqg glvfxvvlqj zlwk wkh ghihqgdqwv wkhlu qhhgvͷͺʹ ʶ˘˥˘˕˥˔˟ ˉ˔˦˖˨˟˔˥ ʴ˖˖˜˗˘ˡ˧ ʛʶˉʴʜ ʠ ˆ˧˥ˢ˞˘ &huheudo 9dvfxodu $fflghqw &9$ lv fdxvhg e d foow ou khpouukdjh lq dq duhd oi wkh eudlq &9$ fdq ohdg wo zhdnqhvv ou sdudovlv oi dq dup ohj ou oqh vlgh oi wkh eog exw dovo wo wzlvwlqj oi wkh idfh oovv oi edodqfh glvwxuedqfh oi ylvloq suoeohpv lq vshhfk gliilfxowlhv lq xqghuvwdqglqj dqg oovv oi foqwuoo oi wkh eodgghu ou eozhov 7kh uhfoyhu iuop d vwuonh fdq ydu d oow iuop lqglylgxdo wo lqglylgxdoͷͺ͵ 7kh dgmxvwphqwv uhtxluhg ghshqg oq wkh suoeohp wkdw wkh shuvoq suhvhqwv 7khuh pljkw eh d qhhg iou dgmxvwphqwv oi wkh foppxqlfdwloq vwoh suhvhqfh oi d fduhu khos zlwk lqwhusuhwdwloq ou xvh oi 0dndwoq vljqv dqg vpeoov wo foppxqlfdwhͷͺͷ ʶ˛˥ˢˡ˜˖ ˂˕˦˧˥˨˖˧˜˩˘ ˃˨˟ˠˢˡ˔˥ˬ ʷ˜˦˘˔˦˘ ʛʶ˂˃ʷʜ &kuoqlf 2evwuxfwlyh 3xopoqdu ‘lvhdvh &23’ lv d jhqhudo whup wo uhihu wo fkuoqlf euoqfklwlv hpskvhpd ou eowk &23′ lv suojuhvvlyh dqg qoquhyhuvleoh dqg lwv vpswopv duh foxjk zkhh]h dqg euhdwkohvvqhvv 3huvoqv zlwk &23’ pljkw qhhg ,elg ,elg ,elg ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 lqkdohuv ou souwdeoh o[jhq lq wkh povw vhyhuh fdvhv 7kh lqkdohuv wdnh voph wlph wo zoun dqg wkh fdq fdxvh sdoslwdwloqv dqg gl]]lqhvvͷͺͷ 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv pljkw lqfoxgh iuhtxhqw euhdnv ou d voozhu sdfh gxulqj fuovvh[dplqdwloqvͷͺ ʷ˘˔˙ˡ˘˦˦ ˔ˡ˗ ˛˘˔˥˜ˡ˚ ˟ˢ˦˦ ‘hdiqhvv lv wkh fopsohwh ou dopovw lqfopsohwh lqdelolw wo khdu ‘hdi shosoh foppxqlfdwh lq yduloxv zdv 6oph shuvoqv zlwklq wkh ghdi foppxqlw go qow foqvlghu ghdiqhvv dv d glvdelolw exw uhjdug wkhpvhoyhv dv d fxowxudo dqg olqjxlvwlf plqoulw juoxsͷͺ 3ovvleoh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv duh suoylglqj lqwhusuhwhuv oi wkh vljq odqjxdjh dooozlqj wkh suhvhqfh oi d vxssouw shuvoq idflqj wkh ghdi shuvoqv nhhslqj hh foqwdfw dqg jlylqj wkh qhhghg wlph wo dqvzhuͷͺͺ 2wkhu sovvleoh suoplvlqj sudfwlfhv lqyooyh fkoovlqj d txlhw uoop zlwk joog oljkwlqj dooozlqj wkh xvh oi lqgxfwloq ooos ou zulwlqj lqioupdwloq dqg lqglfdwloqv :khq wkh mxgjh dqg wkh owkhu suoihvvloqdov lq wkh foxuw vshdn wkh vkoxog qow vkoxw ou h[djjhudwh zlwk kdqg jhvwxuhv ou idfldo h[suhvvloqv exw wkh vkoxog vshdn lq d vwhdg ukwkp pdnh d olwwoh sdxvh diwhu hyhu vhqwhqfh wo doooz wkh wudqvodwloq ooon dw wkh ghdi shuvoq dqg xvh ixoo vhqwhqfhv ,w lv lpsouwdqw wo uhphpehu wkdw wkhuh lv qo xqlyhuvdo vljq odqjxdjh exw wkhuh duh pdq qdwloqdo vljq odqjxdjhv )ou wklv uhdvoq ehlqj dzduh oi wkh odqjxdjh vsonhq e wkh shuvoq lv lpsouwdqwͷͺͻ ʷ˘˔˙˕˟˜ˡ˗ˡ˘˦˦ ‘hdieolqgqhvv foqvlvwv oi d oovv oi ylvloq dqg khdulqj ‘hdieolqgqhvv ydulhv iuop shuvoq wo shuvoq )ou lqvwdqfh voph shuvoqv pd eh ixoo eolqg dqg kdug oi khdulqj ,elg ,elg ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon $xvwudold 6hfwloq ,elg 6hfwloq (txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon 8. $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 dqg owkhu lqglylgxdov pd eh ghdi zlwk voph vljkw 6oph shosoh pd dovo h[shulhqfh oi fopsohwh ou qhduo fopsohwh oovv oi eowk vljkwvͷͻͳ 3huvoqv zko duh ghdieolqg pd uhtxluh wkh suhvhqfh oi lqwhusuhwhuv zko duh h[shuw lq wdfwloh vljq odqjxdjhͷͻͳ ʷ˜˔˕˘˧˘˦ ‘ldehwhv lv d foqglwloq wkdw fdxvhv eooog vxjdu wo ehfoph woo kljk 7sh gldehwhv lv xvxdoo wuhdwhg zlwk wdeohwv vshflilf glhw h[huflvh dqg vophwlphv lqvxolq lqmhfwloqv 7sh gldehwhv lv dovo fdoohg ௵lqvxolqghshqghqw gldehwhv௶ ehfdxvh lqglylgxdov qhhg lqvxolq lqmhfwloqv wo olyh 7kh shuvoq zlwk gldehwhv iuhtxhqwo qhhgv wo whvw wkhlu eooog vxjdu ohyhov wo pdnh lqmhfwloqv dqg wo fduu voph ioup oi vxjdu zlwk wkhp hj joxfovh wdeohwv il]] gulqnv fkofoodwhͷͻʹ 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv fdq foqvlvw lq oujdql]lqj il[hg euhdnv iou eooog whvwlqj dqg lqmhfwlqj dooozlqj ioog dqg gulqnv lq wkh foxuw hqvxulqj wkdw wkh vfkhgxoh gohv qow lqwhuihuh zlwk wlph vhw iou oxqfk ou glqqhuͷͻ͵ ʷ˜˦˦ˢ˖˜˔˧˜ˢˡ ‘lvvofldwloq lv d zd wkdw wkh plqg foshv zlwk woo pxfk vwuhvv dqg lw fdq eh olqnhg wo wudxpd ou wo d phqwdo khdowk suoeohp ou lw fdq eh d vlgh hiihfw oi dofokoo ou phglfdwloq 3huvoqv zko h[shulhqfh glvvofldwloq ihho ghwdfkhg iuop wkhlu eog dqg wkh zouog duoxqg wkhp 7klv ihholqj fdq odvw iuop koxuv wo xs wo poqwkv 3huvoqv pd eh xqdeoh wo uhphpehu lqioupdwloq deoxw wkhpvhoyhv ou wkh pd h[shulhqfh wkh zouog dv iojj ou xquhdo 7kh pd ihho olnh wkh duh vhhlqj wkhlu hpowloqv iuop oxwvlgh ou wkh pd ihho glvfoqqhfwhg iuop wkhlu eog 7kh pd dovo vzlwfk iuop gliihuhqw sduwv oi wkhlu ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon $xvwudold 6hfwloq ,elg 6hfwloq (txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon 8. ss ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 shuvoqdolw xvh gliihuhqw qdphv ou vkliw lghqwlw 3hosoh zko kdyh uhjxodu h[shulhqfhv oi glvvofldwloq pd eh gldjqovhg zlwk d glvvofldwlyh glvoughuͷͻͷ 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv fdq foqvlvw oi uhfouglqj hylghqfh zkhq wkh shuvoq lv qow h[shulhqflqj glvvofldwloq suoylglqj dq lqwhuphgldu dooozlqj d vxssouw shuvoq dqg dooozlqj wkh shuvoq wo jlyh hylghqfh lq vhyhudo gliihuhqw lghqwlwlhvͷͻͷ ‘hphqwld dqg $o]khlphu௲v ‘lvhdvh ‘hphqwld lv qow d vshflilf glvhdvh exw lw lv d fooohfwloq oi vpswopv wkdw duh fdxvhg e glvoughuv diihfwlqj wkh eudlq $o]khlphu௲v ‘lvhdvh lv oqh ioup oi ghphqwld ‘hphqwld kdv lpsdfwv oq wklqnlqj phpou ehkdyloxu ylvxovsdwldo dzduhqhvv vhqvhv dqg wkh delolw wo shuioup hyhugd wdvnvͷͻ ‘hphqwld fdq diihfw shosoh lq gliihuhqw zdv dqg zlwk gliihuhqw lqwhqvlw )ou wklv uhdvoq suoplvlqj sudfwlfh foqvlvwv oi dvvhvvlqj hdfk vlwxdwloq dqg hvwdeolvklqj wkh dgmxvwphqwv foqvlghulqj wkh vshflilf nlqg oi ghphqwld dqg wkh shuvoqdo flufxpvwdqfhv oi wkh ghihqgdqw ([dpsohv oi uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv duh dooozlqj uhjxodu euhdnv ohwwlqj d vxssouw shuvoq sduwlflsdwh lq wkh khdulqj dqg dgmxvwlqj sdfh dqg woqh zkhq vshdnlqjͷͻ 3ovvleoh dgmxvwphqwv lq wkh fdvh oi $o]khlphu௲v ‘lvhdvh lqyooyh suoylglqj dq lqwhuphgldu dooozlqj d vxssouw shuvoq lq wkh khdulqj dqg uhfouglqj hylghqfh zkhq wkh shuvoq lv oxflgͷͻͺ ʷˢ˪ˡ ˆˬˡ˗˥ˢˠ˘ ‘ozq 6qguoph lv d jhqhwlf foqglwloq uhvxowlqj lq dq h[wud fkuopovoph ‘ozq 6qguoph lv fkdudfwhul]hg e d udqjh oi skvlfdo khdowk fkdudfwhulvwlfv dqg ,elg s ,elg ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon $xvwudold 6hfwloq ,elg 6hfwloq (txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon 8. s $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 ghyhoosphqwdo hiihfwv $ foppoq fkdudfwhulvwlf oi ‘ozq 6qguoph lv voph ghjuhh oi lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw ͷͻͻ 6oph shuvoqv zlwk ‘ozq 6qguoph pd qhhg foppxqlfdwloq dgmxvwphqwv olnh wkh xvh oi foppxqlfdwloq dlgv ou wkh khos oi d vxssouw shuvoqͳͳ ʷˬ˦˟˘˫˜˔ ‘voh[ld pdqlihvwv lwvhoi dv d gliilfxow zlwk uhdglqj zulwlqj dqg vshoolqj 7kh fouh fkdoohqjhv oi gvoh[ld duh wkh udslg suofhvvlqj oi odqjxdjhedvhg lqioupdwloq dqg zhdn vkouwwhup dqg zounlqj phpou % dgxowkoog pdq shosoh kdyh htxlsshg wkhpvhoyhv zlwk goslqj vwudwhjlhv wkdw doooz wkhp wo ghdo zlwk vlwxdwloqv lq zklfk wkh h[shulhqfh gliilfxowlhv 6oph shuvoqv pljkw dovo uho oq whfkqoooj iou pdq dvshfwv oi wkhlu gdlo olihͳͳ 9duloxv uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv fdq eh pdgh dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqj %hiouh wkh khdulqj oudo lqvwuxfwloq fdq eh ioooozhg e zulwwhq lqglfdwloqv dqg uhplqghuv 7kh lqvwuxfwloqv vkdoo eh jlyhq lq sodlq odqjxdjh wkuoxjk hohfwuoqlf phdqv dqg lq fdvh oi zulwwhq lqglfdwloqv wkh ioupdwwlqj vwoh vkdoo eh fohdu hj dw ohdvw ioqw vl]hv juhdw vsdflqj foooxuhg sdshu ‘xulqj wkh khdulqj shuvoqv zlwk gvoh[ld pljkw qhhg uhjxodu euhdnv fohdu h[sodqdwloqv vlqjohdvnhg txhvwloqv wlph wo wklqn deoxw wkh lqioupdwloq dqg wkh sovvlelolw oi dvnlqj txhvwloqv dqg fodulilfdwloqv ,q jhqhudo wkh vkoxog qow eh h[shfwhg wo jlyh yhu suhflvh ghwdlov ou wo uhphpehu hyhuwklqj dqg sovvleoh plvxqghuvwdqglqjv vkoxog qow eh uhjdughg dv hydvlyhqhvv dqg lqfoqvlvwhqfͳʹ ʷˬ˦ˣ˥˔˫˜˔ʢʷ˘˩˘˟ˢˣˠ˘ˡ˧˔˟ ʶˢˢ˥˗˜ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ ʷ˜˦ˢ˥˗˘˥ ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon $xvwudold 6hfwloq ,elg 6hfwloq (txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon 8. ss ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 ‘vsud[ld lv dq lpsdluphqw ou lppdwxulw oi wkh oujdqlvdwloq oi poyhphqw 3huvoqv zlwk gvsud[ld fdq eh vooz khvlwdqw soouo foouglqdwhg dqg zlwk soou sovwxuh dqg edodqfh 7kh pljkw dovo kdyh suoeohpv zlwk vshhfk ehfdxvh oi soou foqwuoo oi poxwk pxvfohv 6ophwlphv wkh dovo vkoz gliilfxowlhv zlwk vofldo vnloov vkouwwhup phpou vhtxhqflqj vnloov wlph pdqdjhphqw ghflvloqpdnlqj oujdql]dwloqdo vnloov dqg pdqdjlqj fkdqjhv dqg qhz uoxwlqhv 3huvoqv zlwk gvsud[ld pljkw dovo h[shulhqfh kshuvhqvlwlylw wo qolvh woxfk dqg oljkw dqg wkh pljkw ihho oyhuzkhophg e vlpxowdqhoxv wdvnv fopsoh[ lqioupdwloq dqg exv hqyluoqphqwvͳ͵ ʸ˔˧˜ˡ˚ ʷ˜˦ˢ˥˗˘˥˦ (dwlqj glvoughuv duh fkdudfwhul]hg e dq deqoupdo dwwlwxgh wo ioog diihfwlqj hdwlqj kdelwv dqg ehkdyloxuv (dwlqj glvoughuv duh oiwhq olqnhg wo dq[lhw ghsuhvvloq ou oevhvvlyhfopsxovlyh glvoughuv 7khuh duh yduloxv nlqgv oi hdwlqj glvoughuv lqfoxglqj dqouh[ld qhuyovd exolpld elqjh hdwlqj glvoughu dqg (‘126 hdwlqj glvoughuv qow owkhuzlvh vshflilhg ‘xulqj d wuldo shuvoqv zlwk dq hdwlqj glvoughu pljkw dsshdu wluhg xqlqwhuhvwhg ou wkh pljkw kdyh gliilfxowlhv lq iofxvlqjͳͷ 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv pljkw lqfoxgh iuhtxhqw euhdnv oxqfk dw djuhhg wlphv dqg dyolgdqfh deoxw fopphqwv oi wkh shuvoq௲v skvlfdo dsshdudqfhͳͷ ʸˣ˜˟˘ˣ˦ˬ (slohsv lv d qhxuooojlfdo glvoughu fkdudfwhul]hg e hslohswlf vhl]xuhv 7khuh duh pdq wshv oi vhl]xuhv dqg shuvoqv fdq h[shulhqfh hslohsv lq yduloxv zdv ghshqglqj oq zklfk sduw oi wkh eudlq lv diihfwhg 6oph vhl]xuhv fdq odvw iou d ihz vhfoqgv shwlwpdo ou devhqfh oi vhl]xuhv dqg wkh fdq fdxvh wkh lqglylgxdo wo vwos vwduh eolqn ou ooon ydjxh 6oph vhl]xuhv fdq odvw iou d ihz plqxwhv judqgpdo ou woqlffooqlf vhl]xuhv dqg wkh fdq fdxvh xqfoqvfloxvqhvv eog vwliiqhvv dqg wzlwfklqj $iwhu wkhvh ,elg ,elg ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 vhl]xuhv lqglylgxdov xvxdoo h[shulhqfh d shulog oi guozvlqhvv foqixvloq dqg khdgdfkhv ,q voph lqglylgxdov vwuhvv dqg vshflilf oljkwlqj fdq wuljjhu vhl]xuhvͳ 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxgh suoylglqj d vdih fkdlu dqg wulqj wo uhgxfh wkh vwuhvv oi wkh foxuwuoop hqyluoqphqw ,q fdvh oi skowovhqvlwlylw iodvklqj oljkwv ou ioxouhvfhqw vwuls oljkwlqj vkdoo eh dyolghg *hqhudo nqozohgjh deoxw koz wo ehkdyh lq fdvh oi d woqlffooqlf vhl]xuh fdq eh yhu xvhixo wo nhhs wkh shuvoq vdih dqg wo dyolg dodup ,q fdvh oi foqyxovloqv kdupixo oemhfwv qhdu wkh shuvoq vkoxog eh uhpoyhg dqg d fxvkloq vkoxog eh sxw xqghu wkh khdg ‘xulqj foqyxovloqv wkh shuvoq vkoxog qow eh uhvwudlqhg ou poyhg h[fhsw lq fdvh oi lpphgldwh gdqjhu dqg qowklqj vkoxog eh sxw lq wkh poxwk oi wkh shuvoq :khq wkh foqyxovloqv vwos wkh shuvoq vkoxog eh sxw lq wkh uhfoyhu sovlwloq lh oq wkh vlghͳ ʹ˜˕˥ˢˠˬ˔˟˚˜˔ )leuopdojld lv d ooqjwhup foqglwloq fdxvlqj zlghvsuhdg dqg yduldeoh sdlq doo oyhu wkh eog 7kh h[dfw ouljlq oi ileuopdojld lv vwloo xqnqozq dqg lwv gldjqovlv lv gliilfxow 7kh vpswopv duh dovo yduloxv dqg wkh lqfoxgh zlghvsuhdg foqwlqxoxv sdlq h[wuhph vhqvlwlylw vwliiqhvv dqg pxvfoh vsdvpv soou vohhs txdolw khdgdfkhv pljudlqhv fojqlwlyh suoeohpv dqg gliilfxowlhv lq uhphpehulqj wklqjv 6ophwlphv shuvoqv dovo h[shulhqfh foxpvlqhvv gl]]lqhvv uhvwohvv ohjv vqguoph dq[lhw ghsuhvvloq dqg luulwdeoh eozho vqguophͳͺ ‘xulqj wkh khdulqj uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxgh uhjxodu euhdnv odwh vwduwv ou vkouwhqhg gdv dvvlvwdqfh zlwk wkh wudlo exqgoh vooz sdfh gxulqj fuovvh[dplqdwloq dqg uhduudqjhphqw oi wkh oughu oi jlylqj hylghqfh wo dyolg wlphv zkhq h[kdxvwloq dqg sdlq duh pouh suhvhqwͳͻ ,elg ss ,elg ,elg ss ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 ʻ˔˟˟˨˖˜ˡ˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ +dooxflqdwloqv foqvlvw oi wkh h[shulhqfh oi vhhlqj khdulqj vphoolqj ou ihholqj wklqjv wkdw go qow h[lvw oxwvlgh wkhlu plqg +dooxflqdwloqv pd offxu lq shuvoqv zlwk vfkl]oskuhqld elsoodu glvoughu ghphqwld $o]khlphu௲v 3dunlqvoq௲v glvhdvh ou &kduohv %oqqhw 6qguoph exw dovo dv d foqvhtxhqfh oi guxj xvh dofokoo zlwkgudzdo h[wuhph wluhgqhvv ou uhfhqw ehuhdyhphqw +hdulqj yolfhv lv d uhfojql]hg vpswop oi vfkl]oskuhqld elsoodu glvoughu dqg ghphqwld 9lvxdo kdooxflqdwloqv duh dovo foppoq zlwk vfkl]oskuhqld dqg 3dunlqvoq௲v glvhdvhͳͳ ,i wkh shuvoq lv h[shulhqflqj kdooxflqdwloqv gxulqj wkh khdulqj lw lv lpsouwdqw wo foqvlghu zkhwkhu lw lv sovvleoh wo foqwlqxh ,q fdvh wkh khdulqj foqwlqxhv sovvleoh uhdvoqdeoh dgmxvwphqwv foqvlvw lq dgoswlqj d fdop pdqqhu dooozlqj hylghqfh wo eh jlyhq ehklqg vfuhhqv ou dw dqowkhu wlph iofxvlqj oq oqh txhvwloq dw d wlph dqg uhshdwlqj txhvwloqv 2wkhu vooxwloqv duh wkh xvh oi dq lqwhuphgldu dqg oi hylghqfh lq zulwwhq ioupͳͳ ʻ˘˔˥˧ ˗˜˦˘˔˦˘ +hduw glvhdvh fdq diihfw khduw pxvfohv khduw ydoyhv eooog yhvvhov oi wkh khduw ou dq owkhu sduw oi wkh khduw ([dpsohv oi khduw glvhdvh duh foqjhqlwdo khduw glvhdvh fdugloposdwk fouoqdu duwhu glvhdvh dqjlqd khduw dwwdfn pofdugldo lqidufwloq kljk eooog suhvvxuh kshuwhqvloq dqg khduw idloxuhͳʹ ‘xulqj wkh khdulqj voph shuvoqv vkdoo eh dooozhg wo xvh d *71 vsud ou wdeohwv wo sxw xqghu wkhlu woqjxh $iwhu wkh xvh oi wklv phglfdwloq wkh pljkw qhhg d euhdn ehfdxvh *71 fdq fdxvh sdoslwdwloqv gl]]lqhvv oljkwkhdghgqhvv ou khdgdfkhͳ͵ ʻʼˉ ˔ˡ˗ ʴʼʷˆ ,elg ss ,elg ,elgss ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 +,9 kxpdq lppxqoghilflhqf yluxv lv d yluxv wkdw dwwdfnv wkh lppxqh vvwhp diihfwlqj wkh eog௲v delolw wo iljkw lqihfwloqv $,’6 dftxluhg ,ppxqh ‘hilflhqf 6qguoph lv wkh ilqdo vwdjh oi +,9 lqihfwloq zkhq wkh eog lv qo ooqjhu deoh wo iljkw fhuwdlq lqihfwloqv ou glvhdvhv olnh 7% ou fdqfhu 0dq vwljpdv pwkv dqg plvfoqfhswloqv duh vwloo suhvhqw deoxw +,9 dqg $,’6ͳͷ 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxgh lqfuhdvhg euhdnv dqg vkouwhu gdv dydlodelolw oi zdwhu dqg hdv dffhvv wo wolohwvͳͷ ʼˡ˖ˢˡ˧˜ˡ˘ˡ˖˘ ,qfoqwlqhqfh foqvlvwv oi dq lqdelolw wo foqwuoo qdwxudo ixqfwloqv ou d qhhg wo uho oq edjv dqg sdgv 6wuhvv fdq pdnh pdwwhuv zouvhͳ 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv fdq lqfoxgh uhjxodu euhdnv dffhvvleoh wolohwv qhdu wkh foxuwuoop wkh oofdwloq oi wkh foxuw yhqxh qhdu wkh koxvh oi wkh ghihqgdqw dqg d suhdjuhhg vljqdo wo lqglfdwh zkhq wkh shuvoq qhhgv dq lpphgldwh euhdn ,q h[wuhph fdvhv wkh hylghqfh fdq eh wdnhq e ylgho olqnͳ ʼˡ˙˟˔ˠˠ˔˧ˢ˥ˬ ˕ˢ˪˘˟ ˗˜˦˘˔˦˘ ,qiodppdwou eozho glvhdvh lv d jhqhudo whup lqfoxglqj &uokq௲v glvhdvh dqg xofhudwlyh foolwlv exw lw gohv qow lqfoxgh luulwdeoh eozho vqguoph ,%6 :kloh &kuoq௲v glvhdvh diihfwv wkh hqwluh jxw iuop poxwk wo dqxv xofhudwlyh foolwlv diihfwv wkh odujh lqwhvwlqh 7kh eowk fdq fdxvh degoplqdo sdlq eooog glduukhd dqg jhqhudo loo khdowkͳͺ 7kh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxgh uhjxodu euhdnv dffhvvleoh wolohwv qhdu wkh foxuwuoop oofdwloq oi wkh foxuw yhqxh qhdu wkh koxvh oi wkh ghihqgdqw dqg d suh ,elgss ,elg ,elgss ,elg ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 djuhhg vljqdo wo lqglfdwh zkhq wkh shuvoq qhhgv dq lpphgldwh euhdn ,q h[wuhph fdvhv wkh hylghqfh fdq eh wdnhq e ylgho olqnͳͻ ʼˡ˧˘˟˟˘˖˧˨˔˟ ˗˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧ˬ ,qwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw lv fkdudfwhul]hg e vljqlilfdqw olplwdwloqv lq lqwhoohfwxdo ixqfwloqlqj dqg dgdswlyh ehkdyloxuv 7khuh duh yduloxv wshv dqg ghjuhhv oi lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw 3huvoqv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw pd kdyh gliilfxowlhv lq foppxqlfdwlqj lqwhudfwlqj zlwk owkhu shosoh dqg olylqj lqghshqghqwo 3hosoh zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolwlhv qhhg pouh wlph wo xqghuvwdqg vsonhq dqg zulwwhq lqioupdwloq dqg wkh pd kdyh gliilfxowlhv xqghuvwdqglqj lqvwuxfwloqv ou devwudfw foqfhswv 7kh pd dovo kdyh suoeohpv uhodwhg wo dwwhqwloq vsdq dqg phpou dqg ehfoph wluhg hdvloʹͳ ʿ˔˥ˬˡ˚˘˖˧ˢˠˬ /duqjhfwop lv wkh uhpoydo oi wkh oduq[ dqg lw lv xvxdoo d uhvxow oi fdqfhu $iwhu wkh vxujhu lqglylgxdov kdyh wo uhohduq koz wo vshdn 7khuh duh wkuhh pdlq zdv oi dvvlvwlqj zlwk vshhfk d yolfh suovwkhvlv ou wudfkhdohvoskdjhdo sxqfwxuh ohvoskdjhdo vshhfk ou hohfwuooduq[ʹͳ 3ovvleoh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxgh xvlqj zulwlqj idflolwlhv dqg hylghqfh lq zulwwhq ioup ehiouh wkh khdulqj dqg dvnlqj oqo hvvhqwldo txhvwloqvʹʹ ʿ˘˔˥ˡ˜ˡ˚ ˗˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ /hduqlqj glvdelolw lv d olihooqj foqglwloq dftxluhg ehiouh gxulqj ou vooq diwhu eluwk wkdw diihfwv lqwhoohfwxdo ghyhoosphqw ,w vkoxog qow eh foqixvhg zlwk wkh ௵vshflilf ohduqlqj gliilfxowlhv௶ vxfk dv gvoh[ld /hduqlqj glvdelolw fdq eh plog poghudwh ou vhyhuh 3hosoh zlwk d ohduqlqj glvdelolw kdyh gliilfxowlhv wo xqghuvwdqg dqg uhphpehu qhz ou fopsolfdwhg lqioupdwloq wo ohduq qhz vnloov dqg wo jhqhudol]h dq ohduqlqj wo ,elg ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon $xvwudold s (txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon 8. s ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 owkhu vlwxdwloqv 6oph shuvoqv duh xqdeoh wo uhdg ou kdyh gliilfxowlhv lq vshdnlqj dqg voph lqglylgxdov pljkw dovo kdyh suoeohpv lq dffopsolvklqj gdlo wdvnvʹ͵ 7khuh lv d zlgh udqjh oi sovvleoh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lq wkh fdvh oi ghihqgdqwv zlwk ohduqlqj glvdelolwlhv ‘xulqj wkh khdulqj wkhuh fdq eh dgmxvwphqwv lqfoxglqj d ylvlw wo wkh wulexqdo ehiouh wkh vwduw oi wkh wuldo olyh olqnv ou vfuhhqv iuhtxhqw euhdnv wkh xvh oi dq lqwhuphgldu sodlq odqjxdjh foppxqlfdwloq dlgv dqg ixuwkhu h[sodqdwloqv deoxw wkh foqwh[w dqg wkh suofhgxuh (yhq lq hydoxdwlqj wkh hylghqfh wkh shuvoq௲v ohduqlqj glvdelolw vkoxog eh wdnhq lqwo dffoxqw $qowkhu suoplvlqj sudfwlfh lv wkh xvh oi 0dndwoq dqg wkh suhvhqfh oi dq lqwhusuhwhu zko nqozv lw 0dndwoq lv d odqjxdjh suojudpph wkdw hqdeohv shuvoqv zlwk foppxqlfdwloq gliilfxowlhv wo h[suhvv wkhpvhoyhv lqghshqghqwoʹͷ ʿ˨ˣ˨˦ /xsxv lv dq dxwolppxqh foqglwloq wkdw fdq udqjh iuop plog wo olihwkuhdwhqlqj 7kh pdlq vpswopv duh idwljxh molqw sdlq dqg udvkhv 3owhqwldo vpswopv duh kljk eooog suhvvxuh pljudlqh 5dqdxg௲v glvhdvh vhl]xuhv ghsuhvvloq dqg phpou oovvʹͷ $ssuosuldwh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv ghshqg oq wkh qdwxuh dqg vhyhulw oi wkh vpswopv ,q jhqhudo uhgxflqj wkh vwuhvv oi wkh suofhhglqj pljkw eh khosixo 3ovvleoh zdv wo uhgxfh wkh vwuhvv lqfoxgh dgglwloqdo euhdnv h[shglwlqj wkh ilqdo khdulqj gdwh odfn oi ghodv vkouw ilqdo khdulqjv dqg d fdop woqh gxulqj wkh fuovvh[dplqdwloq $qowkhu sovvleoh vooxwloq lv jlylqj wkh shuvoq wkh sovvlelolw wo jlyh hylghqfh iluvwʹ ˀ˘ˡ˧˔˟ ˛˘˔˟˧˛ ˗˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧ˬ 0hqwdo khdowk glvdelolw fdq lqfoxgh poog glvoughuv hj ghsuhvvloq sovwqdwdo ghsuhvvloq elsoodu glvoughu dq[lhw glvoughuv hj skoeldv sdqlf dwwdfnv vofldo ,elg ss ,elg ,elg ss ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 dqg jhqhudo dq[lhw oevhvvlyhfopsxovlyh glvoughuv dqg svfkowlf glvoughuv hj vfkl]oskuhqld voph ioupv oi elsoodu glvoughu 0hqwdo khdowk glvdelolwlhv pd diihfw wkh zd shuvoqv wklqn ihho dqg lqwhudfwʹ ,w lv lpsouwdqw wo qow vwljpdwl]h phqwdo khdowk suoeohpv dqg eh dzduh wkdw wkh pljkw eh oqo hslvoglf 3ovvleoh dgmxvwphqwv fdq eh yduloxv dqg wkh ghshqg oq wkh vshflilf suoeohp dqg oq zkdw wuljjhuv wkh shuvoq ([dpsohv oi sovvleoh dgmxvwphqwv duh dooozlqj uhjxodu euhdnv olplwlqj wkh qxpehu oi shosoh lq wkh foxuwuoop dooozlqj d sovwsoqhphqw iou phglfdo uhdvoqv dooozlqj ylgho olqnv vhwwlqj pouh vshflilf uxohv iou fuovvh[dplqdwloq jlylqj h[wud wlph wo dqvzhu dqg suoylglqj uhdvvxudqfh li qhfhvvduʹͺ ˀ˜˚˥˔˜ˡ˘ 0ljudlqh lv d foqglwloq oi uhfxuulqj khdgdfkhv oi d sduwlfxodu nlqg 0ljudlqh xvxdoo suhvhqwv owkhu vpswopv olnh vhqvlwlylw wo oljkw dqg qolvh hhvljkw fkdqjhv ohwkduj dqg qdxvhd 6oph shuvoqv pljkw h[shulhqfh pljudlqh zlwk ௵dxud௶ suhvhqwlqj qhxuooojlfdo vpswopv olnh fkdqjhv lq vljkw hj ]lj]djv gdun vsowv glvwxuedqfhv wo vshhfk dqg khdulqj ou sduwldo sdudovlv 0ljudlqh dwwdfnv xvxdoo odvw oqh ou wzo gdv dqg duh oiwhq xqsuhglfwdeohʹͻ 3ovvleoh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv duh dooozlqj dgglwloqdo euhdnv vkouwhqhg gdv ioog dqg zdwhu lq wkh foxuwuoop uhgxfhg oljkwlqj hdvlhu txhvwloqv dqg lqglfdwloqv dqg dgglwloqdo wlph wo suofhvv lqioupdwloq ,q jhqhudo d suoplvlqj sudfwlfh foqvlvwv lq foqvxowlqj wkh lqglylgxdov oq zkdw wuljjhuv wkhlu pljudlqh͵ͳ ˀˢ˕˜˟˜˧ˬ ʼˠˣ˔˜˥ˠ˘ˡ˧ ‘lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon $xvwudold 6hfwloq 8.௲v (txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon ss ,elg ss ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 0oelolw lpsdluphqw fdq ghshqg oq d ohj ou ioow lpsdluphqw jhqhudo pxvfxodu zhdnqhvv looqhvv ou lqmxu 3huvoqv zlwk d poelolw lpsdluphqw pd xvh dq dlg olnh d vwlfn fuxwfkhv ou d zkhhofkdlu͵ͳ ,q wkh fdvh oi d ghihqgdqw zlwk d poelolw lpsdluphqw wkh dffhvvlelolw oi wkh foxuwuoop lv hvvhqwldo 7kh hqwudqfh dqg wkh uoxwh wo wkh yhqxh vkdoo eh dffhvvleoh dv zhoo dv wkh uoxwh wo dqg iuop wkh zlwqhvv eo[ 7kh foxuwuoop vkdoo dovo suhvhqw dssuosuldwh vhwwlqj duudqjhphqwv dffhvvleoh wolohwv dqg vdih suofhgxuhv lq fdvh oi iluh ou zkhq wkh oliwv fdqqow eh xvhg 0ouhoyhu xvhuv zlwk zkhhofkdlu vkoxog eh dooozhg wo kdyh d sovlwloq zlwk d joog vljkw oi wkh mxgjh dqg wkh dgyofdwhv &duhuv ou dpdqxhqvlv vkoxog eh dooozhg wo sduwlflsdwh dqg wkh khdwlqj vkoxog qow ilqlvk odwh wo dyolg wkh uxvk zkhq wkh lqglylgxdo zloo xvh sxeolf wudqvsouw )lqdoo wkh ghihqgdqw vkdoo qow eh uhtxluhg wo vwdqg xs iou wkh mxgjh dqg wkhlu dlgv vkdoo qow eh woxfkhg ou poyhg zlwkoxw wkhlu foqvhqw͵ʹ ˀˢ˧ˢ˥ ˁ˘˨˥ˢˡ˘ ʷ˜˦˘˔˦˘ 0owou 1hxuoqh ‘lvhdvh lv d uduh dqg suojuhvvlyh ghjhqhudwlyh glvhdvh wkdw diihfwv wkh powou qhxuoqv 0owou qhxuoqv duh vshfldol]hg qhuyh fhoov dqg wkhlu foqwuoo lv lpsouwdqw iou dfwlylwlhv olnh zdonlqj vshdnlqj euhdwklqj dqg vzdooozlqj 7klv glvhdvh ohdgv wo d judgxdo oovv oi ixqfwloqv wkdw fxoplqdwhv lq wowdo eog sdudovlv dqg vljqlilfdqw euhdwklqj gliilfxowlhv ,q povw fdvhv lqwhoohfw dqg phpou uhpdlq lqwdfw exw wkh lqglylgxdo ghshqgv ixoo oq owkhuv iou gdlo ixqfwloqv͵͵ 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv vkoxog eh suoylghg ghshqglqj oq wkh ohyho oi lpsdluphqw 7kh dgmxvwphqwv uhtxluhg lq wkh fdvh oi d ghihqgdqw zlwk powou qhxuoqh glvhdvh pdlqo folqflgh zlwk wkovh qhhghg lq fdvh oi poelolw lpsdluphqw 2wkhu h[dpsohv oi xvhixo uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv duh dgglwloqdo euhdnv ylgho olqnv dqg ,elg ss ,elg ,elg ss $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 zulwlqj idflolwlhv 0ouhoyhu wkh txhvwloqv vkoxog eh nhsw dw d plqlpxp dqg wkh khdulqj pljkw eh khog hyhq dw wkh koph oi wkh ghihqgdqw li qhfhvvdu͵ͷ ˀ˨˟˧˜ˣ˟˘ ˆ˖˟˘˥ˢ˦˜˦ 0xowlsoh vfohuovlv lv d glvhdvh diihfwlqj qhuyhv lq wkh eudlq dqg vslqdo foug ,w fdxvhv suoeohpv zlwk pxvfoh poyhphqw edodqfh dqg ylvloq 7khuh duh gliihuhqw wshv oi pxowlsoh vfohuovlv dqg wkh fdq diihfw shuvoqv lq yhu gliihuhqw zdv 6oph shuvoqv h[shulhqfh wkh uhodsvlqjuhplwwlqj wsh wkdw foqvlvwv oi oqh vkouwolyhg hslvogh dqg vxevhtxhqw vpswopiuhh shulogv 2wkhu shuvoqv h[shulhqfh vhfoqgdu suojuhvvlyh wsh oi pxowlsoh vfohuovlv wkdw fdq ghwhuloudwh udslgo͵ͷ 7kh vpswopv oi pxowlsoh vfohuovlv ydu zlgho dqg foqvxowlqj wkh shuvoq lv dq hiihfwlyh zd wo xqghuvwdqg wkh lqglylgxdo qhhgv dqg wkh h[wud dlg dqg dvvlvwdqfh wkdw vkoxog eh oujdql]hg ,q jhqhudo uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv iou d ghihqgdqw zlwk pxowlsoh vfohuovlv duh iuhtxhqw euhdnv vkouwhqhg gdv dydlodelolw oi zdwhu dqg wkh xvh oi d idq ou dlu foqglwloqlqj ehfdxvh h[wuhph khdw fdq fdxvh d uhodsvh ,i wkh shuvoq kdv poelolw lpsdluphqw wkh vdph uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv ghvfulehg lq wkh vhfwloq oq 0oelolw ,psdluphqw vkoxog dsso͵ ˀˬ˔˟˚˜˖ ʸˡ˖˘ˣ˛˔˟ˢˠˬ˘˟˜˧˜˦ ʛˀʸʜʢʶ˛˥ˢˡ˜˖ ʹ˔˧˜˚˨˘ ˆˬˡ˗˥ˢˠ˘ 0dojlf (qfhskdoopholwlv 0(&kuoqlf )dwljxh 6qguoph lv d qhxuooojlfdo glvhdvh fkdudfwhul]hg e ghelolwdwlqj idwljxh zklfk fdq eh wuljjhuhg e plqlpdo dfwlylw 7kh vpswopv pd lqfoxgh pdodlvh khdgdfkhv vohhs glvwxuedqfh gliilfxow zlwk foqfhqwudwloq dqg pxvfoh sdlq 7kh vpswopv pd ioxfwxdwh lq lqwhqvlw dqg ydulhw 6oph shuvoqv xvh d zkhhofkdlu͵ ,elg ,elg ss ,elg ,elg ss $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxgh dgglwloqdo euhdnv vkouwhu gdv odwh vwduwv lq wkh pouqlqj vxssouwlyh fkdluv ooz oljkwv d txlhw hqyluoqphqw dqg dgmxvwphqwv wo foppxqlfdwloq dqg fuovvh[dplqdwloq vwoh ,i wkh shuvoq suhvhqwv poelolw lpsdluphqw wkh dffhvvlelolw dgmxvwphqwv uhtxluhg lq wkh vhfwloq 0oelolw ,psdluphqw vkoxog eh dssolhg͵ͺ ˂˕˘˦˜˧ˬ 2ehvlw gohv qow kdyh d foqvlvwhqw ghilqlwloq ,q povw fdvhv wkh shuvoq௲v eog pdvv lqgh[ %0, lv d joog lqglfdwou ,%0 fdq eh plvohdglqj zkhq vophoqh kdv d oow oi pxvfoh 1oupdoo %0, oi lv foqvlghuhg oyhuzhljkw dqg lv foqvlghuhg oehvh͵ͻ ,q voph fdvhv voph dgmxvwphqwv fdq eh pdgh 7khvh dgmxvwphqwv lqfoxgh odujh hujoqoplf fkdluv duudqjhphqwv iou d fopiouwdeoh fkdlu zlwqhvv wdeoh dqg qo ghodv wo dyolg wkh uxvk oi wkh ghihqgdqwͷͳ ˃˔˥˞˜ˡ˦ˢˡϡ˦ ˗˜˦˘˔˦˘ 3dunlqvoq௲v glvhdvh offxuv zkhq wkh eudlq qo ooqjhu suogxfhv hqoxjk oi d vxevwdqfh fdoohg gosdplqh zklfk lv qhfhvvdu iou poyhphqw 6pswopv ydu iuop shuvoq wo shuvoq exw wkh pdlq vpswopv duh xvxdoo wuhpouv hvshfldoo kdqg wuhpouv voozqhvv oi poyhphqw eudgnlqhvld dqg pxvfoh vwliiqhvv ou uljlglw 2wkhu wslfdo vpswopv duh idwljxh guooolqj foqvwudlqhg kdqgzulwlqj dqg voiwqhvv oi yolfhͷͳ 3ovvleoh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv duh dgglwloqdo euhdnv dvvlvwdqfh zlwk wkh wuldo exqgoh ou soxulqj zdwhu ,i wkh ghihqgdqw kdv d poelolw lpsdluphqw wkh vdph ,elg ,elg ss ,elg ,elg ss $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv ghvfulehg lq wkh vhfwloq 0oelolw ,psdluphqw vkdoo dsso dovo khuhͷʹ ˃˔˧˛ˢ˟ˢ˚˜˖˔˟ ˔ˡ˗ ʷ˘ˠ˔ˡ˗ ʴ˩ˢ˜˗˔ˡ˖˘ 3dwkooojlfdo ghpdqg dyolgdqfh 3’$ foqvlvwv oi dyolglqj hyhugd ghpdqgv dqg h[shfwdwloqv wo dq h[wuhph h[whqw 3hosoh zlwk 3’$ kdyh xvxdoo d qhhg iou foqwuoo wkdw lv oiwhq dq[lhw uhodwhg 7khvh shuvoqv pd kdyh gliilfxowlhv zlwk vpdoohu lpsolhg ghpdqgv zlwklq odujhu h[solflw ghpdqgv wlph dqg wlphnhhslqj ghpdqgv dgydqfh sodqqlqj h[shfwdwloqv dqg sudlvh 6oph shosoh pd dovo idfh suoeohpv zlwk lqwhuqdo ghpdqgv olnh shuvoqdo h[shfwdwloqv dqg ghvluhv ou eoglo ghpdqgv $ glvwlqfwlyh fkdudfwhulvwlf oi wkh shuvoq zlwk 3’$ lv wkh xvh oi vofldo vwudwhjlhv wo dyolg ghpdqgv 7kh 3’6 6oflhw vdv wkdw wkhuh lv d klhudufk oi dyolgdqfh dssuodfkhv )luvw wkh shuvoq pdnhv dwwhpswv wo glvwudfw pdnh h[fxvhv dqg ghod wkhq wkh shuvoq ihhov skvlfdo lqfdsdflw zlwk d uhgxfwloq oi phdqlqjixo foqyhuvdwloqv dqg zlwkgudzdo wo idqwdv wkhq wkhuh lv d skdvh oi wdnlqj foqwuoo lq zklfk wkhuh lv fopsohwh fopsoldqfh exw d odwhu euhdngozq ilqdoo wkh shuvoq h[shulhqfh sdqlf dffopsdqlhg e djlwdwloq djjuhvvloq vkxw gozq uxqqlqj dzd vhoikdupͷ͵ 7kh suoeohp oi wkh ohjdo suofhvv lv wkdw lv ixoo oi gluhfw dqg lqgluhfw ghpdqgv dqg lw lv fkdudfwhul]hg e vwuoqj xqfhuwdlqw 3ovvleoh uhdvoqdeoh dgmxvwphqwv duh wulqj wo uhgxfh xqfhuwdlqw zlwk dq h[sodqdwloq oi wkh yduloxv vwhsv dqg uhtxhvwv qow jlylqj pdq vlpxowdqhoxv wdvnv dqg pdnlqj wkh ghpdqgv pouh lqgluhfw 0ouhoyhu wkh mxgjh fdq h[sodlq wkh uhdvoqv ehklqg ghdgolqhv ou zkhuh sovvleoh jlyh wkh lqglylgxdo voph dxwoqop dqg ioh[lelolw 5hjxodu euhdnv dqg sdwlhqfh zkhq wkh shuvoq uhixvhv wo go vophwklqj duh dovo xvhixoͷͷ ˃˘˥˦˘˖˨˧ˢ˥ˬ ʷ˘˟˨˦˜ˢˡ˦ ,elg ,elg ss ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 3dudqold foqvlvwv oi xqioxqghg eholhiv wkdw owkhu shosoh lqwhqg wo kdup wkh lqglylgxdo ‘hoxvloqv duh sdudqolg wkoxjkwv 3dudqold kdv d udqjh oi vhyhulw dqg wkh povw vhyhuh ioupv foqvlvw oi shuvhfxwou ghoxvloqv 3huvoqv zlwk shuvhfxwou ghoxvloqv kdyh vwuoqj sdudqolg foqylfwloqv dqg qo idfwv ou uhdvoq fdq fkdqjh wkh shuvoq௲v wklqnlqj 7klv lv d ioup oi svfkovlv 3huvoqv pljkw h[shulhqfh shuvhfxwou ghoxvloqv doo wkh wlph ou oqo offdvloqdoo zkhq xqghu vwuhvv 7kh fdq eh uhodwhg wo voph vhuloxv phqwdo looqhvv suoeohpv olnh ghoxvloqdo glvoughu vfkl]oskuhqld dqg elsoodu glvoughuͷͷ ,w lv lpsouwdqw wo dyolg glvuhjduglqj wkh shuvoq௲v hylghqfh oqo ehfdxvh oi wkh ghoxvloqv ,qghhg wkhuh duh yhu vshflilf ghoxvloqv hj d ghoxvloq foqfhuqlqj oqo d vshflilf lqglylgxdo dqg wkh vhyhulw oi ghoxvloqv pljkw ydu )ou wklv uhdvoq wkh zhljkw oi wkh hylghqfh foplqj iuop wkh shuvoq vkoxog eh dvvhvvhg fdvh e fdvh 7khuh duh dovo voph lqglfdwloqv wo uhvsoqg wo d ghoxvloq gxulqj d wuldo 7kh mxgjh dqg wkh owkhu ohjdo suoihvvloqdov vkdoo olvwhq wo wkh shuvoq qow glvsxwh wkh ghoxvloq dqg qow hqjdjh zlwk wkh ghoxvloq ou wu wo xvh oojlf wo vkliw lw 7kh vkdoo vlpso iofxv oq wkh hohphqwv wkdw duh yhulildeoh dqg eh fduhixo zlwk wkhlu eog odqjxdjh dqg zd oi foppxqlfdwlqjͷ ˅˔ˬˡ˔˨˗ ˗˜˦˘˔˦˘ 5dqdxg௲v glvhdvh lv d foqglwloq diihfwlqj eooog vxsso wo fhuwdlq sduwv oi wkh eog olnh ilqjhuv dqg wohv 7kh shuvoq௲v eooog yhvvhov jo lqwo d whpsoudu vsdvp wkdw fdq odvw iou d ihz plqxwhv ou vhyhudo koxuv 7kh shuvoq kdv gliilfxowlhv lq xvlqj ilqjhuv zkhq wkh duh diihfwhg 7kh skhqophqoq fdq eh wuljjhuhg e foog dq[lhw ou vwuhvvͷ 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv pd foqvlvw oi hqvxulqj d zdup uoop dqg uhjxodu euhdnv li wkh uoop lv qow hqoxjk zdup 7kh shuvoqv vkoxog dovo eh dooozhg wo zhdu d ,elg ss ,elg ,elg s $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 kdw d vfdui ou jooyhv li qhhghg $vvlvwdqfh iou pdqhxyhulqj wkh wuldo exqgohv pljkw dovo eh qhhghgͷͺ ˆ˜˖˞˟˘ ʶ˘˟˟ ʷ˜˦˘˔˦˘ 6lfnoh &hoo ‘lvhdvh lv d jhqhudo whup iou d vhw oi lqkhulwhg foqglwloqv diihfwlqj uhg eooog fhoov 7kh povw vhuloxv glvhdvh lv wkh vlfnoh fhoo dqdhpld 7kh pdlq vpswopv duh dqdhpld lqfuhdvhg ulvn oi vhuloxv lqihfwloqv dqg hslvoghv oi sdlq nqozq dv ௵vlfnoh fhoo fulvlv௶ zkhq vpdoo eooog yhvvhov ehfoph eoofnhg ‘hkgudwloq vwuhvv vwuhqxoxv h[huflvh dqg edg zhdwkhu pd eh idfwouv ohdglqj wo wkh fulvlvͷͻ 5hdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv pd eh dffhvv wo zdwhu uhjxodu euhdnv d zdup foxuwuoop dqg wkh sovvlelolw iou wkh ghihqgdqw wo vlw gozqͷͳ ˆˣ˜ˡ˔ ʵ˜˙˜˗˔ ˔ˡ˗ ʻˬ˗˥ˢ˖˘ˣ˛˔˟˨˦ 6slqd elilgd lv d jhqhudo whup uhihuulqj wo vshflilf foqjhqlwdo deqoupdolwlhv wkdw diihfw wkh vslqh dqg fhqwudo qhuyoxv vvwhp 7khuh duh wkuhh gliihuhqw wshv oi vslqd elilgd vslqd elilgd offxowd vslqd elilgd phqlqjofohoh dqg vslqd elilgd phoophqljofohoh dqg wkh vhyhulw oi wkh glvdelolw ydulhv iuop oqh wsh wo wkh owkhu 6slqd elilgd phoophqljofohoh lv wkh povw vhyhuh wsh dqg lw fdq uhvxow lq sduwldo ou wowdo sdudovlv oi wkh oozhu olpev dqg lqfoqwlqhqfh 3hosoh xvxdoo suhvhqw ohduqlqj glvdelolwlhv ehfdxvh oi d foqglwloq oi zdwhu lq wkh eudlq kguofhskdoxv )ou wklv uhdvoq wkh pljkw suhvhqw phpou suoeohpv lpsdluhg vshhfk vkouw dwwhqwloq vsdq suoeohpv zlwk oujdql]dwloqdo vnloov ylvxdo suoeohpv suoeohpv oi foouglqdwloq dqg hslohsvͷͳ 7kh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lq wkhvh fdvhv fdq eh uhjxodu euhdnv wkh vhohfwloq oi wkh dyhqxh qhdu wkh koph oi wkh shuvoq dqg ylgho olqnv iou wdnlqj hylghqfh ,q wkh fdvhv lq zklfk wkh shuvoq kdv poelolw lpsdluphqw ou lv lq d zkhhofkdlu wkh vdph ,elg ,elg s ,elg ,elg ss $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv uhfopphqghg lq wkh vhfwloq oi wkh 0oelolw ,psdluphqw dsso dovo khuhͷʹ ˆˣ˜ˡ˔˟ ʶˢ˥˗ ʼˡ˝˨˥ˬ 6slqdo foug lqmxulhv duh yhu yduldeoh dqg wkh fdq eh fopsohwh ou lqfopsohwh 6oph vslqdo lqmxulhv fdq uhvxow lq fopsohwh sdudovlv ehooz wkh solqw oi lqmxu dqg wkh pd suhvhqw owkhu phglfdo fopsolfdwloqv olnh eodgghu eozho glvixqfwloq dqg lqfuhdvhg vxvfhswlelolw wo uhvsludwou dqg khduw suoeohpv 6oph shuvoqv pd kdyh lpsdluhg euhdwklqj dqg wkh pd ghshqg oq d yhqwlodwou 7kh pd dovo xvh dgdswhg sozhu zkhhofkdluv dqg htxlsphqw wkdw pd eh foqwuooohg wkuoxjk poxwk foqwuoo yolfh dfwlydwloq fklq foqwuoo khdg foqwuoo hheuoz foqwuoo ou hh eolqnlqjͷ͵ 7kh uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv lq wkhvh fdvhv fdq eh uhjxodu euhdnv wkh vhohfwloq oi wkh dyhqxh qhdu wkh koph oi wkh shuvoq dqg ylgho olqnv iou wdnlqj hylghqfh ,q wkh fdvhv lq zklfk wkh shuvoq kdv poelolw lpsdluphqw ou lv lq d zkhhofkdlu wkh vdph uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv uhfopphqghg lq wkh vhfwloq oi wkh 0oelolw ,psdluphqw dsso dovo khuhͷͷ ˆ˧˔ˠˠ˘˥˜ˡ˚ 6wdpphulqj lv d qhxuooojlfdo foqglwloq fdxvlqj d shuvoq wo uhshdw suoooqj ou eoofn voxqgv dqg zougv zkhq vshdnlqj 3huvoqv pd kdyh pophqwv lq zklfk wkh vwdpphu dqg wlphv zkhq wkh vshdn ioxhqwo 7kh vhyhulw oi vwdpphulqj ydulhv dovo iuop shuvoq wo shuvoq 6wdpphulqj fdq eh dffopsdqlhg e vhfoqgdu ehkdyloxuv wkdw duh fdxvhg e wkh hiiouwv wo dyolg vwdpphulqj dqg wo vshdn ioxhqwo ([dpsohv oi wkhvh ehkdyloxuv duh eoglo whqvloq dqg lqyooxqwdu poyhphqwv hj txlyhulqj olsv eolqnlqj hhv wdsslqj ilqjhuv julpdflqj vwdpslqj ihhw 3hosoh pljkw dovo fkdqjh zougv ,elg ,elg s ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 dyolg zougv wkh xvxdoo vwdpphu oq ou xvh iloohu zougv olnh ௵xp௶ ௵hk௶ ௵ox nqoz௶ ou ௵dfwxdoo௶ͷͷ ‘xulqj wkh wuldo shuvoqv zlwk vwdpphulqj pljkw kdyh suoeohpv lq vshdnlqj dqg dqvzhulqj wkh txhvwloqv vo wkh pljkw qhhg pouh wlph wo dqvzhu dyolg wdonlqj d oow qow suhvhqw wkhlu dujxphqw ixoo fkoovh gliihuhqw zougv wo dyolg vwdpphulqj dyolg dvnlqj ixuwkhu txhvwloqv dqg wkh pljkw vkoz qhuyoxvqhvv 7kh mxgjh pljkw kdyh gliilfxowlhv xqghuvwdqglqj zk wkh shuvoq lv qow sxwwlqj iouzdug wkhlu ylhzv hylghqfh ou dujxphqwv dqg zk wkh shuvoq lv wdonlqj lq dq duwlilfldo zd vkozlqj qhuyoxvqhvv ,q wklv zd wkh mxgjh pljkw eh lqioxhqfhg lq mxgjlqj wkh uholdelolw oi wkh lqglylgxdoͷ ‘xulqj wkh khdulqj shuvoqv zlwk vwdpphulqj vkoxog eh uhdvvxuhg dqg vkoxog kdyh wkh wlph wo dqvzhu dw wkhlu vshhg 7kh mxgjh fdq dovo fkhfn wkh wxuqwdnlqj dqg foqwuoo zkhwkhu wkh shuvoq kdv vophwklqj wo vd ou kdv xqghuvwoog hyhuwklqj ,q jhqhudo wkh mxgjh vkoxog eh fdxwloxv deoxw pdnlqj dvvxpswloqv edvhg oq wkh vooz vshhg wkh xvh oi iloohu zougv wkh qhuyoxvqhvv wkh khvlwdwloq lq vshdnlqj dqg owkhu hohphqwv wkdw pljkw ghulyh iuop vwdpphulqj ,q voph fdvhv khdulqj wkuoxjk ylgho olqnv wkh xvh oi lqwhuphgldulhv dqg wkh xvh oi zulwwhq hylghqfh pljkw eh xvhixo ,q jhqhudo d txlhw foxuwuoop khos gxulqj wkh odwk hj ohw wkh fohun ou xvhu vd wkh zougv vlpxowdqhoxvo zlwk wkh ghihqgdqw sdwlhqfh dqg uhvshfw iou wkh ghihqgdqw௲v vshhg lq wdonlqj duh fohyhu dqg vlpsoh zdv wo khos d ghihqgdqw zlwk vwdpphulqjͷ ˉ˜˦˨˔˟ ˆ˧˥˘˦˦ 9lvxdo vwuhvv lv d jhqhudo whup wkdw ghvfulehv d vhw oi gliilfxowlhv zlwk uhdglqj ozlqj wo ylvxdo shufhswxdo gvixqfwloq 7kh foqglwloq lv ghvfulehg dv ௵glvfopiouw zlwk uhdglqj௶ dqg lw lv iuhtxhqwo dvvofldwhg zlwk gvoh[ld gvsud[ld pljudlqhv dqg hslohsv ,q wkh povw vhyhuh fdvhv wkh shuvoq zlwk ylvxdo vwuhvv suhvhqwv vhqvlwlylw wo euljkw oljkw dqg ,elg ss ,elg ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 pljkw eh glvwxuehg hyhq e wkh joduh oi d zklwh sdshu &oppoq foqvhtxhqfhv duh oovlqj wkh sodfh oplwwlqj ou plvuhdglqj zougv idwljxh dqg khdgdfkhvͷͺ ,q wkh fdvh oi d ghihqgdqw zlwk ylvxdo vwuhvv voph suoplvlqj sudfwlfhv fdq eh dssolhg )ou lqvwdqfh gxulqj wkh khdulqj wkh mxgjh fdq doooz pouh wlph iou wkh shuvoq wo uhdg wkh gofxphqwv ou fdq pdnh vophoqh hovh uhdg h[fhuswv iuop wkh gofxphqwv 7kh gofxphqwv vkoxog dovo eh zulwwhq lq wlqwhg sdshu zlwk dghtxdwh vsdflqj mxvwlilfdwloq oi wkh wh[w dyolgdqfh oi fdslwdol]dwloq iou zkooh zougv ou vhqwhqfhv dqg d ioqw dw ohdvw vl]h ͷͻ ,elg ,elg $11(; ,, (;$03/(6 2) ‘,6$%,/,7,(6 7+$7 0,*+7 5(48,5( 352&(’85$/ $’-867(0(176 akk-íɍmmmɍŸjja˜îɍubɍ§i-ɍ•˜a §m abɍcm$ak -ɍak$ɍŸîŸ§-jm ɍ˜- ujj-k$a§mukŸɍ $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 ʼʼʼʡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ʽ˨˦˧˜˖˘ ˙ˢ˥ ˃˘˥˦ˢˡ˦ ˪˜˧˛ ʷ˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ ʴʡ ʸˤ˨˔˟ ˧˥˘˔˧ˠ˘ˡ˧ ˕˘˙ˢ˥˘ ˧˛˘ ˟˔˪ʟ ˟˘˚˔˟ ˖˔ˣ˔˖˜˧ˬ ˔ˡ˗ ˘ˤ˨˔˟ ˣ˔˥˧˜˖˜ˣ˔˧˜ˢˡ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˔˟ ˚˨˜˗˔ˡ˖˘ ˔ˡ˗ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 6wdwh mxvwlfh dfwouv pxvw zlwklq wkh sdudphwhuv oi wkhlu uhvshfwlyh uhvsoqvlelolwlhv hqvxuh wkdw wkh dffoug shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv htxdo wuhdwphqw zlwk owkhuv lq lqwhudfwloqv zlwk wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv pxvw suoylgh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zlwk jhqghu dqg glvdelolw dssuosuldwh suofhgxudo dqg uhdvoqdeoh dffoppogdwloqv zkhuh qhhghg wo idflolwdwh wkhlu sduwlflsdwloq oq dq htxdo edvlv ʴʡ -xvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog lqwhusuhw h[lvwlqj odzv dqg soolflhv foqvlvwhqwo zlwk wkh &53' ʵʡ -xvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog dfw wo hqvxuh wkdw suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv dqg owkhu vxssouwv wo idflolwdwh wkhlu hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq duh suoylghg iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zkhuh qhfhvvdu 5hvsoqvleoh mxvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog uhvshfw dqg hqvxuh wkh hiihfwlyh uljkw wo sduwlflsdwh iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk odz hqioufhphqw gxulqj wkh suofhhglqjv dqg lq doo ioooozlqj vwdjhv oi lw ʴʡ 7kh uljkw hqfopsdvvhv dffhvv wo foxqvho dqg zkhuh qhfhvvdu ohjdo dlg dqg wkh dffopsdqlphqw oi vxssouw shuvoqv oi wkh ghihqgdqw௲v fkoovlqj lq doo vwdjhv oi fulplqdo suofhhglqjv vwduwlqj iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk odz hqioufhphqw ʵʡ 1o shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw vkoxog eh fopsohoohg wo kdyh d shuvoq dvvlvwlqj wkhp zlwkoxw wkhp ehlqj deoh wo yolfh wkhlu suhihuhqfhv ou zlwkoxw wkhlu foqvhqw )ou pouh ghwdlov oq jhqghudssuosuldwh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv sohdvh vhh 9dolglw )oxqgdwloq )dlu 7uldo 'hqlhg 'hihqgdqwv zlwk 'lvdelolwlhv )dfh ,qdffhvvleoh -xvwlfh lq wkh (8 s vv $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 5hvsoqvleoh mxvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog hqvxuh vdih idlu dqg hiihfwlyh hqjdjhphqw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh suofhhglqjv dqg wkh ossouwxqlw wo ixoo sduwlflsdwh lq suofhhglqjv 7kh uhvsoqvlelolw lqfoxghv wkh suoylvloq oi dgmxvwphqwv dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouwv lqfoxglqj lqwhuphgldulhv vxssouw vhuylfhv ou vxssouw shuvoqv zkhuhyhu dqg zkhqhyhu qhhghg wo hqdeoh fohdu foppxqlfdwloq dpoqj dqg ehwzhhq shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg foxuwv 5hvsoqvleoh mxvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog lpsohphqw d vxssouwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj dssuodfk zkhuhe d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw foqwlqxhv wo koog doo ghflvloqpdnlqj dxwkoulw dqg dxwoqop -xgjhv vkoxog dozdv hqvxuh gluhfw foqwdfw zlwk wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk d glvdelolw hyhq zkhuh owkhuv duh lqfoxghg lq vxfk foqwdfw wo suoylgh wkdw shuvoq zlwk vxssouw ʴʡ ,i d shwlwloq iou jxdugldqvkls lv pdgh lw vkoxog eh ghqlhg oq wkh juoxqgv oi yloodwlqj wkh shuvoq௲v lqglylgxdo dxwoqop ʵʡ 7kh uooh oi dq lqwhuphgldu ou d odzhu pxvw qow uhsodfh wkh gluhfw foqwdfw oi wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk wkh mxgjh /dzhuv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw ghflvloqv wkdw gluhfwo ou lqgluhfwo lqyooyh sduwlflsdwloq lq wkh suofhhglqjv oi wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk d glvdelolw duh zlwk wkh ghihqgdqw $ 7kh vxssouwhg ghflvloqpdnlqj pogho iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv phdqv wkdw wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk d glvdelolw lv wkh shuvoq pdnlqj wkh ghflvloq ,i wkh fkoovh wo lqfoxgh d vxssouw shuvoq wkh zoun oi wkh vxssouw shuvoq lv wo hqvxuh wkh ghflvloq lv pdgh dw wkh ghihqgdqw௲v zloo dqg suhihuhqfh -xvwlfh dfwouv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw foqvwuxfwv vxfk dv ௵fojqlwlyh lqfdsdflw௶ dqg ௵phqwdo lqfdsdflw௶ dv ghwhuplqhg iou lqvwdqfh e ixqfwloqdo ou phqwdo vwdwxv dvvhvvphqwv duh qow xvhg wo uhvwulfw d shuvoq௲v uljkw wo ohjdo fdsdflw $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 ,i d ghihqgdqw zlwk d glvdelolw lv ghwhuplqhg diwhu wkh suoylvloq oi doo qhfhvvdu vxssouw wo sduwlflsdwh lq d fopsohwh ohjdo suofhvv wo odfn wkh qhfhvvdu lqwhqw phqv uhd zlwklq wkh xvxdo phdqlqj oi wkh whup wkh vkoxog eh wuhdwhg wkh vdph zd dv dq owkhu ghihqgdqw zko odfnv lqwhqwͳ -xvwlfh dfwouv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw dq dvvhvvphqwv foqgxfwhg lq uhvshfw oi ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ehiouh dqg gxulqj foxuw suofhhglqjv duh dlphg oqo dw ghwhuplqlqj wkh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloq dqg vxssouw uhtxluhg wo hqvxuh wkhlu ixoo dqg hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq lq wkh suofhhglqjv 6xfk dvvhvvphqwv pxvw kdyh wkh zloo dqg suhihuhqfh oi wkh lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw dv wkhlu fhqwudo iofxv ˆˬ˦˧˘ˠ˜˖ ˅˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv pxvw kdyh htxdo dffhvv wo wkh suofhhglqjv dqg wo wkh ghihqfh $ $ vvwhp oi vxssouw vhuylfhv dqg suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wo hqvxuh hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq suofhhglqjv dqg wuldov pxvw eh ghyhooshg dqg lpsohphqwhg lq sudfwlfh vhh ehooz wkh ghwdlov oq suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iuop wkh iluvw vwdjhv oi wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh suofhvv dqg wkuoxjkoxw wkh suofhhglqjvʹ % )uop wkh hduolhvw vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv lghqwlilfdwloq oi wkh qhhgv iou suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouwv pxvw wdnh sodfh vhh vhfwloq ,9 3uofhvv iou lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw iou dgoswloq oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv ehooz 3uofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv vkoxog eh suhvhqw ehiouh gxulqj dqg diwhu wkh whuplqdwloq oi suofhhglqjv wo suhyhqw glvfulplqdwloq dqg wkuoxjkoxw doo suofhvvhv $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh .qozohgjh +xe ,psohphqwlqj wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv $ eulhilqj sdshu -xo s $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh .qozohgjh +xe ,psohphqwlqj wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv $ eulhilqj sdshu -xo s $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 & $ poqlwoulqj phfkdqlvp vkoxog eh sxw lq sodfh lq oughu wo poqlwou zkhwkhu suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv duh ehlqj xvhg dqg fopsolhg zlwk 5hfojql]h dqg dvvxph wkh ixoo ohjdo fdsdflw dqg uljkw oi ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo sduwlflsdwh lq doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv dqg lq doo foxuwv $ (qvxuh wkdw ghihqgdqwv zko kdyh ehhq suhyloxvo ghfoduhg wo eh zlwkoxw ohjdo fdsdflw wo sduwlflsdwh lq foxuw suofhhglqjv kdyh wkh uljkw wo dsshdo ou owkhuzlvh vhhn uhvwoudwloq oi wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw dqg kdyh dffhvv wo dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouwv dv zhoo dv ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh wo sduwlflsdwh lq foxuw suofhhglqjv % -xgjhv dqg owkhu uhohydqw mxvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog eulqj wo wkh dwwhqwloq oi wkh odzpdnhuv dq ohjlvodwloq wkdw lv lq yloodwloq oi wkh &53' ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ ϝ ,q 6sdlq /dz uhfojql]hg ohjdo fdsdflw iou doo shosoh zlwk glvdelolwlhv jxdugldqvkls zdv holplqdwhg dqg mxglfldo phdvxuhv oi vxssouw iou shosoh zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh dgoswhg d dv odvw uhvouw ,q wklv zd wkh 6sdqlvk ohjlvodwloq poyhg iuop d vvwhp oi vxevwlwxwloq oi ghflvloqpdnlqj wo d vvwhp oi vxssouw lq ghflvloqpdnlqj & :khuh sovvleoh xqghu wkh qdwloqdo ohjdo vvwhp wkh mxgjhv pd lqlwldwh suofhhglqjv iou uhylhz oi wkh ydolglw oi wkh ohjlvodwloq lqfopsdwleoh zlwk wkh &53' ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ )ou lqvwdqfh mxgjhv lq 6ooydnld pd vwduw suofhhglqjv ehiouh wkh &oqvwlwxwloqdo &oxuw wo vwulnh gozq wkh ohjlvodwloq $ uhylhz oi soolfhv jxlgholqhv dqg sudfwlfhv vkoxog eh xqghuwdnhq e 6wdwh dxwkoulwlhv /dz /d gh gh mxqlo sou od txh vh uhioupd od ohjlvodflµq flylo suofhvdo sdud ho dsoo d odv shuvoqdv foq glvfdsdflgdg hq ho hmhuflflo gh vx fdsdflgdg mxu¯glfd m%2(} 1o -xqh $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 $ 6wdwhv vkdoo uhylhz dqg zkhuh qhfhvvdu holplqdwh ou uhylvh soolflhv jxlgholqhv dqg sudfwlfhv wkdw vhuyh gluhfwo ou lqgluhfwo uhvwulfw wkh ohjdo fdsdflw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj wkovh wkdw foqwdlq dqg dsso gofwulqhv oi ௵xqilwqhvv wo vwdqg wuldo௶ dqg ௵lqfdsdflw wo sohdg௶ zklfk suhyhqw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv iuop sduwlflsdwlqj lq ohjdo suofhvvhv edvhg oq txhvwloqv deoxw ou ghwhuplqdwloqv oi wkhlu fdsdflw % 6wdwhv vkdoo uhylhz dqg zkhuh qhfhvvdu holplqdwh ou uhylvh soolflhv jxlgholqhv dqg sudfwlfhv wkdw dxwkoul]h phglfdo suoihvvloqdov wo eh wkh vooh ou suhihuuhg ௵h[shuwv௶ lq ghwhuplqlqj koz dqg wo zkdw h[whqw dqg zlwk zkdw vxssouw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv fdq sduwlflsdwh lq ohjdo suofhhglqjv & 6wdwhv vkdoo uhylhz dqg zkhuh qhfhvvdu holplqdwh ou uhylvh soolflhv jxlgholqhv dqg sudfwlfhv lqfoxglqj foxuw oughuv wkdw vxemhfw ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo ghwhqwloq zkhwkhu lq d sulvoq d phqwdo khdowk idflolw ou dq owkhu lqvwlwxwloq iou d ghilqlwh ou lqghilqlwh whup edvhg oq shufhlyhg ௵gdqjhuoxvqhvv௶ ou qhhg iou fduh wkdw dulvhv iuop wkh foqglwloq oi glvdelolw 6wdwhv vkoxog ghyhoos foppxqlwedvhg vxssouw dqg vhuylfhv wo uhsodfh lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq vhfxulw phdvxuhv ou ioufhg phglfdo dqg svfkldwulf wuhdwphqw lq lqvwlwxwloqv 6wdwhv vkoxog wdnh phdvxuhv wo lpsuoyh wkh fxuuhqw suofhvv iou h[fkdqjlqj phglfdo uhfougv lq oughu wo hvwdeolvk d fohdu vvwhp iou sdvvlqj oq lqioupdwloq dv lqglylgxdov poyh wkuoxjk wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhp zklfk lv hvvhqwldo wo plqlpl]h huuouv dqg jxdudqwhh dssuosuldwh fduh dqg phglfdwloq dffhvv 0hqwdo +hdowk 3huvshfwlyhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq /lwkxdqld9loqlxv (1$%/( 3uomhfw s $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 6wdwhv vkoxog fooohfw glvdjjuhjdwhg gdwd oq wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp dqg xvlqj wkdw gdwd ghyhoos dqg lpsohphqw vwudwhjlhv wo uhioup soolflhv sudfwlfhv dqg odzv wo hqvxuh htxdo dffhvv wo mxvwlfh ʵʡ ˅˘˦˧ˢ˥˔˧˜˩˘ ˝˨˦˧˜˖˘ ˣ˥˜ˡ˖˜ˣ˟˘˦ ˆˬ˦˧˘ˠ˜˖ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 6vwhplf $owhuqdwlyhv wo wudglwloqdo fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv vxfk dv wkuoxjk uhvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh suofhvvhv dqg sulqflsohv vkoxog eh lpsohphqwhg dfuovv wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv dqg eh htxdoo dffhvvleoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv $ $owhuqdwlyh vvwhpv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh suoylghg zkdwhyhu dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouwv duh qhhghg wo sduwlflsdwh htxdoo % 5hvwoudwlyh mxvwlfh vkoxog eh lqfoxghg lq ohjdo vwxglhv fxuulfxod dv zhoo dv lq wudlqlqjv iou mxvwlfh dfwouv 6hh dovo ixuwkhu ehooz lq wudlqlqj ʶʡ ˇ˥˔˜ˡ˜ˡ˚ ˢ˙ ˣ˥ˢ˙˘˦˦˜ˢˡ˔˟˦ ˆˬ˦˧˘ˠ˜˖ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 6wdwhv vkoxog suoylgh shuloglf dqg kljk txdolw wudlqlqj oq d pdqgdwou edvlv wo mxvwlfh dfwouv $ 'hyhoos d foqvlvwhqw dqg foouglqdwhg wudlqlqj sodq uhjduglqj glvdelolw lvvxhv wdujhwlqj wkh gliihuhqw mxvwlfh vvwhp suoihvvloqdov % &uhdwh d vvwhp oi oqjolqj pdqgdwou wudlqlqj iou mxvwlfh dfwouv zko lqwhudfw zlwk shuvoqv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv .(5$ )oxqgdwloq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s &hqwuh iou /hjdo 5hvoxufhv %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 5opdqld %xfduhvw (1$%/( 3uomhfw s $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 l )ou mxgjhv ohjdo sudfwlwloqhuv dqg soolfh shuvoqqho wkhuh vkoxog eh d iofxv oq wkh kxpdq uljkwvedvhg pogho oi glvdelolw oq dffhvv wo mxvwlfh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv lghqwlilfdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg oq foppxqlfdwloq zlwk doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj shuvoqv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv ll )ou doo mxvwlfh dfwouv wkhuh vkoxog eh iofxv oq koz wo foppxqlfdwh zlwk d shuvoq zlwk glvdelolw oq wkh lpsdfw oi ghwhqwloq dqg phglfdo wuhdwphqw oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg koz lq sduwlfxodu phglfdwloq diihfwv wkhp lq foxuw ou d khdulqj 7khvh lqfoxgh iou h[dpsoh vooz uhvsoqvhv ou wkh idfw wkdw khdulqjv vkoxog qow eh vfkhgxohg vkouwo diwhu wkh shuvoq uhfhlyhg phglfdo wuhdwphqw 6wdwhv vkoxog jxdudqwhh hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wudlqlqj $ 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog eh lqyooyhg lq wkh ghyhoosphqw dqg wudlqlqj oi mxvwlfh dfwouv lqfoxglqj iou wkh sxusovh oi idflolwdwlqj d ehwwhu xqghuvwdqglqj e mxvwlfh dfwouv oi wkh h[shulhqfhv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq ohjdo suofhvvhv $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 ʼˉʡ ˃˥ˢ˖˘˗˨˥˔˟ ˥˜˚˛˧˦ ˢ˙ ˣ˘˥˦ˢˡ˦ ˪˜˧˛ ˗˜˦˔˕˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ ˔˧ ˔˟˟ ˦˧˔˚˘˦ ˢ˙ ˧˛˘ ˔˗ˠ˜ˡ˜˦˧˥˔˧˜ˢˡ ˢ˙ ˝˨˦˧˜˖˘ʩʩʪ ʴʡ ˅˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˣ˥ˢ˖˘˗˨˥˔˟ ˔˖˖ˢˠˠˢ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ ˅˘ˤ˨˘˦˧˦ ˙ˢ˥ ˔ˡ˗ ˢ˙˙˘˥˦ ˢ˙ ˔˖˖ˢˠˠˢ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˔˟ ˚˨˜˗˔ˡ˖˘ ˔ˡ˗ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ $ ghihqgdqwv uljkw wo d idlu wuldo dqg gxh suofhvv lq wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh oq dq htxdo edvlv zlwk owkhuv pxvw eh uhvshfwhg iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk odz hqioufhphqw oiilfhuv dqg wkuoxjkoxw doo suofhvvhv lqfoxglqj wkuoxjk dffhvv wo suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv $ 5hvsoqvleoh mxvwlfh dfwouv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv duh dydlodeoh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo doooz iou wkhlu sduwlflsdwloq lq hdfk suofhgxuh iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk odz hqioufhphqw dxwkoulwlhv dqg wkuoxjk doo suofhvvhv % $oo suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv vkoxog eh jhqghu dqg djhdssuosuldwh & 3huvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog sduwlflsdwh lq wkh suofhvv oi wkh lghqwlilfdwloq dqg ghwhuplqdwloq oi wkhlu glvdelolwlhv :khuh wkhuh lv dq lqglfld wkdw dq lqglylgxdo pd kdyh d glvdelolw wkhuh lv dq oeoljdwloq oq wkh dxwkoulwlhv wo pdnh d ixoo ghwhuplqdwloq wdnlqj lqwo dffoxqw wkh lqglylgxdo௲v ylhzv ' $ghtxdwh vxssouw vhuylfhv vkoxog eh pdgh dydlodeoh zlwklq wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhp wo hqvxuh wkh suoylvloq oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv l :khuh lghqwlilfdwloq oi qhhgv iou suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv qhhgv wo eh lq sodfh lw pxvw eh goqh dw wkh ehjlqqlqj oi wkh suofhhglqjv dw wkh hduolhvw vwdjh 5hfopphqgdwloqv lq vhfwloqv ,9,9 duh dssolfdeoh wo doo suofhhglqjv qow oqo fulplqdo suofhhglqjv $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 ‹‹ǥ ”‡’ƒ”ƒ–‹‘• ˆ‘” ’”‘…‡†—”ƒŽ ƒ……‘‘†ƒ–‹‘• ƒ† ‘–Š‡” ƒ†Œ—•–‡–• ‹ –Š‡ Š‡ƒ”‹‰ —•– „‡ ƒ†‡ ’”‹‘” –‘ –Š‡ ’‘Ž‹…‡ ‘” ‘–Š‡” ‘ˆˆ‹…‹ƒŽ ‹–‡”˜‹‡™ǡ ‘” ’”‹‘” –‘ –Š‡ Š‡ƒ”‹‰ȁ–”‹ƒŽǥ $oo sduwlflsdqwv lqfoxglqj ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog eh lqiouphg deoxw wkhlu uljkwv dqg wkh dydlodelolw oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wkuoxjkoxw wkh foxuvh oi wkh suofhhglqjv $ $xwkoulwlhv pxvw hqvxuh wkdw ghihqgdqwv duh pdgh dzduh oi wkh sovvlelolw oi kdylqj suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wkuoxjkoxw wkh suofhhglqjv dqg nqoz wkdw wkh fdq uhtxhvw wkhp dw dq wlph % ,w vkoxog qow eh wkh vooh uhvsoqvlelolw oi wkh ghihqgdqw wo uhtxhvw wkh dffoppogdwloqv 5hvsoqvleoh mxvwlfh dfwouv kdyh d suodfwlyh gxw wo lqlwldwh wkh suoylvloq oi dffoppogdwloqv -xvwlfh dfwouv dqg qdwloqdo dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog foqvxow foovho zlwk dqg dfwlyho lqyooyh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg wkhlu uhsuhvhqwdwlyh oujdql]dwloqv lq doo glvfxvvloqv dqg ghflvloqpdnlqj uhjduglqj suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv 5hvsoqvleoh dfwouv vkoxog fooshudwh wo hvwdeolvk d xqlioup dqg hiihfwlyh iudphzoun iou suoylglqj dssuosuldwh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv (iihfwlyh foouglqdwloq lv qhfhvvdu dw fhqwudo dqg oofdo ohyhov ˆˬ˦˧˘ˠ˜˖ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ -xglfldulhv vkoxog ghyhoos dqg dgosw uhjxodwloqv dqg vwdqgdugv wkdw uhfojql]h dqg hqioufh wkh uljkw wo uhfhlyh suofhgxudo djh dqg jhqghudssuosuldwh dffoppogdwloqv lqfoxglqj vxssouw qhfhvvdu wo hqdeoh ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo h[huflvh wkhlu ohjdo fdsdflw dqg sduwlflsdwh hiihfwlyho lq dq dssolfdeoh mxglfldo ou dgplqlvwudwlyh suofhhglqjvͺ 7khvh lqfoxgh dgdswdwloq oi wkh yhqxh dooozlqj ohdglqj txhvwloqv dyolglqj fopsoxqg txhvwloqv ilqglqj dowhuqdwlyhv wo fopsoh[ ksowkhwlfdo txhvwloqv suoylglqj h[wud wlph wo dqvzhu shuplwwlqj euhdnv dv qhhghg dqg xvlqj sodlq odqjxdjh dqg xvh oi suhwuldo ylgho uhfouglqj oi hylghqfh dqg whvwlpoq li qhfhvvdu sudfwlfdo dqg sovvleoh lq vxfk d pdqqhu dv qow wo foqwudyhqh $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 $ fopsuhkhqvlyh suofhgxuh iou uhfojql]lqj uhtxhvwlqj dvvhvvlqj dqg suoylglqj lqglylgxdo vxssouw iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog eh ghyhooshg dqg lpsohphqwhg &ohdu dqg hiihfwlyh suofhgxuhv uhodwlqj wo wkh suoylvloq oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv pxvw eh ghyhooshg dqg lpsohphqwhg e mxvwlfh dfwouv zkhqhyhu d shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw dqg lq sduwlfxodu d shuvoq zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lqwhudfwv zlwk wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhp $ $ jxlgh ou pdqxdo oq suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iou wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh vkoxog eh suogxfhg dqg zlgho glvvhplqdwhg wo idflolwdwh wkh fouuhfw dssuodfk e mxvwlfh dfwouv foqfhuqlqj shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ˃˥ˢ˖˘˦˦ ˙ˢ˥ ˜ˡ˗˜˩˜˗˨˔˟ ˔˦˦˘˦˦ˠ˘ˡ˧ ˙ˢ˥ ˔˗ˢˣ˧˜ˢˡ ˢ˙ ˣ˥ˢ˖˘˗˨˥˔˟ ˔˖˖ˢˠˠˢ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˔˟ ˚˨˜˗˔ˡ˖˘ ˔ˡ˗ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ $ sudfwlfdo phfkdqlvp wo lghqwli glvdelolw hduo lq ohjdo suofhvvhv wkuoxjk dq lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw vkoxog eh ghyhooshg dqg lpsohphqwhg vo wkdw doo qhfhvvdu phdvxuhv duh wdnhq wo hqvxuh wkdw wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw zloo jo wkuoxjk wkh hqwluh fulplqdo mxvwlfh suofhvv oq dq htxdo edvlv $ lghqwlilfdwloq iou h[dpsoh wkuoxjk dq lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw vkoxog offxu hduo lq wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh suofhvv dw wkh yhu ehjlqqlqj oi wkh suofhhglqjv dqg sulou wo dq dfwloqv xqghuwdnhq dv sduw oi wkh fulplqdo mxvwlfh suofhhglqjv iou lqvwdqfh sulou wo d soolfh lqwhuylhz % 7kh soolfh owkhu odz hqioufhphqw dxwkoulwlhv dqg dq owkhu mxvwlfh dfwou ou lqglylgxdo lqyooyhg lq wkh lghqwlilfdwloq oi glvdelolw pxvw diwhu lghqwlilqj wkh lqglylgxdo kdv d glvdelolw hqvxuh wkh suoylvloq oi edvlf uljkwv vxfk dv wkh uljkw wo foqiuoqw dqg fuovv h[dplqh zlwqhvvhv dssuosuldwh zdlwlqj vsdfhv uhpoydo oi foodnv dqg zljv dgmxvwphqwv wo wkh sdfh oi suofhhglqjv vhsdudwh exloglqj hqwudqfhv dqg zdlwlqj uoopv dqg suowhfwlyh vfuhhqv wo vhsdudwh shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv iuop owkhuv li qhfhvvdu gxh wo skvlfdo ou hpowloqdo glvwuhvv poglilfdwloqv wo wkh phwkog oi txhvwloqlqj lq dssuosuldwh flufxpvwdqfhv vxfk dv $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 dvvlvwdqfh dffoppogdwloqv dqg vxssouw iuop wkh hduo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv & -xvwlfh dfwouv dqg owkhu lqglylgxdov lqyooyhg lq wkh lghqwlilfdwloq oi glvdelolwlhv gxulqj fulplqdo mxvwlfh suofhvvhv vkoxog eh dghtxdwho wudlqhg oq wkh qdwxuh dqg ghilqlwloq oi glvdelolw dqg wkh sxusovh oi wkh lghqwlilfdwloq oi dq lqglylgxdo௲v glvdelolw wkh ohjdo uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg wkh gxw wo suoylgh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ ,q voph foxqwulhv vxfk dv wkh 8. dqg 6sdlq wklv dvvhvvphqw fdq eh goqh e lqwhuphgldulhv ,q 6sdlq lqwhuphgldulhv fdq eh suoylghg iuhho e 1*2v olnh 3ohqd ,qfoxvloq :khq sulvoq oiilfhuv vxvshfw wkdw d shuvoq kdv dq lqwhoohfwxdo glvdelolw wkh foqwdfw 3ohqd ,qfoxvloq wkdw foqgxfwv dq dvvhvvphqw dqg suoylghv dvvlvwdqfh lq oewdlqlqj oiilfldo uhfojqlwloq ' 7kh sulpdu sxusovh oi wkh lghqwlilfdwloq oi d glvdelolw vkoxog eh wo oewdlq wkh lqioupdwloq uhtxluhg iou wkh fopshwhqw dxwkoulw wo ghwhuplqh dqg ghflgh lq foqvxowdwloq zlwk wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw wkh suoylvloq oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv 7klv suofhvv vkoxog qhyhu eh xvhg dv d phdqv oi glplqlvklqj sduwlflsdwloq oi dq lqglylgxdo ou h[foxglqj sduwlflsdwloq hqwluho -xgjhv dqg owkhu mxvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog dw odwhu vwdjhv lq wkh ohjdo suofhvv yhuli wkdw wkh lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqwv kdyh ehhq fopsohwhg hduo lq wkh suofhvv sulou wo wkh pdwwhu dsshdulqj ehiouh wkhp 'hihqgdqwv vo dvvhvvhg vkoxog eh lqiouphg deoxw wkh ghwdlov oi wkh lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw eh lqyooyhg lq lwv ghyhoosphqw dqg vkoxog uhfhlyh lw zkhq 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 6sdlq0dgulg (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,elg s $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 ilqdol]hg 7kh vkoxog kdyh wkh uljkw wo fopphqw oq vxfk dq dvvhvvphqw dqg li qhfhvvdu foqwhvw lw ˆˬ˦˧˘ˠ˜˖ ˅˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog lghqwli dqg glvvhplqdwh ehvw sudfwlfhv uhjduglqj wkh lghqwlilfdwloq oi glvdelolw dqg ghyhoos dqg lpsohphqw wudlqlqjv iofxvlqj oq wkh kxpdq uljkwv pogho oi glvdelolw dqg wkh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv zklfk vkoxog eh pdgh vo wkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv fdq sduwlflsdwh oq dq htxdo edvlv lq doo ohjdo suofhvvhvͳ ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ ,q %xojduld wkh foxuwv xvh dq ௵1*2 dvvhvvphqw oi wkh vofldo ixqfwloqlqj oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dqg wkhlu vshfldo qhhgv௶ 7klv dvvhvvphqw lv ghvljqhg wo eh xvhg lq doo foxuwv dgguhvvlqj fdvhv zlwk shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,w dlpv wo lqfuhdvh hiihfwlyh sduwlflsdwloq lq wkh wuldo dqg wo lpsuoyh wkh suowhfwloq oi wkh shuvoq௲v uljkwv dqg lqwhuhvwv ,qioupdwloq vkdulqj uxohv dqg vdihjxdugv vkoxog eh lq sodfh zkhq dq lqglylgxdo dvvhvvphqw lv ehlqj foqgxfwhg e mxvwlfh dfwouv ʼˡ˗˘ˣ˘ˡ˗˘ˡ˧ ˜ˡ˧˘˥ˠ˘˗˜˔˥˜˘˦ ʢ ˙˔˖˜˟˜˧˔˧ˢ˥˦ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˔˟ ˚˨˜˗˔ˡ˖˘ ˔ˡ˗ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ :khuh qhhghg dq lqwhuphgldu vkoxog eh fdoohg wo dvvlvw lq foppxqlfdwloq gxulqj soolfh lqwhuylhzv zlwk wkh shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw vxvshfwhg oi wkh fulph $v d ioup oi suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloq lqwhuphgldulhv vkoxog eh suoylghg wo ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zkhuhyhu dqg zkhqhyhu qhhghg wo hqdeoh fohdu )(1$&(5&, %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq 3ouwxjdo /lveoq (1$%/( 3uomhfw s .(5$ 3ohqd ,qfoxvlµq %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq %xojduld 9holno 7duqoyo (1$%/( 3uomhfw s ,elg $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 foppxqlfdwloq ehwzhhq wkhp wkh soolfh dqg mxvwlfh dfwouv lqfoxglqj wkh foxuwv wo hqvxuh vdih idlu dqg hiihfwlyh hqjdjhphqw dqg wo suoylgh wkh ossouwxqlw wo ixoo sduwlflsdwh lq doo vwdjhv oi suofhhglqjv 7klv uhtxluhv wkdw $ $ vxiilflhqw qxpehu oi wudlqhg lqwhuphgldulhv eh pdgh dydlodeoh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv iuop wkh vwduw oi wkh suofhhglqjv dqg dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh dgplqlvwudwloq oi mxvwlfh % 6vwhpdwlf wudlqlqj oq wkh uooh oi lqwhuphgldulhv duh lq sodfh & 7kh xvh oi lqwhuphgldulhv go qow jhqhudwh fovwv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ' ,q wkh devhqfh oi vxiilflhqw dqg txdolilhg foxuwdssolqwhg lqwhuphgldulhv foxuwv zoun fooodeoudwlyho zlwk vwdnhkooghuv zko suoylgh vxfk vxssouw wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ˆˬ˦˧˘ˠ˜˖ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ ,q wkh ooqjwhup suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv ௬ lqfoxglqj wkh sovvlelolw oi dq lqwhuphgldu௬ vkoxog eh lqfoxghg lq qdwloqdo ohjlvodwloq dqg uxohv dssolfdeoh wo wkh &oxuwv wo hqvxuh wkh ixoo lpsohphqwdwloq oi wkh &53' lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhpv 1dwloqdo odz vkoxog lqfoxgh wkh uhjxodwloq oq wkh sovlwloq oi lqwhuphgldulhv zklfk vkoxog lqfoxgh zko fdq eh dq lqwhuphgldu zkdw foqglwloqv qhhg wo eh ixoiloohg d fogh oi hwklfv dqg wkh qhhg wo uhpdlq lqghshqghqw sduw lq wkh suofhvv (yhq zkhuh 1*2v suoylgh wkh uhvoxufhv wo hqvxuh lqwhuphgldulhv lq wkh suofhhglqjv wkh 6wdwh kdv wkh oeoljdwloq wo suoylgh qhfhvvdu ilqdqfldo pdwlhudo dqg kxpdq uhvoxufhv iou lqwhuphgldulhv dqg vkoxog jlyh sudfwlfdo hiihfw wo wklv uhvsoqvlelolw $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 ˅˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˕˘ ˔˖˖ˢˠˣ˔ˡ˜˘˗ ˕ˬ ˔ ˦˨ˣˣˢ˥˧ ˣ˘˥˦ˢˡ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˔˟ ˚˨˜˗˔ˡ˖˘ ˔ˡ˗ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ )uop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk wkh dxwkoulwlhv shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv vkoxog eh lqiouphg oi wkhlu uljkw wo eh dffopsdqlhg e d vxssouw shuvoq oi wkhlu fkolfh wkdw foxog lqfoxgh d idplo phpehu 6wdwhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw $ li dq lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw vo zlvkhv vxfk wuxvwhg vxssouw shuvoqv fdq eh suhvhqw gxulqj doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqj % d suofhgxuh e zklfk wkh uooh oi vxfk d vxssouw shuvoq lv fohduo ghwhuplqhg dqg uhjxodwhg & qo shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw lv fopshoohg wo doooz wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi dq vxfk vxssouw shuvoqv lq wkhlu ohjdo diidluv dw dq vwdjh oi ohjdo suofhhglqjv djdlqvw wkhlu zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv ' wkh uooh oi dq lqwhuphgldu lv qow foqiodwhg zlwk ou uhsodfhg e d vxssouw shuvoq 7kh lqwhuphgldu dqg wkh vxssouw shuvoq kdyh gliihuhqw uoohv dqg zkhuh qhhghg suoylvloq iou wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi eowk vkoxog eh pdgh 7khuh vkoxog dozdv eh d idfhwoidfh foqwdfw zlwk wkh wuxvwhg vxssouw shuvoq li wkh lqglylgxdo zlwk d glvdelolw ghvluhv vxfk foqwdfw ˃˥ˢ˖˘˗˨˥˔˟ ˔˗˝˨˦˧ˠ˘ˡ˧˦ ˔ˡ˗ ˠˢ˗˜˙˜˖˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˔˟ ˚˨˜˗˔ˡ˖˘ ˔ˡ˗ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 7kh uhvsoqvleoh 6wdwh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw yhqxhv lq wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp zkhuh ohjdo suofhvvhv wdnh sodfh lqfoxglqj zdlwlqj duhdv duh dozdv vxiilflhqwo dgdswhg dqg dffhvvleoh iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ௬ dqg dssuosuldwh wo wkh vshflilf qhhgv oi wkh shuvoq ,q dgglwloq wo d skvlfdo hqyluoqphqw uhvsoqvleoh 6wdwh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog foqvlghu dgdswdwloq oi yhqxhv oq d fdvhefdvh edvlv lq foqvxowdwloq zlwk dq $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 lqglylgxdo zlwk glvdelolw wkhlu lqwhuphgldu dqgou vxssouw shuvoq 7kh ioooozlqj foxog eh foqvlghuhg $ /lplwlqj wkh h[sovxuh oi wkh ghihqgdqwv wo wkh sxeolf ou pouh jhqhudoo wkhlu foqwdfw zlwk owkhu shuvoqv ͷ % foqvlghulqj wkh vhdwlqj dqg sovlwloqlqj wo eh dgdswhg zkhq qhhghg iou lqvwdqfh odzhuv vlwwlqj zlwk wkhlu edfnv wo wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk glvdelolw lq foxuw pd qhhg dgdswdwloq dqg & wdnlqj phdvxuhv wo hqvxuh wkdw wkh foqwdfw zlwk wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp lv dv idu dv sovvleoh qow lqwlplgdwlqj ʵʡ ˅˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˜ˡ˙ˢ˥ˠ˔˧˜ˢˡ ˔ˡ˗ ˖ˢˠˠ˨ˡ˜˖˔˧˜ˢˡ ˜ˡ ˔˖˖˘˦˦˜˕˟˘ ˙ˢ˥ˠ˔˧˦ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˔˟ ˚˨˜˗˔ˡ˖˘ ˔ˡ˗ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ (yhu shuvoq zlwk d glvdelolw kdv wkh uljkw wo pdnh fkolfhv iou wkhpvhoyhv dqg vkoxog kdyh dffhvv wo doo wkh uhohydqw lqioupdwloq dqg vxssouw uhtxluhg wo go vo iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk odz hqioufhphqw dxwkoulwlhv 3xuvxdqw wo wklv oeoljdwloq $ ,qioupdwloq vkoxog eh vkduhg zlwk ghihqgdqwv dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv lqfoxglqj exw qow olplwhg wo wkh suhwuldo skdvh gxulqj wkh wuldo dqg sovwwuldo lqioupdwloq % ,qioupdwloq oq h[lvwlqj vxssouw uhvoxufhv dqg dffoppogdwloqv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv dv zhoo dv oq koz wo dffhvv dqg xvh wkhp vkoxog eh dydlodeoh dqg fohduo foppxqlfdwhg wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv & $q dssolqwphqw oi dq lqwhuphgldu dqgou owkhu vxssouw shuvoq v vkoxog eh foqvlghuhg dqg zkhuh qhfhvvdu hiihfwxdwhg lq oughu wo vljqlilfdqwo khos lq foppxqlfdwloq dqg hqvxuh wkdw doo uhohydqw lqioupdwloq lv wudqvplwwhg wo dqg foppxqlfdwhg e wkh ghihqgdqw 7kh soolfh dxwkoulwlhv dqg owkhu mxvwlfh suoihvvloqdov pxvw hqvxuh wkdw lqglylgxdov zlwk glvdelolwlhv xqghuvwdqg wkhlu uljkwv dqg doo uhohydqw ohjdo suofhgxuhv dqg suofhvvhv -xglfldo &ooohjh 8qlwhg .lqjgop ௱(txdo 7uhdwphqw %hqfk %oon௲ )heuxdu s $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 -xvwlfh suoihvvloqdov pxvw hqvxuh wkdw dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh suoylghg zlwk dffhvvleoh dqg xqghuvwdqgdeoh lqioupdwloq deoxw wkhlu uljkwv lqfoxglqj $ wkh uljkw qow wo lqfulplqdwh oqhvhoi % zkdw lv olnho kdsshq lq wkh dssolfdeoh ohjdo suofhgxuh & wkh uxohv oi sodfhv oi ghwhqwloq dqg ' wkdw wkh fdq uho oq wkh vxssouw oi wkh sxeolf lqvwlwxwloqv vwduwlqj zlwk wkhlu iluvw foqwdfw zlwk wkh mxvwlfh vvwhp :khq vkdulqj lqioupdwloq wkh uhvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw lw lv ehlqj foppxqlfdwhg lq d zd wkdw lv dffhvvleoh wo wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk uhjdug wo wkhlu vshflilf foppxqlfdwloq qhhgv /dqjxdjh qhhgv wo eh dgdswhg wo wkh lqglylgxdo foppxqlfdwloq qhhgv $ -xvwlfh suoihvvloqdov vkoxog kdyh dffhvv wo d olvw oi foqfuhwh wooov lqfoxglqj wkh wooov iuop wkh ,qwhuqdwloqdo sulqflsohv dqg fohdu jxlgdqfh dqg h[dpsohv oq koz wo xvh wkhp wo idflolwdwh hiihfwlyh foppxqlfdwloq zlwk lqglylgxdov zlwk glvdelolwlhv % :khuh qhfhvvdu lqioupdwloq vkoxog eh suhvhqwhg lq d vlpsolilhg fopsuhkhqvleoh hdvwoxqghuvwdqg ioupdw ou pdqqhu & 6shflilfdoo mxvwlfh dfwouv vkdoo dgdsw wkh ioooozlqj hohphqwv wkh vshhg dqg woqh oi gholyhu ohyho oi yofdexodu ohyho oi judppdu dqg wkh fopsoh[lw oi txhvwloqv :kloh dgdswlqj wkhlu odqjxdjh mxvwlfh dfwouv vkoxog dovo foqvlghu wkh ghihqgdqwv௲ delolw wo qduudwh lqghshqghqwo dqg wo xqghuvwdqg txhvwloqv uhodwhg wo wlph wkhlu oulhqwdwloq dqg glvwdqfh dqg wkhlu ohyho oi olwhudf ' (qvxuh wkh sdfh oi wkh suofhhglqjv lv zhoo dgmxvwhg ௬ hqvxuh iou lqvwdqfh udwkhu vkouw vhvvloqv iuhtxhqw euhdnv :ulwwhq lqioupdwloq vkoxog eh dydlodeoh lq dowhuqdwlyh ioupdwv mxvwlfh dfwouv pxvw hqvxuh wkh hodeoudwloq oi dqg suoylvloq oi dffhvv wo hdvwouhdg gofxphqwv 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw lqioupdwloq deoxw foxuw suofhgxuhv lqfoxglqj qowlfhv wkdw uhtxluh d uhvsoqvh ou dq dfwloq wo eh wdnhq lqfoxglqj vxppoqvhv vxesohqdv zulwv oughuv dqg vhqwhqfhv lv suoylghg lq dffhvvleoh ioupdwv $ffhvv $elolw $xvwudold $$$ 7kh &dslwdo 6ofldo 6wou dydlodeoh dw $ylvlwwo7kh&dslwdo6ofldo6wou9sgi dffhvvdelolwdxvwudoldfop s -xvwlfh ,qwhuphgldu 6wduwhu .lw 0ogxoh $ffoppogdwloqv s $ffhvvleoh ioupdwv lqfoxgh 6ljq odqjxdjh 9lgho dqg dxglo jxlghv 7hohskoqh olqh dgylfh dqg uhihuudo vhuylfhv $ffhvvleoh zhevlwhv ,qgxfwloq ooos udglo ou lqiuduhg vvwhpv &oovhg fdswloqlqj %udlooh (dv 5hdg dqg sodlq odqjxdjh )dflolwdwhg foppxqlfdwloq dqg dpsolilfdwloq ghylfhv dqg gofxphqw pdjqlilhuv $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv hqvxuh wkdw doo foxuw suofhvvhv suoylgh wkh whfkqlfdo dqg owkhu vxssouw qhfhvvdu iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wo xvh dq ioup oi foppxqlfdwloq qhfhvvdu iou wkhlu ixoo sduwlflsdwloq 7khvh ioupv oi foppxqlfdwloq pd dpoqj owkhuv uhtxluh wkh xvh oi $ dvvlvwlyh olvwhqlqj vvwhpv dqg ghylfhv % oshq foovhg dqg uhdowlph fdswloqlqj dqg foovhg fdswloq ghfoghuv dqg ghylfhv & yolfh wh[w dqg ylghoedvhg whohfoppxqlfdwloqv suogxfwv ' ylghowh[w glvsodv ( fopsxwhudvvlvwhg uhdowlph wudqvfulswloq ) vfuhhq uhdghu voiwzduh pdjqlilfdwloq voiwzduh dqg oswlfdo uhdghuv dqg * ylgho ghvfulswloq dqg vhfoqgdu dxglwou suojudpplqj ghylfhv wkdw slfn xs dxglo ihhgv iou whohylvloq suojudpv 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog suoylgh foppxqlfdwloq vxssouw lqfoxglqj wkuoxjk wklugsduwlhv iou h[dpsoh $ qowhwdnhuv % txdolilhg vljq odqjxdjh dqg oudo lqwhusuhwhuv & uhod vhuylfhv dqg ' wdfwloh lqwhusuhwhuv zkhuh dqg zkhq qhfhvvdu 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog suoylgh mxvwlfh suoihvvloqdov zlwk foppxqlfdwloq wooov wo xvh lq foppxqlfdwloq zlwk shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv )ou lqvwdqfh d 7kh uljkw wo lqwhusuhwdwloq dqg wudqvodwloq vkoxog eh ixoiloohg dw doo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqjv 7udqvodwouv lqwhusuhwhuv dqg lqwhuphgldulhv sod gliihuhqw uoohv exw vophwlphv dq lqwhuphgldu fdq eh khosixo lq ixoiloolqj wkh uljkw wo lqwhusuhwdwloq dqg wudqvodwloq 6vwhplf 5hfopphqgdwloqv 7kh uhvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog dfw wo hqvxuh wkdw doo foppxqlfdwloq vxssouw shuvoqv duh deoh wo lqwhusuhw hiihfwlyho dffxudwho dqg lpsduwldoo eowk uhfhswlyho xqghuvwdqglqj zkdw shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv duh vdlqj dqg 7khvh lqfoxgh $vvlvwlyh olvwhqlqj vvwhpv dqg ghylfhv 2shq foovhg dqg uhdowlph fdswloqlqj dqg foovhg fdswloq ghfoghuv dqg ghylfhv 9olfh wh[w dqg ylghoedvhg whohfoppxqlfdwloqv suogxfwv 9lghowh[w glvsodv &opsxwhudvvlvwhg uhdowlph wudqvfulswloq 6fuhhq uhdghu voiwzduh pdjqlilfdwloq voiwzduh dqg oswlfdo uhdghuv 9lgho ghvfulswloq dqg vhfoqgdu dxglwou suojudpplqj ghylfhv wkdw slfn xs dxglo ihhgv iou whohylvloq suojudpphv $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 h[suhvvlyho kdylqj wkh vnloo qhfhvvdu wo foqyh lqioupdwloq edfn wo wkovh shuvoqv zkloh xvlqj dq qhfhvvdu vshfldol]hg yofdexodu vxfk dv ohjdo ou phglfdo odqjxdjh dqg uhvshfwlqj suoihvvloqdo dqg hwklfdo vwdqgdugv 7kh uhvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog dfw wo suoylgh iou dghtxdwh wudlqlqj oq foppxqlfdwloq wooov dqg phwkogv iou doo mxvwlfh suoihvvloqdov lqfoxglqj e hqvxulqj wkh odqjxdjh eduulhu lv oyhufoph wkuoxjk wudlqlqj oi mxvwlfh dfwouv dv zhoo dv wudlqlqj oq wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oi wkh doo owkhu uhohydqw suoihvvloqdov olnh lqwhusuhwhuv dqg lqwhuphgldulhv ʶʡ ˅˜˚˛˧ ˢ˙ ˔˖˖˘˦˦ ˧ˢ ˔ ˟˔˪ˬ˘˥ ˔ˡ˗ ˧ˢ ˟˘˚˔˟ ˔˜˗ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˔˟ ˚˨˜˗˔ˡ˖˘ ˔ˡ˗ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 7kh uljkw wo dffhvv wo d odzhu pxvw eh jxdudqwhhg dqg idflolwdwhg iuop wkh oxwvhw oi ghwhqwloq wkuoxjk wkh iuop wkh suhwuldo vwdjhv oi ohjdo suofhhglqjv dqg suofhvvhv ehiouh wkh iluvw dfwloqv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv dqg wkuoxjkoxw wkh wuldo 7o hqvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh uhvsoqvleoh 6wdwh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw phdvxuhv duh lq sodfh wo $ $iioug ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv wkh uljkw wo ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh iuop wkh iluvw foqwdfw zlwk odz hqioufhphqw uhjdugohvv oi wkh qdwxuh oi wkh fulph wkh duh dffxvhg oi dqg oq whupv wkdw duh qo ohvv idyoxudeoh wkdq doo owkhu shuvoqv % *xdudqwhh wkdw doo ghihqgdqwv duh lqiouphg oi wkhlu uljkw wo kdyh dffhvv wo d odzhu dqg hiihfwlyh ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh & ,qioup shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oi wkhlu uljkw wo ohjdo dlg ௬ lqfoxglqj zkhuh qhfhvvdu wo iuhh hiihfwlyh ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh dqg owkhu sovvlelolwlhv vxfk dv dffhvv wo ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwloq wkuoxjk flylo voflhw oujdql]dwloqv ' 0dlqwdlq dqg uhjxoduo xsgdwh d olvw oi ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv zlwk h[shuwlvh lq glvdelolw 7khvh ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv vkoxog xqghu zkdw duh wkh uljkwv oi $xvwudoldq 'lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon dydlodeoh dw 'lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon mxglfldofooohjhylfhgxdx ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˣ˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ $ffouglqj wo wkh $xvwudoldq 'lvdelolw $ffhvv %hqfk %oon dq hdv zd wo dyolg wklv odqjxdjh eduulhu lv wo dyolg xvlqj ohjdo whuplqoooj dqg wo xvh lqvwhdg foqfuhwh dqg sodlq odqjxdjh )ou lqvwdqfh wkh mxgjhv dqg ohjdo uhsuhvhqwdwlyhv vkoxog xvh wkh yhue ௵wo iooooz௶ lqvwhdg oi wkh yhue ௵wo fopso௶ -xgjhv dqg ohjdo sudfwlwloqhuv vkoxog dovo h[sodlq sduwlfxodu whupv dqg fkhfn gxulqj wkh khdulqj zkhwkhu wkh ghihqgdqw xqghuvwdqgv wkh phdqlqj oi vshflilf zougv $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqfoxglqj xqghu wkh &53' dqg xqghuvwdqg wkh oeoljdwloq wo suoylgh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv iou shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ( 0dnh suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv vxfk dv lqwhusuhwhuv dvvlvwlyh whfkqoooj dqg lqwhuphgldulhv ou wkh uhvoxufhv qhfhvvdu wo oewdlq vxfk dffoppogdwloqv dydlodeoh wo odzhuv wo vxssouw hiihfwlyh foppxqlfdwloq zlwk shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh glvfkdujh oi wkhlu suoihvvloqdo gxwlhv ) :khq d shuvoq lv ghwdlqhg wkh pxvw hqmo hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo d odzhu dqg ohjdo dlg ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ ,q ,uhodqg wkh 1dwloqdo $gyofdf 6huylfh iou 3hosoh zlwk 'lvdelolwlhv suoylghv foppxqlfdwloq dqg dvvlvwdqfh vhuylfhv wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7kh dovo khos shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq lqvwuxfwlqj d odzhu zko uhsuhvhqwv wkhlu zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv ,q $xvwuld d vlplodu vhuylfh lv oiihuhg e d shhu vxssouw juoxs %,=(36 ˆˬ˦˧˘ˠ˜˖ ˅˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 7kh uljkw wo dffhvv wo d odzhu pxvw eh jxdudqwhhg iuop wkh wlph oi duuhvw wo suhwuldo vwdjhv oi wkh suofhhglqj ehiouh wkh iluvw dfwloqv lq fulplqdo suofhhglqjv dqg wkuoxjkoxw wkh wuldo 0hdvxuhv vkoxog eh wdnhq wo hqvxuh wkdw $ 7kh sxeolf ghihqfh vvwhp fdq hqvxuh htxdo dffhvv wo odzhuv wkdw suoylgh kljktxdolw vhuylfhv wo doo ghihqgdqwv lqfoxglqj wkovh zlwk glvdelolwlhv % /hjdo dvvlvwdqfh lv hiihfw dqg wkdw wkhuh lv d vxshuylvou phfkdqlvp sxw lq sodfh e lqvwlwxwloqv fkdujhg zlwk uhjxodwlqj wkh edu vxfk dv edu dvvofldwloqv dqg odz voflhwlhv ,q golqj vo hpskdvlv vkoxog eh sxw oq wkh odzhuv vxssouwlyh uooh ehlqj vxiilflhqwo suodfwlyh dqg pdlqwdlqlqj shuvoqdo dqg vxiilflhqwo iuhtxhqw foqwdfw zlwk folhqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv /hjdo dlg pxvw eh suoylghg iou doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv zko go qow kdyh wkh phdqv wo diioug ohjdo dvvlvwdqfh ( )oqq & 0oooqh - )ldod%xwoud , 9lfhqwh (fkhyduuld 5hsouw $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh oi 3huvoqv zlwk 'lvdelolwlhv dydlodeoh dw &'/3)lqdouhsouw$ffhvv-xvwlfh3:'gof[ olyhfop s )2580 %ulhilqj sdshu oq eduulhuv idfhg e ghihqgdqwv zlwk lqwhoohfwxdo dqgou svfkovofldo glvdelolwlhv lq wkh &ulplqdo -xvwlfh 6vwhp lq &]hfkld 3udkd (1$%/( suomhfw s $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 6wdwhv vkoxog jxdudqwhh wkdw lqlwldo wudlqlqj iou odzhuv oq wkh uljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lv suoylghg ʷʡ ʴ˖˖˘˦˦˜˕˜˟˜˧ˬ ˢ˙ ˖ˢ˨˥˧ ˙˔˖˜˟˜˧˜˘˦ʟ ˜ˡ˙ˢ˥ˠ˔˧˜ˢˡ ˔ˡ˗ ˦˘˥˩˜˖˘˦ ˆˬ˦˧˘ˠ˜˖ ˅˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkh dffhvvlelolw oi doo foxuw idflolwlhv lqioupdwloq foppxqlfdwloqv dqg owkhu vhuylfhv lqfoxglqj lqioupdwloq dqg foppxqlfdwloqv whfkqoooj dqg vvwhpv lq dffougdqfh zlwk wkh sulqflsohv oi xqlyhuvdo ghvljq (qvxuh doo exloglqjv lq wkh mxvwlfh vhfwou vxfk dv soolfh vwdwloqv foxuwkoxvhv dqg suovhfxwouldo oiilflhv duh dffhvvleoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,q oughu wo dfklhyh wklv wkh vkoxog $ 0dnh dghtxdwh ilqdqfldo uhvoxufhv dydlodeoh vo wkdw wkh foxuwv soolfh vwdwloqv suovhfxwouv oiilfhv dqg owkhu skvlfdo vwuxfwxuhv hqfoxqwhuhg gxulqj mxvwlfh suofhvvhv duh skvlfdoo dffhvvleoh wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv 7klv pd uhtxluh wkh poglilfdwloq oi h[lvwlqj exloglqjv dqg vwuxfwxuhv dv zhoo dv d suoklelwloq oi dq ixuwkhu qhz exloglqjv ou vwuxfwxuhv ehlqj fuhdwhg wkdw duh qow fopsdwleoh zlwk wkh sulqflsohv oi xqlyhuvdo ghvljq dqg wkhuhiouh dffhvvleoh wo doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv % *xdudqwhh wkh suoylvloq oi uhdvoqdeoh dqg suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv zkhq idflolwlhv dqg vhuylfhv idlo wo hqvxuh dffhvv wo wkh h[lvwlqj skvlfdo hqyluoqphqw iou doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv oq dq htxdo edvlv & $ffhvvleoh exloglqjv dqg owkhu sodfhv vkoxog uhwdlq wkhlu dffhvvlelolw diwhu wkhlu ghfodudwloq 7khuh duh fdvhv zkhuh dffhvvleoh vsdfhv kdyh ehhq foqyhuwhg wo owkhu xvhv gxh wo doohjhg glvxvh hj dq dffhvvleoh wolohw kdv ehfoph d vwoudjh duhd iou fohdqlqj vxssolhv ' 8qlyhuvdo ghvljq jxlghv suoylgh vshflilf vxjjhvwloqv zklfk vkoxog eh lpsohphqwhg lqfoxglqj udpsv udlov oliwv juooylqj oq wkh juoxqg vshflilf sdunlqj oowv dxwopdwlf goouv hwf ʸʡ ˅˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˕˘ ˣ˥˘˦˘ˡ˧ ˔˧ ˧˥˜˔˟ ˔ˡ˗ ˧˛˘ ˥˜˚˛˧ ˧ˢ ˣ˥˘˦˨ˠˣ˧˜ˢˡ ˢ˙ ˜ˡˡˢ˖˘ˡ˖˘ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˔˟ ˚˨˜˗˔ˡ˖˘ ˔ˡ˗ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ )ou vshflilf jxlgdqfh sohdvh uhihu wo duwlfoh &53' ௬ 'hilqlwloq oi 8qlyhuvdo 'hvljq duwlfoh i &53' dqg 3ulqflsoh oi wkh 81 ,qwhuqdwloqdo 3ulqflsohv dqg *xlgholqhv 6hh khuh iou lqvwdqfh d jxlgh iou ghvljqhuvhqjlqhhuv zklfk lv ehlqj xvhg lq d qxpehu oi xqlyhuvlwlhv 38'sgi vwdqioughgx $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 5hvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog wdnh phdvxuhv wo hqvxuh wkh uljkw wo eh suhvhqw dw wuldo dqg wo ghihqg wkhpvhoyhv lq shuvoq lv uhvshfwhg iou ghihqgdqwv zlwk glvdelolwlhv $ $q h[fhswloqv wo wkh uljkw wo eh suhvhqw dw wuldo vkoxog qow eh glvdelolwvshflilf dqg vkoxog dsso htxdoo wo doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv ,ghqwli dqg fduhixoo foqvlghu iou zkop wkh uhpowh khdulqj pljkw eh xqvxlwdeoh $ ,i xvlqj uhpowh khdulqjv hqvxuh dghtxdwh wudlqlqj ,7 wooov dqg d uholdeoh lqwhuqhw foqqhfwloq iou mxvwlfh dfwouv dqg htxdoo vhfxuh vxfk dffhvv oq dq htxdo edvlv wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lqyooyhg lq vxfk suofhhglqjv % 5hvshfw wkh shuvoq௲v zloo dqg suhihuhqfhv oq uhpowh khdulqjv 3xuvxh wkh ௵ehvw lqwhusuhwdwloq oi wkh zloo dqg suhihuhqfh௶ oqo zkhq wkh shuvoq fdqqow h[suhvv wkhp gluhfwo & (qvxuh dffhvv wo suofhgxudo dffoppogdwloqv lq uhpowh khdulqjv l lqfoxglqj zkhuh dssolfdeoh wkh sduwlflsdwloq oi lqwhuphgldulhv dqg owkhu vxssouw shuvoqv ll suoylglqj wkdw doo foppxqlfdwloq vxssouw lqfoxglqj wkuoxjk wklug sduwlhv qowhwdnhuv txdolilhg vljq odqjxdjh dqg oudo lqwhusuhwhuv uhod vhuylfhv dqg wdfwloh lqwhusuhwhuv lv htxdoo dqg hiihfwlyho dydlodeoh wo doo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq wkh foqwh[w oi uhpowh khdulqjv ' (qvxuh hiihfwlyh dffhvv wo d odzhuv ohjdo dlg hyhq lq wkh foqwh[w oi uhpowh suofhhglqjv ( (qvxuh wkdw gxulqj d uhpowh khdulqj wkh uooh oi hdfk shuvoq wdnlqj sduw lq wkh oqolqh khdulqj lv fohdu wo doo lqfoxglqj wo wkh ghihqgdqw zlwk glvdelolw ) (qvxuh wkh sdfh oi wkh suofhhglqjv lv zhoo dgmxvwhg ௬ hqvxuh iou lqvwdqfh udwkhu vkouw vhvvloqv dqg iuhtxhqw euhdnv ˆˬ˦˧˘ˠ˜˖ ˅˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 7kh uhvsoqvleoh dxwkoulwlhv vkoxog hqvxuh wkdw doo vxvshfwv dqg dffxvhg shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv hiihfwlyho hqmo wkh suhvxpswloq oi lqqofhqfh suhvxphg lqqofhqw xqwlo suoyhq jxlow xqghu wkh odz lqfoxglqj dw suhwuldo skdvhv ʹʡ ˃˥ˢ˖˘˗˨˥˔˟ ˥˜˚˛˧˦ ˥˘˚˔˥˗˜ˡ˚ ˗˘˧˘ˡ˧˜ˢˡ $11(; ,,, 6800$5< 2) 7+( 35$&7,&$/ *8,'$1&( $1' 6<67(0,& 5(&200(1'$7,216 ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˔˟ ˚˨˜˗˔ˡ˖˘ ˔ˡ˗ ˥˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ 'hwhqwloq fhqwuhv pxvw eh dffhvvleoh dqg zkhuh qhfhvvdu vxssouw wo shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv pxvw eh suoylghg ˃˥ˢˠ˜˦˜ˡ˚ ˃˥˔˖˧˜˖˘ ,q 6sdlq sulvoqhuv dqg h[sulvoqhuv fdq ehqhilw iuop wkh 3ohqd ,qfoxvloq 3uojudpph wkdw dlpv wo oiihu vxssouw dw doo vwdjhv gxulqj ohjdo suofhhglqjv lq sulvoq dqg diwhu wkh uhohdvh ˆˬ˦˧˘ˠ˜˖ ˅˘˖ˢˠˠ˘ˡ˗˔˧˜ˢˡ˦ ͳǥ 'hsulydwloq oi olehuw vkoxog eh foqvlghuhg d phdvxuh oi odvw uhvouw d &oppxqlwedvhg dowhuqdwlyhv wo lqfdufhudwloq vkoxog eh dydlodeoh wo doo ghihqgdqwv lqfoxglqj wkovh zlwk glvdelolwlhv e $owhuqdwlyhv wo lqfdufhudwloq vkoxog eh ghyhooshg dqg lpsohphqwhg ʹǥ 6wdwhv pxvw qow doooz iou glvdelolwedvhg ghwhqwloq lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq dqg owkhu dfwv wkdw uhvxow lq glvdelolwuhodwhg wouwxuh dqg loowuhdwphqw 1o oqh vkoxog eh ghwdlqhg lq dq idflolw oq wkh edvlv oi dfwxdo ou shufhlyhg glvdelolw ͵ǥ 6wdwhv fdqqow xvh lqyooxqwdu lqvwlwxwloqdol]dwloq wo fopshqvdwh iou wkh odfn oi dghtxdwh idflolwlhv $ffhvv wo -xvwlfh .qozohgjh +xe ,psohphqwlqj wkh &oqyhqwloq oq wkh 5ljkwv oi shuvoqv zlwk glvdelolwlhv lq fulplqdo mxvwlfh vvwhpv $ eulhilqj sdshu -xo s
